HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

blackguardx

3,708 karma · joined September 28, 2008

Hardware, FPGA, Firmware, iOS
submissionscomments
blackguardx··on Alphabet's Waymo Alleges Uber Stole Self-Driving Secrets
This happens more than you would think. The mistake is probably compounded by two designs being almost the same and potentially the same engineers involved.

I'll bet the supplier searched for the engineer's name in his inbox and responded to a big email thread about the project with many people involved. The Otto engineer's old colleagues got the email instead of him.

blackguardx··on Alphabet's Waymo Alleges Uber Stole Self-Driving Secrets
Altium Vault uses SVN for version control (or at least did the last time I used it).

Is that better than git for binaries?

blackguardx··on Why Founders Fail To Market Their Products
Were they users or paying customers? It is impressive either way, but they are very different things.
blackguardx··on Humans evolved to tolerate smoke poisoning [pdf]
Thanks for sharing those links. It looks like it would be hard to start the rocket action correctly. You would have to preheat the circulator "chimney" somehow. Until then, smoke would pour into your house.

This is a problem with normal wood-burning cooking stoves as well. Smoke doesn't go into the chimney until you establish a convection draft or the wind creates a venturi effect.

blackguardx··on Living in the world's most welcoming countries
I live in Colorado. You get used to the altitude in a few weeks.
blackguardx··on More Serotonin, Less Motivation? It Depends on the Circumstances
Your original comment makes more sense now. I thought you were doubting the SSRI link to weight gain.
blackguardx··on More Serotonin, Less Motivation? It Depends on the Circumstances
Rats are a decent model, but they aren't humans. From googling around, it appears that weight gain is a common side effect in most (all?) anti-depressants.

http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/depression/exp...

https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-antidepressant-diet...

blackguardx··on Tesla employee writes of low wages, poor morale; company denies claims
I agree Tesla is a small automotive company, but it isn't a startup. There are plenty of small companies that aren't startups.
blackguardx··on Tesla employee writes of low wages, poor morale; company denies claims
Telsa is publicly traded on the US stock market. Surely it has graduated to "real company" by now. If not, when would you mark that point for a company?
blackguardx··on Circuit building: stop using antique parts (2014)
The problem with the article is that there is no nuance. Some beginner is going to read it and think all BJTs are bad, but that isn't even remotely true. It all depends on application.

I would certainly use MOSFETs for lighting (a power application). I probably wouldn't design an analog front-end for a specialized sensor with them though.

blackguardx··on Circuit building: stop using antique parts (2014)
JFETs main application these days is for when you need very low noise, usually for precise measurements. A depletion mode MOSFET has similar behavior, but not specs.
blackguardx··on Circuit building: stop using antique parts (2014)
There is nothing wrong with bipolar transistors. They aren't antiquated. FETs have definitely overtaken them in power applications (for good reason) but it seems hard to displace them for small signal applications. Small signal FETs just aren't that plentiful or cheap. There are many instances where a small signal FET makes sense (level translators, etc) but the cost doesn't justify its use. Using a 2n2222 and the like is appropriate.

On top of that, BJTs excel in many analog applications. There is a good reason why many analog IC companies make parts using a BiCMOS process. If you are doing a discrete analog design (generally for performance reasons) you often need the performance of BJTs or JFETs.

blackguardx··on LG 5K display must be kept at least 2 meters away from Wi-Fi routers
The clause about accepting interference means that the device must not fail when recieving interference in a way that would cause it to radiate on another frequency. Product functional failure otherwise is not regulated in the US. The FCC doesn't care if your product bricks itself as long as it doesn't jam the spectrum.

I've been through this testing before. They blast your device with many different frequecies and measure what comes out.

The test was harder to pass in the old days when there many discrete mixers inside radios and poor isolation between the RX and TX paths through the duplexer.

blackguardx··on Free Range VHDL – VHDL programming book available for free
http://www.doe.carleton.ca/~jknight/97.478/97.478_02F/Peterv...

I do FPGA design as part of my job. This is the most concise document I've found that covers everything you need to know to get started. Many verilog books just focus on the language. This short pdf focuses on how to use the language to do hardware design, which is what most people actually want to learn.

blackguardx··on Resources for electronic engineers and hobbyists
Qucs is trying to emulate Keysight's ADS software. It is mainly RF focused, but can do a lot more. ADS is awesome. Qucs has great potential, but needs some work. It is still useful, though.
blackguardx··on Tesla sues ex-Autopilot director for taking proprietary info, poaching employees
Startups don't typically go out and look to see if they violate any IP. Likewise, forward thinking companies like Tesla don't typically go around suing startups for using their IP. They would rather buy them up if they are doing really interesting things. IP lawsuits only get filed if there is a real threat to the business.

Telsa's patent sharing announcement doesn't really amount to much IMHO. It was a press release, not a legal contract.

blackguardx··on Python to Circuits
It looks like someone wanted to make an electronics version of OpenSCAD [0]. I agree, it makes more sense integrated into a graphical schematic capture package. There have been a few times when doing large FPGA pinouts that a tool like this could have been useful.

[0] http://www.openscad.org/

blackguardx··on Python to Circuits
This is an interesting project. It would be cool to integrate with with a schematic generator. You could then edit the schematic for better logical flow / presentation.
blackguardx··on Foxconn Weighs $7B U.S. Display Plant
I think we need "free trade zones" like they have in some asian countries. If you have a mfg business in the zone, you pay zero or reduced taxes on your produced goods and inventory. Maybe throw in some subsides to help comply with regulations as well. These zones can be spread all throughout the country in economically depressed regions.

These programs should be open to all companies, not just the Teslas and tbe Apples of the world. Governors and Presidents should not intervene on behalf of a single company. That isn't capitalism.

blackguardx··on Attention Federal Employees: If You See Something, Leak Something
The republican party in Colorado didn't even have a primary. They just chose the candidate they wanted. No one was allowed to vote.

Shouldn't the republicans be taught some lesson as well?

blackguardx··on Galileo satellites experiencing multiple clock failures
No, it is by force. It is similar to ITAR regulations. If you break that rule, your management team is probably going to jail. It would be akin to spying for a foreign power. Source: I used to do some consulting for a satellite imagery company.
blackguardx··on Noise Protection for Short Term and Vacation Rentals
I've never seen unintentional radiator testing under $5k. What lab does your testing?

UL isn't mandatory, but do you want your product stocked by retailers? You might need it then.

blackguardx··on Noise Protection for Short Term and Vacation Rentals
Your one day prototype will costs thousands to bring to market. Lets look at just the electronics. Have you priced out FCC certification? The wifi module might be already certified, but the whole product isn't. That is $5k to $10k minimum for US only. It also plugs into mains, which means it might need UL certification to it won't burn down someone's house.

Your $20 BOM just gets you a board and loose components, not a complete product. The cost of a complete product is called "cost of goods sold" or COGS and includes things like assembly, testing, and shipping, etc. Even if $20 was your COGS, how much would you have to charge to make a profit? It all depends on how many you sell. If you only intend to sell 1000 or so (likely the case here), you need to charge accordingly.

blackguardx··on Noise Protection for Short Term and Vacation Rentals
I'm a hardware engineer and grasp fully how simple this is. But cost to make in a garage != cost to make at scale. Bringing hardware to market is expensive. You are forgetting mold tooling costs, factory fees, prototype costs, profit, etc. The fixed NRE costs can go to zero at mass scale, but if they intend to only sell 1000 or so (probably a good estimate), they need to account for it somehow.
blackguardx··on Noise Protection for Short Term and Vacation Rentals
I hope it isn't recording audio. That would cost more than just a simple peak detector circuit sampled at 1 kHz or so.
blackguardx··on Noise Protection for Short Term and Vacation Rentals
Can't you say the same thing about any piece of software as well? It costs next to $0 in bandwidth to download an app or program. Why should the price be higher than $0?

Hardware costs a lot of money to develop and manufacture. There have been a lot of posts on HN recently about the price of hardware. Niche hardware like this doesn't cost next to nothing when made in small quantities. All the fixed NREs (all the prototype costs, the plastic mold tooling, any upfront factory fees, etc.) have to be amortized over the few units sold. And that is just breaking even. Selling goods at cost is a tricky business model. It makes sense to add in a little profit.

If you don't like the price, then you probably shouldn't buy it. If enough people agree with you, they will either change their price or go out of business.

blackguardx··on Museum of HP Clocks
I once worked for an HP spin-off (Agilent) and scrounged an old but serviceable spectrum analyzer for the rack in my cube. I remember lifting it up to the top position one night and throwing my back out in the process. It was only after lifting to head height that I could read the warning sticker saying to use two people to lift because it weighed in excess of 80 lbs. Instead of transformers like your power supply, it was full of ovenized crystal oscillators.
blackguardx··on When city retirement pays better than the job
I've also lived in crappy new houses/apartments and it is not that much fun either. I guess YMMV?
blackguardx··on When city retirement pays better than the job
What is wrong with living in an old house? Old wiring, depending on when it was put in, isn't necessarily bad. Knob and tube wiring (a really old style) can probably never start an electrical fire (assuming the outlets are periodically replaced) because the conductors are separated by 18 inches or more. A roof needs to be replaced every 20 years or so. Paint, more often. If the house you own has peeling paint or a leaking roof, look in the mirror and blame that person. Don't blame the age of the house.
blackguardx··on Show HN: Learn how to build electronics with monthly kits
FWIW, Atmel AVR (the Arduino microcontroller) I/Os are typically beefy enough to drive the 20 mA that LEDs usually like to get nice and bright. It was one of their early differentiators.

Depending on the LED, I would have no problem driving it directly with just a current limiting resisitor.

← PreviousPage 15 of 34Next →