HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

blackhole

4,418 karma · joined February 1, 2011

Angry Programmer Bunny: https://erikmcclure.com

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/erikmcclure; my proof: https://keybase.io/erikmcclure/sigs/7L587gG8sECiKPJ7-eL8FW4vCwNQahTkYT60jtaExKE ]

submissionscomments
blackhole··on Why Django Sucks
It's easy to make a boring but informative presentation. It is much more difficult to make a funny but informative presentation. Of course, if you have no sense of humor, I must assume you are a lost traveler from Boringland.
blackhole··on Will Windows 8 emphasis on Tablet features drive users to iPad?
No, its not good for them. I have no idea why they do it, only that they do with surprising consistency.
blackhole··on Is popular music becoming sadder?
I've tried repeatedly to compose songs in Major rather than minor, as I usually do, but I keep ending up with a fucking Pachelbel's Canon chord progression :| It just sucks you in like a whirlpool you have to constantly swim away from.
blackhole··on Will Windows 8 emphasis on Tablet features drive users to iPad?
I've seen lots of people say Windows 8 will be the death of Microsoft. This is about as accurate as saying Vista would be the death of Microsoft. In fact all it's doing is cementing Microsoft's incredibly resilient tick-tock process - release horrible OS, then awesome OS, then horrible OS, then awesome OS. Windows 7 was awesome, therefore Windows 8 will be horrible. This is ridiculously predictable.
blackhole··on Will Windows 8 emphasis on Tablet features drive users to iPad?
Unless they do for the precise reason of proving you wrong and then arguing against the point you are making.
blackhole··on Things I Should Have Known at 20
According to this, I'm actually doing pretty good for being 21.
blackhole··on Buying Adobe Photoshop CS6
Sometimes I wish I could disrupt Adobe, but I can't figure out how. They have /so much/ inertia it is absurd.
blackhole··on Build the "USS Enterprise" in 20 years, for 1 trillion USD
So long as we don't blow said planet up, which so far we have come disturbingly close to doing several dozen times.
blackhole··on Smart people don't think others are stupid
I am implying that stupid people don't listen to rational arguments.
blackhole··on Smart people don't think others are stupid
It is more accurate to say that the difference between stupid people and smart people is that smart people can be proved wrong.
blackhole··on Please don't learn to code
Almost all of these arguments can be applied to a large majority of our school curriculum. If you are arguing that people shouldn't learn to code for the sake of learning to code, you are correct. If, however, you don't actually think learning to code translates to solving problems, or has any real world benefit, you should also be insisting we remove all of Math from our school curriculum, because who uses anything beyond basic algebra? Hell, who uses anything beyond basic arithmetic now that we have calculators that can do algebra and calculus for us? Why teach kids anything?

I should also point out that, the more politicians know how to code, the less politicians treat computers as black boxes that "the nerds" need to perform magic with. It won't go away, certainly, but its a step in the right direction.

blackhole··on Stop Calling People Morons.
Others prefer to work on the game anyway.
blackhole··on Reaching the Limits of Adobe Stupidity
Remember kids, optimization doesn't matter!
blackhole··on Yahoo CEO might have lied about having CS degree
This is probably more about our overcrowded jail system sucking up huge amounts of taxpayer money. The point is likely supposed to be that its one more person in jail, which is bad, but because that person happens to be a CEO, suddenly its about how he shouldn't go to jail because he's a CEO. It's a matter of unfortunate implications.
blackhole··on When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End?
I think this article is misguided in that there has been lots of innovation in the tech sector that has been overshadowed by silly things like "Instagram" that solve "cat picture problems" due to startup culture. The public face of innovation has not been dealing with hard problems, but people are working on them. There are several potential wide-ranging cancer treatments and someone came up with a potential cure for the common cold.

Our educational system and our culture must change if we are to get into a period where there is widespread innovation in dealing with hard problems instead of cat pictures. The internet will be a crucial part of that, and in the future, we will recognize the internet as being a source of cat pictures before we figured out how to use it to unlock our own potential.

blackhole··on The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second
"Guys this new technology looks weird, we should just stick with what works! There's no way this has anything to do with me not being used to it!"
blackhole··on Semicolon: A language of semicolons
brainfuck itself is simply a minor variation of P", created back in 1964.
blackhole··on PHP: A fractal of bad design
Meanwhile, people still manage to write memory leaks in garbage collected languages specifically designed to not leak memory.
blackhole··on Making Binaural Recordings With Earbuds/Headphones
But if you have a mixer, why not just buy proper microphones? A cheap mic is around $5, so buying two of those would yield vastly superior recordings for even less. This is merely a curiosity for unusual situations where standard equipment is not available.
blackhole··on Multi-player piano
Completely impractical but hilarious. Would be significantly more practical if there was a way to have private rooms instead of just making a new one that is inevitably overrun.
blackhole··on The Go-Nowhere Generation
"Good Luck Finding A Cheap Place To Live" Generation "I'm Running A Company From My Bedroom" Generation "I Can Do Basic Cost/Benefit Analysis" Generation "Have Fun Paying Off that Student Loan" Generation

But in all seriousness, this article is ridiculously pretentious and completely out of touch with reality. I know lots of people, including myself, who want to go travelling. Most of them can't afford it. As many others have pointed out, most of them can't afford it because YOUR generation threw the economic in the toilet.

blackhole··on Successful people are successful
People need to stop assuming they know what "success" means for other people.
blackhole··on There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz format.
I am not getting these things mixed up, because the sample rate is related to the maximum frequency that can be stored, and lo and behold, look at all these people claiming that those higher frequencies matter. 44.1 kHz sample rate can only encode tones up to about 22 kHz, whereas 192 can encode frequencies of up to 81 kHz, and those people up there are arguing that these higher frequencies are exactly why 192 kHz is superior. Now, if you want to say that sampling a tone at 44100 times per second somehow won't sound as good than 192000 times per second, I'm not saying that isn't possible, but I don't really take that claim seriously at all.

The fact is, simply distributing music in lossless format carries the vast majority of audible improvements. Arguing over whether or not its 24-bit or 16-bit or making a chunk of sound last 5.2 microseconds instead of 22.67 seems incredibly stupid to me, because you're better off simply improving the mix itself then fiddling over such microscopic differences. These things only become relevant if your mix and performance and recording equipment (or synths) are absurdly close to perfection. This becomes even LESS relevant in an age of indie-musicians.

blackhole··on There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz format.
You always record stuff at 24-bit/192 kHz for many reasons usually involving minimizing analog artifacts and to give you a lot of information to work with. You use 32-bit float wavs to transport stuff around so you don't have to worry about normalizing levels and clipping. Lossless formats drastically improve the quality of transients by an enormous degree. But every single objection to this is either ignoring the points of the article, or talking about the benefits of recording at high fidelity, when this entire article is pointing out that once you have _finished a mix_, there is no reason to distribute things in 24-bit/192kHz. Most speakers can't even play about 20kHz anyway, which makes the entire point moot. I don't care if you have a bajillion kHz, the speakers can't play about 20 kHz, so your screwed.
blackhole··on Hey Github, Remember This Article?
Oh wait, but it doesn't matter! :D Because, you know, the whole point of the article being that whether or not what he did was "right" is irrelevant because banning him and then presenting a twisted truth to customers is not a productive solution to the problem.
blackhole··on Visual Studio '11' Announced
I'm sorry, but I use color to locate things. This, to me, is a disaster. If this isn't a problem for other people, fine, but it's a problem to me. A better solution would have been to use less color and desaturated tones rather than simply going to full on black and white, which serves only to rob the IDE of potential visual cues. This is like using a cannon to kill a bird. Just because they overcolorized VS2010 for no apparent reason doesn't mean they need to overcompensate in the opposite direction. I can't use this until someone comes up with color-based icons for it.
blackhole··on Nearly all binary search and merge sort implementations are broken (2006)
Assuming that hardware will work correctly can be an extremely dangerous assumption.
blackhole··on Education pays ...
There is a big, big, big problem when comparing degrees: People with PhD's are older and therefore have more experience. Everything in this entire chart could theoretically be attributed entirely to experience and not education. Of course, it could also all be education, but as they say, Correlation does not imply Causation.
blackhole··on Math is hard.
Algebra is important. Knowing sum-to-product trig identities, limits to 0/0 and obscure trigonometric integral identities are not. I am not saying none of it is required, I am saying some of it is not required, and that there is an unnecessary emphasis on it.

My comparison to assembly/Python was a comparison, but of course I should have expected people to take it to an extreme hyperbole. But then, your entire argument is based on the assumption that most people are not interested in mathematics, so I guess circular logic is totally fine in these arguments (and hilariously ironic).

No really, let's look at this. I'm saying that teaching high level math alongside low level math (or at least putting less emphasis on low level math) will make more people interested in math. You're saying this won't work because people aren't interested in math. That doesn't work.

blackhole··on Math is hard.
I want to say that while I did very well in math in high school, it didn't hold my interest until I got into calculus in university, and am now deeply interested in advanced vector analysis and other applied mathematics (I still hate proofs). I very much agree that much of high school is spent drilling useless topics into students heads that are completely unnecessary and never even explained beyond a few ridiculous "real-life" applications. All the interesting math is locked away, available only to those who suffer through meaningless tests and bureaucratic madness. It would be much better to introduce higher level topics first, showing students the incredible usefulness of high level math, and then using their curiosity to dig into the lower level concepts that make everything work, instead of forcing them to try and be interested in boring low-level rigor that , without a high-level structure, is of limited use.

It's like we're teaching kids mathematical assembly language instead of Python.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →