HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

blah32497

323 karma · joined August 21, 2013

submissionscomments
blah32497··on Julia, the One Programming Language to Rule Them All
Sounds like a CS PhD! hahaha (maybe Math?) I want to preface by saying that for most work that goes on in Silicon Valley a PhD adds nothing.

I know what you're talking about.

However outside of SV there are a lot of places where that's simply not the case. What you have is basically a cross disciplinary collaboration where you just don't have the educational background nor the expertise to do the engineering yourself.

The resentment your describing is really the same resentment you can feel towards your boss -"All he does is tell us what to do. He's not in the trenches like us!" - and it's directly related to the amount of mutual respect. In essence, how hard do you feel the other person is working relative to you.

Your description of your coworkers seems to indicate that you didn't feel like they're pulling their weight, and that's definitely a big problem.

I've heard second hand that in the valley there are a lot of incompetent PhDs that use their educational background as leverage to slack off. People will often hire graduates solely based on a degree thinking that if someone has a Math PhD "they're smart, they can learn on the job, and they'll contribute in some magical way just by being there". But actually these guys have just spent 5 years in poverty getting an advanced degree and don't want to be a code monkeys with a bunch of fresh out of college 21 year-olds. And, oh yeah - reality check, no one cares about their degree in abstract algebra.

9/10 of these PhDs are crappy engineers and 9/10 times they are thrown at problems they don't really have a background in (so they can't even be crappy and regurgitate equations they're memorized).

blah32497··on Julia, the One Programming Language to Rule Them All
There is a whole world of programming outside of web frameworks and cell phone apps haha.

Think of the people that for example made the traction control system for your car. You think the same person that worked out the math in some simulation in MATLAB wrote the code that went on the controller circuit? It's not impossible, but it's not likely.

Closer to home, you can think of companies like Leap Motion, the Oculus folks, the Kinect people. Often companies that deal with video processing or control systems depend on a core set of algorithms to set them apart from the competition. The engineers behind it generally have a high level of understanding of linear algebra and often statistics and 15+ years of experience in a field.

It's very hard (though in many areas not impossible) for a programmer to learn that stuff to a level where they can innovate and contribute - so you end up relying on specially trained people who don't know about inheritance and how to use git hahaha

Where I work algo development is done by about 50% PhDs, 25% MAs and 25% BA/BS.

blah32497··on Julia, the One Programming Language to Rule Them All
I totally see your point and for a lot of people what you're saying will resonate (I can see this really catching on with gradstudents), but the question really boils down to: do you really want your engineers spending time learning these things?

From what I've seen - it's incredibly hard to find a good engineer that knows his stuff. They generally have PhDs and years of training in math and whatever particular field they work on. If you get one that is actually doing novel algorithm development, each one is a golden goose that will bring in revenue for the company for years to come.

By contrast if you offer a decent salary you can get a good C++ programmer with 3-4 years of experience to do all your C++ grunt work. (we hire CS students from the local University, and bring them up to speed within 6 months)

While not incredibly hard, the problem with learning "appropriate structure for long term maintainability and production use" is that it takes an awfully long amount of time. You need to go through a lot of trial and error and learning from your mistakes. You need to read programming textbooks, and keep up with the latest trends. It's actually a huge time investment.

blah32497··on Julia, the One Programming Language to Rule Them All
(Note: I haven't tried Julia yet)

This would save so many man hours... At my shop, for every MATLAB engineer (mostly older guys) you need a C++ guru (mostly younger guys) to translate his stuff into something that will run fast.

On the other hand having seen the code the MATLAB folks write... I'd be worried. It's possible to write MATLAB in a way that is clean and makes the core algorithm presentable but that's rarely a priority. The real advantage of MATLAB is the quick development cycle. With the right packages you can make C++ look comparable... sorta.

Fundamentally the problem with MATLAB engineers is that they don't understand how to optimize code b/c they don't understand what's going on under the hood and they don't understand how to organize code b/c they don't have a concept of object oriented development, writing to interfaces, design patterns etc. etc.

EDIT: Just to clarify, I don't mean to denigrate MATLAB engineers. I'm just saying that in the current system you have two groups that specialize in different things. One focuses on algorithm development, and one on programming. I'm just speculating that maybe there is a good reason for it, and it may be unreasonable to ask one person to do both.

blah32497··on Microsoft Said to Be Preparing to Make Satya Nadella CEO
"Microsoft really isn't a consumer company"

yeah, except the video game market and the whole hardware market...

It's definitely the most obvious area for growth that they have available. The enterprise market is more or less saturated by them already. They're sorta trying to push their cloud solution, but they're late to that game. They aren't going to sell a whole bunch more of MS Office... It's a segment that will continue to develop organically, but the place where they really wanna be dumping cash on is definitely the consumer market.

I know everyone hates on Balmer, but he seemed to follow a very sensibly strategy and there seems to have been a genuinely big effort to integrate their different platforms and services into something that pleasant to use and develope for. At least stylistically, Windows RT, 8, Phone and Xbox are identical. The underlying "meat" is in wonderful languages (C#/F#), with a great IDE (VS13), with - from what I understand - and well made new libraries. They've also aggressively tried to cut out the old moldy stuff, and have paid for it in the short term (ex: Windows RT not supporting Win32 & Windows Phone 7 not being very compatible with Windows Phone 8)

blah32497··on A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will Stop Looking So Dorky
How about how when people use their smart-phones and the lil camera points at whoever is opposite them? It always kinda weirds me out and I wonder if they're taking a picture. But I think people are more or less okay with it now and 99% of people don't notice and don't mind.
blah32497··on Technology and wealth inequality
Yep yep. The John Rawls's theory of justice should be a required topic in school.

What matters is how well the poorest in society are doing, not the income distribution. If a system creates a mega rich class but ends up with the poorest in society being better off - then that's a better system.

I'd also qualify that "poverty" is flexible and always changing. I live on 10K/yr in college (2 years ago). I had to share a room with a roommate, ate a lot of rice and beans. I was a pain in the ass - though not nearly as bad as I thought it would be. However not being able to afford a cellphone or a car, having an ancient computer and not being able to afford a lot of social activities (movies, restaurants, etc.) had a noticeable negative affect on my life. If I had grown up my whole life on 10K/yr it probably would have had a major impact.

20 years ago, a car and a phone and internet were a luxury, in Africa or South America it's still a luxury. In modern america, it's poverty.

blah32497··on How to Start an Anonymous Blog
Finally someone who gets it! I've been saying this for ever. Our society is moving to one with fewer and fewer secrets.

When Facebook pushes privacy concerns, it's actually just reflecting our new reality and trying to stay relevant.

The "issue" that we will be coming up against is that people need time to adjust and to be honest, people aren't used to knowing everything about each other.

To give an absurd example for the purposes of illustration: If your boss finds out that you like to cross dress on the weekend it may reflect poorly on you . In reality this is simply b/c he knows something unusual about you and your coworkers continue to look "normal" in his eyes. If he knows that you crossdress, Jeff likes to be tied up, and Bob's wife is a tranny then it no longer becomes a big deal.

The same goes for more sensitive things, like the amount of women that have abortions, or misscarriages, or people that have mental disabilities or are on antidepressants, or do hard drugs in their spare time. We shield ourselves from certain things to the point where when we get exposed to them we don't react appropriately b/c we have no reference point.

The reason Obama wouldn't be okay with a mic is mostly because no president before him has had a mic. So if he cusses out other world leaders on the daily, he'll look like a grade A asshole - regardless of whether or not other presidents have done it.

blah32497··on Vinod Khosla Wants Californians To Keep Out of Martins Beach
Sorry, but this is such a vapid statement.

Yes, sometimes people ascribe things to culture which aren't due to culture, and sometimes the converse is true too.

It's one thing to say "No, actually you're ascribing something to culture which isn't part of Indian culture at all. This is just him being a tool" but you've made no effort to explain why you think his actions aren't in line with his cultural upbringing.

PS: As a child of immigrants, I constantly see how culture is the root cause of a lot of my parent's "bad"/unacceptable-in-America behavior.

blah32497··on Companies Flee U.S. Tax System by Reincorporating Abroad
Well they aren't really rich if they can't spend the money haha

But I see your point: Though it would seem that the way people currently get paid with stock options - where you pay tax when you "cash out" - is effectively equivalent (except it's even more regressive because the capital gains tax is a joke).

blah32497··on Companies Flee U.S. Tax System by Reincorporating Abroad
"If you abolish corporate income taxes, then I could have my company loan you the $1000 and receive the interest; it would then compound at 5% per year, and I would only pay income tax when the money is paid out to me as a dividend. In effect, you would be turning corporations into tax shelters."

Can you explain what the problem is? I mean you use the term "tax-shelter" and we associate that with something bad. But what's wrong with only taxing when you actually get access to the money you made?

You can't even sell the company without having to pay taxes. The money seems 100% unusable till you pay taxes on it. I guess you can reinvest it into something else without cashing out, but that hardly seems like a bad thing

blah32497··on Why I'm Betting On Julia
I used R day to day, but it's NOT as easy as MATLAB. There just isn't the same level of documentation and clarity.
blah32497··on Dropbox raises about $250 million at $10 billion valuation
Well why doesn't that square up with the valuation then? Did Dropbox lowball themselves?
blah32497··on Keyboard innovation is making them worse
I thought the author sounded like a curmudgeony luddite. Ofcourse anything "different" will feel wrong for a little while. You have some muscle memory that you need to get over. So if you really wanna write a review, suck it up and use it till your fingers get rewired. Then write your reviews complaining about keyboard design.

I don't think he even tried the keyboards he's talking about, let alone give himself some time to get used to them.

I don't go read Vi's man page and then complain how it's too hard and unusual.

blah32497··on Dropbox raises about $250 million at $10 billion valuation
EDIT: "benmanns" pointed out the point of confusion. thanks!

I don't think we're disagreeing.

Sure they bought 2% not 100% of the company, but that's not really relevant. The $200M/yr they currently make is I assume profit - which is either payed out as dividends or invested back into the company. It's not really important which ones b/c the two are in the grand scheme of things equivalent. An investment increasing the worth of the company and therefore the worth of their share of it.

I feel like in the end it still represents an expectation of 2% growth...

blah32497··on Dropbox raises about $250 million at $10 billion valuation
I don't really know how these numbers are generated, so I really have no idea what I'm talking about - but just back-of-the-napkin:

100*($200 million / $10 Billion) = 2%

So assuming no growth, the investors are back getting 2% a year? So basically matching inflation...

So does this indicate that the market is split on whether they'll continue to grow or not?

blah32497··on Value is created by doing
"what happens when you're too heavy on the "doing" end of the spectrum?"

I can't think of a startup, but I can think of people like that. The first people that come to mind are the Mythbuster people. Very handy, very good at cranking out their ideas into meat-space - but my impression is that there is very very little critical thinking. This is probably in large part due to the demands of TV (You need cool gadgets and experiments - who cares if the experiment is poorly conceived when it looks cool?)

But a lot of hobbyists also fall in to that category: doing projects that have already been done, or ones where the solution isn't particularly intellectually exciting/innovative/stimulating but just mostly takes a bunch of time (ex: spending your weekend programming a PLD to control a stop light).

It's kinda hard to accuse these people of "doing" too much.. b/c doing is better than just sitting watching TV. But say instead of programming a stoplight all weekend you for instance read some textbooks and learning some higher level math, or read some blogs to get some inspiration, or read some scifi to get in a more creative mood - It gets kinda harder to make an objective comparison of which is "better".

blah32497··on Startup Culture Divide: United States and Japan
A very good description! I wanted to add a few things that I noticed to balance off what you said. For context I did a 2 month internship at a Japanese company near Tokyo ( a major multinational, very very salaryman-oriented). I'm clearly not at informed as you, but I think it will be useful.

1 - Management was very very good. It was a little rigid at times, but everything was well organized and I had no complaints. Some things like bells for the start of the work day, start of lunch, end of lunch... were a little eerie at first, but once you got used to it, it was actually fine.

2 - The company is mother the company is father. You're absolutely right that the company takes care of you. It's sorta like a family - though an awkward family. Awkward in part because you have an employer-employee relationship and also because Japanese people are a little more awkward (especially tech people). Anytime someone is transferred or hired in your division (about once every two weeks) you all go out to drink/dinner/karaoke together. It wasn't anything too crazy, but it was generally a really nice restaurant every time and there was a special company account that pays for it. It never felt like the company was being stingy with you (though we didn't have very top of the line hardware to work on...) One time I had some miscommunication about when I was coming back from a short break and my boss was honestly concerned, some phone calls were made to the hotel etc. etc. They really do care about their employees.

3 - You aren't stuck doing the same job till you die. People are constantly shuttled around internally. I think on average people were moved every two years. If you didn't work hard, you could get transferred to a crappy job. If you did really well, you would have say in where you were transferred. In fact since no one is fired the way they squeeze you out is by constantly reassigning you and giving you crappy positions.

4 – For historic reasons people ended up working insane hours. 12 hours days are the norm for a lot of people... But strangely enough there wasn't any explicit requirement to work that long, and it wasn’t really rewarded. In fact the company was pretty concerned about it and was trying to get people to go home earlier. Wednesdays you were explicitly forbidden from working more than 8 hours. Strangely on the whole people didn't see to be in a rush to go see their families, and to be honest the men didn't seem very close to their families. I only saw one guy who worked 8hrs/day every day. No one gave him shit though

5 - US multinationals are on the scene and are causing major changes. I talked to a girl working a Oracle in Japan and she said that there are many new "hybrid" companies that have elements of US and Japanese management. It seemed that they were very successful. The Japanese management style has a lot of good elements, and the US system has a lot of problems. I could see the right mix being great.

blah32497··on Super successful companies
I think it's ruthless in regards to their suppliers/competition/clients, not their employees. The reality of the capitalist system is that you can't be "nice" to your competition or suppliers.
blah32497··on Poll: As a founder, what is your salary?
They're gambling on getting an even larger userbase and having Facebook offer $5B
blah32497··on Poll: As a founder, what is your salary?
lol @ "profitable"

What rock have you been living under? The SV game hasn't been about having a normal profitable business model for the god-knows-how-long.

You gotta get "value" and traffic and buzz and hype! Then maybe Google of whatever will buy you.

It's basically a sort of bubble. And while you operate in a bubble you can make a lot of money!

The only guys in town making money are ad companies, enterprise software companies, and hardware companies

blah32497··on AMD launches Kaveri processors aimed at starting a computing revolution
Can you give examples of medicines developed thanks to computational chemistry simulations?

I'm rather ignorant about this area of research, but it always seemed to me kinda fruitless? Sorta like high throughput screening - a ton of resources and computation is dedicated because it sounds like a good idea... but ultimately there is very little to show for it all.

Way too little signal and way too much noise.

blah32497··on How to stop feeling lonely
Your reply reminds me of the fact that people often confound loneliness and boredom. When your life isn't very engaging you start to feel like you don't have enough people in your life, and you need people to vent your frustrations to.

I think if you look at people that have very full busy lives they are not the sort of people that will often complain about loneliness.

If you look at the top comment for this thread - the suggestion of getting a significant other is actually about fighting boredom. It's about filling in all the gaps in your life with what he characterizes as trivial conversations and concerns.

blah32497··on How to stop feeling lonely
One thing I'd highly recommend is looking at is: 1 what are* your secrets 2 is there a way you can make it so you have fewer of them

secrets are incredibly parasitic and ultimately stressful. There was a recent post on HN about this (though 90% of the comments missed the point he was making) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6891311

blah32497··on All Norwegians become crown millionaires, in oil saving landmark
My anecdotal experience 3 years ago living in Japan (near Tokyo, for 2 months doing an internship) was that the prices on average were similar to what I experienced back home in California. Occasionally some things were surprisingly more expensive, and others were surprisingly cheap. The 100yen (~$1) stores were better stocked than in the US and I could get most things I needed from them. They also were located in malls and were very nice to shop in. Things like sushi that I expected to be cheaper were about the same price as back in the US (which was seriously disappointing!), and cheaper food was seriously cheap and relatively healthy. I lost like 20 lbs eating all those beef bowls and noodles. Trains were not super cheap, but not overly expensive. It's way way waaaayyyy cheaper than Europe and unlike in Europe they privately owned, aren't subsidized and make a profit which was a relief to hear (I can't think of another country that has an unsubsidized public transportation system) I think the bus from Tokyo to Kyoto was about 40 bucks (my memory is a bit hazy). . Owning a car and driving places from what I understood is extremely expensive. I think most of my coworkers didn't own cars. A relatively short drive on the freeway can easily set you back $50 (tolls roads everywhere). I didn't get any hard figures for wages, but I think generally people didn't make a killing, but people lived comfortably and it seemed they could support a family on one wage. They did however work 12 hours a day... so I don't think they got to enjoy whatever income they made.
blah32497··on Tesla Model S Center Console
Since there is all that extra room... The 80s called, can we please have bench-seats back?

I had an old crown vic a few years ago and I missed those huge sofa-like bench-seats all the time. Modern bucket seats in comparison are incredibly constructing and claustrophobic. Not every car needs to feel like a racecar. Sometimes I want a comfy roadtrip on my floating sofa.

blah32497··on Oculus VR’s New “Crystal Cove” Prototype Is Kind of Amazing
"they risk Microsoft or Sony beating them to the punch"

I very curious what the competition is doing. They're obviously working on competing products, but nothing has been made public.

blah32497··on Oculus VR’s New “Crystal Cove” Prototype Is Kind of Amazing
I think walking through walls would be very unlikely.

I spoke with someone who used VR goggles many years ago. The tech demo he was show was simply being in a room with a bottomless pit in the middle. He said even though you knew that in reality there was a carpeted floor, it was impossible virtually impossible to make yourself walk over the pit. You just had way too many mental blocks that stopped you from doing it.

I imagine something similar would happen with a wall. It would feel very eery and uncomfortable to walk through the wall.

blah32497··on JPMorgan Pays for Shorting Madoff Without Telling Anyone
"They were fined for not doing their job"

Which in this case was also the SEC's job... Your statement doesn't contradict refub's

blah32497··on JPMorgan Pays for Shorting Madoff Without Telling Anyone
Does anyone else think it's kinda crazy that banks are required by law to act like policemen? Seems like that's the government's job.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →