HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

blueadept111

285 karma · joined April 14, 2016

submissionscomments
blueadept111··on Ethical bot-making
Animals aren't people, people are animals.
blueadept111··on Which College Produces the Most Billionaires?
Which aftershave produces the most billionaires?
blueadept111··on Against software development
>Software grows until it exceeds our capacity to understand it.

This point is well taken, and I think that many organization would benefit from having a CGR role ("chief grim reaper"), who's job would be not to enhance the codebase or its functionality, but to do the opposite: to kill/simplify code and prevent the codebase from exceeding a certain net complexity over time. Simplicity itself need to be treated as a core feature, and the success of the CGR need to be defined by whether that core feature is maintained.

blueadept111··on Can we rule out near-term AGI? [video]
Yes, we can rule out near-term AGI, because we can also rule out far-term AGI, at least in the way AGI is defined in this talk. You can't isolate "economically beneficial" aspects of intelligence. Emulating human-like intelligence means emulating the primitive parts of the brain as well, including lust, fear, suspicion, hate, envy, etc... these are inseparable building blocks of human intelligence. Unless you can model those (and a lot else besides), then you don't have AGI, at least not one that can (for example) read a novel and understand what the heck is going on and why.
blueadept111··on Artificial Intelligence Hits the Barrier of Meaning
Maybe the future involves direct brain interfacing between humans via biological interconnects, and a new kind of engineering will evolve, defined not by behavior/functionality in the objective world, but in a realm of shared consciousness that is only subjectively accessible to biological entities that have a similar level of brain evolution.

In fact our own brains probably already work this way, with different parts of the brain acting as loci of lower-level consciousness, but also somehow becoming more than the sum of their semi/sub-conscious parts when acting in concert.

And maybe computers just can't participate in this shared consciousness, even in principle, because they're made out of the wrong 'stuff' along a dimension of reality we don't yet understand (or may never understand).

blueadept111··on Artificial Intelligence Hits the Barrier of Meaning
You haven't actually said anything I disagree with, even though I'm in the castle. "Retreat" sounds a little harsh. I would say "Comfortably ensconced". Even if an AI nails down the behavioral/functional aspects of a biological brain, that doesn't necessarily mean that the qualia have come along for the ride.

Does it matter if they have? That seems to be the real question.

Allow me to propose a thought experiment: I'm a traveller from the future, where the notion of 'qualia' is understood and engineered (maybe using techniques we would somewhat recognize today, maybe not). I present you with a machine that has a single red button. When the button is pressed, there is no observable behavior, except that 10,000 AI's are instantly created and subjected to extreme agony until the button is pressed again. What are your thoughts on pressing this button?

blueadept111··on Artificial Intelligence Hits the Barrier of Meaning
Pain and pleasure, which are qualitative experiences, are the basis of operant conditioning (unsupervised learning ala behavioral psychology). This covers the massive domain of behavior that's informed/dictated by reinforcement/punishment. So they are pretty fundamental if you care about building something that's analogous to biological life, depending of course on how deeply you want that analogy to extend.
blueadept111··on Artificial Intelligence Hits the Barrier of Meaning
Everything OP says is correct.

And let's not forget that even in the absence of adversarial attacks, even with flawless associative mapping and incredible generalization, even hypothetically solving the problem of higher level ontological 'meaning', there's STILL absolutely no known way for AI to even begin to address the matter of the qualia - how to build something that's actually has a conscious perception (of pain, for example). We're groping in the dark without matches, and there will be many more seasons/winters to come.

blueadept111··on Show HN: A platform for women to crowd-source advice in confidence
I'm glad you're glad. :)

Re. "the main thing", it would really help me out if you could provide some examples of issues that relate to being a man, that a women cannot advise a man on.

blueadept111··on Show HN: A platform for women to crowd-source advice in confidence
How about a "no African Americans allowed" forum, for fostering "intimacy" for people who need a place to freely talk about issues limited to those who aren't African American?

I'd say that kind of group is latently hostile because it seeks exclusion rather than to encourage a broader perspective, and discussion topics probably center around the excluded group (ingroup/outgroup). Seems like a good litmus test.

blueadept111··on Show HN: A platform for women to crowd-source advice in confidence
That's quite a leap from saying that certain topics are only relevant for women to saying that it's about freedom. Nobody is preventing women from talking about these topics in any other forum. You're saying that the advantage of perceived intimacy is greater than the disadvantage of losing the broader perspective that includes men. If I was in a bad mood, I'd say it's classic ingroup/outgroup psychology, which is latently ugly.

But I'm in a good mood, so I'll only say that there's nothing intimate about an environment where everyone is anonymous.

blueadept111··on Show HN: A platform for women to crowd-source advice in confidence
I don't get it, what problem is this app solving by excluding men from giving or asking for advice as well?
blueadept111··on Neglected side projects for less than $1000
They failed because they're mediocre to abysmal ideas that are implemented probably just well enough to scratch the itch of a hobbyist, before outing themselves as flops in the real world. And any that are actually good ideas with a poor interface need to be rewritten anyways, either to improve the UI or scale with growth/success. So beyond "the idea" of the app (which might have value in some cases), the majority are actually worth less than nothing, they're the proven failures. It's like shopping for a formula one racecar in a junk yard, and thinking "wow, some of these even have wheels!"

You can disagree, no point in flogging a dead horse (or app). :)

blueadept111··on Neglected side projects for less than $1000
If by "almost always" you mean never, then you're right.

Let me put it way: if you wanted to create a terrific blockbuster novel, would you start by scanning in some obscure, cheap title from the discount bin and then editing it, until you had your masterpiece?

These projects are abandoned for a reason. They need to be refactored/modified to go anywhere. If you think it makes more sense to refactor a simple/failed project than rewrite it from scratch, then you're not in the "savvy buyer" category I was talking about.

blueadept111··on Neglected side projects for less than $1000
It's hard to imagine what the value proposition is for the savvy buyer, aside from browsing ideas that they might want to implement for themselves from scratch.

Great site for sellers if they can actually unload here, though.

blueadept111··on Things Stanislaw Lem Predicted
Lem is an underrated genius. He explores deep ideas in philosophy of mind, through entertaining and creative thought-experiment-type short stories that are set in the future. He wasn't a futurist per se, but crafted futuristic scenarios specifically to force the reader to question the fundamental nature of consciousness.
blueadept111··on Why we’re changing Flickr free accounts
My thoughts exactly, those are the images I typically search. Wikimedia commons does seem to have a bot (and/or some kind of manual process) that collects some of the creative commons photos from Flickr, but not all of them, even if they are good photos that are well-tagged. I usually search both sites, so I have a good sense of how often a photo appears one on site and not the other. Incidentally, it would sure be nice if Wikimedia commons allowed you to filter by license type.

I do hope some bot out there is collecting and archiving Flickr's creative commons photos before they disappear for good.

blueadept111··on Why we’re changing Flickr free accounts
This is the death knell for Flickr. I've relied heavily on Flickr advanced search to find nature photos of particular plant and animal species. This new policy will undoubtedly results in many photos being deleted, and therefore limiting the search results. Their large archive of photos is/was a real asset, albeit one they haven't been smart enough to monetize effectively. Deleting these photos is just another small step in the slow disintegration of the site, sadly.
blueadept111··on No Phd, No Problem: New Schemes Teach the Masses to Build AI
For the same reason there's an arbitrary blockade against awarding a phD to someone with no formal training from a university.
blueadept111··on Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks
The concept of "fake" news is a slippery slope. Anyone that's in the business of gathering and presenting news has a number of vested interests. Sensationalism. Fabrication. Fear mongering. Persuasion. Ingratiation. Language itself is mostly a tool for some shade of lying and/or intimidation, with the occasional fringe use of conveying factual information or for enabling cooperation between peers.
blueadept111··on Show HN: Coffee Chat – Trade your expertise
I think "Trade your experience" would be more valuable than "trade your expertise". If I need expert knowledge of a well-defined domain, there's always Google. But if I need advice from someone who's had a particular experience, there's no easy way to find answers.

For example, I'd like to talk to someone who's self-published a book and overcome the many small challenges associated with that journey. Would this person identify themselves as an "expert" in overcoming any of those particular obstacles? Probably not.

And similarly, I have a lot of experiential knowledge to share with others, that doesn't necessarily fit under the umbrella of a single "expert" label. My valuable experiential knowledge covers dozens of niche areas.

I'm not sure how a service could effectively act as a match maker for that type of experiential knowledge, though.

blueadept111··on Universal Basic Income Is Silicon Valley’s Latest Scam
People waiting for UBI can get in the same line as the people waiting for the singularity.
blueadept111··on Tech Workers Now Want to Know: What Are We Building This For?
This trend is nothing more than a reflection of the fact that unemployment is at record lows. It does not represent a new, heightened morality in employees (that would persist even if the job market soured, for example).
blueadept111··on Ask HN: How reliable are Glassdoor reviews?
Well said, Amen.
blueadept111··on How solid is Tim’s plan to redecentralize the web?
That's correct, and if the companies can't see the data, then the data is really just an extension of client side storage, and therefore it can't be trusted, because you can never trust the client.
blueadept111··on Scientists are looking for ways to put the simulation hypothesis to the test
It's absurd to think that any entity within a simulation could draw conclusions about anything outside the simulation itself.

"Better than 50%" my ass, Elon and Neil are hacks.

blueadept111··on Ask HN: Anyone from Google here? The new Gmail UI is painful
I was using Gmail in 'classic' mode until today, when they force-upgraded to the new layout. In my opinion, even the "compact" mode is less compact. I don't like it.

So as of today I'm forwarding all my email to protonmail. This was just the push I needed to start switching over.

blueadept111··on Ask HN: My company plans an ICO despite my opposition as CTO, any advice?
Here's an opposing view, from someone a little older and maybe a little wiser. In the big scheme of things, you're not that important. Your company is also not that important, and whether or not your company chooses to adopt this coin is not that important. If it's a "fraud" by your definition, then many, many other coins (and companies, for that matter) are also fraudulent, and it's not a very important fraud, so don't worry so much about saving the world from it. If you have any interest in working on blockchain technology, go with the flow. Leverage what skills and advantages you have in your life, don't burn bridges, and especially try to keep from burning your bridges because of ego issues. Remember, you're not that important. But you are important enough to do what you enjoy, important enough to have people in your life and career who look out for you, and important enough that every single day you learn something or work on something that progresses your ambition in some way. Maybe this coin offering can be a part of that and maybe not, but the answer is more likely to be found within your own psychology than the details of this particular technological/business crossroads.
blueadept111··on Basecoin: A Robust, Price-Stable Cryptocurrency with an Algorithmic Central Bank
So how does this coin make or save me money, to compensate for the risk of buying it and trusting the "algorithmic" central bank (which apparently has a tweakable algorithm, and therefore requires trust in the central overseer?)
blueadept111··on Ask HN: What are best tools for web scraping?
Jaunt [http://jaunt-api.com] is a good java tool.
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →