HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bluntly_said

109 karma · joined September 12, 2012

submissionscomments
bluntly_said··on Artillery is building a hardcore RTS with HTML5 and WebGL
No, it's really not. This is what consoles are trying to become, but they're also a long way off. They're also expensive, dedicated machines.

Even assuming this IS what console are for, why in the world are you going to complain about more competition in the market for a good way to distribute games?

bluntly_said··on Kevin Spacey on the potential of Netflix to disrupt traditional TV [video]
I think you're being too black and white here.

I agree with you in principle on a LOT of the points, but the real issue is that most content producers (publishers are a different issue...) would LOVE to be able to do this:

"The recipe for dealing with piracy is ages old - increase quality to be competitive"

But realistically it's fucking HARD. Mainly because increasing quality to be competitive with piracy would generally require breaking tax and import laws everywhere.

Even if it doesn't require breaking those laws to be competitive, you have to at least pay enough people to be aware of them, for each and every country you want to be able to distribute your content in.

So decent* DRM isn't about stopping piracy, really. It's about slowing it down just enough that it's still worthwhile to jump through the hoops required to bring that content legally to other regions.

*: It's actually fairly hard to hit this goal on the head, and often I feel companies buy too far into their own bullshit and sense of entitlement with DRM. A lot of shoddy executives with poor understanding of software misuse DRM to the extent that it drastically lowers the value of the content (see: always on DRM) Please continue to bash them, they deserve it.

bluntly_said··on Kevin Spacey on the potential of Netflix to disrupt traditional TV [video]
I think this is the wrong way to look at it.

When you're in a constrained format like radio or cable tv you can only play one thing for your audience at a time. Because of that it's critical that what you play has mass appeal so that lots of people will be okay listening to it.

When you're in an unconstrained model that lets users pick what to watch or listen to, that mass appeal factor becomes much less important.

Sure, there's a HUGE array of music available, and each of us can claim that we think most of it's shitty. But when you actually start comparing what you consider shitty to what I consider shitty, I'd be willing to bet there are a LOT of areas that don't overlap.

This is the power that comes with being able to stream the content that the user wants. Mass appeal becomes much less important.

So yeah, there's a huge amount of music out there that I think is shitty. But there's an equally huge number of people that all have different opinions on what the shit actually is.

bluntly_said··on Kevin Spacey on the potential of Netflix to disrupt traditional TV [video]
Well, in general Netflix seems interested in providing content that falls into one of two categories. The first is what I think of as "low barrier to entry" tv shows. These are shows that people can turn on while cooking, cleaning, or doing other things around the house to replace pre-programmed tv channels.

"Many of the most-watched series have been off the air for years, like Star Trek and The X-Files." [1]

Personally, I think this kind of content goes a long way to keeping subscribers on Netflix, when they might have otherwise been tempted to turn on a tv channel.

The second kind of content Netflix appears to be interested in is content that pulls in new subscribers, This could be things like movies that were very recently released, or their own original content (mainly to replace the expensive deals to get those new movies).

But the thing about Netflix is that even a new show that might be viewed by other network producers as a flop can end up being a a good call. This is because Netflix isn't constrained by the same limits that cable tv is. The shows Netflix produces don't need to be blockbuster hits, as long as they can help fill the gaps in the "low barrier to entry" tv that keeps subscribers happy over the long run.

A cable channel can only show one thing to all it's viewers at a time, so filling that time slot with something that everyone likes is critical. Netflix can afford a slower burn with content that might not get a million viewers in the first season, but could easily be watched by several million viewers in the next 5 years.

[1] http://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/the-exchange/netflix-dropped-...

bluntly_said··on The Cord-Cutting Fantasy
Even assuming the numbers here are correct (and I'm rather skeptical) it means that channels like ESPN are getting heavily subsidized by cable subscribers who aren't interested in that content. That's not a win to me. That's my money going to produce shows that I don't like and don't want to watch.

If ESPN is unable to sustain the level of content/quality they currently show without huge subsidies, they shouldn't be making it. The subsidy to ESPN implies that channels and shows that I DO WATCH are not receiving a fair amount of my bill for the time I spend watching them.

This is not a "better for all" type of socialism. It's a "better for the entrenched" type of taxation.

To reiterate a common theme in the comments: "A la cart distribution is good for consumers and content creators, and is bad for networks and cable providers"

bluntly_said··on Disruptions: It is rude to send a "Thank You" e-mail.
This is self-centered and egotistical to a fault. So a thank email is too hard to deal with, but I'm expected to read him whine about them?
bluntly_said··on Copyright Trolls Order Wordpress To Hand Over Critics’ IP Addresses
This misses his point entirely. Sure, everyone in a small town knows each other, but it used to be that when you moved to a NEW small town (or anywhere else for that matter), almost nothing followed you. You could re-invent yourself, move past old failures. Now you have a constant and easily accessible record of your life online, which anyone can look up. There is no space you can go to that people can't easily find records of who you used to be. THAT is a loss of anonymity.
bluntly_said··on Google services should not require real names: Vint Cerf
It's a dialog that shows up every time I log into youtube, and requires (as of the last time I went through it) clicking about 5 different buttons to keep my real name off the service. I didn't have to lie, but it DEMANDED that I select a reason for not wanting my name on the service, and you can tell they're trying to get users to cave and just click "yes" once. It's shitty, argumentative, and unpleasant to use.
bluntly_said··on Apple Officially Reveals The iPhone 5
But see, that's my point. It's not really the best designed thing on the market anymore. It's one good choice among many.

Sure the first generation iPhone was just hands down better than the competition at the time, but it's not anymore.

Claiming that the look, heft, and hand feel are better is ridiculous, all of them are subjective opinions that vary widely among users (Take me for example, I really like the slate and glass look, but since I have big hands I dislike the heft and hand feel.)

Further, the thing is running a new version of the OS, so when you talk about the UX of iOS 6, what you're really saying is that you believe (based on previous Apple iOS releases) that they will create a good user experience. That's branding.

And I want to stop and state: branding isn't bad. If you've had a previous version of a product and you LIKED it, it's entirely reasonable to assume a future release is also something you'd like. but that doesn't make the device any better or worse, it just makes you more likely to buy it.

And finally, yes I agree that Apple has carefully curated their ecosystem so it seems clean and polished. But it's not any richer (my opinion is that it's considerably less rich since it's so heavily curated, but again that's opinion). MOST importantly though, the ecosystem has little to do with the device itself, that same ecosystem could exist around any device (and does exist around older iPhones).

bluntly_said··on Apple Officially Reveals The iPhone 5
To answer your question: I'd say it means the people choosing to buy the iPhone aren't doing it based on the merits of the device, but rather the ecosystem around it (A LARGE part of which is advertising, particularly advertising that makes the device a status symbol).

I say this because he's right, from a technical perspective the iPhone is "basically" just another smartphone. The guts are the same, the form factor is essentially the same. Hell, at this point even the feature sets of iOs and Android are basically the same.

So yes, there are reasons why people choose to buy an iPhone. But the only real "lesson" I see at this point is that brand names and advertising work...

← PreviousPage 2 of 2