HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bm3719

1,153 karma · joined January 18, 2011

https://macroexpand.com/~bm3719
submissionscomments
bm3719··on RedBalloon – free speech job board
Glad to see this. If nothing else, it's worth it if you want to hedge against a certain kind of situation that we see articles about here every week.

At this point in the culture war, I'd probably rather work for a small Christian company than some of the BigTech corps, all other things being equal. And I'm an atheist. Never thought I'd say something like that, but here we are.

bm3719··on Agile Is Dead, McKinsey Just Killed It
It'd be nice if there were some way to filter out job listings where some heavyweight development methodology was in effect. Some make it obvious in the description text, dropping SCRUM/Agile-related buzzwords. Others sounded awesome, promising an enlightened developer-centric focus and autonomy. Then I've shown up to find I'll be a mechanistic story point generator, wasting everyone's time.

This is an area I've had to exercise acceptance on. Even if SCRUM dies, the selling points for it (control, measurement, and interchangeability) are too powerful such that something else won't come in and replace it. However, I would like to know a team thinks that way, so we can steer clear of each other.

bm3719··on Misinformation on Reddit has become unmanageable, 3 Alberta moderators say
The internet worked just fine before we decided that free speech as a societal value was an inconvenience. Turns out being the thought police is hard work though, so that's good. Maybe you'll save us all the trouble and stop?

Judging from the people in this article and my experience with the cesspool that is Reddit and their mods, I'd rather go back to relying on my own brain than them telling me what the contents of it should be.

bm3719··on The Framework is the most exciting laptop I've used
I use these exclusively and have the trackpad disabled on my Thinkpad (an old x230).

The #1 reason I use it is to not move my hands when I need to do a pointing operation. You can get very precise with it too, but it takes some getting used to. I'm a klutz with a trackpad now, since I've been using the pointer for so many years. I use a tiling window manager and very few GUI apps (often even using the web in w3m), so mousing isn't as important for me, which is another factor.

I wouldn't play a video game with it, of course, but I'd imagine trackpads suck at those too.

bm3719··on Women are nearly half of new gun buyers, study finds
Not sure how anyone can respond to your assertion that it's silly and absurd. I'm fine with you feeling that way as long as you don't try to restrict my right to own them.

I guess one thing I can say is that security needs indeed are met by firearms, including yours to the degree that the police or private security protect you. So, it shouldn't be too foreign of a concept to anyone. Some of us choose to extend that protection to our homes and person, and take responsibility over it to varying degrees.

bm3719··on Women are nearly half of new gun buyers, study finds
This is correct. My current collectables (C&R and antique) are all capable of being fired, but I almost never do due to their value and risk of damaging them. Many are over 100 years old and there's a decent enough chance some irreplaceable part will break during use. I can also easily reduce their value by 1000s of dollars by doing something like this. I keep them because I enjoy their historical significance and the interesting mechanical solutions they embody, not for their ability to launch projectiles. When I'm ready to go to the nursing home, I'll sell them and get my money back or more.

A good percentage of the firearms out there are like this, which was my point for those not aware. Another good percentage are specialized for sporting use. Some are so inappropriate for combat that you'd be better off with a spear (e.g., if given the choice between a 50lb benchrest rifle and a spear, I'll take the spear).

bm3719··on Women are nearly half of new gun buyers, study finds
Between the two, I might go with the knife in most situations. I can't carry my hunting rifle around with me all day. Mine also has a huge scope on it that makes it useless at the distances you would typically encounter a hostile human attacker. The rifle is also overpowered for the job, and introduces concern for damage to unintended targets.
bm3719··on Free markets are creating a major free speech problem
So we're integrating our market more with China's market, making the relationship less one-sided. Some economists have argued that China is actually more economically free than the West in certain areas (like the overhead involved in starting a new business), though I'd say we're at least slightly better off here overall.

However, the West definitely has China beat in the area of free speech. Speech and the market are intertwined at various levels, so we'll see friction there. I'd say it has less to do with market freedom (of either participant) and more to do with China simply not having anything close to free speech.

Whether we decide to stand our ground on this or not is a separate question. One good way to do it at least for the internet is to favor open, non-proprietary systems that aren't controlled by any one profit-focused company. That way we don't all have to suffer the consequences when a single company like Google bends the knee to China for their own financial gain, and leaves the rest of us holding the bag on the reduced free speech front.

bm3719··on Women are nearly half of new gun buyers, study finds
Excellent. There's no reason defensive gun buyers should be demographically different from the general population. It's understandable that gun sales for hunting or other activities might show differences, but we all have the same personal security needs.

Side note: I'm one of the people here with a large collection of firearms. One thing to realize when you see the statistic that the US has more firearms than people is that only a percentage of them are really combat worthy/capable. Most of my collection, for example, are collectable historic pieces, or dedicated target/sporting firearms. Some of these could feasibly be pressed into service if you had absolutely nothing else, but they would be extremely sub-optimal for the task.

bm3719··on Poll: Covid Vaccine Mandate in Tech
When they come for me, I plan to quit. I WFH, live in the middle of nowhere, grow most of my own food, and go weeks without interacting with someone not in the household.

I don't need the money so quitting's not a big deal for me, but I do feel sorry for those not in a position to take a principled stand for personal choice and autonomy over their own bodies.

I'll consider coming back to work when/if something close to the old normal returns some day.

bm3719··on Facial recognition technology: How to opt out at the airport
The facial recognition battle is lost. The only power we have is over how we behave as the losing side.

Of the few options we have, one is normalizing wearing recognition-scrambling makeup/masks. Another would be to get stickers of eyes, brows, and noses, and place them in random places around your face.

It'd be interesting to see some studies of the effectiveness of the different methods.

bm3719··on [dead]
Minimal only in the code the developer has to write, I guess.

Electron: Delivering users nothing we didn't already have, but taking away so much (and sometimes, like here, only on Windows!)

bm3719··on Why Firefox has been in decline for 12 years
There's a theory in the Free Software community that BigTech sponsorship of Mozilla was intended to bring about the current state of affairs.

The idea is that MS, Google, and others really have no reason to donate to a direct competitor. Perhaps they did so because they knew it would give them control. That control was exercised over the years and now Mozilla is more a social justice advocacy organization than a foundation that develops a web browser. The sorry state of FF was the inevitable result.

Whether you buy this narrative or not, the fact is there remains no effective threat whatsoever to the massive data collection that occurs whenever you use Chrome or Edge. 10 years ago, MS/Google had no ability to spy on the web surfing of the vast majority of computer users. Now they do.

bm3719··on 90 Hours a Week and Loving It
I will say I was 100% dialed into the job. I could answer just about any question related to what I was working on and I knew the languages/platforms/domain better than anything I've worked with since. That could be a positive if something out of your control doesn't take it away from you and leave you hanging.

However, the law of diminishing returns definitely applied and my energy reserves were depleted within a few months, never having a chance to recharge. I recall towards the end I would catch myself sometimes just staring at the monitor for an hour or more, doing nothing. I also think this was a one-time shot for me—I lost something I can't get back and wouldn't have it in me to do this again.

In some video games you can deplete stamina, but permanent debuffs can drain max stamina. I like to think of it as the first happening, then eventually the latter.

bm3719··on 90 Hours a Week and Loving It
I've done 84/wk for the better part of a year. With commuting it was well over 90. Didn't bother me too bad at the time, but took a toll on my health and pretty much everything else in life. I wouldn't recommend it just for the health reasons if nothing else, but those other things that just didn't get done were important too. I'll also say that jobs are ephemeral, and there's really not much benefit to going all-in like that on any of them. Apart from larger amounts of cash in a shorter amount of time (and much higher tax burden), I have nothing to show now for that kind of dedication to my employer's cause. It's not like you'll learn more, you'll just work more and the job becomes your life.
bm3719··on The NSA's Backdoor in Dual EC
https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1433470109742518273.html
bm3719··on I Regret Being a Hipster in Tech
Noticed the same pretty early here too. My response was to categorize all tech into ephemeral implementations and more persistent concepts. The latter moves a lot slower. New fundamental ideas just don't come around as quickly as people writing their own take on them or combination of them. Some paths through SE make this easier or harder, i.e. being a front-end dev can easily have you drowning in library churn and simply without the time for any deep thoughts.

It's definitely an important factor to both notice at all and your decision in regards to it has lasting repercussions. In my experience, the majority of devs don't take the conceptual path, so I've tended to let them get excited about NewFancyLibrary and while I focus on more abstract things like architecture, modeling systems, and languages. Seems to work pretty good, since we're both happy with the arrangement.

bm3719··on Clojure builds as an amalgamation of orthogonal parts
As a Clojure developer focused on creating correct/working software, I find the "Simple"-ness of my tooling's internal architecture to be a lower priority than it not leaking additional cognitive load onto my dev experience.

It may be the case that lein's internals are a blob of complexity, without boundaries defined in the "right" places. Maybe Clojure Tools' 3 or 4 components have it correct (though I'm skeptical of that, since there's overlap between them -- even moreso now with tools.build).

Conversely, it may be that build tooling is by its nature a messy affair (dealing with dependencies, resources on the filesystem/network, interaction with tools, tests, etc.), and that making those problems go away to the extent technically possible does your community of developers the greatest service. That would explain why talk of CLI and deps invariably has pushback and lein advocacy.

I wouldn't know if lein is internally complex because I've never had to go digging in it beyond the documentation project.clj file, even to do rather complex build definitions. By comparison, I've easily spent man-weeks on getting to the same place with deps.edn, and I would still find even defining the roles of its components difficult if pressed. I also worry that if we hit new Clojure devs with a wall of tooling issues like this, they won't stick around, even if we tell them the underlying theory of their tooling is more sound.

bm3719··on Clojure builds as an amalgamation of orthogonal parts
Thanks for the reply. While you're here, I'll say that your resources for the CLI stuff made it possible to use those tools at all (for my current Clojure team) several years ago. depstar also is a great resource.

We had to scour the internet and engage in weeks of teeth grinding to get CLI/deps to do all the things our project needed.

bm3719··on Clojure builds as an amalgamation of orthogonal parts
Correct.
bm3719··on Clojure builds as an amalgamation of orthogonal parts
What pain points are those? Last I checked, doing cljs on Clojure Tools wasn't even possible. If that's still the case, then that's not a valid comparison (complex vs impossible).

Also, that's the master version of project.clj, which is a superset of all possible features lein supports. Nobody's project.clj file looks like that, though I suspect you know this. Should we compare that complexity to a monster build.clj and this master deps.edn:

https://github.com/seancorfield/dot-clojure/blob/master/deps...

Lein is also a singular tool vs. a murky interaction between a suite of tools (tools.deps with deps.edn, Clojure CLI, and tools.build).

bm3719··on Clojure builds as an amalgamation of orthogonal parts
Hard agree here. As a full time Clojure dev, my experience is that lein "just works". I've also used the Clojure Tools professionally, and have seen the dev team lose countless days of what would be otherwise productive time putzing with it, building infrastructure that lein has had out-of-the-box for years, and trying to make sense out of its inscrutable docs.

Want a project with both Clojure and Java? Want tests that magically integrate with CIDER's test functions? Complex build profiles for different target environments? Lein makes this stuff as painless as possible, whereas these things are possible with Clojure Tools, but have fun wasting time messing with it and doing awkward stuff like inlining strings of eval-ed clojure code in your build file. With Leiningen these are solved problems.

I also find the core team's behavior perplexing. I'd argue the messy tooling they've been producing has probably been net negative value add to their community. Working downstream from this stuff has degraded the dev experience. Thankfully, it can be safely ignored.

bm3719··on Many people don’t want to work unless it’s from home
Count me among them. I've been WFH for many years now, and partial WFH before that, and am definitely not going back.

That said, one thing I haven't seen mention of in favor of on-site work is regarding skills development. I've personally benefitted greatly from deep team integration early in my career, learning much of the practice of software engineering and applied research. It's easy to imagine that not happening as well or at all if I had been pure remote straight out of college. I've also worked on teams that included less skilled/experienced members that have had a very frustrating work experience due to for some reason having missed out on that learning by deep integration and osmosis.

bm3719··on Magit 3.0
Magit is definitely one of the best addons for Emacs.

Nice to see Forge getting some attention. One less reason to ever leave Emacs is always welcome.

bm3719··on Why do older individuals have greater control of their feelings?
I settled on the triune brain model as a good-enough approximation for my needs in relation to this (whether it's factually accurate is another issue). I would then categorize my thoughts and subsequent actions based on that model (mainly limbic vs. neocortex). It's pretty easy to tell them apart with some high-level introspection. Then, I'd short-circuit any emotional thinking once I spotted myself engaging in it, and injecting rational thought into those times when the limbic system would normally be in control. I'd spent decades of life not doing this, so it took a long time for this to not feel weird, but eventually it became natural.

Once the big reactive emotions (e.g. anger) were dealt with, I turned attention to the more subtle influences. I think there's a middle ground of thoughts that are a more complex or a mix of emotional and rational (think things like national pride, identity, career progression). That's a harder job and a more involved topic. In fact, I can't say I've completely got that done, or even fully mastered the first part. The caveman is always there, of course, and perhaps the best you can hope for is restraining him.

bm3719··on Why do older individuals have greater control of their feelings?
At age 20 or so, I read a quote in a book (on day trading, IIRC) that went something like: "Master your emotions, or they will master you."

After thinking about it, I realized that despite identifying as a logical-thinking individual, I was nevertheless at the mercy of the more primitive parts of my brain. Sometimes totally, but pretty much all executive functions were influenced by it to a large degree. That might be fine, but my limbic system tended to make poor decisions; ones that my more conscious brain would have to pay the price for later. It's also no match for the brains of people not in emotional mode, and would be taken advantage of by things like appeals to emotion in advertising, politics, and rhetoric. I decided my internal caveman was not my friend, and took steps to sideline his vote in decision-making.

bm3719··on How I Became a Libertarian
Hello, neighbor. I dropped off a bag of groceries for you (food being essential for life). That'll be $500, by the way.

If for some reason you refuse to pay for these basic services, I will then be forced to destroy your livelihood and possibly imprison you.

bm3719··on Supreme Court to Decide First-Ever Gun-Carry Case
"Second Amendment zealot" here. I'm optimistic about the future of civil rights in the area of the 2A in upcoming years.

There's a lot wrong with your post, but I'll just say that the right, like others, is written in a way that is absolute. If we want to restrict it, then we should amend the Constitution accordingly, as intended. Ideally, this should occur whenever a right is taken from us. This would make it clear what we're losing and force those proposing it justify doing so.

bm3719··on Microsoft Edge market share grew 13x in the past 12 months, overtaking Firefox
Mozilla did recently lay off 250 people. At the same time their exec pay is up 400%.

https://calpaterson.com/mozilla.html

They've also had plenty of spare energy to participate in trying to cancel rms in recent weeks.

bm3719··on Kicking trolls off your Socials
Interesting how, until around 5 or so years ago, the definition of the word "troll" was someone who deliberately posted content to get a reaction out of others.

Now it mainly refers to people that say mean things or have different opinions than you do.

← PreviousPage 7 of 8Next →