2,226 karma · joined July 18, 2011
But what I find most fascinating about epigenetics is its ability to explain environmental vs biological effects on our traits/behavior, not intrinsically described by our genes. As the DNA-methylation described in epigenetics determines which genes are on/off, it is external stimuli that often affect the methylation of epigenetics in the first place. (a Nature brief on the topic in mice: http://njc.rockefeller.edu/PDF_BN08/topic%202-FrancisEpigene...) It's a fascinating way of understanding how our environment affects us on a biological level.
The most widely cited example in humans is "Dutch Hunger Winter"
The human genome is composed of roughly 20K protein-coding genes, not enough at all to code for all the complexities in our body (if there was a gene for every bifurcation in our capillaries, we'd run out of genes pretty fast; in addition to the fact that there is no single gene for specific human behaviors, i.e. "aggression").
Epigenetics, in its simplest form as DNA methylation, provides a powerful solution to many of the issues of "there aren't enough genes", and explains a lot of the chaos-elements / environmental impacts on heritability of traits.
DNA methylation, by consequence of wrapping the DNA in chromatin, controls access to which genes get turned off/on by transcription factors (TF). TFs in turn are often influenced by environment, especially neonatal. If you do the permutations of which genes are on/off, b/c a TF can/can't access the DNA, b/c the chromatin is on/off = a whole new set of permutations that entail a new information code.
A good example of the impact of epigenetics is obesity. Children's propensity to obesity often has a lot due to with epigenetic influences during neonatal development. For instance, if a mother is pregnant during a famine and thus doesn't eat much, the fetus' digestive system will adapt to starving conditions through epigenetic changes in chromatin that bind the relevant genes, thus developing a "thrifty metabolism" (digests food slowly). This trait then stays through generations, and when such people move to the West, their metabolisms incline them towards obesity as their body still digests food slowly thinking they were born into starving conditions.
So long story shot, epigenetics aren't "evolutionary" in the original sense, but they are redefining how traits/behaviors (too complex to be explained by genes) are inherited/developed.
At the Summit, Jessica Jackley of Profounder and Kiva vocally voiced concern for the Reg A and Reg D restrictions on "accredited investors". Sec Geithner was in the room as well. A month afterwards, the idea had organically permeated other conversations in the White House, and meetings in the OSTP would often bring up the issue. Now it seems its finally made its way into legislative proposal.
Comes to show I think, that even though government is slow, byzantine, and sometimes impossible to access, often all it takes to get something done is to just show up and say something really provocative. Someone may listen!
Entertaining the discussion on the merits of taxation, I've found John Rawls' Justice as Fairness to be especially enlightening. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justice_as_Fairness) Essentially, a just society is one in which decisions are made to benefit the worst-off in society. Given a majority of the factors that contribute to individual success are outside our control (what family you were born into, what neighborhood you lived in, what school you went to, etc), a just society would in turn be one which compensates for such naturally-occurring inequalities. He provides a well-thought out argument for how progressive taxation is a necessary (but certainly not sufficient) lever to do so.
Now in practice, it is true that our government has been terribly inefficient in managing tax revenue and creating public goods. But that shouldn't discount the role government can play. Realizing the potential reach and role of government, the goal shouldn't be to neuter it, but to make it more efficient.
On Buffet's central points, I find them hard to argue with. 1) Lower taxes on the rich in the last 10 years have been neither necessary nor sufficient for economic growth or job creation, especially in light of the 20 years before that. 2) The front-end drivers for entrepreneurs, VCs, and angels have more to do with product creation, addressing a market need, and simply playing the game. Money is of course a big part in too, but tax cuts only play a back-end behavioral incentive- they affect the NPV of behavior that was already in play. 3) Just because the actual tax revenue on the rich may not put a huge dent on the deficit (as some comments seem to imply), the point is that the billions in tax revenue it would raise could still stave of cuts to programs that the poor and middle class depend on.
(And larger food for thought on the role of tax cuts, and how they've contributed to the deficit http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2011/05/the-char...)