HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bnegreve

2,040 karma · joined January 4, 2011

submissionscomments
bnegreve··on Can you break my home rolled encryption?
> anyone [...] can see an obvious weakness here: the procedural algorithm will produce a pattern that can be found and used to break the key. [...] But what if the algorithm isn’t specific? What if the key describes the algorithm? If the key is data that can be used as an algorithm to produce data, we can create a cycle where the algorithm is self modifying and therefor wont create a pattern.

This doesn't seem right. If "the key describes the algorithm" you need another algorithm to generate the algorithm from the key. This other algorithm is unique and will produce patterns like any other deterministic algorithm. Patterns in the generated algorithms will eventually be reflected in the data.

bnegreve··on In Almost Every European Country, Bikes Are Outselling New Cars
@Karunamon:

>I was more referring to compatibility, here.I was more referring to compatibility, here.

Yeah I know, but I got carried away :)

bnegreve··on In Almost Every European Country, Bikes Are Outselling New Cars
Well, that actually a very important point. Clearly adoption of free software is much lower than one could expect. What I mean is: you can argue that Gimp is not as good as PhotoShop, LibreOffice not as good as Office, or that Linux is not as good as Windows (which is clearly debatable) but they are good enough and they are all infinitely cheaper (literally) than their paying alternative. So that should be default choice for 99% of people. But it isn't.

So my point is: The same goes for cars vs. bikes. Most people wouldn't mind using a bike to go to work, but it feels weird to pay only a couple of bucks for a bike, when you've learn that the price to go to work is the price for a car.

bnegreve··on In Almost Every European Country, Bikes Are Outselling New Cars
Apparently not always. With this logic, free software should have 100% of market share.

Edit (in response to jgreen10)

>Are you suggesting no one has a car?

No, I am suggesting that the logic "cheaper stuff outsell more expensive stuff" is wrong.

bnegreve··on NSA monitored calls of 35 world leaders
Still, as a US citizen you should be upset because the NSA went way too far and got caught.

Non-US citizen (inc. me) are just upset because they've been spied on. That's quite reasonable.

bnegreve··on The PC is not dead, we just don't need new ones
People don't only claim that the market is dying, they also say that PCs will simply disappear [1].

And that's a huge difference for the application developers so it's not only about being smart, that's a very relevant question.

[1] https://www.google.com/search?q=pc+will+disapear&ie=utf-8&oe...

bnegreve··on [dead]
- If health insurance companies know you're sick, they won't insure you.

- If airline companies know you have a good reason to travel, they're going to rise the price.

...

So yes, privacy is an issue.

bnegreve··on Learn Haskell Fast and Hard
ahah, no. That was unintentional.
bnegreve··on Learn Haskell Fast and Hard
Well, I would argue that this article really is an introduction to functional programming using Haskell. Most of the concepts he/she introduce are not specific to Haskell but are more or less specific to functional programming languages.

But the author doesn't seem to be very well aware of that. Quoting the article: "Haskell is very different. The language uses a lot of concepts I had never heard about before."

All that to say that if you already know some functional programming this probably isn't for you.

Edit: clarity.

bnegreve··on Learn Haskell Fast and Hard
> there's way too many "toy examples" out there.

I am not sure what you mean. Tutorials can only deal with toy examples. Once you understand them, then you can (and you should) write bigger projects. About Carmack, that's exactly what he did, he implemented Wolf3D in Haskell to have a real impression about Haskell. (Assuming you're talking about this video where he discuss functional programming for games)

Aren't you just being lazy? :)

Edit: that video:

http://functionaltalks.org/2013/08/26/john-carmack-thoughts-...

bnegreve··on 30 Window Managers in 30 Days
Nothing much [1] but it works fine. I use it everyday.

[1] http://notion.sourceforge.net/#changes

bnegreve··on Ma’am, Your Burger Has Been Paid For
> [..] a lot of people here must be in a low mood because they're starting their own business and struggling, or hating their current job and wanting to do a startup..

You're the one being cynical... It's just a bias, people don't comment if the only thing they have to say is "oh that's great".

bnegreve··on What are the Windows A: and B: drives used for?
ahaha thanks :) I checked on LibreOffice and naively assumed that anything else would have a more modern icon set.
bnegreve··on What are the Windows A: and B: drives used for?
And I've just noticed that the "save file" icon in word processors isn't a floppy disk as it used to be.
bnegreve··on D-Wave Computer's Solution Raises More Questions
Good question, I am not sure :) There can be many reasons. But the problem modeling is surely very different in its D-Wave form so the fact that there are improvements doesn't mean that it is because of quantum effects.

Other than that, too limited experiments, comparing specialized vs general algorithms, sub optimal classical algorithms are also possible reasons.

bnegreve··on C++, it's time to go
I think this is confusing.

If C++ has to go because the paradigm is wrong, because it has to be replaced by say more functional languages, OK. But then so does Java, C# and so on.

Now, if C++ has to go because of some language aspects, I disagree. There is no point. The language is good enough and can still be improved.

When I choose C++ over other languages I don't do it because I like the language, I do it because it generates native code, because of manual control of the memory management, because templates can be useful to solve some problems elegantly, etc.

bnegreve··on D-Wave Computer's Solution Raises More Questions
It is actually a very crucial question: If the D-Wave machine is a just quantum computer emulator supported by classical hardware, we cannot expect much improvement in the future due to the inherent limitations of classical physics.

On the other hand, if it does behave like a quantum computer, it may end up being a lot faster than any classical computer.

bnegreve··on Arizona solar plant achieves six hours after sun goes down
Availability is a big issue when it comes to solar energy. As you can guess, producing solar energy during the day ins't that much of a problem, but supplying the demand in the evening or at night with solar energy is a much bigger challenge.

So, even if takes 6 hours to heat up in the morning, it still expand the usability of solar energy for electricity production.

bnegreve··on Open access: The true cost of science publishing
Science is still a very creative (i.e. non systematic) process. To create new "scientific findings" you need new insights. These insights typically come from publications/conferences/discussions with other researchers rather than big machine readable datasets.
bnegreve··on Modern Minimalism
Creating temporary accounts to post harsh comments is also something that I have hard time to understand.
bnegreve··on Modern Minimalism
> I have an 11-inch Macbook Air and an iPhone 5. No other devices.

For some reason, I knew this was going to pop up somewhere in the list.

Smartphones are arguably one of the biggest gadget of the century. And they can be used to watch TV, movies, read news, books, as GPS, as game device and so on.

So why iPhone and no soap?

bnegreve··on GNU Make 4.0 Released
I see. Nice feature.
bnegreve··on Why is there no Nobel in mathematics?
I assume it says "forty" which is enough to avoid this kind of ambiguity.

Edit: Actually no, quoting the official website [1]:

> A candidate's 40th birthday must not occur before January 1st of the year of the Congress at which the Fields Medals are awarded.

[1] http://www.mathunion.org/general/prizes/fields/details/

bnegreve··on GNU Make 4.0 Released
> "do", which always rebuilds everything,

To rebuild everything with Make, you can use the -B switch:

       -B, --always-make

            Unconditionally make all targets.
bnegreve··on What If IBM’s Watson Dethroned Google as the King of Search?
This is certainly not ridiculous. It is very legitimate to wonder whether systems involving more AI such as Watson are going to take over standard search techniques or not. Regarding Bing, it is as you said: Microsoft has been chasing Google but Watson is a totally different approach so the question is still open.
bnegreve··on A 3D printed toothbrush for all your teeth
> What an awful way to encourage inventive people to follow their dreams and build new products for everyone. These attitudes kill entrepreneurship.

How to provide useful feedback is a very serious problem. On the one hand, I agree that we are usually biased toward negative criticism, on the other hand overly positive feedback is exactly 0% useful.

If people on HN have this kind of reaction, it's very likely that other people out there will also have this kind of reaction so as an entrepreneur, you really want to know real people's reaction so you can improve your pitch.

So let's make sure that we provide constructive and encouraging feedback but let's also not refrain emotional reactions just because we want to encourage inventive people to follow their dreams and build new products for everyone. Otherwise, it's not feedback anymore.

bnegreve··on What I learned from turning my ‘Out of Office’ auto-replies on for a month
What do you use instead?
bnegreve··on Where do Github users live? WebGL visualization
I find it very hard to read because you cannot see the height of the bar from above. And when you can see the bar, then you can't see the country.
bnegreve··on Codebreaker found in bag attended US security conference before death (2012)
Wait, so what exactly is the British government style of killing people?

If you assume the British government chooses to murder people, it also perfectly reasonable to assume that it does it using someone else style to cover its crime e.g. russian mafia style.

bnegreve··on What I would have written
But most successful online services are attractive even without knowing much about them. Tweeter doesn't feel attractive at all.

The consequence is that after seven years Tweeter simply ignored by half of the IT population.

← PreviousPage 18 of 25Next →