HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bnegreve

2,040 karma · joined January 4, 2011

submissionscomments
bnegreve··on If Philosophy Won’t Diversify, Let’s Call It What It Really Is
I'm not sure this logic makes any sense.

Science is also very euro-centric, yet most of us here would argue that science is among the most objective disciplines out there.

bnegreve··on Is the tech bubble popping? Ping pong offers an answer
Only if having a ping pong table (or free food) improve productivity.

That's a rather strong assumption.

bnegreve··on CERN has released 300 terabytes of research data from LHC
This is from Andrew Tanenbaum AFAIR
bnegreve··on Study of non-programmers' solutions to programming problems [pdf]
I said boolean logic because the paper mention fifth graders, which are unlikely to be at ease with complex boolean formulae. But there are number of more complex concepts that would also work: OOP, maps or reduce, mutexes and so on.

To answer your question, in my experience (I taught programming 101 number of times) many people are indeed confused when they need to reason about complex if statements. Typically, they make redundant tests, and it takes a little while before they understand why it is not needed.

bnegreve··on Study of non-programmers' solutions to programming problems [pdf]
> We don't have any control over the fact that medicine and physics are complicated because they reflect nature.

I don't agree that this is all that different.

In physics, some phenomenons can be either simple or complex to describe, depending on what formalism you use to describe them. And sometimes, complex formalisms can be hard to understand at first, but help producing simpler description of the phenomenons your looking at.

For example functions and derivatives are hard to understand at first, but they drastically simplify the description of classical physics.

So in programming just as in physics, you just need the right conceptual tools to describe your problem. And while boolean logic may be hard to understand at first, it really helps specifying complex behaviors.

In that sense, I think I agree with GP: over simplifying the conceptual tools may not results in better problem descriptions.

bnegreve··on Voltron: A hacky debugger UI for hackers
It makes sense actually. The imaginary world in the matrix trilogy is inspired from the unix hacker folklore [1]. So if you're a hacker, it's not surprising that what's on your screen looks like what's on the screens in the Matrix.

[1] as shown here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PxTAn4g20U

bnegreve··on Ram air turbine
Actually water turbines (aka hydrogenerators) are also an option, but it's less common.

http://cdn.streamlike.com/secure/Covers/68/17853.jpg

bnegreve··on How to reduce the cognitive load of your code
It does increase the cognitive load for no particular reason. Which is what the author is trying to avoid.
bnegreve··on Oculus Rift is Shipping
What makes you believe that these reasons were all wrong? Many (most?) technologies have failed after all, possibly for these reasons.

One recent example that comes to mind is Google glass

bnegreve··on VNC Roulette
> Take a topic you know absolutely nothing about. Let's say it's aerospace. Now every year we have an aerospace day to try and explain to you how various types of fan and jet engines work. You certainly wouldn't expect everyone to be able to handle fixing one after that one day, do you? Same with internet security.

People don't interact with jet engines, but they do interact with planes. And they're lectured about airplane safty evey single time they get in a plane. So this might actually be an argument in favor of educating people about internet security.

Bottom line: please don't overuse analogies. They don't prove anything.

Edit: simplify

bnegreve··on If You Drive the Right Speed, This Musical Highway Will Play You a Song
There are many variables that do not vary linearly with the speed (e.g. rubber's stiffness) so it could be that the sound is indistinguishable at higher speed.

The goal is clearly to slow people down, so that would be really surprising if it would work the same way at higher speed, wouldn't it be? Maybe I'm just too naive..

bnegreve··on Akin's Laws of Spacecraft Design
Wikipedia says it's Voltaire quoting an ancient Italian saying.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_is_the_enemy_of_good

Old sayings don't really have frontiers, so it might as well be an old Russian saying.

bnegreve··on Opera: Introducing native ad-blocking feature for faster browsing
I wonder if blocking ad-blocking people from viewing content is viable in the long term.

People producing content want to maximize the probability for their content to go viral don't they? Blocking anybody (ad-blocking or not) seems counter productive.

bnegreve··on AlphaGo Can't Beat Me, Says Chinese Go Grandmaster Ke Jie
I suspect that training the AI is the most CPU intensive part.

If they would release the (trained) AI to everybody, that would prove that the training phase is general enough to beat any player, not just one.

Google doesn't have to pay for the CPU time. Ke Jie can find sponsors if he pretends he can beat AlphaGo.

(Edit: clarify)

bnegreve··on AlphaGo Can't Beat Me, Says Chinese Go Grandmaster Ke Jie
But that would prove that they are not overfitting their opponent. Which would be nice.
bnegreve··on AlphaGo beats Lee Sedol again in match 2 of 5
Even if he is now, there is a probability that people will learn how to beat AlphaGo.

In a sense this is unfair: alphaGo was trained with a lot of human data, but AFAIK Lee Sedol is playing AI for the first time.

bnegreve··on Is this prime?
There is a 60 sec timeout.
bnegreve··on Mercedes Boots Robots from the Production Line
I think the takeaway is:

Humans assisted with robots are superior to just robots when the variety is high.

bnegreve··on HaxeDevelop: A Haxe IDE on Windows
Haxe is a cross plaftform language [1], Haxe develop is just an IDE it seems.

[1] http://haxe.org/

bnegreve··on Canadians don’t live as far north as you think
It doesn't make much sense to compare temperatures at latitudes from different sides of the Atlantic ocean. The Gulf Stream [1] makes the European cost a lot warmer at the same latitude. E.g. NYC is colder than North of Spain despite being roughly at the same latitude.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulf_Stream

bnegreve··on Sci-Hub: Removing barriers in the way of science
It uses scholar as a search engine, but then it replaces the links in the results. e.g.

    http://link.springer.com/link-to-paper
becomes:

    http://link.springer.com.sci-hub.io/link-to-paper
As far as I can tell, it works for some articles.
bnegreve··on The Fermi Paradox Is Not Fermi's, and It Is Not a Paradox
> Except that we've been pumping radio waves out of this rock as loud as we can for decades.

It's true but there is a possibility that human radio activity does not last that long. We choose to transmit information using electromagnetic waves that propagates in every possible direction when there is no alternative, but it's a massive waste of energy and we may not continue to do so forever.

As a matter of fact, an increasing amount of communications travel through optic fibers, which are not observable from space. (And that's also why they're efficient)

If that's a correct prediction, we won't be pumping radio waves out of that rocks for more than a couple of decades. This is nothing compared to the age of the universe and may very well be missed, even if there's someone to observe.

bnegreve··on A Programming Language with Deterministic Multithreading
This is debatable, SIMD instructions and GPUs are highly synchronized, yet they do help with scalability.
bnegreve··on Include-what-you-use: Clang tool to analyze includes in C and C++ source files
I don't get it, can you give an example?
bnegreve··on Dear GitHub
There are more authors on the second page.
bnegreve··on How the Powerball rules were tweaked to make the game an even bigger ripoff
> Experts aren't entirely sure why "those who can least afford it play the most,

Is this that irrational?

With 1000 trials, probability of winning at least one time is 3*10^-6 which is low.

But what are the odds of becoming a billionaire given that your annual income is below $10,000?

bnegreve··on Private messages at work can be read by EU employers
> Because it believed it was accessing a work account, the judges said, the firm had not erred.

I think this is relevant, at my workplace which is in EU, sysadmins are allowed to access anything that is not explicitly marked as personal.

I've always assumed that this is some kind of EU regulation, but I don't know. Does anybody here knows?

bnegreve··on Replacing Judgment with Algorithms
I think you're being unfair. The author has given us many clear issues with closed source algorithm that would not exist with open source algorithms.

Showing that the benefits outweigh the costs would require a model of the impact the (closed or open) algorithmic judgments on the society, and thus a model of the society itself.

Such model would inevitably be subject to even more subjectivity and discussions.

If you're not buying it, it's your choice, and you may even be right. But that doesn't make the whole argument unreceivable. Instead, you should mention the benefits of closed source algorithms for the society, they're not that obvious to me.

bnegreve··on Replacing Judgment with Algorithms
It seems to me that the whole article is about proving this point.

Relevant quotes:

> The secrecy of the algorithms further pushes people toward conformity. If you are worried that the US government will classify you as a potential terrorist, you're less likely to friend Muslims on Facebook.

> If you know that your Sesame Credit score is partly based on your not buying "subversive" products or being friends with dissidents, you're more likely to overcompensate by not buying anything but the most innocuous books or corresponding with the most boring people.

> Uber is an example of how this works. Passengers rate drivers and drivers rate passengers; both risk getting booted out of the system if their rankings get too low.

> Many have documented a chilling effect among American Muslims, with them avoiding certain discussion topics lest they be taken the wrong way.

bnegreve··on How to C in 2016
But desktop processors also don't zero pages, do they?

And by zeroing pages, you prevent lazy memory allocation policies which do not allocate the pages until they're read or written for the first time. This can have a significant impact on memory usage, data locality etc.

So I'm quite skeptical that there is no difference between calloc and malloc. Is there more evidences of this somewhere?

← PreviousPage 10 of 25Next →