HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bobm_kite9

457 karma · joined April 27, 2013

submissionscomments
bobm_kite9··on AWS, MongoDB, and the Economic Realities of Open Source
I'll be interested to see what Jepsen[1] makes of this. MongoDB traditionally lost a lot of data when there was a split-brain in the network. According to the post, AWS is a re-implementation of MongoDB v3. Will Amazon's implementation fare any better?

[1]: https://aphyr.com/posts/284-call-me-maybe-mongodb

bobm_kite9··on Software Projects Fail: The Software Development Risk Landscape
This is a really good point, and I need to cover this in a bit more depth, probably as part of the Operational Risk page.

(After a bit of digging, it seems that Basel II puts Legal Risk in the Operational Risk bucket, which is something I tend to agree with... will open a ticket)

bobm_kite9··on Software Projects Fail: The Software Development Risk Landscape
Are there any others that you find useful that aren't suggested here?
bobm_kite9··on Software Projects Fail: The Software Development Risk Landscape
This is a single page from Risk-First, introducing the idea that we can categorise the risks we face on software projects.

What do you think?

Does our discipline lend itself to this kind of rigor, or are all our projects unique software snowflakes?

bobm_kite9··on Wilderness: SVG Animation Library
I put this on here because I saw anime.js on here earlier. I'm trying to pick a decent SVG animation package at the moment, hoped there would be some users of this who might want to share their experiences?
bobm_kite9··on Anime.Js 3.0.0 is out now
How does this compare to

https://wilderness.now.sh

... I am about to pick an SVG animation tool and I'm not sure which way to go...

bobm_kite9··on Agency Risk in Software Teams
Hi,

Author here. This is a page from the "Risk-First" project, about risk in software projects... trying to catalog different types of risks within software development.

I'd really appreciate some feedback on this subject from this knowledgeable community, cheers!

Feel free to ask anything.

bobm_kite9··on Software Methodology: Why One Size Fits No One
I agree, maybe it does _sound_ depressing. But the food you eat and air you breathe _are_ based on risk! Our bodies try to warn us about the bad air and food by making it smell/taste bad. You can go ahead and eat it if you want!

I agree with you that it's nice that our bodies make things _nice_ to eat as well as recognising nasty stuff. I wonder if there is an evolutionary reason for that too...

Sadly, there are still some things that _don't_ taste bad but will kill you... hidden risks of eating I guess.

I talk about Complexity Risk here: https://github.com/risk-first/website/wiki/Complexity-Risk

Often, Complexity is fine, but then something bites you in the ass unexpectedly. Sounds like risk to me.

bobm_kite9··on Software Methodology: Why One Size Fits No One
These risks get a lot of coverage in Risk-First:

- https://github.com/risk-first/website/wiki/Communication-Ris... - https://github.com/risk-first/website/wiki/Complexity-Risk#c... - https://github.com/risk-first/website/wiki/Coordination-Risk

bobm_kite9··on Software Methodology: Why One Size Fits No One
Sounds necessary, but maybe not sufficient for project success.

Problem is, the context of the project will often involve people of questionable competence...

bobm_kite9··on Software Methodology: Why One Size Fits No One
Haha nice, brings to mind the Mike Tyson quote:

"Everyone has a plan 'till they get punched in the mouth."

bobm_kite9··on Software Methodology: Why One Size Fits No One
I haven’t read it but I’ll put it on my reading list, thanks.
bobm_kite9··on Software Methodology: Why One Size Fits No One
That's very helpful advice, thanks a lot.
bobm_kite9··on Software Methodology: Why One Size Fits No One
That's an excellent question, and one I'm currently struggling with.

On the one hand, I would like to grow Risk-First as a community, and get other people authoring articles. With this in mind, I am trying to automate the process by which collaborators are added to the github organisation... it's manual at the moment which is already painful.

On the other hand, I wanted to publish this work in order that it could be read off-line (in print form, should be ready end of Feb) or on a kindle (which is currently pre-order). This _probably_ won't generate much income as it essentially is content that is already for free on the website.

Probably, the license is sufficiently permissive that other people could also publish the work as a book for their own means, so long as they retained attribution or copyright notices. I guess this is the usual quandary on making anything open-source.

I expect you're right that the license _should be_ CC-BY. I need to investigate further on this. Do you have any further thoughts on this?

bobm_kite9··on Software Methodology: Why One Size Fits No One
Hi,

Author here. This is a single page from the larger "Risk-First" project, about risk in software projects.

I put the front page up a week or so ago and it was fairly well-received. Hopefully people will enjoy a festive second-helping.

Feel free to ask anything.

bobm_kite9··on Show HN: Risk-First Software Development – About Complexity Risk
Author here, merry Christmas!

This is a post about defining and understanding the concept of "complexity risk" within software projects.

Hopefully this will be useful and interesting to people here.

Feel free to ask anything and let me know if you think I'm missing anything fundamental.

Cheers

bobm_kite9··on Risk-First Software Development
Thanks, done.
bobm_kite9··on Risk-First Software Development
Updated it for you: https://github.com/risk-first/website/wiki

Using plain english is harder than it sounds! :)

bobm_kite9··on Risk-First Software Development
Hi Mikekchar,

Thanks so much for your feedback. Addressing each point in turn:

1. UAT/Integration: this was just an "example process", one that you _might_ follow. YMMV and you could get better results doing things in a different order or with extra steps. The point was to show that each step on your process (whatever it is) is meeting reality and managing risk. I'm with you on this: you should _totally_ prepare for UAT ahead of doing it, because that preparation actually manages risk too - the risk of the users not knowing what to test, or not being available, or not understanding the functionality, or the data not being right etc.

2. On "Do the simplest thing... and refactor": this (and YAGNI) are great "rules of thumb" about how to develop. What I'm trying to do here is explain _why_ they are great. That is, explain how they attempt to manage risk on software projects. On the refactoring point, I cover this in a lot more detail in the section on "Complexity risk", which I'd really appreciate your feedback on.

It's here: https://github.com/risk-first/website/wiki/Complexity-Risk

I'll invite you to the project on github too

thanks, Rob

bobm_kite9··on Risk-First Software Development
Can you expand on that a bit and give an example? It sounds like an important point..
bobm_kite9··on Risk-First Software Development
Author here, hope you enjoy reading this.

Feel free to ask anything.

thanks

bobm_kite9··on Mars likely to have enough oxygen to support life: study
I thought the absence of a magnetosphere would mean that any atmosphere would be stripped away by solar radiation anyway?
bobm_kite9··on Decentralisation: the next big step for the world wide web
This seems to miss the problem completely to me. The internet essentially solved the problem of _distribution_. That meant disintermediating away from publishers, and allowed anyone to publish.

The problem then moved onto being one of _curation_. Companies such as google, facebook, amazon are in the business of providing curation: i.e. taking away the leg-work of what we should attend to.

A de-centralized web doesn't appear to decentralize the problem of curation at all, which means we are going to still end up with centralized curation and the same or similar monopolies on attention that we have now.

bobm_kite9··on Gerald M. Weinberg has died
This hit me hard. I’ve read several of his books and it’s strange how you can feel like you know a person from that. But his writing was excellent and his personality was very evident.

If anything, I feel like now I want to read a few more of his books as a mark of respect.

And, you know, because they were excellent

bobm_kite9··on The ‘Terms and Conditions’ Reckoning Is Coming
What I want is a standardized set of icons, which grant or deny specific things, that all websites can agree on, sort of like the ones available for software licensing, here:

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/

It would be great if we could "standardize away" the whole T&C fiasco.

bobm_kite9··on Peter Thiel, Tech Billionaire, Reveals Secret War with Gawker
Finally. Amazing that I had to read through miles and miles of comments siding with either Thiel or Gawker to get to the real problem:

Why is it that an (already a millionaire) entertainer _needs_ to get a billionaire on his side just to try and get justice done? This is a totally crazy state-of-affairs.

bobm_kite9··on Show HN: Marginotes, quick and elegant side notes for your paragraphs
Basically, this function is just an onMouseOver event, which then inspects the element and displays text from the "desc" tab in the right place.

I've been thinking for a while that it would be nice if we could add events to the CSS syntax, something like:

a[desc] { onMouseOver: asideFunction(); }

I _kind_ of worry that this is subverting the purpose of the css, but since it also handles hover and selected behaviour, it seems like the line isn't well-drawn anyway as to where styling ends and where behaviour begins.

What do other people think?

bobm_kite9··on Eve: My Concerns
> Well, if you took away Excel, the banking system would collapse.

Lovely comment, and so true. And you're right: for a POC it's unstoppable. I was trying to get to the nub of "why is it perfect for a POC, but not for running an enterprise application"? That's kind of my point, though I admit it was a bit clunkily-put.

bobm_kite9··on Pure4J: Compile-Time Functional Purity and Immutability for the Java Language
So, rather than reinvent the wheel, I just ported the Clojure collections over, added generics and made them more Java-ery [1]

In the Clojure world, (and indeed in Haskell and other pure-fp languages) there is a lot more garbage collection. Rich Hickey makes a great case for this trade off here [2].

On the JVM now very little of it is stop-the-world GC, it mostly does incremental. It's been a while since I profiled a Java app in anger, but even back on JDK5 this was the case, and I know they changed it significantly in JDK7 to the G1 collector.. anyone have a clue about that?

[1] https://github.com/robmoffat/pure4j/blob/master/docs/tutoria... [2] http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Value-Values [3] http://www.oracle.com/webfolder/technetwork/tutorials/obe/ja...

bobm_kite9··on Pure4J: Compile-Time Functional Purity and Immutability for the Java Language
A couple of people have suggested this idea - pure by default, as opposed to impure by default. In Frege, as you point out, anything written in Haskell is pure by default. However, if you want to call methods from libraries or the JVM which are written in Java, then you have to tell Frege their level of purity. So effectively, your Haskell code is the "island of purity" inside the wider sea of impure Java runtime.

But yes, I think this is a workable idea - so long as there was some way of identifying 3rd-party code purity instead of the annotation.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →