HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bolanyo

192 karma · joined January 31, 2023

submissionscomments
bolanyo··on On a great interview question
Perhaps spend some time on a real-world toy problem, the kind where you spend a lot of time dealing with small practical things like error handling?

I have interviewed a lot of people for coding jobs, and I usually try to test ability at doing things like this, and when I find someone junior who already knows how to approach problems like this, I am always very in favor of hiring them. Based on the discussion here I'm definitely not the only one.

bolanyo··on On a great interview question
Perhaps there is a sort of selection bias going on, where the people who work at Google have been chosen because they are good at leetcode type problems and think they are important, and so they tend to solve problems by implementing their own tries and similar data structures, rather than by using robust canned implementations.
bolanyo··on On a great interview question
Absolutely right. I once had an interview where the interviewer asked me for a way of calculating pi, along certain specific lines. When I didn't get it, he 'explained' to me how such an approach could work. I pointed out correctly that his idea was wrong. I was rejected. I'm pretty sure that he never found anyone who came up with this approach just based on the initial vague prompt, and was actually interested in people who nodded in an impressed way when he explained his idea.
bolanyo··on On a great interview question
Aesthetic judgements, and the ability to justify and defend them, are very important, but not the only important thing IMO.

Someone who can explain why they love Rust and hate Python (or vice versa) is a convincing candidate but I think you need to see a couple of other things from them. In addition, sometimes you just don't hit on the right question to get evidence of their aesthetic judgement. (Like the candidate who doesn't care about Rust vs Python, but who hates Postgres and loves MariaDB..)

bolanyo··on On a great interview question
This is the right answer. Questions of this type test for both experience (what you want from non-junior candidates - the fact that they have learned to program defensively, check edge cases, etc) and common sense (what you want from junior candidates - not making silly simplifying assumptions, thinking divergently about what could go wrong, etc).

Importantly, it also allows you to examine fluency. The candidate who can write a code/pseudocode solution as fast as they can type, and explain it verbally at the same time, is much more impressive than the candidate who pauses for a long time before starting haltingly and unconfidently. Fluency in solving leetcode problems just tests for having practiced leetcode, but fluency in writing real code tests for actual productivity.

If you have a question like this, you can drill down into performance characteristics just as the question in TFA does. Not necessarily using big-Oh notation, but "what if you have to do this millions of times? what if you have to provide results immediately? what if some of the files are too big to fit into RAM?". But you can also drill down into other aspects of the problem like changing specs, noisy input, constrained resources, observability.

FWIW, when I came up with a question like this (with the constraint that it had to represent a problem I had solved that morning), ChatGPT was not able to solve it correctly.

bolanyo··on On a great interview question
> Not even the Soviet Union had a process where job interview questions were regularly approved by a committee.

Not defending Google's practices here, but this claim is nonsense. Many public sector/third sector jobs in Western society will only use interview questions which have been pre-approved by explicit policy.

bolanyo··on Substack Notes Launched
A lot of the top writers have large guaranteed incomes and related incentive structures. The 20M is not all revenue, some of it is a cost for Substack.
bolanyo··on Substack Notes Launched
I honestly don't care about his political views in my choice of social media (and I'm not aware of any views he holds that I would find extremely objectionable in any case).

I care about being able to choose between "For You" and "Following". I don't want an algorithmically curated feed which includes things I have consciously chosen not to look at. And I don't want people who follow me not to be able to see things I link to because of a pissing contest between tech companies.

bolanyo··on People with severe mental illness have been failed by a dysfunctional system
How do you know that 'most of us' feel that way?

I definitely do want to live in such a society.

bolanyo··on People with severe mental illness have been failed by a dysfunctional system
> If the people advocating for the homeless and mentally ill have a better solution than leaving them on the streets to rot

The comment you are replying to put forward exactly such a solution: that treatment should be helpful enough and sufficiently respectful of users' rights, that people who need it don't refuse it.

bolanyo··on I fixed a parasitic drain on my car in 408 days
Mine doesn't.
bolanyo··on Defamed by ChatGPT
The suggestion that this is a threat to someone's reputation is no less a fantasy than the ChatGPT response.
bolanyo··on For the first time, the Fed is losing money
I don't think this is the correct interpretation of 'fiat currency'.

'Fiat' of course refers to making something come into existence simply by saying it, as G_d supposedly did with the words 'Let there be light'.

My understanding of 'fiat currency' is that it is not the currency as a whole which comes into existence by fiat (which would seemingly apply to most currencies, including Bitcoin and metallic ones), but that individual units of the currency come into existence by fiat. The government (meaning the union of the Fed and the Treasury) can create additional dollars simply by writing 'X has Y dollars'. No one can create Bitcoin in this manner, so it is not a fiat currency.

bolanyo··on For the first time, the Fed is losing money
I don't think this is true.

If you look at the projects funded by the Roosevelt New Deal (where the stated purpose of the spending was to reboot the economy and create employment, rather than chasing a particular return), a lot of them returned many, many times the government's investment. For example, the Tri-Borough Bridge, the Hoover Dam, the paintings of Jackson Pollock.

bolanyo··on For the first time, the Fed is losing money
Another thing that people generally get wrong is what government spending goes on, with wide swathes of people believing that vastly more money goes to welfare than actually is the case.
bolanyo··on CFTC sues Binance and CEO Changpeng Zhao [pdf]
Obviously this is very different from saying "They chose to illegally run a business in the US."
bolanyo··on Employees are feeding sensitive data to ChatGPT, raising security fears
if you didn't use throwaway accounts your karma would presumably be much higher?
bolanyo··on Employees are feeding sensitive data to ChatGPT, raising security fears
Perhaps the actual phenomenon is that humans are much better at saying "Alice wrote this code, she's pretty good at scripting but she might have made a noob mistake, better check it", or even "I wrote this code.." than they are at saying "ChatGPT wrote this code, but that application is not guaranteed to have correctly identified my problem, but may have just returned something that seems right both to the statistical model and to me, but which is actually deeply flawed, better check it".
bolanyo··on CFTC sues Binance and CEO Changpeng Zhao [pdf]
What does "receiving information 'regarding HAMAS transactions' on Binance" mean? Isn't it clear that the actual context of this conversation - what the transactions were, what the information was, what the actual connection to Hamas was, has been deliberately omitted here? Like, the CFTC chose what to include, if there was anything more incriminating, they would have included it.
bolanyo··on CFTC sues Binance and CEO Changpeng Zhao [pdf]
It really doesn't appear he was 'knowingly financing Hamas and Russia'. There is a transparent attempt by the CFTC to talk up the pretty nothingy evidence of this.
bolanyo··on CFTC sues Binance and CEO Changpeng Zhao [pdf]
Yes, the line about "after receiving information about 'HAMAS' transactions" seems deliberately intended to withhold the actual content of the conversation about Hamas.
bolanyo··on CFTC sues Binance and CEO Changpeng Zhao [pdf]
But you are arguing, if you run a gas station, and you see a couple of dudes in a car hanging out on the opposite corner all day, and you come to believe that they are selling drugs out of their car, when they come to you to buy gas you have to refuse on the basis that you would be aiding and abetting and subject to prosecution? Is that actually what you believe?
bolanyo··on CFTC sues Binance and CEO Changpeng Zhao [pdf]
It's not literal terrorist financing, it's a CFTC enforcement action where they mentioned chat remarks including the words 'HAMAS' and 'AK47', without any context or explanation, in the complaint in order to a) get media attention, and b) gain public buy-in for prosecuting people who aren't even in the US for futures regulation rule-breaking.
bolanyo··on CFTC sues Binance and CEO Changpeng Zhao [pdf]
Isn't it more the other way around here?

The CFTC want to prosecute Binance for violating restrictions on allowing US persons to buy and sell derivatives, but they are aware that this is somewhat weak sauce, because the people buying and selling are all sophisticated institutional players, and Binance themselves are only very dubiously subject to US jurisdiction.

So they make it into a case about 'funding terrorism' based on a casual remark from a chat log.

bolanyo··on CFTC sues Binance and CEO Changpeng Zhao [pdf]
how was their business 'in the US'?
bolanyo··on Tell HN: Chase shadow banned and closed my bank accounts
this isn't very good speculation
bolanyo··on I use cheap notebooks
The Muji ones cost considerably more than the cheapest similar notebooks from eg a supermarket.
bolanyo··on Cobble_stone – The texture of your childhood (2021)

  - Donkey Kong Country 3: Dixie Kong's Double Trouble
  - Turok
The first doesn't appear to be the same, the second is evidently a completely different, simpler texture.

Several of the other DK images don't look right, but it's hard to be sure - they could be heavily edited, and some of the samples are quite small.

Some of the Banjo-Kazooie ones also don't look right but are hard to be sure of.

If you can clearly highlight the matching unique features on all of those images that would be interesting to see!

bolanyo··on Understanding British Money: What's a Quid? A Shilling? (2020)
Disagree. A mile is a well-defined quantity, and furlongs are widely understood by older men.
bolanyo··on Understanding British Money: What's a Quid? A Shilling? (2020)
A dollar is 10 shilling, or half a pound, and I believe the name goes back much further than the US dollar, to the time when various European precious metal coinages would have been recognized and converted.

The Australian dollar, and perhaps others, was set equal to half a British pound at the point when they obtained their own currency.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →