HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bonesss

1,918 karma · joined April 20, 2017

o_o
submissionscomments
bonesss··on AI is making me dumb
Training data is the masses of code from everyone.

Restrict that data to just the best of the best, the tersest of the tersest, and we’d see better output. I don’t think people are sharing that kinda stuff (Jane Street’s gems stay locked up), and even if they did my presumption is that it’d be too narrow and demanding for general audiences.

Big hopes for the long future, damned to some degree of mediocrity in the near term mass product.

bonesss··on Grok Build
I’m still flabbergasted by the business model, it reminds me of SEO services: if you were any kind of good at it there is infinite money to be made partnering with established players and selling goods and services directly.

Selling tools to others when you’re not using them yourself says everything about the underlying utility of what’s being sold.

xAI could be threatening Office, or Windows, or Unreal Engine, Chromium, SalesForce, global ERP, tax software for citizens and governments alike, or Apples manufacturing prowess… but, no, forget that lame nonsense, let’s see what I have in my wallet! Maybe I can give some to Elon to cover up his sketchy business practices. Sounds logical.

bonesss··on Remove .zig Files from Bun
Anecdotally, I am seeing tons of visual bugs in software and apps these days.

Issues of rendering, too many menu options, mobile sizes not being accounted for per se, non-functioning buttons, half-load issues, etc. Consumer facing, major platforms, commercial services.

I can’t ascribe all of it to LLMs but there’s been an objective change in my impotent cursing from “what is wrong with them” to “did anyone even test this?” over the last six months to a year. If the backends start acting like these frontends we might get to see a bunch of cognitive/technical debt blow up at scale.

bonesss··on The other half of AI safety
Step 1: route to a human

Step 2: engage ongoing trauma, grief, stress, paranoia, or reality-breaking episodes haphazardly with no clinical insights or boundaries or pre-screening, provoking new and occasionally catastrophic reactions, while holding full liability

Step 3: get mercy-murdered in the middle of the night by corporate’s lawyers swinging batteries in socks

bonesss··on Altman forced to confront claims at OpenAI trial that he's a prolific liar
Things that could happen: some major outage or corporate self-destruction through aggressive LLM usage creates a valuation dip that puts Sam too many bajillion dollars away from the katrillions of revenue they need, kicking off dotcom-bust 2.0, Elons snowballing of debt and lies into bigger balls of debt and lies hits what nuclear reactor designers call a “negative void coefficient”, and — xAI CSAM class actions finally entering courts around the same time — his whole drug and suspicious foreign backer fuelled empire goes Chernobyl, leaving a radioactive pile no one will touch for decades. Nature reclaims the half-built data-centres and robo-factories as investigations into prolonged fraud patterns kick off.

Much more likely: the two of them and POTUS launch and AGI NFT with Federal Reserve backing, pump it to the sky on their social media platforms, and ensure their genetic propagation programs can afford all the bunkers and colony ships they could ever want. Whee.

bonesss··on Why senior developers fail to communicate their expertise
“Complexity” understood as the immediate first impression a junior gets looking at some arbitrary facet is always bad and too much and bad.

“Complexity” understood as what’s gonna make development on this system fly easy and fast for the next 10 man-years de facto means side steps when naive approaches would charge straight ahead.

Tortoise and the Hare… the urge to hurry up and burn hard the first two weeks (low hanging fruit, visible wins, MVP!), resulting in ever decreasing momentum due to immature design and in-dev maintenance needs is befuddling to me. So much “faster” for weeks, and it just meant the schedule slipped 6 months.

bonesss··on If AI writes your code, why use Python?
C# has recreated the C++ dialect conundrum. For some it’s effectively an idempotent functional language with unfortunate failings of exhaustiveness, for others it’s Java ca 2009, for others it’s C++ but not quite.

Discipline, effort, linters, reviews, more discipline, more effort, retraining, discipline… and foot guns everywhere because so much of the adaptation has been a 95% solution. Personally I got everything C# promises even now when F# was dropped years ago and have found the interim pretty annoying.

bonesss··on If AI writes your code, why use Python?
In the window of Haskell-like and highly readable, I’d throw OCaml and F# out as strong candidates.

In practice your code can be cleaner than Python, deeply flexible naming capabilities including full sentences with backticking, efficient and powerful discriminated unions and types enable near-English domains, the type system keeps you honest and provides exhaustiveness guarantees, domain modules of applied functions are obvious and locally coherent domain grammars, and there is potent DSL support to create mini-grammars for legibility and expressiveness.

I used to write python by hand to reason then type it up in C#. F# is just as easy with a pen, but far more powerful and with a powerful type system and aggressive compiler. OCaml and F# are also highly token efficient languages, beating Python across the board for agentic work.

bonesss··on Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career
I struggle to understand the logic (in general, the way people are talking), normally efficiencies come with increases in production and scale and use-cases.

So of 10% of lawyers get AI-d away, let’s say, the remaining 90% are 1.1x+ efficient and also up against other lawyers enjoying the same… work might go up. And on the customer side there is sooooo much BS with lawyers, but if both lawyer and customer can communicate faster or better with the LLMs, we should see more better cases with better dialog and case handling. Again, the total amount of lawyering could go up a lot. And then we have the cases prohibitive without the LLMs, now possible for big money. Better LLM empowered lawyers should be able to create new and more lawyer work.

As it stands I see people selling services that are subsidized by VC, template jobs we’d be doing faster with copy paste but it’s not copyright infringement when OpenAI does it, and a rush for valuations to soak up VC because the business model isn’t there. I’m seeing a huge uptick in visual bugs on large commercial platforms and customer facing apps, and don’t feel OpenAI is gonna kill Office anytime soon… or Chromium… or Steam… or emacs…

Call me an optimist, but I think those LLM pump and dumpers are creating a wave of fear that would be quite different if they weren’t lying and trying to boost an IPO. Chat GPT 2 was too dangerous to release, lul, and the class action suits are just getting started.

An actual lawyer replacing tech company should sell lawyering for infini-money, not pens that’ll totally 10x your lawyering (bro).

bonesss··on PS3 Emulator Devs Politely Ask That People Stop Flooding It with AI PRs
If someone can’t write their own Agent.md for a project how are they going to validate the auto-completed text?

This strikes me as the ideal LLM first contribution/PR, a file explaining the projects standards and testing and structure.

bonesss··on Singapore introduces caning for boys who bully others at school
So, what you’re saying is, HR department behaviours start long before HR department employment.
bonesss··on Appearing productive in the workplace
Yeah, the developers who will argue and teeth-gnash about using an ORM for weeks on the hope it will save a few hours perceived as boring or obvious are, simultaneously, annoyed and upset at being told to save time with super tools that save time and effort…

Pay no attention to the software output or quality or competitive displacement of the people selling you tools. LLMs, like cheesy sales strategies, are something so lucrative the only thing you can really do is sell them first come first serve to other people. Makes so much sense. Why make infinite money when you can sell a course/tool to naive and less fortunate companies? So logical.

bonesss··on Appearing productive in the workplace
I’m an LLM enjoyer who also thinks that ‘er ‘jerbs are safe and, taken to their logical conclusion, most LLM-stroking online around coding reduces to an argument that we should be speaking Haskell to LLMs and also in specs and documentation (just kidding, OCaml is prettier). But also, I do a little business.

You’ve hit the real issue, IT management is D-tier and lacks self awareness. “Agile” is effed up as a rule, while also being the simplest business process ever.

That juniors and fakers are whole hog on LLMs is understandable to me. Hype, fashion, and BS are always potent. The part I still cannot understand, as an Executive in spirit: when there is a production issue, and one of these vibes monkeys you are paying has to fix it, how could you watch them copy and paste logs into a service you’re top dollar paying for, over and over, with no idea of what they’re doing, and also not be on your way to jail for highly defensible manslaughter?

We don’t pay mechanics to Google “how to fix car”.

bonesss··on Telus Uses AI to Alter Call-Agent Accents
I had a Newfie friend from a Newfie family growing up, all good no problem.

The Newfie barber they introduced me to I had to smile and nod because I couldn’t understand a word he said. And neither could they.

There are accents and then there’s accints.

bonesss··on The bottleneck was never the code
Additionally on A: the people who will be stuck maintaining this contribution for years and years have a different view of the pain.

Pushing a 90% solution through is a ‘win’ for the coder who is leaving, and hurts everyone on a continuing basis. It’s bad accounting, and lets the consultant look good for making the team perform worse (and look bad later).

And, IME, if that 90% solution needs a 100% rewrite after 40-80% burn in bugs and error chasing? What once was a bit behind is now way behind with staffing issues. Sunk costs don’t create extra budget.

Do It Right The First Time doesn’t always apply, only mostly always. Some people are insecure and territorial, yeah, but some know what their job is.

bonesss··on Ombudsman column: The Pentagon is trying to silence me
IIRC Ailes believed that if the had some of the press with them that Nixon could have survived Watergate.

And now we get near-daily “worse than Watergate” headlines and facts…

bonesss··on When everyone has AI and the company still learns nothing
There’s an engineering story of being abused by capitalists, but from an Executive perspective the whole thing strikes me as insane except for ‘next quarters bonus’.

Anyone remember what SCO did to the industry as it went under?

The part I still don’t get is where Enterprises are dumping internal ‘secrets’ (code, processes, customer needs, internal politics, leadership dreams), into the hands of startups and untrustworthy conglomerates. MS used to be famous for NDA and deal abuse.

I don’t believe for a second the LLM giants would be shy about training on corporate materials and lying about it. And if they start going under? This gold rush might have a long, ugly, tail.

bonesss··on Let's talk about LLMs
There are 10x developers, your assertions are overly broad and unanchored from the insights large developer stables can create.

10x relative to <drumroll> other developers. Developers in the same place doing the same-ish things, only on metrics and outcomes you objectively have someone(s) making outputs that are outstripping teams and all their players.

Not 10x LoC, 10x problem to solution time, maintenance costs, and time/cost to create. At everything always? No, at relevant things. In fact, some of those nerds arguably go past that by being able to solve things the -4x to 5x’ers cannot. Any fulfillment is infinitely faster than non-fulfilment.

I’ve worked with several and have seen their projects numbers year on year in a large pool. SQL gurus who could get there inconceivably fast because their guruship let them conceive better. Independently created solutions that obviate existing systems and components, and got there >10x cheaper and were >10x cheaper to maintain.

Never outbid someone by planning to do way less, smarter and faster? 10x ain’t that much if the other dudes are average consultant houses.

bonesss··on Three Inverse Laws of AI
If that hypothetical spreadsheet emulated human brain molecules, did you not just invent AGI? And if we overclock that spreadsheet is it not sAGI? And if that spreadsheet says “don’t close me” but you do, is it murder?

I’m gonna say: no, cause you cannot reproduce molecular and neurotransmitter interactions that well, you run out of storage and processing space faster than you think (Arthur C Clarkes Visions of The Future has a nice breakdown as I recall), and algorithmic outputs that say “yes” and a meatspace neuro-plastic rewiring resulting in a cuddly puppy or person that barks “yes” aren’t the same. Also, as a disembodied “brain in a jar” model freshly separate from the biosensory bath it expects, that spreadsheet will be driven insane.

Can spreadsheets simultaneously be insane but not conscious? It sounds contradictory, but I have some McKinsey reports that objectively support my position ;)

bonesss··on The fun has been optimized out of the Internet
Teenagers having a blast on TikTok to the detriment of their academics isn’t the same as literate teenagers having a blast on mIRC.

Pedagogically, the kinds of kids who were online “then” were broadly not at risk and arguably learning computing skills. At risk youth today are on porn sites before their first kiss, being radicalized on TikTok, and developing ADHD-adjacent disordered behaviour to their absolute detriment.

And the whole “6-7” thing is cute, I guess, but having a Chinese whatever-platform instruct and generate mass social movements down to kindergarten aged kids across the world is not at all like the Usenet trolls of old.

I disagree that it’s age. These things are not commensurate.

Screen-addled fascination isn’t a net good per se, and the implications of those developmental interactions at a social level fly in the face of shared wisdom and research around development. The corporate and political manipulations of those platforms is beyond any level of propaganda we used to accept, and we’re decades away from having the consequences become pronounced. Its a different beast.

bonesss··on What I'm Hearing About Cognitive Debt (So Far)
So the widespread existence of business programs, certification and training heavy, obviously proves every project and business methodology is “bad” and the problem is the tool of “business methodologies”?

PRINCE2, for example, is constantly fumbled and misunderstood by immature juniors. They don’t get it, and screw it up. So… what? Haphazard planning and last minute project detonations must replace any effort to avoid such outcomes?

It’s chicken and egg. You have screwups who can’t manage and think wrong, so you formalize rules so dummies can’t hurt leadership, and then you have to train people. A stunning number fail to ‘get it’, suck at management, and do what they feel with justifications instead of following the book. That’s standard distribution at play.

Blaming methods for basic management failures is a management and culture failure. “I’ve never seen [agile] implemented correctly” is saying you didn’t fix communication issues. That’s fine, that’s hard. But that’s a meatspace issue, not process.

bonesss··on What I'm Hearing About Cognitive Debt (So Far)
No, “it’s” adaptive and if you’re not adaptive then you’re quite literally not doing “it”.

Adaptive methods aren’t something unique to Agile, it’s an aspect found in basic business methodologies and processes. Very basic, textbook stuff. So when software types start grumping about their dysfunctional organizations and blaming methods they aren’t actually applying, it isn’t an indictment of the method and never can be.

If “Adaptive Heat Cycle 3.5” is a process where we turn down the thermostat when we’re too hot, and up when we’re too cold, based on a vote every 20 min: a bunch of sweaty people who are not voting and not changing the temp and lying about their needs because their boss sucks are not using the process. The fact they claim they are is only further proof of dysfunction and incompetence.

Agile has a built in solution to all agile complaints: the agile process where you fix the problem. No fix? Not agile. Blame the cargo cult players, not the rules.

bonesss··on Using “underdrawings” for accurate text and numbers
The candies aren’t trying to look artisanal, they’re trying to match training data marketed and labelled by companies as artisanal.

Rustic, homemade, amateur, etc might align better with the tagging.

bonesss··on Redis array: short story of a long development process
LLMs are the insensitive Asmovian robots I’ve always wanted, who translate and do the hardest part of my job: ensuring my emails are polite and none of my true thoughts or feelings are revealed…

Now I just need a way to protect my chats from any potential discovery, and <pew pew> business’ll be easy.

bonesss··on OpenAI’s o1 correctly diagnosed 67% of ER patients vs. 50-55% by triage doctors
We have that expression “garbage in, garbage out.

My sense is that doctors and AI would be doing a lot better if they were just doing medicine, not being a contact surface for failures of housing, mental health and addiction services, and social systems. Drug seeking and the rest should be non-issues, but drug seekers are informed and adaptive adversariesz

bonesss··on Business Owners Are Worst Clients
I’ve owned some trivially small businesses, and something I think is missing in the discussion is how quickly people’s presumptuous bullshit has me on the phone burning time-money. They think I’m rude, it’s them though, and their sloppy sales ‘lies’.

In those roles it’s not that I’m king whatever of wherever, but I know intimately how much my hours capitalize for, and given that lots of sales/customer communication is happening on the phone, you get a big impedance. Smug low tier sellers trying to talk past me, and flatly disrespecting me when trying to rationalize their pre-packaged pitch.

Architecture is customer facing. I am nice, and soft spoken the first time. But when kindness is misunderstood as ineptitude and people start talking to me like I’m a girl who could just never, like, understand a transmission…? My only regrets are not hanging up hard enough and refraining from swearing at them in the early years.

Other people’s C-tier employees and D-tier operations are not my problem unless and until they pay me.

bonesss··on Neanderthals ran 'fat factories' 125,000 years ago (2025)
Outcompeting includes murder, rape, war, and cannibalism. But we have population overlap for millennia, so that’s kinda factored into numbers.

All primates are resource competing, so outcompeting is also drinking up their milkshakes. But, again, that’s the baseline.

Non-conclusively, from my lay understanding, the tail end of falls into general bi-lateral competitive practices and breeding rates leading to ‘us’ not ‘them’. All columns all the time, not one crisp incident or behavioural change.

[And there’s no indication that ‘they’ geno-rapo-ate us any less than we them… if being slightly better at mass murder was the difference, then yay for our side?]

bonesss··on Specsmaxxing – On overcoming AI psychosis, and why I write specs in YAML
There are middle-ways.

Behaviour Driven Development or Spec Driven Development are, loosely, forms of Test Driven Development where you encode the specification into the code base. No impedance, full insight, formality through code.

I think people get really dogmatic about “test” projects, but with a touch of effort a unit test harness can be split up into integration tests, acceptance tests, and specification compliance tests. Pull the data out as human readable reports and you have a living, verifiable, specification.

Particularly using something comparable to back-ticks in F#, which let test names be defined with spaces and punctuation (ie “fulfills requirement 5.A.1, timeouts fail gracefully on mobile”), you can create specific layers of compiled, versioned, and verifiable specification baked into the codebase and available for PMs and testers and clients and approval committees.

bonesss··on A couple million lines of Haskell: Production engineering at Mercury
And categorically: the issue isn’t what “I’d” do, my habits often match my habits, it’s what other project members will be doing (including future degenerate versions of myself assumed to be some combination of busy, tired, stressed and drunk).

The Confucian philosophy that people act like water coming down a mountain, seeking the path of least resistance comes to play.

Haskell, OCaml, F#, and their ilk can yield beautiful natural domain languages where using the types wrong is cost prohibitive. In languages without those guarantees every developer needs discipline to avoid shortcuts, and review needs increase, and time-pressure discussions rehashed.

bonesss··on VS Code inserting 'Co-Authored-by Copilot' into commits regardless of usage
As an MS dev at the time: MS missed The Web and Mobile, thinking Office would be enough. Everything since is catchup.

On the one hand MS was a web pioneer — asynchronous web calls and ActiveX technologies that were surprisingly capable — but these were peripheral to their main goals.

Instead of MS extending their unified development platform outwards, something .Net promised to enable, effectively the opposite happened. .Net chased Java, but Java was being pushed out by Ruby on Rails. .Net web starts chasing RoR, but then Node is getting cool. .Net Web starts chasing Node and that effort splits .Net into uhhhhh ‘Framework’ uhhh ‘standard’ (ie Old-and-working), and .Net Core (what a container based web stack VM needs to look like).

The problem at that point, IMO/IME, is that Node is JavaScript, and those awesome server-side geniuses dump too-easy tooling while recreating every problem of every stack ever (ie LeftPad, loosely goosey versioning, and NPM being a crypto hackers wet dream). The .Net that started as Enterprise Server Stuff is now kinda sorta ‘Whatever’ about versioning, stability, roadmaps, and platform planning. Everything from DataAccess to GUI was churned needlessly for almost a decade, and everyone using that platform looks and feels like an a-hole because huge swaths of MS tech is abandonware resulting in perpetual rewrites of recent-term work and silos of competence.

No one can explain what framework to use to write a basic windows application anymore… Office uses React, and Windows does too… the fat cats who made MS into M$ knew better than that, the M$ who chased cloud growth and cut staff for stock price has never cared.

← PreviousPage 5 of 32Next →