HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bonestormii_

233 karma · joined February 19, 2020

submissionscomments
bonestormii_··on Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group after delays
Will we be more wealthy if we lose the ability to create the most advanced chips? I think not.

It's not hegemony for the sake of hegemony, but hegemony for the benefits of hegemony, which in our recent history have included technological and economic supremacy, both tightly correlated to one another.

I think globalism can be a good thing, and I hardly oppose the notion of outsourcing some economic activities. However, the original point was regarding ceding our production capabilities for a short term and potentially insignificant improvement in the performance of a single company.

> The US would be a weaker nation if we had to commit a bunch of human capital to textiles.

There is something to be said for balance, taste, and sensibility. Like, it would be cool if we were able to manufacture essential medical PPE during a pandemic. Them be textiles, my friend.

If we are unprepared for a crisis that can gut our economy because we were prioritizing the economy over preparedness... I'm sorry, but that is stupid and short sighted.

Jobs are important. The economy is important. But it's as if all nuance is lost on the GDP-measuring mouth breathers. You want a strong economy? Maintain the hegemony. Be a global leader in many diverse categories.

bonestormii_··on Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group after delays
Why have we immediately reduced the conversation to the "economic" value of manufacturing? There is also a strategic geopolitical advantage to retaining domestic manufacturing, which is the most relevant part of this discussion.

Jobs, the economy... there is more to life, and more to maintaining a hegemony.

bonestormii_··on Falsehoods programmers believe about build systems (2012)
> (Disclaimer: my current implementation is not as fast as make for some things, because it's written in python. Eventually I'll rewrite it an C and it'll be very, very fast.)

Lol. Whatever, python community...

Anyway, I don't think redo really provides an answer to the insanity that is the js build system(s). I'm also a bit of a DJB fan, like python as a language, etc. However, this implementation in python... eh... I'm not sure about it. It's annoying to require someone to have some particular version of python to utilize a simple build system. He uses SQLite instead of the file system as a database paradigm favored by DJB.

DJB's software is all about technical correctness and simplicity of design. There's nothing wrong with this per se, but it wouldn't surprise me in the least to run this on some version of python that it isn't quite coded for and have it fail in some weird way without me realizing it.

The whole "I'm moving my python code to C tomorrow" thing is becoming a bit of a smell IMHO.

Shell script or a compiled language would be preferable in my opinion.

bonestormii_··on Former ICANN CEO is now co-CEO of the private equity firm that tried to buy .org
Paul Vixie talks about DNS: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxTdEEuyxHU
bonestormii_··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
It's almost as if $7,500/month for a 2BR apartment is ridiculous, no matter where it is.
bonestormii_··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
And it all goes back to all entities paying their fair share of taxes to fund infrastructure, etc.

As if there isn't enough money in San Francisco to build roads and trains! The city governments certainly don't have it, but it's there.

bonestormii_··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
Market forces are real, but can be regulated to align with our priorities. It's not a matter of explaining "how the world works." The market works how we design it to work. If it is unregulated, it frequently reflects exploitation.

You make a quip about engineers and political theorists, but fail to explain why a market cannot be regulated in order to benefit society in general. We do it all the time.

bonestormii_··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
I agree, but I also believe housing regulation and health care reform must accompany these things. Allowing these markets to buoy with the increase in everyone's income will negate the positive impact, having the effect of routing the additional income into the hands of the same people who already hold all of the wealth.
bonestormii_··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
Agreed, it doesn't provide an answer for lack of supply, and growth needs to be controlled to pace with things like public and private infrastructure, and even jobs.

However, it doesn't justify the runaway inflation of the entire housing market. Also, I'd point out that generally speaking, the population of an area will be limited by the jobs available in that area, so there is an external limit on the demand for housing to at least some extent. There are jobs and money to be made in development of additional housing to meet the demand. Supply issues are not insurmountable, and should be addressed as such.

I'll also note that in the USA, all of the "intangibles" you listed are already typically collected by the landlord along with the leasing application itself. This isn't a result of rent caps, just high demand and standard tenant screening practices.

To solve problems, you may actually have to try. Obstacles don't justify problems, they just need to be addressed.

bonestormii_··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
> Even when there is a rental price cap, that tends to only work in the short term and exacerbates supply/demand problems long term. San Francisco, for example, implemented a rent control system in ~1980. Since then, only 40% of rental units are eligible for rent control and lots of potential rentals stay off the rental market. There are loopholes which allow conversion of a rent-controlled unit to a market-priced rental and no new built units are rent controlled, so there is a bifurcation of the market. Rent controlled units are very affordable, but increasingly scarce. Market priced units are growing (slowly) in numbers, but cost 2x - 5x what a comparable rent-controlled unit does.

True, there are real supply issues in some very hot markets, but few markets are like San Francisco.

So--why do you say that the price cap is what exacerbates the supply/demand problems long term, when you clearly understand the issue is that there are loopholes being utilized to reclassify units to get the back to market price? Those loop holes aren't accidents--the NIMBY groups put them there intentionally. But they aren't just NIMBY--they are also private investors who do not even live there.

I'm all for building additional housing to meet demand in general. However, it does need to be done carefully. By that I mean, upgrading train stations, roads, grocery options, etc. in order to deal with the increase in population. You can't just add 15,000 people to a neighborhood and not add parking or public transit capacity.

bonestormii_··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
It's not an example chosen at random. It's a real example.
bonestormii_··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
I'm for regulation of the housing industry, but he's not wrong that public housing policy is a shit show. What he is wrong about is that landlords actually prefer it this way, because they prefer subsidies to pricing regulation.
bonestormii_··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
How can that be, exactly? If it's "extensively regulated", then why is it so expensive? Can you point to a relationship between capping the price and inflating it? They seem to be inversely related.
bonestormii_··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
> When I was young, I had roommates. I don’t think every working person should be able to afford a 1 bedroom apartment.

Not everyone working minimum wage is doing it "when they were young." Do you really think it's a good objective for a 55 year old cook for a non-profit organization to be living with room mates? Would you want that?

The solution is there if you are willing to reduce the wealth generated by investment properties for an already much wealthier investment class. How do you justify your priorities ethically?

bonestormii_··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
Having worked a lot in a rental market with a very active housing subsidy program, I agree that the administration of such programs is an actual nightmare, but you really are missing the point I think.

Start with the assumption that people need to be able to afford a place to live, and that a full time job should be able to achieve that. Do you agree?

Now, if we both agree that a housing subsidy program is an administrative nightmare, what's left? Simple: Regulating prices on the housing market.

A subsidy is a nightmare to administer; is subject to corruption, mis-targeting, abuse, and extreme wait lists; and drains public resources. So why do we do it? Simple: Because the real estate industry has lobbied the government to pursue this as a means to address housing inequality. Rather than being told that the earnings of their investment properties will be capped by regulation, the government is writing a check to make up the difference.

So now, after years of waiting, a single mother of two might get a 3/4 of her rent paid by a subsidy. The apartment needs to pass ridiculous inspections which are conducted historically by specialized contractors who benefit from failing due to re-inspection fees, and they will fail an inspection because a screw is missing from a light switch cover, blowing up a lease deal and elongating the timeline for a subsidized move-in by months. It sucks for the residents, and it sucks for the landlord from a administrative/management perspective (mainly dealt with by hired management), but at the end of the day, they have a government-guaranteed rent payment for a greatly inflated rent market. Coronavirus cut your tenant's hours?! No problem! At least 3/4 the rent will be paid, and the margins are still profitable.

And we wonder why wealth inequality is growing in the US! This literally inflates the rental market by creating more demand for overpriced housing than exists, by creating a class of people who can afford it only through a majority subsidy. It also encourages investment property purchases by doing so, in turn creating more competition in the buyers market and causing price inflation there as well. This also has the effect of keeping more people renting instead of being able to buy.

In conclusion, PEOPLE NEED HOUSING! Real estate industry doesn't need subsidies. Yes,that includes private landlords with investment properties. Someone else's housing or health care shouldn't be an unregulated investment opportunity if we care about the well being of the people.

bonestormii_··on Group brainstorming is a waste of time (2015)
Exactly. That said, a one-on-one type thing with someone you trust can be great.
bonestormii_··on Programming at the REPL (2018)
Programming in the REPL is something I do all the time and generally enjoy, but I sometimes feel like the actual design of the program then becomes too focused around REPL usage. Too much abstraction can harm performance and waste time. The REPL encourages this by making you think about the internals of your program as an interface that will actually get used, when in reality some function may get called twice ever from within your own code, and isn't really meant to be exposed. But because you are repeatedly invoking it manually via the REPL, it feels like an interface worthy of considerable design.

Maybe it is, and maybe it isn't. I've just noticed this tendency in myself when working in REPLs. Not every part of your program is an API.

bonestormii_··on Group brainstorming is a waste of time (2015)
I don't think well in groups, because conversation is distracting. I think this applies to everyone when the subject matter is deeper than like, advertising or something superficially creative.

The value of brainstorming is mainly the suspension of criticism, and it's an important part of any creative task, even if applied alone. I see it all the time--a very smart person with lots of aptitude who can't write, can't draw, can't code, can't do anything because any small attempt is immediately "not good enough".

The suspension of criticism is necessary in order to push through. You can't run from the problems forever, but I do think that making some shitty version of something before you make a good version is... necessary? You never really know what you are doing until the shitty version exists and you can see the problems, and subsequently the solutions.

bonestormii_··on Uber, Postmates Agree on $2.65B All-Stock Deal
Perhaps--I really know nothing about it.

However, if you allow yourself to simplify the problem, it seems there is really no physical difference from a food delivery and a ride. Pick up at one location, drop off at another--maybe with extra time required to get out of the car. In both cases, there is a limited allowable waiting threshold.

So if you can merge those work forces, you could attain higher utilization. The main problem I see though is that both sectors surge at roughly the same times, so it isn't quite as complimentary as you might initially hope.

bonestormii_··on Uber, Postmates Agree on $2.65B All-Stock Deal
You raise an interesting point. Maybe with uber the goal is to integrate delivery work force with ride work force to improve utilization of drivers/deliverers. Horizontal, but complimentary.
bonestormii_··on A Journey building a fast JSON parser and full JSONPath, Oj for Go
> It's the lingua franca of data transfer.

Fortunately, this is really only true at the application level. Space/line delimited byte strings and binary formats are used frequently at lower levels.

bonestormii_··on The Wrong Abstraction (2016)
This is a good example of how this overall topic gets reduced to "How much abstraction?" instead of "In what ways should something be abstracted?"

Obviously an Add/Edit field are operating on the same record in a hypothetical database, so it makes little sense to duplicate the model.

On the other hand, if the conditionals within the abstracted version become too complex or keep referencing some notion of a mode of operation (like, ` if type(self) == EditType && last_name != null` lines of thinking), that is sometimes another type of smell.

But say you make some kind of abstract base class that validates all fields in memory before committing to the database, and then place all of your checking logic in a validate() method. That sounds like pretty clean abstractions to me.

And moreover, this is probably provided by an ORM system and documented by that system anyway--so that's a publicly documented and likely very common abstraction that you see even between different ORMs. That, I think, is the very best kind of abstraction, at least assuming you are already working in such an environment as a high-level language and ORM. Making raw SQL queries from C programs still contain their own levels of abstractions of course without buying whole sale into the many-layered abstraction that is a web framework or something.

This question becomes more important when you aren't just updating a database though. If you're writing some novel method with a very detailed algorithm, over abstraction through OOP can really obscure the algorithm. In such a case, I try to identify logical tangents within the algorithm, and prune/abstract them away into some property or function call, but retain a single function for the main algorithm itself.

The main algorithm gets its definition moved to the base class, and the logical tangents get some kind of stub/virtual method thingy in the base class so that they have to be defined by subclasses. The more nested tangents are frequently where detailed differences between use cases emerge, which makes logical sense. It's not just that it's abstract, but the logic is categorically separated.

It's a very general pattern supported by many languages, so you see it all over the place. That organization and consistency in itself helps you to understand new code. In that way, it also becomes a kind of "idiom" which in a sense is one more layer of abstraction, helping you to manage complexity.

As a counter of that, you see code where `a + x * y - b` becomes self.minus(self.xy_add(a), b). More abstract, but not more logical; not categorically separating; not conforming to common idioms; obscuring the algorithm; and so on...

And then there is performance! Let's not talk about the performance of runtime abstractions.

bonestormii_··on A look at the Gemini protocol: a brutally simple alternative to the web
It's like wearing clothing.

If I wear a polo and dress pants, and I'm on the train at 8am, I'm going to white collar work. If I wear jeans at the same time and have my partner with me, I'm a middle class, middle aged, probably-parent on personal business that could probably be described as "running an errand". If I'm a 42 year old man wearing bright purple halter top, with black lipstick and combat boots on the train at 8am--you don't know me! Where the hell am I going? How am I living? You don't understand how to talk to me, so don't bother unless you are a 27 year old woman with red eye liner, green air, blue lipstick and a brady bunch t-shirt on! We wouldn't understand each other!

Elaborate protocol jokes aside, it's an apt analogy. It works--for some people, some of the time. They are dreamers living life waiting for a tomorrow that may never come, but the cause gives them their identity. Chances are that Bob and Linda still have to straighten up on Monday mornings and assimilate to the general protocol. But that's the world we live in, is it not?

I like it. I don't like to deal with it when I'm at the bank or the brokerage, but Friday night, it's alright with me.

I don't begrudge their them identities. However, it's a weak, unopinionated protocol. No inline images? Just because you support them doesn't mean they don't exist.

Users will have their inline images, and they will build clients, and the protocol will be defined. If not by you, then by someone else.

That is the story of the modern web, and that is, funny enough, how we got here.

Nostalgia isn't productive. A new protocol isn't insurmountable, but it has to be native to the time you are living in. You don't need to necessarily inline videos and graphics, but you need to define how these should be handled, or at the very least, the boundaries of the protocol. Waxing whimsically at people creating readers to handle inline images in an ad hoc way... lol, why? Why are they doing this?! They were just bemoaning the current state of the web! My god, have some foresight!

Make a protocol, make a browser, define the boundaries and perhaps adjacent protocols, set your browser roadmap accordingly. Stop when you feel the coverage of the desired space is sufficient. If that's text-only, fine. But you must have answers to how an image or video should be served to the good people of this community.

bonestormii_··on MaXX Interactive Desktop: A Re-Implementation of the IRIX Interactive Desktop
Oooo. So I think this is a terrible idea for most people, but something I would personally love. I'm a big fan of 3 monitors in a slight "wrapping" formation, but there are times when some event occurs on a screen which is literally behind me if I'm looking at one of the far monitors. It would be so cool to have 3D audio feedback that lets you calibrate to the layout of your monitors.
bonestormii_··on Apple and Facebook
That's a well-reasoned response which I can appreciate. But honestly, read my original post to which you replied. I said I shared the parent's disgust, but I don't think I'm really reveling in outrage or speaking in such extreme terms as you characterize.

I'll quote it...

> "There are certainly shades of gray, but if I can speak on behalf of the post you are responding to, it seems their argument would be that it is a net negative, and that the "Good PR humanity" is relatively shallow in the end. Consider a $100,000,000 education fund for app developers. Certainly, app development can be a gateway for some people, but once they develop apps, where do they go if not a market place that Apple tightly controls? They are a machine funding the creation of new cogs in this scenario.If your overlords buy you an opulent dinner and provide you with a warm bed, it doesn't mean you are free.Freedom can be a vague and high-minded ideal that obviously needs to be balanced with communal concerns, but I agree with the parent poster's overall disgust. It feels that a company like Apple is so big that they are beyond any societal control or regulation, and that is unacceptable. To hear their minions rush to their defense as if their interests are somehow aligned (they're not) is too much to handle sometimes. It's tiring."

Honestly, I use so much language to balance and mitigate my argument that it's overly verbose.

> "There are shades of gray", "relatively shallow", "Certainly, app development can be a gateway for some people...", Freedom can be high-minded and needs to be balanced,".

Is it possible to make this point passively enough to satisfy your requirements?

I'll also admit that the parent comment was a bit more extreme in it's tone. And I'll admit there are many injustices in the world that go beyond tech. But I think the underlying issue of acquiring and maintaining freedom of all kinds is valid.

It's like saying, "With racial inequality being what it is, how can you spend your time belaboring a point about campaign finance reform?" The answer is simple: Because one form of freedom (in this case, governmental representation) facilitates those adjacent freedoms (racial equality). The importance of one doesn't invalidate the importance of the other.

I'm like, not that outraged. But I am like, casually disgusted by people who seem to have allowed huge corporations to become so apart of themselves that they lose the ability to see some obvious flaws.

I love my iPhone. Apple is far from the worst of it. But there are some very disturbing trends in tech and the world that warrant our skepticism and yes, our disgust. That it is treated as normal is part of the problem.

bonestormii_··on Apple and Facebook
I'm not trying to shut down the conversation.

In this case it is the conversation. "Why do we defend and obsess over 3rd party business interests of corporate giants?" is the topic we are discussing. Keep up.

bonestormii_··on Apple and Facebook
Oh yes, the fabled <20% marketshare.

So where should I go from Apple if not into the waiting arms of Google/Android? Is that better?

This isn't actually a conversation specifically about Apple if you recall. It is a conversation about all such companies. And yes, your defense of Apple is a little cringe-y. Why do you need to defend such a behemoth in a conversation that is decidedly not dedicated to them? Per the parent comment--Why does HN obsess over the actions of these companies that are categorically not for anyone's benefit other than their own? That was the original question.

I honestly am asking you to reflect on it. Why do you care? What's it to you?

bonestormii_··on Apple and Facebook
There are certainly shades of gray, but if I can speak on behalf of the post you are responding to, it seems their argument would be that it is a net negative, and that the "Good PR humanity" is relatively shallow in the end.

Consider a $100,000,000 education fund for app developers. Certainly, app development can be a gateway for some people, but once they develop apps, where do they go if not a market place that Apple tightly controls? They are a machine funding the creation of new cogs in this scenario.

If your overlords buy you an opulent dinner and provide you with a warm bed, it doesn't mean you are free.

Freedom can be a vague and high-minded ideal that obviously needs to be balanced with communal concerns, but I agree with the parent poster's overall disgust. It feels that a company like Apple is so big that they are beyond any societal control or regulation, and that is unacceptable. To hear their minions rush to their defense as if their interests are somehow aligned (they're not) is too much to handle sometimes. It's tiring.

bonestormii_··on Apple and Facebook
I couldn't agree more with this. "Drip feeding 'new emojis'" sent chills down my spine.

The problem always seems to be the question, "How do you get a decentralized system to a reach critical mass of mainstream usage?"

Consider the concept of a labor union. The word "union" implies a unification, formalization, and to some extent a centralization of workers around an administrative structure that is not the business that employs them. I think many people would agree that such a union is a necessary counter force if you want to achieve progressive workplace reforms.

Technology to free us from the walled garden always pursues decentralization as a means to evade control. But there must be some unified, centralized force promoting it early on.

The downside to this is that it creates a large attack surface vulnerable to legal threat and infiltration of competing interests. However, we can't replace the global internet with enmeshed home networks. We can't replace fiber with dreams, or iphones with raspberry pis.

It would be great if the governments represented the people, and did not act like some self-interested third party so much of the time. Perhaps, the government--our government--would be an appropriate body to administer a formative revolution. But since we know that they like to spy, control, and arbitrarily regulate, it forces the question of how to form a dedicated central entity powerful enough to promote the changes we want to see, but resistant to the trappings of other corporations and government.

It's a deep question that arises when you pursue freedom of any kind.

bonestormii_··on My dream dating app has been banned by Apple
I mean, is a woman more qualified to judge whether a situation is an example of misogyny? Perhaps not, as a man could reach the same conclusion. But it's certainly more appropriate than leaving it to a group of men, or an industry that is generally dominated by men. It's relevant, not because the logic is dependent on the fact, but because it is a perspective regarding societal power.

The article indicates that hating astrology is characteristic of white cis men. The parent comment says "FWIW, I'm not those things, and I hate astrology." They aren't asserting their authority to make a logical argument. They are offering their perspective as a sample.

Respectfully, I think you are letting your intellect get in the way of your ability to think by dismissing these perspectives, misidentifying a report of someone's subjective experience as a logical argument, and therefore a fallacy.

Personally, I hate astrology, but I wouldn't have this app flagged as spam and banned from the app store because of it. I think the argument that this is a form of (probably unintentional) racial/gender/sexual discrimination holds water. If nothing else, I find the idea that Apple happily exerts this kind of force on their customer's personal interests super frustrating and distasteful, and bad for business. Money talks, and bullshit walks. If there is no market for it, let it die on its own merit. I don't need Apple's protection from astrology.

We don't all have to embrace each other, but we do have to suffer each other. And traditionally, some of us have been suffering a lot more than others.

That's just my opinion. Take it for what it's worth.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →