2,010 karma · joined November 10, 2015
I think it's a good policy and it helps ensure some minimum bar of code review from everyone, but it's not sufficient by itself. A person who is only motivated by the promo/review process is going to give "just doing this to check the box"-quality reviews.
I've found that people are much more inspired by all of the intrinsic motivations for doing code review, like learning from others' code and helping your teammates improve. But putting it into promo packets is a good first step to start building that culture.
I used nitrous for childbirth and it was helpful in early labor, but the pain pretty quickly reached a point where the nitrous barely touched it. Nitrous works great at the dentist, but it was so profoundly insufficient for labor.
It sucks that as a result of women being forced to do twilight sleep even if they didn't want to, now we've taken that choice away completely and you can't do it even if you do want to.
I don't recall we even needed a lot of resources or personal attention or special student/teacher ratios in gifted class--they just set us loose with computers and told us to write logo programs (it was the early 90s), instead of being stuck in regular class trying to figure out how to cut myself so I could feel something other than bored.
I would've ended up getting a phd with or without gifted classes--I didn't need it to get a jump start on career success or something like that. I needed it to keep me sane.
An example: https://twitter.com/CuttleXYZ/status/1468275963980963845
If you're not totally set on doing direct work for climate change, you could consider a similar strategy. In my case, I think it's probably more impactful than I could be if I tried to pivot into a climate-related career.
Yet another instance of fast/cheap/good, pick two.
When I fill out the NIH's "is this human research" tool with my understanding of what the study did, it tells me it IS human subjects research, and is not exempt. There was an interaction with humans for the collection of data (observation of behavior), and the subjects haven't prospectively agreed to the intervention, and none of the other very narrow exceptions apply.
I got the Moderna shot and I've been totally nerding out about how cool it is. It's just mRNA, which basically falls apart when you look at it funny, with just enough lipids to hold it together until it gets into your cells. If there were going to be terrible side-effects, I would expect them to show up immediately or not at all, since the constituent ingredients are simple things that break down quickly in the body.
Coming from a background like that, I find that the days/weeks feedback loop time in tech makes me positively giddy with joy. It's hard for me to imagine thinking of 5 days as a long time to work on a problem.