HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bonsaitree

624 karma · joined February 28, 2008

submissionscomments
bonsaitree··on And now, some smoking guns (or “part two of angels that charge”)
Perhaps my information is simply out of date.

Given that Mr. Calacanis is active on this thread, he clearly would be the best source to clarify things.

FWIW, (see below) I also disagree with these practices, but have serious reservations on the methods and motivations employed to expose them.

bonsaitree··on And now, some smoking guns (or “part two of angels that charge”)
As I've said before, and will repeat one final time, I DO NOT agree with these firm's practices, but I will defend their right to apply whatever bidding/pitch process they'd like, under the law, within their respective organizations.

Aside from the usual litany of trade-secret/defamation issues (largely paper tigers here) and clearly vested bias by the publisher, the release itself isn't the issue.

What IS wrong is the instant garnering of credibility of this single-sourced material without any fact-checking of these accounts nor dialog with/about the respective parties. Whistle-blowing is fine IF released through 3rd parties who apply independent due diligence.

To use an analogy, it's as if the coach of a college football team calls a press conference to expose the corrupt high school recruiting practices of a rival university.

If true, and the coach genuinely places the best interests of those high school students foremost, he insures its release through ESPN, the college athletics association, or any 3rd party perceived to be reasonably neutral.

If, on the other hand, he personally brings forth these allegations in his own forum, it only serves to degrade their credibility, do a disservice to those whom ostensibly he is attempting to serve, and cast a great deal of umbrage on his true motivations.

One final addendum, if that $18k story is true, then it sure looks like an open and shut case for a breach of contract suit, but more likely, an easy opportunity to reach a pre-trial settlement for the majority of the proceeds.

If the founders blindly paid these fees w/o any sort of written agreements of performance on the part of the Angel firm, nor applied any inverse due-diligence to their potential investors, then I seriously question if they have necessary modicum of business acumen to run a company.

bonsaitree··on In which I stomp on some of our glorious “green shoots”
It's from Business Week. 'Nuff said. Business Week is to business journalism what Mariah Carey is to business journalism.
bonsaitree··on And now, some smoking guns (or “part two of angels that charge”)
That would be fine IF there was any semblance of an open/neutral forum and Calacanis hadn't already used blanketing statements. What sane set of founders would voluntarily violate agreements to "come out" publicly FOR their experiences in this context? It's a rigged trial.

As I've already stated, from what's been published, I disagree with these practices, but we're only hearing "leaked documents" from ONE SOURCE. There's ZERO discourse here--just fear mongering and name-calling. It all comes across as extremely pandering and childish. Hopefully, that will change.

It would be one thing if Calacanis had some semblance of independence, but as a partner in Sequioa, he is, quite literally, a fiduciary in a competing firm.

How would you like to have your business's private contractual affairs paraded in front of a bully pulpit?

bonsaitree··on And now, some smoking guns (or “part two of angels that charge”)
Um, it's none of YOUR business how these firms run their deals. Not that I find the practice equitable, nor a lawsuit meritorious on the available information, but if that's THEIR business model and the founders are willing to fork over the cash, that's THEIR CHOICE.

If you really want to FIX this, offer up a viable structured alternative to aggressively pursue their business. It's easy to throw spit-balls from the back of the classroom. I'd expect much more from somebody who's been down that road--on both sides of the table.

Instead this whole affair comes across, in gestalt, as a series of public ad hominem attacks on other parties and a plea for personal attention in the minimus.

If your ambition is to be a "shock podcaster" and garner a Dave Winer-esque reputation, you're, sadly, headed down the right track. You complained about being publicly "berated" at Gnomedex '07. Kettle. Pot. Black.

bonsaitree··on Dyson blade-less fans 98% less power than air conditioning
Um...yeah. Not that I expect anything but pablum on business (let alone basic science) from BusinessWeek, but comparing direct adiabatic air conditioning cooling (direct air temperature change) to evaporative cooling (more air movement) is apples vs. oranges.

At "desk fan power levels", buffeting is a non-issue beyond a few fan-blade radii distances from the rotor.

Child-Safe "flexible" blades running off of de-torquing motors on non-burn-out electronic transmission feedback circuits have been around for 20+ years.

The key metric to examine is, across a variety of humidity gradients and temperatures, what the volumetric cooling efficiency is per watt of input power (i.e. delta-Temp/m^3/s/watt).

Unless it's MUCH better than a typical fan (unlikely), this product is just the Dyson name attached to an Coanda airfoil fed by a conventional ducted fan--most definitely not even worth $150 USD--let alone $300+.

bonsaitree··on "Writing Multithreaded Programs Can't Be Done In C" - Spolsky
It's just Joel doing the "Joel 'Thang"--namely effective, but disingenuous, attention marketing. Examine the context of his original statement.
bonsaitree··on Do Assholes Really Finish First?
Immediate journalism 101 error. Headlines should not be interrogatives.
bonsaitree··on Mark Zuckerberg: The evolution of a remarkable CEO
Except that different yardsticks of measurement are required for "owners", "investors", and "employees" since they, by definition, have different areas of responsibility, and economic alignments based on nearly dichotomous ROI models.

Total "compensation" should be based on salary relative to their areas of expertise cross-industry & the current strike price of any option grants relative to current valuations & vesting schedules.

Based on the article, it not at all clear that Facebook is doing any of this.

FWIW, those maxims apply to compensation strategies irregardless of company size, business model, or public/private status. I refer you to Warren Buffett's many communications on such matters over the years.

Additionally, if anyone had similar access to the wealth, privilege, and social contacts as Mr. Zukerberg did during their childhood & adolescence, they'd better damn well be changing the world.

bonsaitree··on The only alternative is to work harder
Honestly, I don't know where to begin, but suffice it to say, everything else is NEVER equal in the real world.

1. You're assuming "success" is zero-sum-game. 2. There's no opportunity cost for working towards a different goal. 3. There is some sort of equitable measure of "success" across all participants in "the game". 4. The effort/reward curve is averages positive for your given set of stratagems. 5. You are the ONLY vested participant in the game (e.g. no ancillary costs for increased efforts to other parties (e.g. family, friends, partners, investors etc.).

bonsaitree··on A new house number ...
It's just intentional obfuscation. Just like the double inversion.
bonsaitree··on An interview question you had better know how to answer
This is a bad, bad, question because it doesn't structure the response towards learning about the candidate's thought processes and pre-stages the context of their response as a value judgment.

At best, you'll get a narrative about a specific project context and the candidate's actions which resulted in "failure". At worst, you'll get a disingenuous canned response from someone trying to game the interview and frame the chosen scenario as "success".

A better phrasing would be:

"Please tell me about a project experience when a plan, scenario, or design didn't unfold as originally intended."

The candidate can frame their response as "success", "failure", "improvisation", etc. and this opens up avenues to explore their thought processes, strategy, and 'leadership style' when responding to novel scenarios. This is also an opportunity to weigh the candidate's level of disclosure and frank communications as to what sorts of value judgments they, themselves, apply to the chosen scenario and their qualitative reactions to it.

bonsaitree··on Rands: Hurry
Nothing original, but an extremely well-structured narrative approach to the traditional "call to action" essay.
bonsaitree··on Public Suffix List
Unfortunately it's wrong for certain countries such as Thailand (.th) which only allow for 3rd-level (e.g. .*.th) public domain registrations.
bonsaitree··on Starting a Bank
This reminds me of the wonderful theoretical country discussions we had in my economics classes at college.

Forget a new kind of bank. Go total bluesky. What IF, we could design our own set of sovereign laws and principles.

What would the "modern" country look like?

bonsaitree··on What are eigen values?
Yes. Thanks for the correct re-wording as "or" and "equivalence class".
bonsaitree··on What are eigen values?
Days late, but worth the response for accuracy's sake since I just popped in on HN now:

> 1. A linear mapping is not a "kind of equivalence" by any > reasonable definition.

By definition, ANY mapping is an equivalence relation--even if that relation results in a 0 or NAN value.

> 2. The eigenvectors are not the rows of the diagonalized > matrix...

Correct. It depends on one's orientation (columns vs. rows), but the matrix which does the coordinate transforms contains the eigenvectors. Bad wording on my part. The key behind diagonalization is it removes any orientation issues from the relationship by establishing eigenweights across a given vector space.

> 3. I think the paragraph beginning "For the common 3D isometric ..."

Your interpretation is correct and, indeed, my choice of verbiage was poor. I really should have used the words "ortho-normal to a given vector space" which collapses to the common XYZ unit vectors in a linearly partitioned vector space of 6 degrees of freedom (3 translations & 3 rotations)--e.g. classic Cartesian space.

> Tensors are just as linear as matrices.

Most tensor fields are modeled using linear approximations (i.e. matricies of n-dimensions), but the very fact that a tensor itself is being used in the characteristic equations is typically indicative of non-linear behavior in the overall system. For example, in fluid dynamics used to model airflow across a wing or boundary values issues when the Cauchy stress tensor is used for structures undergoing plastic deformation.

I believe that you are conflating Manifolds with Tensors. The latter is a refinement and/or characteristic relation defined upon the former. A non-linear Tensor is defined upon a manifold with one or more non-linear relations. Perhaps you are used to dealing exclusively with metric tensors?

> The probabilities in a Markov chain's stationary state are not eigenvalues.

Here you are spot-on. Indeed it's the eigenvalues of the transition matrix (or convergence for ergodic ones) to which I was referring. Thanks (again) for the correction and further clarification.

bonsaitree··on Self: The Power of Simplicity
Please edit your entry to include an additional "[pdf]" type designator since the link is directly to a PDF document and not to a web page nor a Scribd embed.
bonsaitree··on Is Taleb a crank?
It's a really sad commentary on our society, and specifically the HN community, when a headline framed as a question (a no-no in Journalism 101) gets traction. Great response.
bonsaitree··on Cops Use Old Brink's Truck to Shame Suspects
Technically speaking, the residence is being accused of an infraction, not a crime. It's akin to a parking ticket.

As I've noted in my earlier comment, the "jig" is up with this procedure the minute the infraction is fought in court and a single precedent is established in case law.

bonsaitree··on Cops Use Old Brink's Truck to Shame Suspects
It's a nice niche solution for non-violent "nuisance" issues, but it will only scale to the point where the cost of temporary criminal activity shutdown and/or location movement is less than the risk/cost of dirt-cheap anti-materiel sabotage actions against the truck. A very, very low bar to hurtle.

Examples: Thermite + Firecracker Ignition against an axle, Short-range "spray painting" of camera portals w/ heat-set epoxy, Long-range shooting of camera portals with suppressed sub-sonic ammo or high-powered air rifles.

Additionally, the very minute a reasonably well-educated/funded home-owner brings a case against the "nuisance" claim to court, any further use of the truck would be limited to the local municipality's statutory limits on mere infractions (non-crimes)--typically no more than 24 hours.

To enable the truck to loiter any longer, the local prosecutor would have to file formal criminal charges and declare the particular residence a "crime zone".

bonsaitree··on What are eigen values?
If ever there was a time when I wish every browser had the MathML plug-in... sigh.
bonsaitree··on What are eigen values?
Yes.

For a linear system (of any kind of equivalence) within an N-dimensional vector space, the Eigenvalues represent the scaling factors across those dimensions when the system's state is represented by an NxN sparse-diagonalized matrix (i.e. all values are 0 except for the main diagonal).

Those non-zero values along the main diagonal are its Eigenvalues and its rows are Eigenvectors.

For the common 3D isometric (e.g. xyz) coordinate system, the Eigenvalues can be thought of as a kind of multiplier across the unit vectors (Eigenvectors) [[1,0,0][0,1,0][0,0,1]]. This is the "stretching" analog mentioned in the article.

FWIW, Eigenvalues are not just a salient property of linear systems (i.e. matrices), but also of higher-order tensors.

Finding (or more-often approximating) these "characteristic scaling states" is a critical step in numerical analysis in everything from quantum mechanics, financial hedging strategies, and even consumer product marketing plans.

If you've ever represented a system as a series of Markov probability chains, every row of the "convergent/dominant" (if any) state contains an Eigenvalue.

bonsaitree··on Bullies can be stopped, but it takes a village
Applying adult standards to child behavior is so fraught with flaws, I don't even know where to begin.

Suffice it to say that, with near universal applicability, all human societies throughout recorded history have made clear distinctions between the boundaries of acceptable social behavior (and punishments for breaching these boundaries) for children and adults.

There's also quite a large accumulated body of modern scientific measurements which suggests that children and early teenagers lack the sufficiently streamlined cerebral pathways (pre-puberty) which would allow them to make the social judgment calls and impulse control to both avoid being a bully and/or a bullied victim. In both roles, they can not balance the short-term costs against the long-term consequences.

You also make a gross assumption about the training and responsiveness of a local police force to situations involving minors in the custody of a school. Baring extreme violence, a history of criminal behavior, or property damage, in most municipalities, this is the fiduciary responsibility of the public school district. For private institutions, a specific set of liability clauses and insurance is part of the enrollment contract.

bonsaitree··on I Quit The iPhone
Looks like Mikey is looking for some filler for a slow end-of-week news cycle. Plus, he can continue to add more follow-up "content" on Pre & Android experiences.

Just more "jurinal"-istic pablum. Next.

bonsaitree··on The Dark Side of Entrepreneurship
Likely the financial (and social family) cost of "gross negligence" litigation would well exceed any measurable benefit. If the owner has a strong case, a private settlement for 30-50% damages is the most likely outcome.

Even in the unlikely event the accounting firm broke/abused their fiduciary duties AND a circuit/general court tort verdict was in this owner's favor, it would take years for the funds to work their way through the system.

bonsaitree··on The Dark Side of Entrepreneurship
Some types of capital-intensive business models essentially require debt funding unless the founders are independently wealthy and/or are willing to trade equity for VC funding.

A classic example is starting/owning a restaurant or bakery.

bonsaitree··on What’s Right and Wrong with Media Now
A TC post on HN which apparently features "journalism" from Ms. Lacy. I call double-fault & loss of serve.

Ms. Lacy can't string English sentences together with even a modicum of workmanship competence. She cites reference she hasn't even read, crassly pimps her own works in 3rd party organs, and continues to offer exclusively hyperbolic punditry over reasoned & thoughtful analysis.

What's wrong with media today? I offer up the "career" of Ms. Sarah Lacy.

bonsaitree··on Work and Meaning: View from a Senior HP Manager
I suspect there's just a wee bit of hypocracy taking place here.

One has to wonder if this truly was the case, and he came to these conclusions in a reasonable timeframe (on the order of 1 year), why on earth he's bothered to stay with HP for 2 full years?

Very likely this was due to an "earn out" clause in the acquisition agreement of Tabblo (his start-up).

So, in other words, the author has stayed-on for...the paycheck.

bonsaitree··on Techcrunch misleading about dangers of using "tweet" in names
TechCrunch spews forth a non-story on a non-issue and folks act as if this isn't business as usual. Next.
← PreviousPage 6 of 8Next →