HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bookaway

541 karma · joined March 27, 2020

submissionscomments
bookaway··on Aaron Swartz and Sam Altman
Yes, definitely. But becoming the head of YC was also due to his own merit. His merit was persuading the right people. After all, the essay where pg is giving his highest praise is an essay about fundraising.

Will you not agree that him becoming "the driving force of OpenAI" involved some highly publicized back-to-back persuasion drama as well? First he got Ilya and gdb to side with him against Elon, then he got OpenAI employees to side with him against Ilya and the board (a board that accused him of deceiving them). PG reiterated after that drama that Altman's special talent was becoming powerful.

This observation does not necessarily mean someone is a bad CEO, since the job of the CEO is to do good by your investors or future investors. And it's possible to do that without any morals whatsoever. But I think the recent drama did more to drive the competition than some of his investors would have liked.

Edit:

>At that time, OpenAI had no clear path to becoming the unicorn it is today, and YC was definitely better from a career standpoint.

This is very incorrect in my view. The presence of Elon Musk as investor and figurehead and Ilya, Karpathy, and Wojciech as domain experts, not to mention investments from YC members themselves (and the PayPal mafia) made OpenAI a very attractive investment early on.

bookaway··on Aaron Swartz and Sam Altman
PG liked him, because Altman decided to go to great lengths to get PG to like him.

While Drew, Chesky and the Collison brothers were busy building billion dollar companies, Altman took the “shortcut” and made a concerted effort to cozy up to the most powerful man in the room — and it payed dividends. Altman did the same thing in the early OpenAI days by doing flaterring video series interviews with Elon Musk, Vinod Khosla and others [0]. Incidentally, The YC interview with Elon Musk was done the year Musk made a donation to OpenAI (2016),

I still remember PG’s essay where he gave Altman the ultimate character reference (2008) [1]:

>When we predict good outcomes for startups, the qualities that come up in the supporting arguments are toughness, adaptability, determination. Which means to the extent we're correct, those are the qualities you need to win…Sam Altman has it. You could parachute him into an island full of cannibals and come back in 5 years and he'd be the king. If you're Sam Altman, you don't have to be profitable to convey to investors that you'll succeed with or without them.

(In retrospect, praising Altman for being the “king of cannibals” has a nice touch of gallows humor to it. Hilariously, even recently pg has a seemingly unintentional tendency to give Altman compliments that appear to be character warnings masquerading as compliments.)

In 2009, pg included Altman in the top 5 in a list of the most interesting startup founders of the last 30 years.[2] If this was an observation made from afar, you could easily say it was “prescient”. But objectively at the time, no one could find any verifiable evidence in the real world to justify such an assessment. It wasn’t prescient because pg had became directly responsibly for Altman’s future success, in a case of self-fulfilling prophesy. Altman was often referenced in the acknowledgments of pg’s essays for reading early drafts and is probably referenced more than any other founder in the essays. Altman’s entire streetcred came from pg and also, once he made Altman head of YC, YC. From afar, it looks like a victory for office poltics, a skill incidentally that sociopaths are known to excel at.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tnBQmEqBCY0

[1] https://www.paulgraham.com/fundraising.html

[2] https://www.paulgraham.com/5founders.html

bookaway··on Sam Altman's sister files lawsuits against Sam alleging sexual abuse
The OpenAI drama isn't the only reality distortions that Altman has been accused of engaging in. PG himself has said Altman "is extremely good at becoming powerful" [0]. A former Reddit CEO in the past detailed the lengths he was willing to go to get his way[1], in reply to a post called, "What is the longest con you ever pulled", no less. One could say allegedly, but Altman did comment on the former CEO's accusation at the time, and one could also say in his defense that he was being sarcastic in his comment, but it is curious that regardless of whether you take Altman's comment seriously or sarcastically[2] -- in both cases it comes off as a brag that doesn't bother denying the accusation.

I don't know who's right in this case, but parents siding with the more successful and stable siblings doesn't seem too surprising. And if I'm not mistaken, Altman and his sister were both minors at the time, so I don't understand the people who are invested in taking sides. But it does make sense to point out that the parents also have a conflict of interest if something like this happened to two minors under the same roof -- who after all ends up taking the blame (fairly or unfairly) if the minors cannot be blamed?

[0] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/10/10/sam-altmans-ma... (he also said something in tweet form after Altman returned to OpenAI as CEO)

[1] https://old.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/3cs78i/whats_the...

[2] https://old.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/3cs78i/whats_the...

bookaway··on DJ Alfredo, a pioneer of "Balearic Beats", has died
Amnesia set circa 1989

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ULe_PoACvc&pp=ygUXZGogYWxmc...

bookaway··on GPT-5 is behind schedule
Yes, I think they had to push this reveal forward because their investors were getting antsy with the lack of visible progress to justify continuing rising valuations. There is no other reason a confident company making continuous rapid progress would feel the need to reveal a product that 99% of companies worldwide couldn't use at the time of the reveal.

That being said, if OpenAI is burning cash at lightspeed and doesn't have to publicly reveal the revenue they receive from certain government entities, it wouldn't come as a surprise if they let the government play with it early on in exchange for some much needed cash to set on fire.

EDIT: The fact that multiple sites seem to be publishing GPT-5 stories similar to this one leads one to conclude that the o3 benchmark story was meant to counter the negativity from this and other similar articles that are just coming out.

bookaway··on Buying a TV in 2025? Expect lower prices, more ads, and an OS war
With adblockers disabled, I was seeing ads midstream ages ago. Ads that I don't see with an adblocker. Anecdotally, my subjective experience when adblockers are disabled seems to get exponentially worse whereas my adblocker experience seems to degrade at a much slower rate (e.g. manually skipping author recited ads on a podcast). Currently the TV is the weakest link, and people should be publishing layman's guides to pihole, or as others elsewhere have mentioned, refer them to a adblocking DNS redirect from an adblocker company. Midstream ads are especially obnoxious with music streams and I hope the majority's intolerance tips them over the edge.
bookaway··on Review of Mullvad VPN
Yeah, this sort of stuff seems incredibly short-sighted. It gives me queasy "methinks the lady doth protest too much" ExpressVPN vibes.
bookaway··on Canada euthanasia now accounts for nearly one in 20 deaths
I'm sure someone will try to frame it as a Catch 22: "If we knew for sure they would choose suicide if they didn't get the help they requested, we would prioritize them over non-suicidal applicants. But the only way we would know if they would actually choose suicide is if they actually committed to voluntary euthanasia".

...

bookaway··on Ask HN: What are your most regretted tech purchases?
This is hilarious. The Devil's been urging me to buy one of high-end ones for the past year -- I specifically clicked on this post hoping to see someone regretting buying one of these things so I could use it as fuel against my utopian fantasies.
bookaway··on The Impact of Jungle Music in 90s Video Game Development
I asked in response to another comment[0] above somewhere but do you have any recommendations for more recent producers/djs on the ragga jungle sound?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42136943

bookaway··on The Impact of Jungle Music in 90s Video Game Development
I'm looking for the more Ragga heavy melodic dirty sounding jungle a la Krinjah's Return or Hold Yuh remix. Any new people on that sound?
bookaway··on FBI Raids Home of Polymarket CEO Shayne Coplan
Unless my memory is completely off, I don't recall Polymarket giving "Trump will win" vibes in the general lead up to the election. When they did, it was probably in the last few days.

If that's the case, I would've expected to the statement to be something like, "From our understanding, our only crime is to have presented an analysis that the outgoing administration also understood to be valid."

bookaway··on Reflections on Palantir
You should write a book about how a society composed entirely of pure-bred mercenaries outlasted all other competing civilizations on the planet. I'd be very interested in reading it.
bookaway··on Meta fires staff for 'using free meal vouchers to buy household goods'
It's official. There are some perks that are better in relatively "shithole" countries than in Elysium. In that universe, they put allowance money on your food card that is mostly accepted by certain restaurants. But there are a few supermarkets that accept it as well and you're completely free to use the card "wherever it's accepted".

This facebook example by contrast is hilarious bean counting partnering with moronic principles.

And where is the quote from the person that bought toothpaste at the request of a homeless person? I'd like to be in the HR office for that conversation.

bookaway··on MacOS sometimes leaks traffic after system updates
> governments are still vastly less competent than multinational corporations.

Speaking of competence devoid of context misses the point. They are resembling each other greatly in the sense of misaligned incentives with their "users", which supersedes run-of-the-mill competence in terms of importance in this context. I'm not going to give points to some moron who is swimming competently in the wrong direction.

> MNCs also don't force you to pay taxes or buy their products.

An oddly naive comment given all that has been written about how Amazon operates, to give one example.

bookaway··on Filed: WP Engine Inc. v Automattic Inc. and Matthew Charles Mullenweg [pdf]
>Sept 26: WP Engine is banned from Wordpress.org [6] breaking plugin updates from WP Engine

Also someone who is late to the party, but the "breaking plugin updates from WP Engine" wording confuses me. From the wording in [6] it seems like WP Engine was using plugins hosted by wordpress.org, which all broke when wordpress.org blocked WP Engine's access to those plugins. Did I get that right?

bookaway··on Crypto Has Bought the 2024 Election
Where's the citation for the Crypto PACs winning 86% of 42 primaries they funded coming from? Can't seem to find it.
bookaway··on US judge throws out FTC's ban on non-compete agreements
Well, if one party or another thinks the way the current pieces are lying on the board are advantageous to them, I would think it's a reason for them not to fix Congress.
bookaway··on VCs don't care if you're nice, they want founders who take risks
Could the answer be that on average Canadian VCs are simply not rich enough compared to their American counterparts and the few that are succumb to the peer pressure of trying not to be the one schmuck who lost a lot of money?

I've seen the same behavior from freshly minted American millionaires who want to take a swing at this "angel investor" thing due to FOMO.

bookaway··on VCs don't care if you're nice, they want founders who take risks
>It's a self fulfilling prophecy

Funny, when I was trying to formulate a theory in my mind I was thinking of the phrase "vicious cycle". I was close enough, I think:)

I'm wondering if it's because Canadians and other countries with similar environments have been conditioned to exercise a different muscle: getting and retaining public funding. The incentive there is to under-promise and deliver/over-deliver, or at least appear to be delivering or over-delivering on paper. It's like that because the public judges are often much less knowledgeable and are forced to judge you on what you said you were going to do on your initial proposal and you're often times forced to start working before any money is deposited in your bank account.

bookaway··on VCs don't care if you're nice, they want founders who take risks
>I've noticed it's both a very real thing and a very wide spread thing.

Sorry, just to be clear -- is the very real thing the fact that Canadian Funds believe Canadians aren't ambitious enough or is the real thing (in your opinion) that Canadians aren't ambitious enough.

bookaway··on Zero calorie sweetener linked to blood clots and heart disease, study finds
To add to that, they seem to have anticipated the OP's reaction since it was mirrored by the Calorie Control Council (industry cartel?) and are literally saying: if the study is sound and if you are worried about clotting or heart disease you need to watch your intake. This is because they claim the amount that was used was the same amount in common sugar-free sodas.

If the OP is saying their intake is way higher than that and that the only way they can reduce that is to return to their old sugar habit and become clinically obese, then yeah, without additional information I guess it's better to stay on sweeteners. But if you're escaping a burning building and are in danger of getting hit by a car when doing so, the course of action is to avoid getting hit by the car -- not run back into the burning building or wait till the car hits you.

If you live in a place with accessible healthcare (easy access, fast appointments, or cheap, depending on your criteria) you should just keep tabs on your heart at least.

bookaway··on Rising rates of cancer in young people prompts hunt for environmental culprit
>Human excrement is now so toxic it cannot be used as fertilizer.

This sounds fascinating, where can I read more.

bookaway··on Rising rates of cancer in young people prompts hunt for environmental culprit
>10 of the 17 cancer types which are rising in the young cohorts are obesity-related.

This would mean that 40% is non-obesity related which seems...kinda high?

The article has this line:

>Bafflingly, many of the new clinic’s young patients are in good shape, exercise regularly and eat healthily.

Is this supported by the study, or a journalistic observation?

bookaway··on OpenAI co-founder John Schulman says he will leave and join rival Anthropic
Some people are wary of enabling ceos of disruptive technologies become the richest people in the world, take control of key internet assets and -- in random bursts of thin-skinned megalomania -- tilt the scales towards politicians or political groups who take action that negatively affect their own quality of life.

It sounds absurd, but some are watching such a procession take place live as we speak.

bookaway··on OpenAI co-founder John Schulman says he will leave and join rival Anthropic
If being sued by the world's richest billionaire or the whole non-profit thing didn't complicate matters, and if the board had any teeth, one could wish the board would explore a merger with Anthropic with Altman leaving at the end of all of it and save everyone another years worth of drama.
bookaway··on OpenAI co-founder John Schulman says he will leave and join rival Anthropic
For someone who cares deeply about the future of the company, lining up several significant departures temporary or otherwise on the same dates--including your own--seems the opposite of damage control.

I could imagine a parody of the discussion between Altman and the board go something like this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sacn_bCj8tQ

bookaway··on OpenAI co-founder John Schulman says he will leave and join rival Anthropic
Yeah, I was flabbergasted myself at the lack of commotion here when I got to the end of this article and learned of gdb's departure only then.
bookaway··on OpenAI co-founder John Schulman says he will leave and join rival Anthropic
More inclusive title including Greg Brockman and Peter Deng departures:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41166862

bookaway··on Passengers at EU Airports Not Allowed over 100ml of Liquids on Cabin Luggage
Is the tıtle purposely ambiguous for clicks? They obviously mean each liquid bottle has to be max 100 ml, not that the total amount of liquids allowed is 100 ml, right?
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →