HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bradleyjg

18,575 karma · joined December 28, 2011

submissionscomments
bradleyjg··on AI Data Centers Use More Water Than Most Tech Giants Report
You can just not plant anything. It’s not required that every inch of desert is used for irrigated cultivation.

Alfalfa is the cleanest case of a crop that would not be planted nearly as much if western water law (prior appropriation) wasn’t so colossally stupid.

bradleyjg··on AI Data Centers Use More Water Than Most Tech Giants Report
Alfalfa isn’t food.
bradleyjg··on AI Data Centers Use More Water Than Most Tech Giants Report
Radical Luddite posting on the internet is … something.
bradleyjg··on AI Data Centers Use More Water Than Most Tech Giants Report
I don’t really know how to rephrase it. It’s a distraction.

This article could have been about shipping alfalfa to the Middle East and Asia, but instead it was about this.

bradleyjg··on AI Data Centers Use More Water Than Most Tech Giants Report
My point was that google generates hundreds of billions of dollars from the same water that $34 million in alfalfa. It’s absurd to complain about their usage.

Water use policy is about agriculture, agriculture, and also agricultural. Everything else is a distraction.

bradleyjg··on AI Data Centers Use More Water Than Most Tech Giants Report
Google’s just-released 2025 sustainability report is an instructive example. The company said it consumed 10.9 billion gallons of water—a 34% increase from 2024—almost all for data-center cooling.

…

Google consumes around three times as much water indirectly as directly, according to a paper published earlier this year by Alex de Vries-Gao, a researcher at the Netherlands-based university VU Amsterdam.

—

My take: they should report this in acre-feet instead of gallons, and then compare it to a crop, alfalfa for example.

My back of the envelope says even at the larger number Google is using the enough water to grow about 23,000 acres of alfalfa. That would produce about 138,000 tons which would sell for about $34 million.

bradleyjg··on Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown
Yes, that’s where we are today. Colleges definitely can’t avoid fundamentals right now. But at the same time, they should be skating ahead of the puck. Once the calculator has been invented—-even when it’s rare and awkward—-they begin easing off the slide rule reps.
bradleyjg··on Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown
In 2024, we had some coding exams, and AI was explicitly NOT forbidden, which lead to them making the exam more difficult (because with AI, you can solve it so much more quickly, so gotta make it harder), which was really annoying, because it made it practically impossible to solve it yourself because of the time crunch. I hope they realized how wrong that was.

There should be at least one class, probably more, that work exactly like that.

That’s where the industry is moving. Yes, get the fundamentals too, but don’t omit teaching what graduates will actually be doing out of some misplaced sense of purity.

bradleyjg··on Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown
> Imo, the fix should be to work on culture.

We can’t even agree on what’s wrong with it. We aren’t going to be able to fix it.

bradleyjg··on Project Valhalla, Explained: How a Decade of Work Arrives in JDK 28
I definitely see people asking for features from c++. In part because virtually every feature is in c++.
bradleyjg··on The AirPods Effect
I’d say it’s the opposite. We get non enforcement and anti enforcement because lots of people aren’t directly affected.

Different neighborhoods, work from home, private transportation to work, or—admittedly to a lesser degree—AirPod insulation.

If we were really all this together quality of life in our cities would be taken far more seriously.

bradleyjg··on Israeli firm BlackCore suspected of meddling in New York and Scotland votes
That wasn’t anti Protestantism and this isn’t antisemitism.

You should defend Israel and its actions directly on the merits. Why is that so difficult?

bradleyjg··on Israeli firm BlackCore suspected of meddling in New York and Scotland votes
During the Troubles in the 80s was Northern Ireland rilled with anti Protestantism? Just a bunch of people that hated all Protestants for no reason?
bradleyjg··on Israeli firm BlackCore suspected of meddling in New York and Scotland votes
There’s definitely antisemitism out there. Criticizing Israel is not part of it. The people that run to that ever. single. time. ought to be ashamed of themselves for crying wolf. They have no right to abuse the term and rob it of legitimate meaning because they don’t have a good response on the merits.
bradleyjg··on H.R. 6028 would fundamentally change the U.S. Copyright Office
That’s too high a level of generality. Sure police situations where the branches are at direct loggerheads.

But in this case we have a law passed by congress and signed by the president. There’s no need to step in, the ordinary political processes are more than sufficient. If the new President and congress doesn’t like what the last ones did they have the exact same tools at their disposal to undo it.

Let them play!

bradleyjg··on Israeli firm BlackCore suspected of meddling in New York and Scotland votes
No one has ever called me a kike or Christ killer. No one has ever accused me of controlling the media or banks. No one has spray painted a swastika on my house, or my synagogue for that matter.

My nation, the most powerful in the world, puts a menorah in its halls of government every year for Hanukkah. The legislative and judicial branches have Jewish members at the very top level. The head of government has a Jewish son-in-law.

Even online, I see much more pervasive criticism of my nation than yours.

Yet, listen to Zionists and I’m practically living in Weimar Germany. That dog won’t hunt.

People have criticisms of Israel. They may be fair or unfair. Address them on the merits and leave the rest of us out it. It has nothing to do with Jews qua Jews.

bradleyjg··on H.R. 6028 would fundamentally change the U.S. Copyright Office
I don’t think it does. Discretion is fundamentally case by case. Drawing categorical lines is legislative.

It’s akin to the distinction between law and equity courts at common law.

Stepping back, both doctrines (non delegation, unitary executive) are fundamentally about the courts overstepping. If both houses of Congress pass a law creating an agency with a director that can only be fired for cause and the president signs it, the Supreme Court should stay out of it.

Enacting legislation is very difficult, the presumption of constitutionality should be taken more seriously.

bradleyjg··on H.R. 6028 would fundamentally change the U.S. Copyright Office
I suppose in that case you are wholly opposed to the regulatory system as legislative power should be part of the legislative branch?
bradleyjg··on Google to pay SpaceX $920M a month for compute capacity at xAI data centers
I bonds have to be bought from that website but tips can be bought from dealers.
bradleyjg··on Google to pay SpaceX $920M a month for compute capacity at xAI data centers
TIPS are yielding 2.1-2.75% _real_ across the curve from 10 to 30 years out.
bradleyjg··on I'm skeptical about efforts to revolutionize schooling
Strong correlations to actual outcomes. That can be career outcomes or otherwise but actual outcomes people care about. Not test scores.

We have a zillion natural experiments because there are so many schools in the world and within many of them teachers given a lot of leeway.

Does any of it make a damn bit of difference controlling for everything else? We have Waldorf schools teaching woodworking and cram schools shoving AP courses at eighth graders—-that’s a large difference, what do life outcomes show?

bradleyjg··on I'm skeptical about efforts to revolutionize schooling
The study picked an artificial and useless proxy.

What did tutored students go on to do? Were they over represented in Nobel Prizes, hedge fund billionaires, heads of state?

Or did they do well on a meaningless test and then forget all about whatever they “learned” just like everyone else?

The entire field is absolutely littered with this problem. Everyone is targeting cholesterol and not all cause mortality.

bradleyjg··on I'm skeptical about efforts to revolutionize schooling
I had students that I knew were smart that I was forced to fail. They would grasp the subjects quickly when I was speaking, they would ask good questions during class...and then they would simply never study or do the homework I assigned them, and then they would do terrible on tests and I'd be stuck having to give them a bad grade. They were smart students, but they didn't want to be there.

I think you need to go a level up. Forget the people that flunked the class. Did the people that get good grades learn anything? Really? Do you think they still know it?

Was learning the point for anyone or any institution involved?

bradleyjg··on Anthropic confidentially submits draft S-1 to the SEC
The index don’t use the full market cap, they use free float. Except for nasdaq and the Dow which just pick numbers out of the air.

At least at first the spacex free float will be quite modest.

bradleyjg··on I think Anthropic and OpenAI have found product-market fit
> That's a _huge_ shift. Most people I know cite +20%-40% velocity with these tools, against the actual work their company cares about doing.

We all have our own observations and mine don’t significantly diverge. But that’s bottom up. At this point shouldn’t we be seeing it top down?

If we are beyond potential and into significant productivity gains, why isn’t that showing up for the customers?

Why didn’t delta airlines get significantly more operationally efficient in the last 3 months due to the introduction of better software?

This is a genuine question, I am seeing a disconnect.

bradleyjg··on The real cost of owning a home
> Not easy I'm sure,

Can confirm it’s not easy. If you want to describe a method of finding one, I’m all ears.

bradleyjg··on Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them
I’m definitely aware they have bells. Evidence for breaks is much thinner on the ground.
bradleyjg··on Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them
And then bicyclists will hit the people crossing to the side walk.
bradleyjg··on Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them
Great, now how are we going to force bicyclists to open red lights and stop signs?
bradleyjg··on The West forgot how to make things, now it’s forgetting how to code
That's because it requires less skill! Critiquing something is always easier than doing it.

No, it was always the other way around. Mediocre programmers always wanted to rewrite everything because reading and understanding an existing codebase was always harder than writing some greenfield thing with a “modern language” or “modern libraries” or “modern idioms.” So they’d go and do that and end up with 100x the bugs.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →