HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

braiamp

1,429 karma · joined August 29, 2023

submissionscomments
braiamp··on Understanding the recent DDoS attack against Read the Docs
> Most of their docs hosting is static/easily CDN cached

The article says

> and it purposefully attacked areas that bypassed caching

So that doesn't work. Also, it seems that they were trying to cause financial harm, not to take down the infrastructure but to make it costly for the org itself. That's smart.

braiamp··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
What if you keep the protections that actually benefit you, but doesn't restrict your clients? ie. if you keep the exclusive combined right to distribute reproduced works, but not to distribute (you already sold a copy) or reproduce (after you sold a copy it doesn't matter what happens with that copy).
braiamp··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
You don't need to abolish copyright, you just have to limit the scope to the economic mechanism that actually matter for authors: reproduction and distribution of the reproduced works. Removing all of copyright except that combined right will still give authors the ability to license under the terms they find reasonable and viable, without harming any of the consumer abilities that we've come to expect.
braiamp··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
It wouldn't have mattered how long copyright is if it wasn't expanded beyond the immediate economic desincentives that it is supposed to address for the most insidious problems it causes. It should be been limited exclusively to the combined right to reproduction and distribution. Yes, that means that I could reproduce the protected work without limit, so long as don't distribute it. Also means that I could distribute the protected work so long as I do only the copies I acquired.

I, like you, through for a while that length was the problem, now I've poked around enough and known about enough actual examples where shorter length wouldn't have prevented the problems that happens with copyright. The content Sony had repeatedly removed from people's libraries was well within copyright term, shorter copyright wouldn't have saved it. What would have saved it is copyright scope that never extended to controlling access to copies already sold

braiamp··on Fileregister: Tagging and reference layer for your files, in plain text
I wanted something like this for a org, but I wanted it to be integrated with the OS/file browser. Windows 7 had some tagging, which is the flat structure you need for that, but never got the buy in from management to use it (they preferred a strict tree folder structure), so this seems cool but I want to see it integrated into something else, maybe a library?
braiamp··on How to Create a Tor Exit Node (2015)
Wow....

> I’ll go with Ubuntu 14.04 (Trusty)

This is extremely old. I am aware that the Tor project tries to keeps their defaults sane for any use, but someone has checked that the configuration here is still valid for this use?

Also, running tor as a root is bad idea, I don't think the client allows you to anymore (or at least warns you)

braiamp··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
Ok, I was thinking that probably they were saying that he was accidentally right, but missed the timing. It's not that. It isn't that he was accidentally right in a certain scenario also. It's that "I reinterpret the prediction to make it fit my own vision of the world"... that's not how prediction works. Hell that's not how anything would work.

Here's an actual prediction I made about a year ago: LLMs have to demonstrate that they make productivity gains that explain the costs or economics will make this problem solve itself, via higher energy cost and loss of business/productivity.

That prediction is unbound in the time horizon but it's bound by conditions that explain the triggers and how they will behave. Such prediction is useful. Hell, I could even make a prediction on why the timeline can't be bound while making a prediction on the timeline: I predict that in the next 3-5 years this will have to solve itself, because there's a limit on how much money irrational actors can pour onto something that have limited value. 7-10 years is way too much. I at least hope their coffers are that deep... if this drags on long enough, at some point people are going to want a change

braiamp··on Python's pre-declared constants are kinda weird
> No more shell scripts, or TS/JS/PHP backend services

You didn't use Perl before? https://xkcd.com/353/

braiamp··on New EU-wide product repair rules come into force
Just look at anything that require certification and prohibit modification, PCI endpoints, FIPS, fuel pumps, aviation, medical software, gambling machines... most of those are outlawed because the law made it prohibitively expensive or cumbersome for someone to make an alternative even if the implementation is known
braiamp··on New EU-wide product repair rules come into force
This comment implies that we have options... we do not have options. Hell, there are places where such options are actually outlawed!
braiamp··on MartyPC is a cross-platform emulator of early PCs written in Rust
But if it's written in rust and with llm then they both implode and we get really insightful comments
braiamp··on I gave Qwen 3.8 27B a reverse-engineering job and it finished in 30 minutes
Well, it seems that Linus doesn't use those:

> And this was a debug session from hell, enormously helped by an AI doing much of the grunt-work.

> I'd like to call it my tireless helper, but the AI several times stated flat out that this was impossible and unsolvable and that we should just write a report about it.

> I suspect those things have been trained by people who may not be quite as stubborn as I am.

https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/lin...

braiamp··on Felony charges for citizen deleting phone data at US Border
I am baffled that the number of comments trying to work around a problem that shouldn't exists is above zero. No, this crap shouldn't happen. It's an appalling situation that it is happening at all.
braiamp··on Fairphone is now officially available in the United States
Because you need to show something that executives can parse and people that only want to eat slop writing to read. People literally took marketing material as gospel before. They still do now.
braiamp··on Show HN: Mic Drop, a real-time multiplayer karaoke game
> We use Ai to detect offensive material being uploaded to use as stage backgrounds and facemasks. Ai is also used to flag offensive room names and descriptions. Use of AI art is used in some marketing material for the steam page and announcements

They don't??? Did you buy the game?

braiamp··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
By making the thing that is unsafe to use safe to use?
braiamp··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
I've had the pleasure of working in work safety, kids safety and food safety, so I'm familiar with concepts such as "safe to use", "safe to consume", "safe by design". That's why harm tolerance is in the "it's unnecessary and it's avoidable" territory, as we know how and why it's causing harm in these products
braiamp··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
What? Nobody is asking someone to collect more information, in fact the solution is to collect even less information. How can you survey if you collect less?
braiamp··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
Since I can't edit the top post, a response to all of the above: the solution is platforms with sane defaults. Honest by default. No content discovery unless you go looking for it. The feed shows what you chose to follow, in order and stops there. The platform behaves how you configured it, not how it's most profitable for them. Right now the default is whatever keeps you on longest, that's the only thing that needs to change
braiamp··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
What are you talking about? I'm against that. I'm saying to remake Facebook so that you don't have the cesspool anymore. Did you read the post?
braiamp··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
Why does your "better solution" shift responsibility from the people who built the unsafe environment to the parents? A platform labeling itself 18+ doesn't make it safe, it just moves the blame. Adult content isn't where the supposed "harms" we are trying to protect children from are coming from. They're from how the platform is designed to keep people on it. That's fixable. Infinite scroll, algorithmic radicalization, engagement mechanics, etc. None of that requires an age label, it requires a different product. I want every platform to be safe no matter who uses them and a warning sticker on the door is not a substitute for that. We don't allow arsenic in bread just because people got used to eating it
braiamp··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
So social networks dont benefit from radicalizing people? Abusing their own human nature against them? Thats your argument, really?
braiamp··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
Nobody mentioned speech. Infinite scroll isn't speech. Engagement-maximizing algorithms that push increasingly extreme content to keep you on the app longer ain't speech. The business model that makes outrage more profitable than accuracy isn't speech. You can have complete freedom of expression and still regulate that a platform isn't designed to psychologically exploit the people using it. These are not the same thing
braiamp··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
> The problem is that any age verification system effectively becomes an identity verification system. And such tools rarely remain "just for kids"—they quickly become used for other purposes. The only secure way is to verify not the person's identity, but the device's status (for example, that it's a children's device). This is called age assurance: we confirm age without knowing who exactly is in front of us.

Age assurance is still treating the symptom. If the platform is designed to addict and radicalize, a children's device getting in doesn't help the child, it just means the harmful design now has a younger victim. The only fix that actually works is making the platform safe for everyone, which means regulating what these services are allowed to do to users in the first place, not building better gates around them.

braiamp··on Don't classify, hallucinate
Because that's structured data and structured data is usually hidden away from users _and_ machines. Product rarely want to be honest, unless it's B2B in a very competitive market (and even then!). So, yeah, it's not that they are bad, it's that there are few good sources of information.

(Lets ignore for now that no one seems to agree to what should be the spec sheets)

braiamp··on The UK's War on Anonymity Has Come to America
I clicked flag, then clicked to unflag. Nothing changed
braiamp··on Stop Killing Games: It's time to sue Sony, join us
So you agree that consumers mostly see the sticker price and don't think much about the quality of the product, therefore there must be protections ensuring that the product is at least fit for purpose.
braiamp··on Stop Killing Games: It's time to sue Sony, join us
What the heck are you talking about? Both Apple and Google were hit by the EU anti-gatekeeping law. I am not going to engage with the rest since it's based on a supposition that is plainly wrong.
braiamp··on Stop Killing Games: It's time to sue Sony, join us
Nobody is questioning consumer behavior, consumers would buy bread with sawdust if it was cheaper, they don't because we have standards to protect consumers that makes it illegal to sell it. This is the same principle but with a more subtle harm.
braiamp··on Stop Killing Games: It's time to sue Sony, join us
I don't know how the specifics would work, but if they reversed course immediately, they would have still caused some harm to some consumers during a specific amount of time.
← PreviousPage 4 of 19Next →