HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

breischl

1,890 karma · joined May 18, 2012

submissionscomments
breischl··on Salt and salary: Were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017)
Tangentially, this makes me think about how much recently-introduced slang is for basically-random reasons like "it happened fit well into the rhyme and meter of a popular song" or "somebody attractive/famous said it" or "it sounds cool and kids' parents hate it".

Maybe there's a good reason for the bacon thing, or maybe some guy just tended to buy bacon on payday. /shrug

breischl··on In 2024, please switch to Firefox
I was using it, though I _think_ it was causing intermittent hangs and crashes on my Win 11 machine. It's hard to be sure, because it was so hard to repro, and could've been due to something else just interacting with FF badly. But it seems like Brave doesn't have the problem.

Which is a shame, I'd like to use FF, and still do on other machines.

breischl··on You can't do that because I hate you
The problem is that all the "do what I mean" examples become part of the spec, and then have to be supported forever. Whereas "prints an extra-informative error" is much easier to change.

Even for low hanging fruit. eg, `exit` in Python can be redefined as a variable - so if I do that and then type `exit`, should it print that value for me or quit the REPL? Is it better to guess, or just not encourage the user to do the wrong thing?

If I make `-?` print help, what happens when I want to define `-` as "read the following text as input" and then users start getting bizarre behavior instead of the help file?

You can probably come up with ever-fancier ways to work around this, but that takes effort, and more testing, and more code...

breischl··on Desalination can beat batteries for excess energy
Sorry I stated my original point poorly, and it wasn't exactly what you were saying. My bad.

Demand response for A/C tends to look more like pre-cooling before the hottest hours, then reduce demand during the hottest hours. So it's not about shifting demand towards maximum production, but rather shifting demand away from the demand peak (aka, peak shaving). So it's similar but a little different.

>Practically I don't think the utility companies are going to cut them in on a big enough part of the profits to incentivize them to do so.

The commercial version of what I stated in the previous paragraph (ie, demand response/peak shaving) empirically already happens, and has non-trivial dollars attached to it. Again, maybe not exactly what you're talking about, but it rhymes.

breischl··on Desalination can beat batteries for excess energy
This seems like a special case of the general concept that matching electricity demand to supply is important, and whereas a fossil fueled grid has enough dispatchable power sources to match supply to demand, a renewable-powered grid has to instead match demand to supply (at least to a much greater degree).

So it's interesting, although at some point it seems unnecessary to enumerate that this same concept applies to every possible source of electricity demand.

breischl··on Desalination can beat batteries for excess energy
>we might be able to even do this for air-conditioning, washing machines, or car-charging (if you have a PHEV or EV).

No _might_ about it, this currently happens for A/C, and is just getting going for car charging (see EV Managed Charging as a category).

Also some functions of commercial/industrial facilities that can be ramped more easily, eg shut off half of the hallway lighting in an office building. I think I recall things like rock crushers being turned off, but I might be misremembering that.

breischl··on Tacit Knowledge Is Dangerous
I know many people love video, but I personally think this is only slightly better than not recording it anywhere. Video is much harder to search and nearly impossible to skim, so it's difficult to use for anything other than a classroom-style "let's sit down and learn" session.

Most often I'm looking for some particular piece of information. Finding a video that _may_ contain the answer _somewhere_ in the hour (or whatever) of information just means now I have to decide on the likelihood that it'll be worth trying to watch.

Yes, some things are better explained in video format. But not very many, especially in knowledge work.

ETA: Also video is much harder to update as the situation changes. For the most part you just need to re-record the whole thing, which probably isn't going to happen.

breischl··on Firefox on the brink?
It is my default, but keep a Brave install around just for the ability to "fake" a site into being an app. ie, it gets a separate launcher shortcut, a separate icon, etc. Very useful for sites I use constantly so they're not trapped in the same window as random surfing.
breischl··on Floating solar power array on hydropower plant
>big lakes are used for recreational boating

This is a great point. Many of those reservoirs included recreation benefits in the accounting that led to them being funded in the first place, so it may not be trivial to impinge on them.

>in the west, putting these in water might not make so much sense.

OTOH, evaporation is also a big problem there (roughly a couple million acre-feet/year in the Colorado drainage, from memory) so mitigating that would be beneficial.

breischl··on Wealth Systems in RPGs
>having thieves steal their money if they got too rich

Money attracts that kind of thing, even in the real world. There's a reason rich people have guards. Also bodyguards - I was just listening to a podcast about how a fairly rich (and flashy) drug dealer got kidnapped and ransomed because he didn't think about what a target he was. Obviously more challenging when you're talking about heroes who are personally formidable, but think about friends, family members, retainers, etc.

breischl··on Launch HN: Stralis (YC W23) – Hydrogen electric aircraft for medium-haul travel
News articles frequently say that lack of aircrew availability is a major cost and constraint for air travel currently. Wouldn't moving to smaller aircraft exacerbate that issue? Or do you think it won't be a problem?
breischl··on Working remotely can more than halve an office employee’s carbon footprint
>aimlessly wandering/engaging people looks like productive work.

Indeed, even though it might actually be _negative_ work, if one of those people would have otherwise been productive. Which was one of my major gripes with being in the office.

breischl··on Bike Lane Sweepers (2021)
As a cyclist that sounds great, but don't the plows for the roadway then push snow back onto the bike lanes? That would happen with the designs I'm familiar with but maybe they have a different layout or something.
breischl··on Don't fire your illustrator
I'm not in illustration, but isn't it already common to hire someone to create a "style book" of what it should look like, and then have other illustrators follow that? eg, I recall animated shows working that way.

Doesn't seem so incredibly different from that.

breischl··on Ask vs. Guess Culture
That solution is a bit like the game theory solution of "I cut, you choose". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divide_and_choose
breischl··on Remote work requires communicating more, but less frequently
"Looking over your shoulder" was just a figure of speech, not a literal description. And I suppose I could have grabbed the keyboard, but there's social niceties to navigate, everyone likes their keyboard & IDE set up different ways, and it's generally a PITA.

Also the way I tend to code is never linear in a way that anybody else could follow. I write something, edit it, throw it away, put it back, rename it, hack out something I _know_ is buggy so I can see how it looks, and basically "thrash" my way to a solution that I like. That makes it essentially impossible for anybody to follow in real time, and having them try to point out errors would be counterproductive. In the later stages someone could help polish it, but even then I think it'd mostly be a waste of time.

That's before we even get to things like dealing with interruptions, or answering other questions quickly. Ideally interruptions don't happen, but in practice they do, and I don't want to be wasting someone else's time.

There's a lot I liked about XP, but I still think that (for some people) it's just a great way to make two devs produce the output of one intern.

breischl··on Remote work requires communicating more, but less frequently
I think it can work great for some people. I did it for a few weeks at one point, and found it thoroughly unproductive. 90% of my time was spent waiting for somebody else to type something, or trying to verbally communicate something that would be better done in writing/code.

Even now I find it incredibly off-putting to have somebody looking over my shoulder when I'm trying to work, to the point that I basically just can't. People have asked to watch me do something, and my response is that you can either watch me, or I can do it, but not both. It's like Heisenberg Uncertainty for work output.

breischl··on PRQL: Pipelined Relational Query Language
I was not trolling, I actually dislike MongoDB aggregation syntax and it seems like PRQL is something that could potentially replace it or go on top. Admittedly I only took a quick glance at PRQL though, so perhaps I misunderstood something or it's not applicable to this case.

There are examples on Mongo's page, eg https://www.mongodb.com/docs/manual/core/aggregation-pipelin...

eg:

  db.orders.aggregate( [
   // Stage 1: Filter pizza order documents by pizza size
   {
      $match: { size: "medium" }
   },
   // Stage 2: Group remaining documents by pizza name and calculate total quantity
   {
      $group: { _id: "$name", totalQuantity: { $sum: "$quantity" } }
   }
  ] )
breischl··on PRQL: Pipelined Relational Query Language
Having spent more time in MongoDB aggregations than I'd like to lately, I really wish they'd support this. So much more sensible than the madness they've got going on.
breischl··on A surprisingly simple way to foil car thieves
I've come pretty close to keying "FIX YOUR ALARM" into people's doors for this. In the end left them notes about it, which did result in it getting fixed, so I haven't had to actually do it. Someday, though.

I still think car alarms are a net negative to society. Thousands of hours of disrupted sleep and it prevents approximately no thefts.

breischl··on The rule says, “No vehicles in the park”
>Speeding is mostly enforced everywhere.

I disagree. Everyone I've talked to in the US considers 5 mph over the limit to be perfectly safe from tickets (enforcement), and 10 mph over to probably be safe from enforcement. The few times I've heard of people getting ticketed for 5 mph over the limit they were outraged at the injustice of it, and most people agreed with them.

Speeding is mostly enforced if you're 10+ over the speed limit, or driving a heavy vehicle.

breischl··on The Pentagon’s $52k trash can
They go into airplanes, not the Pentagon, which is right at the beginning of TFA.

So they are probably weirdly shaped.

breischl··on Rivian embraces Tesla's charging standard for EVs
They all need to agree how it's done though. And gas cars were the same - did you think the size and shape of the gas pump nozzle were handed down from God or something? Everyone had to agree on that at some point. Apparently that was in 1930, or around 30 years after cars were invented. https://www.cspdailynews.com/csp-magazine/industry-views-all...

We are at that point right now. That is the process happening in front of us. Eventually it will all be settled enough that nobody will have to check that devices work with each other, but we aren't there yet.

breischl··on Dating, education, and sex ratios
The problem is the "future" part. It's hard to sell "I'll be great someday!" especially in a dating profile or anything like that, and particularly since people lie a lot in such situations (the infamous "foreploy").

To be fair, it would also be hard to sell "someday I will have a ton of cash to waste on flashy spending."

But you can have hobbies and work/life balance now, and that can be attractive, albeit in a quieter way.

breischl··on Dating, education, and sex ratios
You attract what you advertise for.

If you're advertising flashy, high-spending lifestyle, that's who you'll attract. But the women who are looking for long-term stability will stay away. And vice versa.

Of course, if you want the not-high-spending women, you need to have something other than money and flashy lifestyle to offer. I think some guys get hung up there.

breischl··on Could we stop Yellowstone from erupting with a giant geothermal power plant?
Fair, but the sandstone and clay in that area is generally pretty awful. TBH most of the ancestral Puebloan structure are crumbling apart despite being protected by overhanging rock "roofs".
breischl··on Could we stop Yellowstone from erupting with a giant geothermal power plant?
In those conditions even plain, untreated wood lasts a long time. Many of those structures still have wood beams in pretty good condition.

ie, the durability of those structures is more due to where they are, than what they are made of.

breischl··on CATL has announced a new “condensed” battery with 500 Wh/kg
Sibling comment is a good point. Also there are lots of other battery chemistries available that use less, or no, lithium. Or approaches burning hydrogen, or ammonia, or methane.

More broadly, this is a class of complaint that you can't see every detail of path and the destination from the very beginning of the road. The solution to that isn't to stand around and complain about it, but _start moving towards the destination_.

breischl··on CATL has announced a new “condensed” battery with 500 Wh/kg
You didn't cite sources for the critical pieces of that (the first three numbers). You also assumed that the battery is 100% lithium, which is obviously wrong. A random Googling says closer to 62kg. And now I'm tired of bothering to fact check you.

I'm also going to say that all the car companies, battery companies, and governments in the world probably took six seconds to do basic math before investing trillions of dollars in it.

https://blog.evbox.com/ev-battery-weight

breischl··on Semaphore: A Full-Body Keyboard

  command: lift left leg to ~horizontal thigh
  control: lift right leg to ~horizontal thigh
So command+control => midair splits?
← PreviousPage 2 of 20Next →