HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

breischl

1,890 karma · joined May 18, 2012

submissionscomments
breischl··on SQL Maxis: Why We Ditched RabbitMQ and Replaced It with a Postgres Queue
On a quick read this seems like another name for Change Data Capture. In general the pattern works better if you can integrate it with the database's transaction log, so then you can't accidentally forget to publish something.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Change_data_capture

breischl··on I fixed a parasitic drain on my car in 408 days
I once spent over a year debugging a furnace. It would run fine, except every now and then on it would just refuse to turn on for a day or two. Eventually noticed it was only rainy days, and was due to it thinking the exhaust was blocked because there wasn't enough pressure differential between input air and exhaust.

Turned out the installer had failed to put in the high altitude kit which told it to expect a smaller pressure differential. Mostly it was fine, but on rainy days with low barometric pressure, the difference would drop below threshold. But I had to be home for enough rainy days to figure it out.

breischl··on Airbnb nightly rates shot up 36% in 3 years
Even if the Google Hotel Search feature fixed it, it doesn't help for other search results, or if people just run a quick search on each site and notice the prices are much higher on one than on the other.

At one point we were sending prices to GHS, which I think were all-in. But it was a fraught relationship, which I think ended. Google was trying to take a huge cut of the fees, while offloading the hard work of managing travelers, owners, payments, complaints, etc to us. It didn't make sense to help them eat our lunch.

breischl··on Airbnb nightly rates shot up 36% in 3 years
> Hosts want to show lower prices, so in search you don't see all the fees, but then when you get all the way down the funnel you finally see these completely ridiculous fees (usually around cleaning) of what you'll actual pay.

This is 100% true. Hosts figured this out pretty fast and leaned into it. The biggest reason is that showing a cheap price on the initial search result page was very effective at getting bookings. I suspect this is even more effective in this case vs some others because rentals are not easily comparable. ie, travelers invest non-trivial time into researching a place (looking at pictures, location, description, etc) to decide that it works for them before they notice the higher price - and then don't want to throw away that "sunk cost" of their time.

>I don't understand why Airbnb is still on the side of hosts with this.

Everything I said up there also works at the level of Google search results. If just one vendor (ABnB, Vrbo, etc) switches to up-front pricing, then all their competitors look _much_ cheaper at first glance. And once the traveler is on their site, it's unlikely that they'll back out and go to a different one. The whole industry is basically in a "Mexican standoff" situation. Or maybe Prisoner's Dilemma if you prefer.

Also, the platforms are perfectly capable of doing all-in-one pricing, because they legally have to everywhere other than the US. There's loooots of extra logic to handle doing it two different ways. At some level they'd love to get rid of that complexity, but just can't for reasons mentioned.

source: worked on pricing at Vrbo for eight years.

breischl··on Perovskite-Based Thermochromic Windows Reduce Load and CO2 Emission in Buildings
You can do something similar with an appropriately sized & angled awning/overhang. eg the visitor center at Zion NP does that, along with a number of other clever things. PDF: https://www.nps.gov/zion/learn/nature/upload/DOE%20Brochure....

But for commercial buildings where they're trying to squeeze out every square foot of rentable space, and probably are not allowed to overhang their property lines, it's likely not an option.

breischl··on My bad habit of hoarding information
I think I do something similar, though on reflection I read things almost as a distraction. Like, I should be working on something useful, and instead I'm reading about the internals of a change to a language I don't even use. It's _interesting_, but usually not _useful_. It's just information porn - to me anyway, it's probably very useful to some other people.

I partially alleviated this by requiring myself to summarize the useful bits from any article I read into a note. The point being that if there's not enough value in the article to make that worthwhile, then there's no point even reading it and I'm just wasting time. And if there is value in it, then forcing myself to summarize that is going to make it more likely that I'll remember it.

I'm not 100% consistent on doing this, but it does help break me out of "information grazing".

breischl··on Fire Them All; God Will Know His Own
To be fair, this article is by a Harvard student, in a Harvard paper. It's very much relevant in that context.

But fair to ask why everyone on HN (including the two of us...) are reading and talking about it.

breischl··on Ask HN: How innovative is the hydrogen industry?
Just looking at energy storage/transmission, the experts I've heard that aren't clearly pushing hydrogen seem to think that it's going to be mostly a niche product.

Might be used for aircraft, ocean shipping, and other places where batteries don't have the requisite energy density and the refueling infrastructure can be installed in a limited number of places (ie, not for passenger vehicles).

Might be used for seasonal energy storage. Although there are relatively few places (salt caverns) in which to store it. Interestingly the same study concluded that natural gas + carbon capture is the next most economically feasible option. https://environment-review.yale.edu/power-127-hours-economic...

Might be stored in an easier-to-handle form - eg make hydrogen, turn it into ammonia, and store that. Of course that lowers the round-trip efficiency even more.

Some utilities have talked about injecting 5-10% hydrogen into the existing natural gas infrastructure to partially de-carbonize domestic heating.

breischl··on <i>: The Idiomatic Text element
Make A Really Quite Unreadable Eyesore, Eh?
breischl··on Meta lays off 11,000 people
In general you're probably right. Though once upon a time I tried to volunteer about three different times and never managed to get a package. At one point my manager literally said "Shut up, you're not getting laid off so quit asking!"
breischl··on Dragon’s teeth – Stopping tanks in their tracks
But... a tank _is an_ AFV. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armoured_fighting_vehicle

You may have meant an IFV, and in some cases those work. But that's like saying that a rifle and a machine gun both shoot bullets, so why would you want a machine gun?

breischl··on Dragon’s teeth – Stopping tanks in their tracks
But when the line was conceived and built, they couldn't have known Germany would invade Poland first.
breischl··on A sand battery could transform clean energy
Interesting point about the economics of Energy Vault. I had not actually done the math before. $80 seems low for current prices but it's about the right order of magnitude. OTOH there is at least one project being built to store 100 MWh, and they have a bunch of investors for millions of dollars. That's a bunch of smart people who surely did at least 5 minutes of math to validate the idea, which makes me wonder what they saw that's missing from this analysis. It's possible it's all just a big scam, but strikes me as unlikely.

Also, doesn't thermal storage have the same problem with long-term storage of energy not producing a lot of revenue? Perhaps the capital investment is lower, but the yearly income would be order-of-magnitude the same.

I was pretty much agreeing with you about thermal being the cheap option, but thanks for the breakout.

Do you know of any examples of 10 GWh thermal storage? Just curious, I haven't really poked into that area too much.

breischl··on A sand battery could transform clean energy
Indeed! But getting ~80% back from batteries or pumped hydro looks even better[1]. Or, the ~90% that EnergyVault claims[2].

I'm very much pro-renewables and pro-storage, but that doesn't mean that all forms of storage are equal. This one has certain advantages (cheap, simple, tough), but the roundtrip efficiency kinda sucks compared to some other options.

And I'm guessing (without checking) that the 30% is for short-term storage (eg, overnight). In which it will drop over time, as the battery inevitably leaks heat into the environment. I'd guess that after 6 months (summer to winter, as you mentioned) it will lose a non-trivial amount of energy so the efficiency will be even lower.

[1] - Actual rates from deployed systems from the EIA: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=46756

[2] - https://www.energyvault.com/newsroom/energy-vault-announces-...

breischl··on A sand battery could transform clean energy
I'd say the marketing on at least this article is more geared at the electric energy. Heat is a form of energy for sure, but not a big enough one that it could "transform clean energy".

Nuclear can be ramped, but typically is not. I haven't dug into why, but I get the impression it's partially economic - the plants are very expensive to build and the marginal cost of a few hours of fuel is so low that they prefer to just run all the damn time. I think there may be some technical reasons as well. In general if you look at how utilities operate, they will ramp down literally everything else before the nuclear plants.

That probably applies less to the Small Modular Reactors people keep talking about, but those are still not really a factor.

breischl··on A sand battery could transform clean energy
It's a cool idea. The big advantage might be in being cheap, simple, and non-toxic, so that it can be easily deployed in less-prosperous areas and with less expertise. It seems probably even simpler than the "concrete stacking battery" whose name I forget. But...

>with currently available technology the process of converting heat back into electricity only has an efficiency rate of 30%

Yes they're recovering heat as well, which is great when it works. But in general 30% is not great. This probably only makes sense to use when you have huge amounts of nearly-free power. Like if you massively overbuilt solar/wind (which could be a plausible thing to do!) or nuclear.

breischl··on Ask HN: Why does the media say inflation is up every month?
I think you touched on it in your last sentence. It's not actually innumeracy, it's an example of "lying with statistics" to get attention and/or push an agenda (depending on the source).

Tangentially, thanks for bringing this up. I've personally been vaguely aware of all the "inflation is high!!!!!!" articles and hadn't dug in enough to see the reality prior to this post.

breischl··on An Australian startup is “growing” water for California
>Where are the prices coming from?

Ironically water prices are largely set by government bodies that created water projects (eg, Bureau of Reclamation which made most of the huge dams in the west, various California water boards). Much of it was knowingly, intentionally priced below the cost to deliver it for various political reasons. If you want to read an in-depth account of that, I suggest "Cadillac Desert".

>"capitalism isn't the issue"

In this case, it's _at most_ part of the problem. Government policies delivered artificially cheap water. Capitalism responded to that incentive. Of course people then fight to maintain those policies, so in that sense one could blame capitalism.

>This analysis is so shallow it's practically Libertarian.

Said the guy who has done no actual analysis, and instead just asked questions. I think we've reached a second peak of HN here.

breischl··on Ask HN: Have you experienced “hiring fraud?”
Interesting parallel. I think I'd disagree that it's considered "fine" when company's do it, though.

What the OP describes is basically a version of a "bait and switch" fraud, which is pretty widely illegal and not considered OK by anyone. Although you can find examples where people ride that line pretty closely[1], but even then people think it's bad behavior.

A subtly different thing that's maybe closer to what you're talking about is hiring contractors and then blaming them for problems. A current major example being many of the Amazon-branded delivery trucks that only deliver for Amazon, but when they do something wrong "oh they're a subcontractor, not Amazon's fault!"

So, not sure I agree 100%, but I understand the anger.

[1] For example, this guy that found name-brand USB-C hubs had the same "guts" as cut-rate crap. https://overengineer.dev/blog/2021/04/25/usb-c-hub-madness.h...

breischl··on Ask HN: Have you experienced “hiring fraud?”
>Second, we ask that candidates bring an example of projects they've worked on, starting with ones they led.

Just curious what kind of "example" you'd expect someone to bring? Surely not code samples, since most people will not be legally allowed to show you code from their previous employer.

The way I've done this before is to have them talk you through what they did and why, with some questions probing at an appropriate level of detail. But that's not exactly "bring[ing] an example".

breischl··on Senior engineers are living in the future
>The rest of the world only cares about what your code does once it's compiled.

People in your company (including non-engineers) definitely care, because code quality bears on how easy it is to debug problems and how easy it is to implement new features or fixes (or sometimes if a feature is even practicable).

breischl··on Want quick answers? Ask questions well
I could see that happening. My experience is mostly with the awful ones for big companies. The kind that are basically like a 1990's era text adventure game where there's only like 6 things you can possibly do, but instead of listing them out they make you guess the exact right phrasing. It's like they figured out the only possible way to make a phone tree even worse than it already was.
breischl··on Want quick answers? Ask questions well
Some people cannot be bothered to (or are incapable of) finding information unless it is spoon-fed to them at the exact time and rate they require. I think this might be the valid use case for support chatbots, even though I personally despise them.

Ex: I was selling an item on Facebook Marketplace. The price of the item is in the item header, and in the item description. Multiple people started a chat with me - opening a chat window that has the price again in the chat header - to ask me what it costs. I don't know what you do about that other than have a bot spoon-feed them that information.

breischl··on Web scraping is legal, US appeals court reaffirms
As another example, I used to work on a site that was roughly hotel stays. A regular person might search where to stay in small set of areas, dates and usually the same number of people.

Bots would routinely try to scrape pricing for every combination of {property, arrival_date, departure_date, num_guests} in the next several years. The load to serve this would have been vastly higher than real customers, but our frontend was mostly pretty good at filtering them out.

We also served some legitimate partners that wanted basically the same thing via an API... and the load was in fact enormous. But at least then it was a real partner with some kind of business case that would ultimately benefit us, and we could make some attempt to be smart about what they asked for.

breischl··on When you get locked out of your Google account, what do you do? (2021)
I assumed that she meant "elusive", but it could also be "illusive" in the sense that it's merely an illusion. :P
breischl··on The Perils of RSS
Oh man, the perils are endless. Back when I worked on an RSS aggregator I wrote a list. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1cvq67iQpk2C7ufOsefsfKnGC...

A few comments on your list:

2. People got suuuuuper confused about this. I agree several kB is too long, though I could see a case for allowing a (reasonable length) URL, as that's a natural ID in some environments.

3. Yeah, basically if there's a fast rate of publishing relative to feed length you have issues. Another way to handle this would be to say the feed must have the last X days of content, and interested readers have to check back at least that often. Not a problem for always-on aggregator sites, though it could be an issue for occasionally-connected clients (eg, smartphone standalone app)

4. To be fair that's a feature in a lot of cases. Some sites have to monetize content somehow or other.

5. Or share buttons...

6. IKR?! For all my complaints I still wish RSS was used more!

breischl··on The Perils of RSS
Try enabling Simple List Extensions[1] on your RSS feed and see if that deletes the old items. Basically this tells the feed reader that your feed isn't a typical "stream of posts", it's a finite list. So it should be treated differently.

Newsgator used to handle that by deleting any posts not in your feed at every retrieval. So maybe Feedly would too.

If you think that guessing at the internal implementation of Feedly's code based on what a company that's been dead for years used to do sounds like a long shot, then bravo. But hey, it's worth a try, right?

It's been a minute, but I think the gist of it is adding

  xmlns:cf="https://www.microsoft.com/schemas/rss/core/2005"
to your <rss> root element, and

  <cf:treatAs>list</cf:treatAs>
under the <channel>. But see the link for examples. Good luck! [1] - https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/previous-versions/windows/d...
breischl··on I Miss RSS
>If RSS feeds contain both the article and the content, then there's both little incentive for the user to actually visit the site and no analytics for the author to understand which articles are popular. When authors put summaries in their feeds with links to the original article, they degrade the experience for the reader.

Yeah, this is definitely a problem. FWIW, Ars Technica solved that by giving you full-text fees only if you pay for a subscription, which seems like a nice approach that more places could hypothetically use.

breischl··on I Miss RSS
>Every user's RSS reader polling every website for changes every few minutes for all eternity is horribly inefficient and unfeasible to do on most platforms and devices today.

1) It's not that inefficient, especially if you recalculate your feed only when it changes and use HTTP statuses (particularly 304 Not Modified) correctly.

2) Most people then and now would go through an aggregator. So they'd really be talking to that instead of the source feed.

3) There were push notification standards out well over a decade ago, including RSSCloud and PubSubHubBub.

breischl··on A not so gentle intro to web3
FWIW, my impression is that enforcement per se doesn't matter, but it does matter what source of truth the enforcement authority looks at.

Somebody puts an entry on the blockchain that says they own my house. OK so what? Nobody cares. They can't get that enforced. If you want to make the sale "real" to the authorities, you have to enter it into the land registry - but now you have a coordination problem. Do we put it into the blockchain first (and hence you pay first) and then the land registry? Or vice versa? Either one requires trust. Hm, maybe we better involve a trusted third party like an escrow company... oh wait we just reinvented the existing system.

All of this is not dissimilar to people selling NFTs of someone else's art. And you'll see the same problems if/when they try to violate copyright on that basis.

If you could convince the relevant authorities that the blockchain was the system-of-record then you'd have something useful. But with all the problems of losing ownership, hacking, inability to recover defrauded assets, etc, what are the odds of that happening?

← PreviousPage 3 of 20Next →