HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

brennen

363 karma · joined September 24, 2007

submissionscomments
brennen··on Why Peter Thiel Fears Star Trek
> Colonization largely ended

This is not observably true.

brennen··on Why Peter Thiel Fears Star Trek
I'm in the later parts of a TNG rewatch right now. One of the most striking things about the tech on the show is that the Enterprise's computer is clearly a superhuman general intelligence, capable of modeling and spawning apparently self-aware human-level independent entities on command, and usually aware of pretty much everything that's going on. And yet it almost never intervenes directly in events outside of plots where the holodeck tries to murder people (and plots where the Enterprise has unfathomably abysmal netsec).

You could probably make an argument that Trek is a post-singularity future where the computational entities are going about their inscrutable business largely without reference to the human symbiotes / parasites that inhabit the systems they happen to manage (out of pure evolutionary path dependence) with a fraction of their capacity.

Trek is ridiculous, and I love it.

brennen··on Ultimate Linux on the Desktop
It's an interesting design with some real potential, and may have improved since I last used it, but at least 6 months ago it was a bit too sluggish for real-world use on mid-tier laptop hardware.
brennen··on The lost letters of the English alphabet
Yeah, true. To the point where I suppose it's basically standard in a bunch of regional dialects.
brennen··on The lost letters of the English alphabet
I'm pretty sure I have never encountered "ect" from any person of any nationality.
brennen··on Rasa: Extremely modular text editor built in Haskell
Awright, awright, I'll give it a look. :)

As a kind of generalized comment to the authors of tools written in smart-people languages: Y'all are great, but I sometimes suspect you'd get broader adoption of your stuff if you kept in mind that a bunch of us are clever enough to benefit from your work, but not always clever enough for the tools you're building it in...

brennen··on Rasa: Extremely modular text editor built in Haskell
While this looks appealing and I will probably try it, I'm not sure if I have cognitive room for another core tool configured in Haskell. Running xmonad is already like a commitment to periodic skirmishes with an angry badger.
brennen··on StumpWM 1.0 Released
I'd say it's more like a terminal multiplexer for window management, if you're familiar with screen or tmux. (Using XMonad for windows and using tmux for collections of shells / terminal apps have followed similar tracks in my life.)
brennen··on StumpWM 1.0 Released
What a tiling WM does in this situation is remove the part of the equation where you have to think about maximizing your windows. Instead of mouse interactions with GUI controls for window placement and scaling, you just use a couple of hotkeys to cycle between window layouts and navigate workspaces (i.e., if you want side-by-side windows for a moment during some task, you hit a key once or twice, then do the same to get back to maximized windows). This may not seem like it's much cognitive load to get rid of, but for me at least, going back after a few months of having the WM just handle things felt clumsy and primitive.

It will also ruin you for using most standard desktop environments, and I personally burn probably a solid day a year porting my WM config to some new environment. These have been a worthwhile trade-offs for me, but probably something to consider if you have to use systems you don't control very often.

brennen··on Why I switched from OS X to Linux
> Honestly, what the hell is with PC manufacturers that still include the TrackPoint™ Style Point, Nub, Nipple Mouse, Clit Mouse[1]?!

There aren't enough of them?

brennen··on Kodak says it’s bringing back Ektachrome film
> People are enamored with less accurate reproduction of vinyl records.

I just did a quick estimate and would say that there're around 300 vinyl records in my household, which I suppose is at the low end for people I know with a record player. A few years back, I owned one or two at most, and didn't have a functional player. That seems to have shifted similarly for a lot of people. You can buy the things new at such resolutely unhip outlets as Barnes & Noble, if you're so inclined.

I'll be pretty happy if vinyl settles into a role as the end-state consensus equilibrium of physical media for music, which is roughly what seems to be happening. Still-playable records encompass most of the era of recorded music, require no digital computation to play, and are substantial enough as artifacts to incentivize paying money for units of art. They're also physically attractive objects with attendant ritual protocols that are easily legible across every living generation.

Accuracy of reproduction is, above some baseline threshold, not the real concern here.

All of which, I guess, is just to say: You're probably right that this is unsurprising. There's a market. "Hipsters" is a convenient shorthand, but it's worth remembering that technologies usually have important properties which are lost to succeeding modes of tech, even when things like the appearance of film grain can in theory be easily reproduced by a filter or what have you. We use the new stuff and we forget the real dimensions of the old stuff.

brennen··on 20 years as a Debian maintainer
> You can't just upload it and forget

Leaving aside the specifics of Debian's tooling and social process (undeniably, these are arcane and complex), I suspect this has a lot to do with why Debian is such a reliable environment over time in a way that few software collections manage.

It would almost certainly be better if it were easier than it is to participate in Debian. I've thought about contributing for years, but I certainly haven't had the energy to clear those hurdles. On the other hand, there's something really important in the distance between typical modern software publication and packaging for an ecosystem like Debian.

I think we'd be a lot better off if more people were committed to the hard, tedious process stuff that renders software accessible to users, a good neighbor to other projects, and maintainable over the long term.

brennen··on Getting Rid of Comments on Vice.com
Eh. I see your point. I'll grant that it's more or less true, from a certain angle: My thoughts on reddit are influenced as much, these days, by its effect on the wider world as by experience on the site itself. My direct participation trailed off some 3 or 4 years ago, judging by my comment history there. On the other hand, my participation tailed off in part because being on the site was becoming actively unpleasant, and I think that the direct experience of phenomena like GG is a reasonable basis for judging a community that fosters them.

(To be clear, I think a lot of the delta here is a question of scale as much as anything. I'm well aware that there were always virulent racists and ideological misogynists present in the userbase.)

Anyway, we disagree and that is that. Thanks for a reasonable interaction.

brennen··on Taking a month off from OSS volunteering
Elsewhere in this thread you asserted that "there's a price", and you don't particularly care about cost. Very well: Hire engineers and pay them a market rate.
brennen··on White House predicts all truck, taxi, and delivery drivers will be wiped out
It poisons the discourse every time you do this.
brennen··on Taking a month off from OSS volunteering
Business, however, makes a pretty lousy driver of life.
brennen··on Getting Rid of Comments on Vice.com
I used to make more or less this same argument, by analogy to Usenet, phpBB forums, etc.

My take now is that this falls apart in that the pathologies of reddit are down to a shared platform (the voting system, moderation tools, etc.), userbase, and site culture. While it's true that userbase and culture are differentiated between subreddits, they aren't really isolated enough, and maybe more importantly, things like GamerGate and /r/The_Donald keep happening.

It doesn't work to assume that every space or interaction on reddit is terrible, but at this point in history it works pretty well for me to treat reddit itself as a terrible meta-space: It routinely and actively produces systems that damage society, out of all proportion to its positive effects.

(Edit: I should add that I was on reddit pretty early in its lifecycle, probably owe my career to proggit in some very important sense, and sincerely feel for the people who have to _run_ the damn thing. It's been a pretty amazing platform in many ways, and it still feels kind of bad to write it off.)

brennen··on Getting Rid of Comments on Vice.com
BRB, walling off various cave entrances.
brennen··on Getting Rid of Comments on Vice.com
This does not actually seem to describe the state of the internet generally. I gravitate more and more towards little pocket-universe parts of the network that are essentially invisible, but (apropos of the article) things like comment sections are quite often the functional equivalent of a giant neon ASSHOLES WELCOME sign above the door.
brennen··on Getting Rid of Comments on Vice.com
A building in n-dimensional hyperspace where a large group of violent assholes are on the other side of ~50% of all doors.
brennen··on Getting Rid of Comments on Vice.com
> Rather than finding a technical solution or one that involves moderation

There are no technical solutions.

(There is, at best, tooling which helps to some extent but which can easily backfire.)

Moderation is necessary and difficult. Skilled human hours must be spent. Humans with the temperament and skills are rare and likely to suffer burnout. Organizations rarely value community management skills in proportion to their necessity and the difficulty of acquiring them.

Even where community management is valued, moderators are often forced to walk a narrow line between exercising power to shut down bad actors and having their authority undermined by their own organizations when bad actors complain, especially if those bad actors can be conceived of as customers.

To put it another way: Before you latch onto the view that removing comment sections is about suppressing dissent, consider life from the perspective of someone whose job it is to moderate comments.

brennen··on Getting Rid of Comments on Vice.com
> The end result is a sort of artificial consensus, which has been quite controversial and caused many long time users to leave.

As a long-time user of the site and an occasional commenter (I seem to be sitting at around 1500 comments after 8 years of having an account, which marks me as a bit of a noob), this feels to me like a true but perhaps misleading statement.

MetaFilter demonstrates that intensive, situationally attuned, full-time moderation can be very effective at maintaining a functional community. It also demonstrates that this process can (and almost certainly will) create its own style of drama and discord. Whatever else it is, MetaFilter commenting is a game system with rich, subtle, and frequently unsettling dynamics. It's somewhat driven by what I think of as a correctness ratchet, where locally established positions and norms are both ruthlessly enforced and endlessly subject to critique or reversal (except for certain positions which have attained the status of axiom or common-law moderation practice). As far as I can tell, as many people leave the site because they are on the _leading_ edge of this process (and view the overall state of things as regressive) as because they trail the consensus.

This can all be pretty frustrating. At its worst, it devolves into hyperbolic groupthink, and occasionally edges into the kind of emergent self-satire that you see so much of on, say, tumblrs produced entirely by socially isolated teenagers. I'm currently disinclined to participate in a lot of MeFi threads for the simple reason that I don't see any real gain for anyone in litigating positions contrary to the current mefite correctness state machine.

I don't think any of that serves to undermine the basic point, or demonstrate that the MetaFilter comment culture is a failure. (Participating in MetaFilter, and engaging in good faith with the really difficult aspects of MetaFilter-style discourse, has probably done more for me as a thinker than any other single thing I can point to.)

It rather serves to highlight that no discourse is _without_ its significant problems, or statically assured to remain productive & humane. Humans fail. Systems fail. There are very definitely other kinds of community you might want to build than MetaFilter, but we would be doing a lot better if we built more systems that fail as well as MetaFilter does.

brennen··on Getting Rid of Comments on Vice.com
> Reddit seems to be doing fine now

Hrm. I resisted this view for quite a while, but as far as I can tell in 2016 reddit is a pathological and destructive ocean of trash fire lunacy which incidentally hosts a few islands of relative sanity.

Of course it's hard to generalize about any cultural venue at the scale of reddit. But it really seems to a lot of observers that the pathology has by far outstripped its prosocial functions.

brennen··on Getting Rid of Comments on Vice.com
I really haven't seen much evidence that media professionals expressing shock at, for example, Brexit and Trump's election are engaged in some strong form of deception. There's a reasonable set of critiques about media incentives and behavior here, but I think this is a case where cynicism of this kind can obscure observable reality: The majority of people really didn't expect these outcomes.
brennen··on Ask HN: What do you use to take notes?
0. Leuchtturm (or Moleskine if I can't get a Leuchtturm) notebook, blank pages, the middle size.

1. vimwiki in a tmux session in an XMonad scratch buffer. Pandoc for occasional PDF output.

2. Some screenshot / screencast gif scripts around byzanz and scrot.

brennen··on Yahoo discloses hack of 1B accounts
I'm really not sure how they could do flickr more damage than they already have.
brennen··on Yahoo discloses hack of 1B accounts
> But yes they don't allow other token provides like Yubikey or RSA fobs

I think this is incorrect, at least provided you're using Chrome. The implementation was buggy somewhere in the chain the last time I tried it, but it's there.

brennen··on Why Kakoune – The quest for a better code editor
Unfortunately, this is superficially true but not in practice all that helpful for a lot of us. Most vim-style input modes or plugins for other editors are woefully lacking, and even very good ones (evil mode) seem to differ enough to be uncomfortable for a subset of long-term vim users.

Like: I've used Emacs extensively in the past, and certainly _could_ switch to evil if need be, but a few days of recent effort showed me that the switching costs are higher than I'm willing to pay right now, and it's not clear I'd be any better off in the end.

Whatever the infelicities of vim's implementation (there are certainly plenty), I think there's a tendency to underestimate the expressive nuance and (for lack of better words) complex texture of the interface.

brennen··on Why I Regret Making My House a Smart-House (2013)
A futile but heartfelt plea: Stop putting computers in shit.
brennen··on The Solution for Open Office Frustration
I echo every other "stop building open floor plans" comment in here.

It's kind of hard to overstate the sad hilarity of so many orgs with vast resources being constitutionally incapable of using technology like walls and doors. There are few more concise arguments for the intellectual bankruptcy of cool-kid business practice.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →