1,107 karma · joined May 25, 2009
I think the author would have no problem with mushrooms from Chernobyl given that they were under a specified level of activity.
This is the real problem as I see it and it extends to most technical work. I didn't see that as the main argument of the article.
I was objecting to the old guard defending their turf.
Academia needs to contend with this problem, and start addressing it right now. People are not going to be able to beat AIs at math. So whats the solution? PhDs will have to be able to show competence in new ways. Publishing and review of mathematical work will have to change. The genie is out of the bottle and there is no putting it back.
“Current automated techniques can produce plausible but unreliable (or even incorrect) arguments which are difficult to distinguish from correct mathematical proofs.”
That seems like a problem for mathematics with or without AI.
Isn’t this a problem with human proofs as well?
“Many current models are also built on data obtained by systematically exploiting licenses and access arrangements that were not made with artificial intelligence in mind, or indeed by simply violating copyright protections”
Copyright? The copyright arguments have been hard to make in domains where copyright is much stronger, mathematical knowledge isn’t even subject to copyright.
“Technologies which affect the way in which mathematics is practiced may disturb the current system of incentives”
Resistance to change again.
“Proper evaluation is endangered if results are communicated through informal channels”
Gatekeeping again.
I can see the argument for use in industrial processes like steel manufacturing as a reducing agent, but not as a power source.