HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

briandw

1,107 karma · joined May 25, 2009

submissionscomments
briandw··on California high-speed rail price tag jumps to $231B, nearly 7x 2008 estimate
You are claiming that this is anti train and pro car conspiracy. Counter ponint : the SF Bay_Bridge cost 6.5 Billion, but was originally budgeted at 200 Million.

The US can't build anything efficiently. It's due to the massive mismanagement, bureaucratic nonsense, environmental review, permitting and NIMBY lawsuits.

The real conspiracy is that "they" never wanted a train, "they" wanted an endless jobs project.

briandw··on Who owns the code Claude Code wrote?
Your employer can claim your code if you use their tools to produce it. Nothing new here. This has nothing to do with AI tooling.
briandw··on UK to permanently ban future generations from buying cigarettes
You assume that there is a balance point. There is an unlimited demand for healthcare. Additionally the more money you give to a failing system, the worse it gets. It’s a positive feedback loop.
briandw··on UK to permanently ban future generations from buying cigarettes
It’s also cheaper to euthanize people rather than treat them. It’s just logical.
briandw··on A programmable watch you can actually wear
No mention of battery life? I guess it depends on the software that you run. But it would be nice to have a benchmark for how long it would last in normal watch mode.
briandw··on Why Japan has such good railways
Switzerland is even more regional than the US. Yet they seem to have built an excellent rail system.
briandw··on Do you even need a database?
The article is fine, but I wanted to call this out.

"Every database you have ever used reads and writes to the filesystem, exactly like your code does when it calls open()."

Technically not true. Applications like SQLite use mmap to map the file into a locally addressable memory space. This lets you skip the syscalls when reading and writing. The kernel can map that data in dynamically much faster than a userland process can.

Later in the article they go over the process of reading in the entire file into memory, again mmap is much better at this. Would have been nice to see that approach used.

briandw··on US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ban unconstitutional
Good! Now let's do civil asset forfeiture.
briandw··on Who is Satoshi Nakamoto? My quest to unmask Bitcoin's creator
This dude can seem to tell the difference between Newsgroups and Mailing Lists. Also described Newsgroups as being displayed in a particular font. What a weird mistake. It's almost like he doesn't care about the details.

The article claims Adam Back "disappeared" on the cryptography mailing lists exactly when Satoshi Nakamoto became active (late 2008) and only "reappeared" around the time Satoshi stopped posting in 2011.

Back's rebuttal: He was highly active, "a lot of yakking" on the relevant lists and forums during Bitcoin's early years. He points out that his high volume of posts on electronic cash and cryptography topics naturally makes him visible in searches, creating confirmation bias when filtering for "Satoshi-like" activity.

The NYT analysis apparently missed or underweighted his continued contributions in developer chats, Bitcoin-related discussions, and other lists/forums.

The stylistic argument is weak. In 1990s technical mailing lists and Usenet, Many cypherpunks showed similar inconsistencies. The article treats these as highly distinctive "fingerprints" rather than common artifacts of the era's informal technical writing.

briandw··on AyaFlow: A high-performance, eBPF-based network traffic analyzer written in Rust
Maybe don’t bother to post then?
briandw··on South Korea Mandates Solar Panels for Public Parking Lots
The sensibility of a policy and the power dynamics of it’s application are orthogonal.
briandw··on Rank the 50 best Apple products
Old guy here. The Apple ][+ didn't make the list! It was the first computer that I used and the product that launched the company.
briandw··on An unstoppable mushroom is tearing through North American forests
I would have thought all the fungus had long ago traveled around the world? Don’t they move easily on the wind or on items shipped from place to place.
briandw··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
I specifically said sex. Gender is mostly undefined. If you say that gender is the societal presentation as male or female, but you can’t define male from female then what are you defining? Its the “trans women are women” contradiction.
briandw··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
Male puberty changes body composition in non-reversible ways. Muscle distribution, composition, quantity and bone density, all favor men that have gone through puberty.
briandw··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
The fact that it's only one way (banning men from competition in women's sports) is evidence against your point, not for it. If it was strictly anti-trans, then it would be an applied to both. The fact that no one cares that if a woman wants to participate in a men's event is pretty telling.
briandw··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
Men are stronger and faster and not just a little bit. If you allow men in women's sports, (basketball, soccer, boxing etc) then women will not be competitive in those sports.
briandw··on FreeCAD v1.1
Looking forward to this update. There are so many hidden gotchas in FreeCAD once you get past the basics. Load of bugs and head scratching issues. However its free and local so can’t complain to much.
briandw··on WolfGuard: WireGuard with FIPS 140-3 cryptography
My limited understanding is that issues like being vulnerable to side channel attacks are very difficult to detect. So you have to have shown that the entire development process is safe. From the code to the compiler to the hardware to the microcode, it all needs to be checked. That said it does seem like compliance is a bigger priority than safety.
briandw··on Vatican Rebukes Peter Thiel's Antichrist Lectures in Rome
Are we talking about the Pope or Thiel?
briandw··on Tinybox – A powerful computer for deep learning
Correct me if I’m wrong, but doubling the volts doesn't change the amps, it doubles the watts. Watts = V*A.
briandw··on FSF statement on copyright infringement lawsuit Bartz v. Anthropic
I'm really confused by the FSF statement here. The court ruled that the use of copyrighted information is fair use. The issue is that Anthropic pirated (obtained illegally) copyrighted work and that was the offense. FSF books are free to download and store etc. The license says: "This is a free license allowing use of the work for any purpose without payment." So how can they claim that their rights were infringed when the court ruled that the problem was the illegal downloading of copyrighted work? It's impossible to illegally download a FSF book.
briandw··on Show HN: Will my flight have Starlink?
It’s too difficult to distinguish between a terminal in small GA aircraft and something with destructive payload. Commercial aircraft are few and controllable.
briandw··on $96 3D-printed rocket that recalculates its mid-air trajectory using a $5 sensor
I think this violates ITAR. You aren't allowed put a guidance system on a rocket. And even if you were allowed to do it for your own fun/education, you certainly aren't allowed to provide instructions to foreign entities about how it do it.
briandw··on Bill C-22, the Lawful Access Act: Dangerous backdoor surveillance risks remain
The bill claims that it doesn’t grant any new powers. Then it goes on to explain that if you don’t collect meta data and retain it for up to a year, that you can be fined or jailed.
briandw··on New 'negative light' technology hides data transfers in plain sight
The “emitter” can either produce more thermal photons than the background thermal noise or fewer. Because it absorbs thermal energy particles of the time and loses that energy at others, it balances out to background. You have to know at what temporal frequency to sample to see it, otherwise the signal will integrate to zero. Very clever.
briandw··on John Carmack about open source and anti-AI activists
This the “no true scott”! fallacy. I sure he writes code and makes it open with an open source license, but he not really doing open source.
briandw··on Malus – Clean Room as a Service
Obviously satire, but it will clearly be what happens in the future (predicting here, I'm not endorsing this practice). We can scratch train a new LLM on code generated from "contaminated" LLMs. We can then audit all the training data used and demonstrate that the original source wasn't in the training data. Therefore the cleanroom implementation holds. Current LLM training is relying less and less on human generated code. Just look at the open source models from China. They rely heavily on distilling from other models. One additional point. Exposure to the original source isn't enough to show infringement. Linus looked at UNIX source before writing linux.
briandw··on Waymo blocking ambulance during deadly Austin shooting
I don't often see a human driven car parked sideways in the middle of a road (never really). If a human was in that Waymo, they would have moved quickly. I'm an huge fan of Waymo and autonomous vehicles. They save lives. However the fact that Waymo's don't have the sense to move out of the way is a major problem and on that they don't seem to be on track to solve. Incidents like this will delay the adoption of autonomous vehicles and that will cost lives.
briandw··on NASA announces overhaul of Artemis program amid safety concerns, delays
I feel the same. The Golden Gate Bridge took 3 years to build, start to finish. It was the biggest suspension to have ever been built at the time. Compare that to any modern public works project of today. There are countless examples of how we used to be able to build things before 1970.
← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →