HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

briandw

1,107 karma · joined May 25, 2009

submissionscomments
briandw··on Sub-$200 Lidar could reshuffle auto sensor economics
The brains (ai models) are more important than the sensors. Cameras are good enough. Lidar doesn’t keep Waymos from driving into an 18” deep puddle, or driving the wrong way down the street. Lidar doesn’t help predict when a pedestrian is going to try to cross the street. Lidar doesn’t give the car the common sense to slow down because a child just ran behind a parked car and will soon be coming out the other side.
briandw··on Can random experimental choice lead to better theories?
This remind me of [Why Greatness Cannot Be Planned](https://mythoftheobjective.com). When looking at scientific discovery there many examples of happy accidents. The researchers were not intending to find the breakthrough that they did. It was the willingness to change course and explore a new and interesting thing that they just stumbled onto. Examples: penicillin, superglue, radioactivity, cosmic background radiation etc. I loved the example of Robert Williams who pointed the HST at an empty patch of sky for 10 days. He had his time allocated and no one could stop him but the other astronomers thought it a poor use of resources. It resulted in the famous Hubble Deep Field image.

Counter example is the decades that amyloid cascade hypothesis was the only allowed / funded research of Alzheimer disease.

briandw··on Tesla Robotaxis Reportedly Crashing at a Rate That's 4x Higher Than Humans
How many of you have run into a bollard or other fixed structure at less than 5 mph and didn't report it?
briandw··on Students Are Being Treated Like Guinea Pigs: Inside an AI-Powered Private School
First let's stick to the lower grades (under 5th). The evidence isn't as clean for upper grades.

Constructivist teaching favors things like student-centered discovery, inquiry-based, minimal-guidance, "child-led" or "whole-language" approaches.

This is just a plain bad way to teach the basics, like reading, writing and arithmetic. People didn't just magically invent these ideas. Most of human history is pre-literacy. Why are we expecting a 5yo to spontaneously learn to read?

This has been studied extensively. Have a look at Project Follow Through (1968–1977). It's the largest study of its kind.

This U.S. government-funded study involved ~120,000 disadvantaged K–3 students across 20+ instructional models in multiple sites. It directly compared Direct Instruction (Engelmann’s scripted, explicit basic-skills model, e.g., DISTAR) against constructivist-oriented models (e.g., Bank Street child-directed, Open Education/EDC exploratory-discovery, cognitive-conceptual discovery approaches).

Abt Associates did an independent evaluation in (1977). Their findings

DI produced the highest gains in reading, math, language, and spelling—raising performance to near national averages. It was the only model with consistent positive effects across basic skills, cognitive-conceptual skills, and self-esteem/affective outcomes.

See page 311 fig1 for the plot of outcomes. https://andymatuschak.org/files/1988-Engelmann.pdf

For more recent evidence, have a look at the reforms in Mississippi and the UK. Mississippi has striking gains for under privileged students. Mississippi Columbus Municipal School District used the "Reading Mastery Signature Edition" DI program.

Demographics: 92% African American, 100% free/reduced-price lunch, 12% special education.

Results as measured by NWEA MAP and Renaissance STAR assessments:

MAP RIT gains: +15.96 points overall 43–45% of students met or exceeded expected growth; top performers gained ~20–28 points.

Similar results in: Baltimore City Public Schools (1996–2008) Arthur Academies (Portland, Oregon metro, 2007–2013) Rimes Elementary, Florida (2011) Gering Public Schools, Nebraska (2004+)

briandw··on Students Are Being Treated Like Guinea Pigs: Inside an AI-Powered Private School
AI is held to a much higher standard than the existing education techniques.

Even without AI teachers are implementing new techniques without any evidence of their effectiveness. In some cases, there is mountains of evidence that their techniques are not effective. From the prohibition on phonics in reading, learning styles, building thinking classrooms, or just the entire idea of constructivism. These are all worse than the techniques that they replace. AI systems at the very least are measured and have some kind of tracking of what works.

I'm not advocating for AI necessarily, but education is in the pre-scientific phase and it needs to start by implementing evidence based techniques, AI or no.

briandw··on EU bans the destruction of unsold apparel, clothing, accessories and footwear
Everything that is not compulsory is forbidden. Everything that is not forbidden is compulsory.
briandw··on Rust implementation of Mistral's Voxtral Mini 4B Realtime runs in your browser
These are good lectures and there is also a discord. https://github.com/gpu-mode/lectures
briandw··on AT&T, Verizon blocking release of Salt Typhoon security assessment reports
This was enabled by the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act (CALEA), enacted in 1994. Congress made their bed, now they need to lie in. Time to remove the govt mandated backdoors.
briandw··on NIMBYs aren't just shutting down housing
This “practicing without a license” tactic has been used before. This case where a city fined someone for making a mathematical model of traffic lights. [ij](https://ij.org/press-release/oregon-engineer-wins-traffic-li...) This will keep happening unless there are consequences for those in government that abuse their authority.
briandw··on Data centers in space makes no sense
Eager Space [Orbital Data Centers Yes or No](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JAcR7kqOb3o) Goes into great detail with extensive calculations (for a YT video at least). TLDR: Cost to orbit needs to be under $200/kg before it makes sense.
briandw··on I made 20 GDPR deletion requests. 12 were ignored
forgot about a few others uber marriott clearview openai €4 899 121 028 or 71.5%
briandw··on I made 20 GDPR deletion requests. 12 were ignored
point conceded, they do enforce gdpr on smaller companies thanks for the enforcement tracker link i scraped that page to get the raw data and added it up by company. i wanted to see how much the main us tech companies paid vs everyone else

these aren't audited but total €6,848,216,522 us tech €4,527,961,028

so 66% from just a few companies from outside europe

briandw··on Xcode 26.3 – Developers can leverage coding agents directly in Xcode
You are of course correct. It's not likely to succeed. "Could work" doesn't mean high chance of success. I was trying to imply the opposite. It's just that Xcode has so much baggage that the previous attempts have been very compromised.
briandw··on Xcode 26.3 – Developers can leverage coding agents directly in Xcode
True that Xcode needs yet another rebuild from scratch. If they forked it and abandoned the old project file and went with a swift first approach, could work. However adding support for Claude is still a huge win. Could lead the way to making the transition to a sane IDE possible / reasonable. This would require leadership that’s completely absent at the company.
briandw··on I made 20 GDPR deletion requests. 12 were ignored
One could argue that the intention of the law is to make it possible to collect revenue from non-EU companies. Since the EU doesn't have any sizable internet companies. Not counting Prosus group as they are a holding company, Spotify is the biggest at 100mm. EU doesn't care about small / midsized companies because they don't have enough income to bother with. "The purpose of a system is what it does".
briandw··on Ask HN: Is there anyone here who still uses slide rules?
I used a circular slide rule when I first started flight training. It was used in flight planing to calculate ground speed and a few other things. You can still buy one.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E6B

briandw··on Show HN: yolo-cage – AI coding agents that can't exfiltrate secrets
Claude code (as shown in the repo) can read the files on disk. Isn’t that already exfiltration? In order to read the file, it has to go to Anthropic. I don’t personally have a problem with that but it’s not secret if it leaves your machine.
briandw··on Ireland wants to give its cops spyware, ability to crack encrypted messages
https://xkcd.com/538/ User data can only be as safe as the user.
briandw··on British redcoat's lost memoir reveals realities of life as a disabled veteran
Are you saying that because there is much more stuff to buy, like an internet connection, that the quality of life is lower? I mean sure after you factor out all the inexpensive / free entertainment, unlimited access to information, incredibly cheep clothing, lighting and consumer goods, vaccines etc life is so much worse than in the 1950’s
briandw··on You Can Just Buy Far-UVC
I need to get one :)
briandw··on Wind power slashed 4.6B euros off electricity bills in Spain last year
Sarcasm? Ca electricity costs 33.60 per kWh vs the US average of 17.98. Personally Ive seen my bill double in the last 10 years.
briandw··on You Can Just Buy Far-UVC
This is Far-UVC (typically 222 nm). Regular UVC can cause eye damage.
briandw··on You Can Just Buy Far-UVC
I looked it up and Far-UVC (typically 222 nm) seems safe-ish. But how do you confirm it's not outputting 254 nm or other wavelengths in the UVA/B range? Seems likely to happen with sloppy production of sources. You really have to trust the filter on the light or verify the frequency somehow.
briandw··on Roam 50GB is now Roam 100GB
Citation needed
briandw··on Ask HN: Share your personal website
I grew up in Elmira NY. Great name :)
briandw··on Ask HN: Share your personal website
https://vartia.ai It's the blog for my burgeoning ML consulting biz. Not sure about the rules on personal. I'm the only one posting for now.
briandw··on VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard with the ID. Polo EV
Honestly this doesn't look better. You still have a large touch screen, but now you also have > 20 buttons on the steering wheel. Capacitive (no touch feedback) ones at that.
briandw··on A spider web unlike any seen before
The big problem with farming spiders for silk is that you can’t have a dense colony of them. This could a solution to that. Breeding these to make super strong silk to harvest would be really cool. Although you have to have a way of separating the strands to make thread.
briandw··on Karpathy on Programming: “I've never felt this much behind”
I've come to a similar conclusion. One example is how much easier it is to put an interface on top of sqlite. I've been burned badly with the hidden details of ORM s. ORMs are the sirens call of getting rid of all that boiler plate code when encoding and decoding objects into a db. However this abstraction breaks in many hidden ways. Lazy loading details, in-memory state vs db mismatch, cascading details, etc all have unexpected problems that can be hard to predict. Using an LLM to do the grunt work lets you easily see and reason about all the details. You don't have to guess about what's happening and you can make your own choices.
briandw··on Alzheimer’s disease can be reversed in animal models? Study
Boosting NAD has a been the focus of taking NMN supplements. Seems like NMN is a dud for boosting NAD. I wonder if P7C3-A20 can be used instead?
← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →