HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

britzl

79 karma · joined November 24, 2016

submissionscomments
britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
Exactly. The license used for Defold (https://defold.com/license/) says:

* You are free to commercialise any software created using Defold * You are free to commercialise any plugin, extension or tool created for use with Defold * You are free to modify Defold and you are not required to share the changes * You are free to distribute original or modified (derivative) versions of Defold)

britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
Not true. I went over the entire website and searched for "open source" and changed the wording. I did not add a bunch of extra "free and open" just for fun.
britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
Defold is Free, meaning that it doesn't cost anything to use and you don't have to pay any royalties.

Defold is Open, meaning that it is possible to modify and extend. It is actually possible to extend the engine even without source code access thanks to our native extension system.

britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
Thank you for the feedback! It was never our intention to step on any toes or misrepresent Defold. Defold is a free (doesn't cost anything) and open (you can extend and modify it) game engine with a permissive license and we invite the community to contribute on GitHub.

Please see this statement: https://twitter.com/defold/status/1262744466311360517

britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
Thank you for the feedback! It was never our intention to step on any toes or misrepresent Defold. Defold is a free and open game engine with a permissive license and we invite the community to contribute on GitHub. Please see this statement: https://twitter.com/defold/status/1262744466311360517

Edit: typo

britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
It was never our intention to step on any toes or misrepresent Defold. Defold is a free and open game engine with a permissive license and we invite the community to contribute on GitHub. Please see this statement: https://twitter.com/defold/status/1262744466311360517
britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
Thank you for the feedback. It was never our intention to step on any toes or misrepresent Defold. Please see this statement: https://twitter.com/defold/status/1262744466311360517
britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
Thank you for the feedback. It was never our intention to step on any toes or misrepresent Defold. Please see this statement: https://twitter.com/defold/status/1262744466311360517
britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
Thank you for the feedback. It was never our intention to step on any toes or misrepresent Defold. Please see this statement: https://twitter.com/defold/status/1262744466311360517
britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
We are humbled by the mostly positive reactions to the news we shared earlier today but also sorry for misrepresenting the license under which we make the source code available. Defold is a free and open game engine with a permissive license. The source code is available on GitHub and we invite the community to contribute.

We have updated the website to reflect this and we no longer use the term "Open Source" as to not confuse it with the OSD.

The Defold license, complete with a summary of what you can and cannot do, can be seen on our license page: https://defold.com/license/

We have also Tweeted this: https://twitter.com/defold/status/1262744466311360517

britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
The question if Defold will be open sourced is one of the most common questions asked since Defold was launched in 2016.

By open sourcing Defold and handing it to the Defold Foundation we build trust with the community. It guarantees that Defold will be around regardless of what happens with King. And by handing over Defold to the Defold Foundation we believe it gives a lot of credibility to Defold as a strong and independent open source game engine.

britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
Yes, you can sell your games!

The license page is very clear on this: https://defold.com/license/

* You are free to commercialise any software created using Defold * You are free to commercialise any plugin, extension or tool created for use with Defold * You are free to modify Defold and you are not required to share the changes * You are free to distribute original or modified (derivative) versions of Defold * You are given a license to any patent that covers Defold

You can sell anything you want created with or related to Defold, but not package the engine+editor and sell those.

britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
The license page (https://defold.com/license/) says "derived from the popular and permissive Apache 2.0 license". It never say that it is the Apache 2.0 license.

It then goes on to show the difference very clearly, and as you can see the only difference from the Apache 2.0 license is that additional clause about non-commercialisation of the engine+editor package. You are still free to sell your Defold games, sell your Defold add-ons and sell your Defold tutorials.

britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
I will not debate you on that one. According to the Open Source Definition (https://opensource.org/osd) Defold is only 90% open source. It's a lot better than the 0% it was yesterday.
britzl··on Defold game engine source now available and free to use for commercial games
True, Defold is only 90% open source according to that definition, but that is definitely a lot better than the 0% it was yesterday.
britzl··on Ask HN: What are you learning?
It is a bit different than many other engines, and it is not for everyone, but once you shift your mindset from large object oriented structures and start thinking about the relationship between your game logic and data in a way that works with Defold I find that you're able to create a lot in a short timeframe.
britzl··on Godot Engine – A decade in retrospective and future
I've been with the Defold team since before the public launch, but I'm not going to debate you over this :-)

As you say, things have changed and we have worked hard since the launch three years ago to show our community of developers that we are serious about Defold as a professional choice for game developers and that we do not have any hidden agenda with giving Defold away for free.

britzl··on Godot Engine – A decade in retrospective and future
(I'm the Defold product owner)

There's not a shred of truth in the above statement. We offered an OPT-IN analytics services that provided you, the developer, with install and retention numbers for your game. No one at King or in the Defold team ever looked at any data. King has hundred of millions of monthly active players of their own games. That's enough data. No need to try and steal data from anyone else...

The optional analytics service along with the optional project hosting was shut down four months ago.

We do use Google Analytics for www.defold.com and the editor. This is clearly stated in the terms and conditions. And it's pretty standard stuff in the industry to keep track of product usage like that.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2