HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

brnaftr361

635 karma · joined January 21, 2022

submissionscomments
brnaftr361··on Children's arithmetic skills do not transfer between applied and academic math
Anecdotally, this is true even as an adult. As a non-trad student the application side of things as they are taught are fairly effete, we learn how to translate graphs in algebra, quadratics, polynomials... I don't recall much in the way of meaningful application in either trig or algebra and what was there was remembered solely in the context of future examination.

In one hand I would argue there is virtually no incentive for play, or discovery, or superfluous activity with the math due to grading, and in fact it's disincentivized as it is one factor of a multivariate optimization problem. On the other hand I would argue that it's taught too fast as an effect of the former condition - as someone who isn't in a highly mathematical branch of STEM the use of mathematics is comparably infrequent when considering the TEM, as such atrophy sets rapidly after examination. And this could be said more generally with the S as well, though there is some degree of reinforcement there.

As things are, I feel that the timeline is askew, the won't if these institutions to produce biologists along the same timeline as they did a few decades ago is a little ridiculous considering the ballooning of quantitative discovery that has occured since, for instance, it wasn't so long ago that DNA was a conceptual exercise.

Moreover, the failure of education to keep with the times and adapt a realistic curricula for the modern era is also inhibitory. Indeed I would argue that the current academic zeitgeist is working against itself. At once being a trade program and while also trying to facilitate the development of "academia" itself are forces acting against one another. The number of premed students running the gauntlet in my program far outweigh the number of people with [let's say] legitimate interest in learning about the concepts in the program, which are also made to compete with the premeds in the limited slots available for lab internships. In my experience this leads to a chilling effect. Fortuitously, once in a lab things tend to be a little more facorable in terms of rapport.

brnaftr361··on NASA: Mystery of Life's Handedness Deepens
My initial hypothesis is that there's something present in the early stages of life that has a higher energy state making it unsustainable for use in a certain conformation and so it was nearly immediately selected out.

E.g. a ring structure whose substituents are affected by steric hindrance in the left-handed scheme.

And the path of least resistance was just to adapt and build around it. Once that precedence was set everything became as such. I expect in the earliest stages of life this would have been an immense factor as metabolism was not nearly as sophisticated as we know it today.

And this selective process may have ocurred well before anything we have observed/modeled, and may well be erased. Which is to say I agree, but with the caveat that it was a substrate-dependent mechanism which selected the downstream components rather than random chance.

brnaftr361··on Cats are (almost) liquid
I complain about it frequently, actually, in context of commercial use and the "commons" the Internet is founded on.

These things also don't compare.

brnaftr361··on Study: Cats Are Almost Liquid
Even better that it got published in Cell.
brnaftr361··on Fraud, so much fraud
D&K ironically misengineered their tests and inadventently misconstrued their data due to floor and ceiling effects. If you ran the gamut of their tests against random noise you get similar results.

https://www.mcgill.ca/oss/article/critical-thinking/dunning-...

I posit that anyone who uses DK unironically is actually committing to the DK-paradox, something I'll leave you to define for yourself.

brnaftr361··on “Golden Lettuce” is genetically engineered to have higher beta-carotene levels
Golden rice had the same problem if I recall correctly. The populations that it was designed to serve were reluctant to eat it because the yellow coloration was similar to that of a particular species of mold they were enculturated to avoid.
brnaftr361··on Beastie Boys dismantled their gold record plaque
Yeah I'd say it's almost certainly veiled in irony given the context. Something derived from reefer madness stylization. I do it as well, quite literally using that phrase. Tinges of unguided parentalism and the vogue surrounding it - otherwise ignorance.
brnaftr361··on Homebound: The Long-Term Rise in Time Spent at Home Among U.S. Adults
Yeah, but you've already got your friend circle, right?

With the socioeconomic-geographic mobility situation - people moving to get good jobs, better lifestyles, and increased quality of life may not. And there are of course regressive movers too, and probably people pursuing greener grass. They aren't going to have friends locally, workplace socializing is... Suboptimal. But in a society that increasingly verbalizes distaste for cold approach, and lacks — as you said a quiet socializing atmosphere (or even competition in such a sphere) there's little left. At least that's my experience.

brnaftr361··on Understanding 3D Graphics
I find modeling to be super intractable. I've sat down several times to attempt a project and I always get super fixated on details. It's seldom good enough for me to just make it look right, I want it to be technically correct. A pic-rail needs to be modeled to spec, dimensions need to be correct. All the shader functions need to be tuned to the real world measurements. Of course I have to model the mechanism! And the geometry needs to be manifold and the topology needs to be technically perfect... It tends towards a crash course every time.

With that said I love it, I've learned so much just toying around with the software: optics, material science, psychology, illusion, compsci, math... Not to mention the actual artistry of CG which is so diverse. And I find overall it facilitates a unique form of reasoning. It's a confluence of a dozen different disciplines and it's a great playground for the ADHD mind if one isn't fixated on productivity.

brnaftr361··on The Marshmallow Test does not reliably predict adult functioning
I expect a contributing factor to this is natural inference. Delayed gratification is just fine for certain windows and in certain domains. But continuous delay (or non-gratifying outcomes) are surefire ends to update priors. Anecdotally, I'm very much in that position. I've delayed and subsequently mistimed my whole life and let's just say my expectations are totally unmet and I'm quickly unraveling into a hedonist plus flagellant.

I'd expect a decay of delayed gratification in aggregate. And this will vary from individual to individual dependant on their expectations/(negative realizations - positive realizations) or similar, and negative realizations are supposedly weighted higher than positive by a factor of 3-5. This exacerbates the rapidity of decay.

I'd posit, then, that delayed gratification can predict within a window; that window may be a "critical window" which leads to enhanced success. Failing to obtain that success then predicts regular decrements to delayed gratification metrics.

And delayed gratification isn't beneficial in all scenarios anyways. Sometimes the payoff is in immediate and remorseless action.

brnaftr361··on Can the moon influence human health? New research
It's honestly derogatory. I would posit this type of research is strongly motivated by the wont of certain individuals to dispel outright any conception of superstition. A la hard-line atheists. They're not intent on observation and development of understanding but rather destruction.

Again, I would push that ancestral explanations tend to hold a kernel of truth and with it value. However, they're very much Fisher Price building blocks, moreover they're nth-hand and have been prostituted into industries and perverted in the process. Sensitivities have declined, people are reactive, and have in many parts of the world grown averse to such enchantment, so motive for a Hawthorne Effect exists, examining behavioral spectra as it relates to seasons and planetary shifts and tides/moon/solar cycles is I'm sure increasingly noisy as to have abated it's appearance almost entirely. Lest we forget our past was exclusively environmentally determined. Sedentary cultivars of humans have only existed for what is essentially the blink of an eye on the evolutionary timescale. And we have only had the probe of formal psychology for an equivalent of a microsecond and it proves unwieldy even now.

And we wouldn't be special in such a lunar/solar/seasonal regime.

What I would say is that it shouldn't be discounted out of hand, and that is all.

brnaftr361··on Can the moon influence human health? New research
The article states that some women synchronize with moon cycles and even professes skeptical speculation that premodern women may have been explicitly attuned. Just putting two and two together. I know I'd be irritable if I had to deal with that kind of pain and the various other symptoms with it - certainly not trying to point blame, after all most of the "trouble" was always trivial. And it may not be my cohort directly, but various other people. It's not hard to imagine knock on effects. Though I wouldn't discount that causality may lie elsewhere if not outright bias.

More curtly, yes, I'm not implying but outright stating on the basis of the article.

brnaftr361··on Can the moon influence human health? New research
This is interesting. I used to work in schools and the teachers swore the swelling of the full moon was a harbinger of bad behavior. It was a predominately female cohort. I wonder if it was the onset of menses sensitizing them to aggravations or if it was students misbehaving, or a combination of the two.

Anyways, astrology has been kicking around for a while. Of course I wouldn't say it's the whole truth, but I expect there's something to it. Radioactive hotspots being occluded. No doubt we have a biological equivalent of bit flips. Sprinkle in some butterfly effect, viola.

I do believe there were studies indicating disparate behaviors from winter-born people and their summer counterparts. Seasonality and the way that people interact with their environment in one vs another, the sensitivity to initial conditions, epigenetics...

There may be more to it than meets the eye, and our ancestors just came up with an overfit model that combines an elaborate multivariate system which has been perverted.

brnaftr361··on MPPP – The first 'designer drug' disaster (2023)
What's the legality like on this? I know there's a comprehensive testing lab in Spain, but I feel like shipping LSD across the US via the postal system alone is a multiple felony, not to mention overseas travel? Is there a legal exception to this or is it just done on faith?
brnaftr361··on Tiny fern has the largest genome of any organism on Earth
We touched on polyploidy in genetics of course but I don't recall anything that was particularly salient insofar as resistances. In humans xploidy typically results in either excessive protein expression or compromised (≤50%) protein expression - in many cases this is fatal or seriously damaging in terms of fertility/development. There are exceptions, for instance the mammalian liver has polyploidal cells.

But plants are way different in terms of habit, think about evolving to sit in the same place for a hundred years...

These for example could have epigenetic crosstalk between their environment (epiphytic nature) and their hosts. E.g. a special chromosome for birch vs oak. Or drought vs monsoon. Given the endpoint of the species is purportedly 350mn years it stands to reason that a highly specialized and nuanced system of regulatory pathways may have emerged. Sequence data and genomics would be revelatory.

It wouldn't surprise me if there was specialized information per-host which was regulated by signal produced by the host, I think this would explain redundancy pretty well. Different epigenetic pathways operating on different x¹ chromosomes yielding differential response to discrete small molecules/proteins/hormones produced by host species which prove beneficial in the looong run. This could have a whole cascade of effects or just subtle SNP differences which yield fitness enhancements. Essentially each one being a subroutine for each host case producing local optimums.

But I'm just a scrubby undergrad so with a grain of salt. There's probably many other more reasonable explanations, it's biology, biology seeks to find exceptions to every rule by its nature.

brnaftr361··on Covid Subcommittee Releases Dr. Fauci's Transcript, Highlights Key Takeaways
This isn't a math problem, it's not a stats problem. Realizing this abstraction of numbers is an error of reification. What's really worthy of consideration is the holistic picture which as of yet can not be resolved due to the ineradicable complexities of the evolving circumstances. The protocol to which we were subjected wrought untold damage and it's unclear in the long run whether the effects which evolved will have ultimately saved any lives.

For instance the current geopolitical regime is certainly informed, in part, by the economic and political effects which originated as a consequence of and during COVID and shutdown mandates. And these economic effects have also affected policy and personal behaviors. It's a whole Pandora's box, and we won't be able to measure it with any meaningful resolution for... Probably decades... And even then there will be conflation because attributing overdose deaths to economic issues emanating from shutdown policies five years after the fact isn't a trivial argument to make, but nonetheless isn't an impossibility when considering actual human circumstances.

And then considering what may have occurred on the obverse, where actually minimal intervention was taken, is also impossible to surmise. But I don't think it's unrealistic to have a meaningful boon. It may be the case that in spite of all the intervening circumstances that mortality would have ultimately been comparable due to the half-hearted nature which may have just been a collosal disruption. e.g. we hit a saturation point which lead to peak mortality and policy failed to modify the consequent mortality in the range beneath it.

And yet another where minimal, targeted interventions a la the Great Barrington Declaration were deployed.

And since nobody acts in isolation in a globalist society it will be yet more difficult to ascertain.

So bandying about mortality numbers, I think, is insufficient when there have been so many consequences which have evolved from COVID policies, many of which are qualitative and difficult to quantify but have considerable meaning outside the silly abstractions we conjecture carry so much meaning.

brnaftr361··on Show HN: HackerNews but for research papers
Seconding this, I love HN because it gives a wide gamut of exposure, it's a glorious nexus of information, however as a MolB I'd love to have something more narrow when it comes to narrowing things down to academic work.
brnaftr361··on One-third of Amazon warehouse workers are on food stamps or Medicaid
No, people should shoulder the burden and when a business model is untenable, there should be a correction which is instantiated by a lack of labor. It's neither the company nor the governments responsibility to dictate what the market will bear, only follow the optimization curve that the charter is architected to. A lot of the problems we see in the modern market are a product of well-intentioned interventions, namely things like welfare that allow for low-wage workers to sustain a long term position at a job that underpays them which is ultimately zero-sum to those individuals which it is supposed to support.

Where interventions need applied to companies, namely conglomerates, they are not and virtually nobody seems to want to discuss this, but it's the bull in the China shop because these monoliths have a unidirectional charter toward profit and infinite coffers by which to affect policy change and ensure that margins can remain relatively extreme without regard to consequences which either the individual or the society in which they operate suffer.

brnaftr361··on Immersive Linear Algebra (2015)
Thank God people are moving towards this modality. I have a fervent hatred for textbooks and publishers. The former are antiquated, static, badly formatted, and often ride with distracting garbage in the margin, or worse inline. It makes actually reading them far more difficult than needs be, with unremarkable asides that may span pages and that are easy to get pulled into. While I understand that they have a purpose, they aren't for everyone so having a platform with the dynamism of a webpage is something that I hope will inevitably lend itself to future development along this course. Not to mention being able to have interactive questions that give quick feedback rather than requiring turning through pages to find out if you're on the right track... And this interactive stuff is just an excellent means to drive meaning from terse and difficult to explain systems.

Cheers to the folks that put this together, a thousand thanks for the travails you've been through to blaze these trails!

brnaftr361··on Industrial Design Student Work: "How Long Should Objects Last?"
I think Gandhi sorta covers the penultimate conclusion of this train, and that's highly local production.

A sort of sentimentality and pride. Maybe you chipped in somewhere along the chain, all the socks in the city have a little bit of your blood, sweat, and tears in the fibers. I think we try to replicate these sensations with all the green-washed corporate mission statement bullshit, and psychologically I think it's a very successful line. Practically, though, not so much.

This of course comes with the curing of all the one-size-fits all shit, too.

brnaftr361··on TheDesk desktop environment
I'd say it has the opposite, the desktop itself is shared among several virtual environments. However, I believe W8 did have it.

You know how you swipe between pages on a phone desktop? Organize all the logically coherent things together for productivity and badda bing badda boom.

And Fences does that, mostly. It has "pages" and the "Fences" themselves. Implementation is... Passable. And unfortunately Stardock's reputation isn't stellar.

It'd be nice to see a native system for Windows or Linux that replicates it.

brnaftr361··on TheDesk desktop environment
I find it remarkable that there really doesn't seem like a lot of momentum to innovate the desktop. I'm dead sick of Windows and Mint is just a carbon copy.

I want several, hard, discrete desktops. I want one that I can toss a bunch of graphics files onto that has something kin to "Fences" so I don't have to navigate the file explorer. And with the flick of a button I can move to a different desktop that I've set up for work, one for play and etc... I think Ubuntu used to have something similar, though I wouldn't be surprised if it actually behaves much like Windows and is just a window manager.

I do a lot on the desktop to specifically avoid the file manager because file managers seem to be intrinsically unnavigable. And then there's inconsistencies between applications which is enough to press me ever closer to an aneurysm. Going between the Win10 file explorer and one from Win95 a la ImageJ is awful.

Shit, with a system like that I reckon you could almost get away without a file explorer.

brnaftr361··on Summers: Inflation Reached 18% in 2022 Using the Government's Previous Formula
This is an interesting take and it got me thinking. The replacement rate in the US is not 4. In fact, I would imagine that 4 is probably unsustainable. I like to see money more as a chemical gradient a la chemotaxis, though more clever people than I call it a carrot. With inflation the carrot is being removed, perhaps even being used as a stick. A superfluity of resources without controls of some sort may well lead to runaway growth, and I presume with the relative expenses of everything that there is an unsustainable imbalance at the fundamental level excess demand for intrinsically limited supply.

Of course the inflation model is applicable outside of the purely monetary. The more people you have the larger the labor army, and with each number added to that the less valuable the individual becomes even in terms of highly specialized labor, because ostensibly this can essentially be predicted with a distribution and with the way people are commoditized in most positions and companies these day, excellence is neither expected, sought for, nor wanted. This is still within the realms of the economists wheelhouse.

I would argue there's a third inflation, social inflation, as well. And this essentially hinges on the same principal that the labor army does: more people, less individual value (“a single death is a tragedy, a million deaths are a statistic”). And I would posit that the decrements have been seriously exacerbated in this realm by social media, television, celebrity, and so forth. I would also point out that the civil rights movement and women's lib has also (rightly) had a profound effect on social orientation that has yet to fully manifest itself.

If I recall correctly many developed nations have declining "native" populations. I'm unsure of the causal factors, but I wouldn't be surprised if it was in some ways an instinctual aversion to these sorts scaling laws. If I'm not mistaken Dunbar's number is roughly adhered to in nature, so it makes sense that there is somewhat of a drive to limit pack/civilizations size.

brnaftr361··on Why drivers risk tickets instead of parking in their garages
This is really frustrating and I would argue feeds into a lot of accessibility issues even outside the more salient points surrounding the handicapped.

The fact that vehicles have grown so large that on-street parking has become virtually necessary is a frustration I've had to deal with frequently as a driver, pedestrian, and cyclist, moreover, just using the street for recreation has become more hazardous. It's even more frustrating when it's done for the sake of convenience. Trebly so when some dickhead parks their RV in the road at an intersection which forces everyone to, quite literally, pull into the lane to see if there's oncoming traffic. And I'm still waiting to get doored while cycling by some dipshit parked on-street for their half-mile unburdened commute since despite the very evident easy-reasonable-good use for our 4mi² town bike lanes are actually just parking.

All of this makes roadfaring in any capacity unnecessarily obnoxious, and I would say it's a glaring oversight which has many, many invisible downstream costs.

brnaftr361··on The history of lead pencils and their lack of any lead (2021)
Same, though on both counts it was totally unintentional.

Sorry, Logan.

brnaftr361··on Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?
Conversely, were over-diagnosing and now everyone is ill.

Which necessarily follows because the closer you look the fewer people are "normal". In fact I'd go so far as to posit that everyone is aberrant, to nobody's surprise.

And of course this is all derivated from a basis of largely qualitative soft-science which had ought be treated as an art than it is a science, however there are pressures which force both practitioners and researchers to justify it as a science.

I'm sure there's some "law of self-awareness" as well. The closest analogy I have is the January Effect which describes an even in the market, a pattern of sell-off in the later year to mark a loss, and subsequent repurchase in January. Upon this pattern being disclosed, the market adapted strategies to exploit it which ultimately resulted in a complete silencing of the effect. In a sense more applicable to this, being diagnosed with some mental illness can also be leveraged to gain favor, I mean I can get a prescription for pharmaceutical grade amphetamines for fidgeting for instance; or excuse my bad behavior with some other diagnosis.

My position is that it's all very unclear. I'm lazy and don't care to dig it up but there was a study from the UK that observed the measurable effects from school based, non-individual interventions and it found their effects to be significantly detrimental for some students - to the extent that they negated the aggregate benefits - which I think supports this position because treatment can exacerbate things. And that's without mentioning pharmacological interventions which are... Interesting.

brnaftr361··on Steve Wozniak and Stuart Brand Discuss Control of IP (1984) [video]
I don't think that's fair. There are a lot of instances where people go out of their way to experiment with systems despite limited literacy. The example that seems most salient is PSP homebrew, something I was doing at the age of 13 without a single hint of how anything computer related functioned.

The question becomes one of community and accessibility, and community begets accessibility. Opening source allows for easier access to fundamental aspects and lowers the "activation energy" of the whole process to develop and thus invites greater participation. Like how many man-hours get spent probing for vulnerabilities that enable jailbreaking? And note that these are specialized rarefied man-hours, and the whole system is also adversarial in that those seeking to crack the code are in competition with those trying to conceal it.

Pull all that out and make it all accessible and perhaps 13-year-old me would've tried to recode that 64x64 limit on the icons and learned something in the process, enable, iterate, participate...

brnaftr361··on Oregon undoes groundbreaking drug decriminalization law
I think one of the elements at play here is the appeal of not facing criminal charges for use. Because Oregon opted for early adoption, Oregon became a hotspot. It makes some sense that this would create a disproportionate response, and draw in both high-functioning and low-functioning users as well as their counterparties e.g. dealers. Any read taken from Oregon can't really be representative of what a uniform policy would look like if deployed nationally.

https://psmag.com/social-justice/people-addiction-simply-gro...

I think that's an interesting take and it's a pattern that I, too, experienced as a young adult. Tossing users into categories of addiction is pretty trivial because, in essence, the current definitions preclude non-addictive use because use itself is illegal and addiction indicates - legally - that actions in violation of the law are characteristic of addiction. All of this really requires an intimate understanding of the individual which is something I don't expect a system-wide approach is ever going to be meaningfully successful at. And additionally I think it serves the point to realize that everybody has a unique relationship with substances, the one-size-fits-all, which is more or less what we have, is only going to exacerbate the severity and elongate the course of suffering inflicted on individuals who would otherwise naturally and of their own volition course-correct because they're put through the same meat grinder as the smaller handful of extreme cases.

It's masterful projection, but I bargained drug use for a steep enhancement in my quality of life and a potential future that was less bleak and otherwise easier than a gambling on success and failure in a more challenging and less hospitable existence which would allow me to continue my substance use pattern. In other words I cleaned up for a decent job. There's a lot of places where that simply isn't an accessible option - creating those opportunities is a win-win though. I think that may be the best modality.

brnaftr361··on GIMP 2.99.18: The last development preview before 3.0
Homogenizing expected behavior is a pretty good idea, it allows open source software to compete at a commodity level instead of a principle or fundamentals level - which considering the open source position would make a pretty good deal of sense as quite a lot of it is free, e.g. GIMP, Inkscape...

Hypothetically if GIMP just copied the photoshop UI and expected behavior a lot of tutorials for PS translate directly making GIMP accessible, which ultimately plays to the favor of GIMP as it is more accessible in that it's open source, free, and doesn't require subscription or accounting.

Also since GIMP is decentralized and volunteer-ran it'd be interesting to see exactly what Adobe would do about it, if they could even do anything.

Something else that would be nice to see from the open source community would be standardization in the control schema across software. For instance I use Blender a lot, but I also use Inkscape, and jumping between the two is... Less than pleasant because there's a pretty significant amount of overlap, but none of it is able to be homogeneous as there is some hard coding that a keymap alone doesn't allow for convergence.

brnaftr361··on A quantitative test of Diamond’s axis of orientation hypothesis
The Horde didn't let that stop them, nor the Romans, not the Spaniards. Certainly there were bottlenecks, but there's instances of insane trade networks for instance Indus Valley artifacts turning up in the EU region and South American bird feathers in the Eastern US. Certainly there's some leakage here and there. And indeed it's known to anthropology that there are many systems to obviate inbreeding in tribal societies, Aboriginals come to mind.

Graeber's proposition, if memory serves, was that while many of the programmatic approaches are true, human volition ultimately decides. I bring that up because the more I think about it the more evident it becomes, it's not just technology but just about anything.

And that was also true of his assertions on the sharing and adoption of technology - for instance North American native tribes refused to adopt the obviously superior instruments of their neighbors for cultural reasons.

← PreviousPage 2 of 13Next →