HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

brokenmusic

260 karma · joined January 4, 2010

submissionscomments
brokenmusic··on The Massachusetts Software Tax
You must understand, that the absence of a state is not equal to the absence of those organizations. The state simply taught you that only it can build and operate them. But the truth is, the demand for those things doesn't vanish with the absence of a state.
brokenmusic··on The Massachusetts Software Tax
You can only vote once in 4 years. I, on the other hand, can stop paying any private company at any point in time if I believe a company hurts me or other members of the society. I don't see how that situation makes a company less accountable.

In practice, private companies don't need to maximize profits at the expense of poor. In Russia, for example, ISPs are competing hard against each other and internet is dirt cheap, you could have a 30mbps connection for around $7/mo. No regulation.

But suppose you're right. Suppose companies would maximize profit and the way to do it would be by not providing service to poor people. It doesn't make it okay to steal money (in the form of taxes) from me. Ask me nicely and give me a REAL option to not pay, and I may as well pay even more than required. But IRS are not nice people. They make people's lives difficult at the slightest hint of tax evasion.

brokenmusic··on The Massachusetts Software Tax
Surely no private company can ever come up with such technological marvel as taps and tubes and water in them.
brokenmusic··on The Massachusetts Software Tax
If only I was paid 1 satoshi every time someone brings up roads, police and all that stuff when I say taxes are theft, I'd have more than Satoshi has.

Just try to imagine how a society without a government could function and still have all the things we currently have. Try to come up with solutions. Think about the demand side of the equation. Just for once, try to imagine how to organize things in a world where it's, for some reason, impossible to create a government. You'd be surprised of your own ingenuity.

brokenmusic··on The Massachusetts Software Tax
Until people realize that all taxes are theft, they're doomed to have new taxes imposed on the most productive of them. It's really a simple test to see whether taxes are theft or not: if there was no way for IRS to find out how much money anyone made, would people still be paying taxes? My guess is that 90% of people who preach about the social contract and helping the poor would keep the money.
brokenmusic··on Obama pledges greater surveillance transparency
Obama is not a disaster. He is a great product of a system called democracy, where people are taught to believe they are free and can make a difference by voting.
brokenmusic··on Obama pledges greater surveillance transparency
Also, note how he put it: "the american people NEED to have confidence". Because WESAYSO.
brokenmusic··on Obama pledges greater surveillance transparency
When people say "but government is supposed to do that" it sounds almost like a religious belief. Just because the holy book - in this case, the constitution - says so, it doesn't mean it is so. It also doesn't mean we should somehow fix the government. When a religious person complains his priest is not praying hard enough for him that's why he's not doing so good, the solution is NOT to find a better priest.

But a less abstract reply to your comment should be this: what does protecting privacy and communication mean in the case of NSA doing it, how is it done specifically and why does it make you safer?

brokenmusic··on Obama pledges greater surveillance transparency
So can you tell me how has NSA protected you? What has it done?
brokenmusic··on Obama pledges greater surveillance transparency
"It's not enough for me as president to have confidence in these programmes; the American people need to have confidence as well."

Great tactic. Redefine the problem. NSA is not the problem. Confidence is.

brokenmusic··on They Know Much More Than You Think
I completely agree with you on not accepting the violent way of changing things and on the fact the system has gone too far to be changed through instituted processes.

One non-violent way of changing things I see is to use Bitcoin for saving and transactions as much as possible, because I don't feed the system with my tax money and confiscation through inflation. It's not perfect, but to me it's far superior to anything we have so far.

Look at it this way. If a thief on the street approaches you and tries to rob you, you have three ways: 1) beg him to not rob you (wouldn't work) 2) fight (would work, but you can get hurt) and 3) pretend you don't have any money (in which case he might as well decide to not bother with you if you can convince him you really don't have it).

brokenmusic··on ‘US-Russian relations above Snowden case' – Putin
It's almost as if Putin makes a facepalm and says "Dude, Edward, what the hell? Why would you do this?". And Putin, mind you, is very aware of the balances of power and the GAME. I think he sees very clearly how all this plays out: public at large won't give a shit over time, Snowden is forgotten, governments keep on doing what they've been doing for a long time: farming and milking their citizens.
brokenmusic··on Freedom: The Big American Lie
Interesting. If you look at history, it is precisely governments and empires that produced more violence than anyone else. The bloodiest, most devastating wars are all the result of government action. Even the most bloodiest anarchist in the world cannot come close to what an average "peaceful" state has done in his lifetime.

Violence is inherent, at least at this point of our development, in human species. Question is, what brings about more violence. I would argue, that it's the idea that we need some sort of government. This very idea creates the incentive for sociopaths and bandits to get into politics and allows the ruling class to continuously keep fucking the population.

brokenmusic··on Freedom: The Big American Lie
Not true. 1) Is gets a lot harder and more expensive to collect taxes when you have to conduct audits 2) It is impossible to collect the inflation tax 3) It's easier to control people when you can close down or freeze their bank accounts for any reason you like.

Bitcoin offers a lot of freedom at a price of learning a little bit about the technology.

brokenmusic··on Freedom: The Big American Lie
Why do you want a government so much?
brokenmusic··on Freedom: The Big American Lie
You know what I don't really get? Why do we need anyone to give power to? Keep it to yourself. We've got everything we really need to make ourselves happy and live our lives. Why do people so desperately need someone to reign over them? This sounds like a Stockholm syndrome.
brokenmusic··on Freedom: The Big American Lie
To be perfectly honest, I wasn't saying exactly that. Yes, you got the point right: if you don't like the services a private company provides - stop paying. It works. With government it has historically been impossible to do, because it controls money supply and extracts taxes with the threat of force (don't want to pay? Go to prison). Bitcoin offers a simple non-violent and effective way out of this, because it would be prohibitively expensive to collect taxes if people used Bitcoin. It would only be possible when they converted it to fiat or physical things big enough to be noticed and tracked (like houses or cars). Thus, my point: use Bitcoin as a unit of exchange and don't pay a cut.
brokenmusic··on Freedom: The Big American Lie
All I said that NSA, Drones and imprisonment of the population for victimless crimes requires money. I would also claim that if taxes were not collected (or would be impossible to collect) with a threat of force, very little number of people would pay them voluntarily. Also, if people were not forced by law to use national currencies for exchanging goods and services, they wouldn't be subject to hidden taxes, such as inflation. Bitcoin makes taxes prohibitively expensive to collect and inflation impossible. How is it an oversimplification then?
brokenmusic··on Freedom: The Big American Lie
> The answer, to a depressing extent, is that our basic freedoms are threatened today because our political system and our very culture make it nearly impossible for us to act.

That's why action should not come as an open fight. History is full of examples when revolutions only lead to blood, after which other elites simply take over and keep exploiting everyone else. Or, alternatively, revolutions fail and after a bloody fight the same elites stay in power.

If you want real change and bloodless revolution, start using Bitcoin. Don't pay them a cut if you disagree with what your money are spent on. It's not democracy that keeps politicians in check. It's simply money. If they have none, they're powerless.

brokenmusic··on Show HN: I made an app that wakes you up when Bitcoin price changes dramatically
I don't know, it probably took him a month or so of work to make it decent. You can probably craft something unreliable in a week. Is it worth it? Also, if you have around 50-100 btc on the exchange, you can easily make 10btc if you catch the right moment. $10 sounds like a good deal to me, although I'm not a trader, so I guess I might not be the target audience.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2