HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

brongondwana

4,509 karma · joined January 9, 2012

CEO of Fastmail Pty Ltd

co-chair of IETF CALEXT, EXTRA, JMAP and SEDATE working groups

Cyrus IMAP developer

Parent, Group Fitness Instructor, Chorister, Human

submissionscomments
brongondwana··on A SpamAssassin Surprise
We have a much better account recovery process than, say, Protonmail where if you lose your encryption key then you really are screwed.

Obviously, the more information we have about you, the easier it is for you to prove your identity! Often the people who lose all their credentials and can't get the account back at all are the ones who used anonymous payment methods, clear all their cookies, use a fake name. Hard to identify those!

But generally, we help people regain access with a combination of payment method, backup communication methods they have registered with us like another email address or a phone number, and at the most extreme - Government ID. Provide enough of those and survive the lockout period in which we've informed the person with access to the account and given them a chance to object, we can get you back in.

Seriously the "24 hour lockout while we make sure nobody is accessing the account" is a pretty key part of slowing down attacks - generally if someone's identity is stolen then the attacker's main advantage is speed rushing through all their other accounts, so the slow-down is hugely advantageous.

brongondwana··on A SpamAssassin Surprise
Thanks! We're all pretty happy to keep doing what we're doing for a long time yet :) Have plenty of new stuff on the go (see the email work happening at IETF, a lot of it's being led or shepherded by someone from Fastmail)

AI is... yeah. I can see in theory being able to have an AI answer questions like "who sent me a question I haven't replied to yet?" or "who have I emailed something expecting a response to and not heard back from?" could be powerful - but the tech is really immature and it hallucinates the craziest things. I don't think it's something we need to do in-house - it's something that could be added on with an IMAP or JMAP connector for those who want it.

brongondwana··on A SpamAssassin Surprise
Obviously :) We're just the best!

More: Fastmail is a bunch of techies who really enjoy working with email and unlike a lot of the big companies we have a core of people who've been doing this stuff for 20 years, but are also keeping up with (or even writing) the latest standards. It's a good combination.

ok, ok - I haven't been at Fastmail for 20 years yet. That's still a couple of weeks away.

brongondwana··on Introducing passkey support to Fastmail
You cite a 5 year old post. We have improved things since then. You can't spoof other people through Fastmail any more, we verify permission to send as any address - either through your account owning the domain or alias - or by authenticating the specific address by confirming you can receive an email there.

If you have your own domain, you can set whatever DMARC policy you like on it. We'll DKIM sign your email for you if your domain is configured to use the keys we create for you, or do your own outbound email as you want.

Also the whole thing about STARTTLS is bogus - that site says "Unable to determine STARTTLS status" - too right. Because we're not listening on those ports. Because that's less secure that only allowing the SSL/TLS ports.

We have written about our reasoning here: https://www.fastmail.help/hc/en-us/articles/360058753834-SSL...

The key paragraph is this:

Today, many email services, including Fastmail, now disable plain text IMAP and POP logins entirely on ports 143 and 110, leaving encrypted connections on ports 993 and 995 as the only option. This makes sure all clients use encrypted SSL/TLS connections to protect sensitive data.

(Disclosure: I'm the CEO at Fastmail)

brongondwana··on K-9 Mail is poised to be Thunderbird for Android
Thanks, I appreciate the kind words. I'm very agreeable; mostly. And quite likeable!

Also keen to see JMAP more widely out there of course, we're plugging away at getting Calendar and Contacts into JMAP over at IETF now. Slowly becoming the full service protocol we've always dreamed of being.

brongondwana··on Encryption at Rest: Whose Threat Model Is It Anyway?
Never underestimate the bandwidth of a stationwagon loaded with tapes.

Arguably, your position is bogus. Why cause a bunch of extra copying around to move a server. "Back up" indeed - to what? Another disk? It's turtles all the way down.

brongondwana··on Proton Mail discloses user data leading to arrest in Spain
I've just been poking around at the Dropbox APIs recently when I got so frustrated by the fact that the Fastmail "attach from Dropbox" feature has been loading directly into my personal files space rather than showing the shared team folders since we switched over to using those last year - and I now have to download and re-upload files from those folders.

It's more than a glorified FTP. FTP does some heinous things with a separate control channel and stuff (let me tell you about adding encryption support to the Perl FTP server some other day), but this is next level!

https://developers.dropbox.com/dbx-team-files-guide

It's not even as simple as just sending a fixed string in the "Dropbox-API-Path-Root" header for every API request (and they're all path based, so you have to make sure you always send that header or the paths won't parse right) - you have to get an ID for the real root, with a separate request, with a scope that we weren't requesting on refresh tokens.

So I hacked together something that worked on my testbed on the train ride home, but making it good is going to include adding a caching layer to the token refresh code, and suddenly it's not just a casual project. I'm still going to do it though, because dammit I have a file to attach to an email on Friday and I'm happy to spend hours on this to save myself 30 seconds.

brongondwana··on Caniemail.com – like caniuse but for email content
Yeah, this is a common request :) I've added your prod to the "this is common" data
brongondwana··on Caniemail.com – like caniuse but for email content
Ctrl-D to format the selected text as monospace in the Fastmail composer is pretty nice - I use it often for sending bits of log line or terminal output when writing up incidents or describing how to do something.
brongondwana··on Caniemail.com – like caniuse but for email content
Huh? You can paste if you have an image in your buffer, or drag-drop image files into an email in the Fastmail composer. I paste images into emails from screenshots almost every day.

(I'll take this report as a "we need to make it clearer you can do this!")

brongondwana··on How to (and how not to) design REST APIs
I would extend Rule 6 much more into Rule 7 - if you're returning an id which is numeric, prefix it with a non-number, so it won't get accidentally converted to a number. This has been a particular pain with Perl (yes, it's still used in place) JSON libraries, where knowing if you're going to serialise to a string or a number is quite dependent on how the variable has been touched - so things like stringifying it in a debug line might change the output.

If you make it so your ID is never something that Excel can incorrectly assume is a date, you're making life better for everybody.

brongondwana··on Tell HN: Fastmail is leaking internal routing email address/username with teams
Your comment here is factually incorrect - the "X-Resolved-To" will not be present anywhere in the email if you Reply, or with a regular Forward.

It will only be present if you "Forward as Attachment" an email which was sent to your alias or masked address, which adds the raw MIME message as an attachment - including all headers.

(the OP did get this correct)

brongondwana··on RFC 3339 vs. ISO 8601
If the timezone name changes, chances are I no longer want to meet at 6pm in London in 10 years' time without double-checking a few things.
brongondwana··on An America-Less Internet
Ooh, that's obnoxious, you're being routed the long way around the world because the closest cloudflare entry point is Singapore, by the looks of things.

It's not massively worse than what I get from here:

11. 103.168.172.63 0.0% 5 251.0 251.2 250.8 251.9 0.5

We're using cloudflare for DDoS protection and hence our packets all go into their edge where they get scrubbed before being passed to our hosts. They don't inspect the content at all, so they can't terminate early, which means every packet is round tripping that 350ms.

BUT - JMAP should still mean it's only a couple of round trips to have a fully loaded mailbox.

brongondwana··on An America-Less Internet
We don't control those databases. I've tried to update them. We're very clear about where our servers are.

We switched to those IPs from a range which was owned by our old datacenter and we were continuing to lease, to give us more network independence and the ability to route our range through better DDoS protection systems.

brongondwana··on An America-Less Internet
Yeah, that is pretty painful - how does it compare to other sites in the USA? I'd be interested in seeing a traceroute. JMAP is designed to be pretty good in that situation (we're in Australia and ~280ms away from our primary datacenter) with minimal round-trips.
brongondwana··on An America-Less Internet
Yeah it's registered and owned in Australia, but routing to the USA. I've tried updating what I can with geolocation databases.

Interestingly this is fun for the IETF's netblock, which usually geolocates my phone to the previous city we met in, 4 months prior! Heuristic guesses create some crazy stuff sometimes.

brongondwana··on An America-Less Internet
We're there because it's where we've found reliable enough remote hands and network. And yes, the thread model of "the USA goes off the internet" is bad enough that we figure things are much worse than us being much use at that point.

And regarding the privacy risk, we haven't seen a credible threat that would have our servers accessed directly by US law enforcement that isn't just as credible anywhere else in the world. It hasn't happened, we don't believe it will happen.

So yeah, we disappear in an interesting little thought experiment like this one (despite having Australian-owned IP space, it's advertised and routed into our US locations, so fair enough it's blocked in this case)

I do think the timing is ripe for us to look at having more datacenters around the world again. We have had both Iceland and Amsterdam locations in the past, and neither were reliable enough to put production traffic to, multiple hour network outages and inability to contact support and get them fixed - but maybe the landscape has changed enough that it's viable again now.

brongondwana··on JMAP – a modern email open standard
Perfectly legitimate question - and I don't think you should have been downvoted for asking.

We're entirely funded by our customers, and fully self-bootstrapped. We have no debts to outside parties.

We have 8 owners, 7 of which work in the business and the 8th is the brother of one of the founders (and only owns a couple of percent).

Source: I'm CEO. Have worked here since 2004, through the Opera acquisition (I moved to Norway for nearly 2 years) and back. We've controlled our growth such that we keep our spending under our income - I know, what a shocking idea in current day!

brongondwana··on JMAP – a modern email open standard
Also, every website would have to have a way to do this. That's a massive bootstrapping effort that, you can't change every website in the world very easily, there'd have to be a very massive advantage for them. I don't see the evolutionary pathway to get your suggestion implemented.

Besides, this already exists anyway, it's basically:

brong+secretkey@fastmail.com

Or if you have fastmail style subaddressing:

secretkey@brong.fastmail.com

brongondwana··on Ask HN: Most interesting tech you built for just yourself?
Back in 2001-ish, looking for a rental house with good public transport. Screen scraped the entire realestate.com.au database overnight, then fed the addresses into some mapping API that gave me coordinates, and caluclated the distance from those addresses to the addresses of Zone 1 train stations.

Also had descriptions, so wrote a simple regex based scorer that classified the descriptions by keywords that I valued. Spat out a hitlist of likely candidate houses to go inspect.

...

Also wrote a basic wedding registry that allowed people to scan our list of things we wanted and say they had purchased them, or were interested and it gave a list of others who might want to go in on a group purchase. No privacy, but it was only sent to friends. Circa 2004.

...

Finally, wrote a diary and calendar tool which took emails with very simply structured subjects and built a static website showing travels through Europe in 2002. Could email from any net cafe with any email address and it would update the travel diary, or a website with a calendar saying which city we were in and how we were traveling to the next one. Friends could elect to get immediate updates or a daily summary. Purely static built from cron and email archives. Worked like a charm.

...

More recently, hmm... as treasurer for various choir things I've written a ton of little commandline tools which give very quick access to data and allow tracking who owes what and logging their payments into a database, and tools which generate email invoices and receipts.

Everything else is either opensource or work stuff. And I don't code so much these days either, though this week I started diving into Python to create tools that help keep data for our marketing team up-to-date without manually copying stuff around, and some maintenance work on code I wrote 15 years ago which is still running really nicely but needs some updates.

brongondwana··on Messaging layer security: Secure and usable end-to-end encryption
Yep, you can apply for a fee waiver if that's a significant challenge, but this org costs quite a lot to run (there's quite a big staff keeping the meeting running).

Having said that, the pricing for remote participants is currently a major topic of discussion.

https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-shmoo-remote-fee...

brongondwana··on Messaging layer security: Secure and usable end-to-end encryption
The MIMI working group is meeting at IETF116 in Yokohama RIGHT NOW. I'm sitting in the meeting.

There's a live audio stream at https://datatracker.ietf.org/group/mimi/meetings/ or the video will be posted later after the meeting. You can also find links from that page to the charter, mailing list, etc, if you want to get involved.

brongondwana··on Focus on things that don't change
Interesting that he identifies three things and then comments on the two which really ARE obviously true long term and not on the third which is much more debatable.

When I go to Amazon I'd often prefer a smaller selection of items for common categories, with better price/quality tradeoff information, and an assurance that I wasn't going to get an inferior substitute.

Not that it's an EASY problem to solve, particularly at Amazon's scale, but it's also the thing where it's most likely that a customer will come up and say "Jeff, I just want to be able to order a USB key that has the capacity it claims without having to wade through thousands of shady vendors".

brongondwana··on Sabre/dav: open-source CardDAV, CalDAV and WebDAV server
Cyrusimap has support for all three of these baked in as well, and we really don't make as much of a big deal of it as we should.

(and of course: JMAP Calendars/Contacts/Files(eventually) will replace all that, we hope!)

brongondwana··on The Untold Story of SQLite (2021)
I had some Perl at a previous job which would produce a multi-thousand line SQL statement that was pasted into a phppgadmin screen to get a data set out. Awful workaround but it was smooth and fast. Very nice db to work with
brongondwana··on Ask HN: If I get locked out of everything, please try to help me
This is highly frustrating and it sucks.

Also Google is totally doing the right thing here. The slow down and wait is precisely the thing that protects you from identity theft if somebody waits until your phone is turned off, clones your SIM, and pretends to be in precisely this situation.

Hopefully in THAT case, you notice the "somebody is trying to get into your account" and say "no, this is a hack attempt".

Good luck.

brongondwana··on A gut-derived hormone suppresses sugar appetite/regulates food choice Drosophila
The thing that worked for me was time restriction. I can't reliably count calories but I can quite easily look at the clock and decide whether it's feeding hours or fasting hours. Doesn't make it easy, but made it possible.

(lost 20ish kg first time with fitness and diet change, put most of it back on over many years due largely to buffet lunch in the office followed by bad habits, lost it again by using time restriction and that seems to have stuck so far)

brongondwana··on JMAP: It’s Like IMAP but Not Really (2019)
I have more faith in JMAP's eventual success than you do, but I do agree that it's frustratingly slow. We knew that adoption would be frustrating slow of course, but I do hope that in 3 years' time we'll have a much better story than we have had in the three years since initial standardisation of the core and mail parts.

Certainly once calendars and contacts are done, and hopefully tasks as well, that will make a more complete ecosystem that is even more attractive than just the email component!

brongondwana··on JMAP: It’s Like IMAP but Not Really (2019)
Hey, I love IMAP. For all its faults it is pretty powerful and good.

I've spent a lot of time on it, but the reasons that JMAP was developed still exist and are still valid :)

← PreviousPage 3 of 26Next →