600 karma · joined October 4, 2010
It doesn't apply to those of thus who aren't well educated and otherwise have remunerative. full disclosure: i went to a shitty public high school in Los Angeles and learned basic math and writing at university.
so while you don't need college/university you absolutely need 1-3. I picked up #1 in university because i went to a lousy, impoverished high school. I mostly taught myself #2 and #3. A new learning community focused on narrow skill acquisition won't help students acquire 1-3.
Investing in basic education will fix these problems, both investing in teachers and in pushing kids to just fucking study and take learning seriously.
This article is the "High Cost of Low Teacher Salaries" http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/01/opinion/01eggers.html?_r=1... is much more relevant in my opinion.
best of luck w/ skillshare but please don't think it will teach calculus to people who can't add.
While mikekarnj has some interesting points about education and the obvious higher ed bubble, he is apparently unaware of education concept of "scaffolding" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instructional_scaffolding
Take kids from wealthy, well-educated families and put them in small groups with educators that also happen to be very well-educated and very passionate and you will get great results whatever the pedagogy.
Contrast this w/ poor kids whose parents had low educational attainments, stuck in giant classes with poorly-paid teachers.
If you put 6 well-off kids with 1 passionate, well-educated teacher, you will get good results almost every time.
Montessori approach may have its merits but I find it very hard to separate them from the demographics of its students and teachers. The study in Milwaukee does not seem sufficient to establish a link. Those passionate about teaching are probably more likely to be attracted to the Montessori school than the regular public schools because it has a distinctive approach and probably more liberal management.
I would love to love to know if the Montessori schools in teh Milwaukee school had the same teacher/student ratio as the other schools in the study. I am betting they didn't.
That said, I believe that the geeks I hired are totally world class. I also believe that w/in 5 years time they will be earning 100,000 USD per year, whether they are living in Nepal or elsewhere. cuz, they are worth it.
If doctors didn't make so much $, I am convinced that women would make up the majority of doctors.
If I was this kid I would go to SUNY Binghamton
A good school can help you but you really have to ask yourself if it worth $200,000 USD
Also, this 18 year old may change his mind in two years about his major and decide that he wants to teach high school science, in which case he will be screwed financially.
I still haven't seen any significant revelations come out of wikileaks, so I think they were right to not pick Assange