HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

busyant

3,027 karma · joined July 20, 2008

a guy who does things
submissionscomments
busyant··on Is mathematics about to enter the conservatory?
> And without mathematicians to ask the right questions

Here, I disagree. What makes you think the AI won't be able to ask the right questions without prompting?

> and able to appreciate the results, why would AI driven research continue?

Here, I think I agree. At some level, there has to be a human in the process that must understand / interpret the results.

I gotta say, however, that I'm not certain about my agreement. I'm worried that I'm missing something where the human can be excised from the process entirely.

busyant··on GLP-1s are being linked to fewer serious infections, including TB
> we should be putting this in the water supply...

Talked to a physician last year who said the entire planet should be on GLP-1s.

busyant··on Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacBook in OpenAI suit
I worked at a pharmaceutical start-up years ago.

* one of our medicinal chemists had studied nights to become a patent agent (this isn't the bad part).

* he landed a pretty nice job at an IP firm with a considerable raise in his salary.

* we were _in the middle of his farewell party_ when the IT guy told the CEO that during the previous few days the chemist had printed our company's entire library of novel chemical structures and their associated biological activity data.

* in the moment, i had no idea what was happening, but i've never seen someone go from looking happy to absolutely miserable at their own farewell party.

* i do remember that my boss later said she wanted him frog-marched out of the building in handcuffs.

busyant··on CEO fired developers to make room for AI. Developers create open source AI CEO
I'm waiting for the press release where both organizations merge.
busyant··on Anthropic tells staff to work from home due to possible security team strike
For my amusement, I recently asked ChatGPT whether OpenAI and Anthropic were worth their proposed valuations or whether they'd be "kneecapped" by the Chinese models etc.

It gave me a long, detailed explanation which boiled down to, "Maybe Anthropic will be worth the 1T market cap if xyz happen, but unless something fundamentally changes w/ OpenAI, they are NOT worth anywhere near 1T"

Here's a quote from ChatGPT:

"And if I had $1 million that had to be invested today in either OpenAI at $852B or Anthropic at $965B, with a 5–7 year lockup: I'd put the entire $1 million into Anthropic. Not 60/40. 100/0 Anthropic."

busyant··on Ask HN: What is one simple thing LLMs are insanely bad at?
Identifying bird species from photos that I upload.

To be clear, it depends on what your definition of "insanely bad" is.

I'd say ChatGPT/Gemini make egregious mistakes on ~10% of my photo uploads.

I recently uploaded a photo of a short-billed dowitcher and ChatGPT told me that it was a Wilson's snipe, explaining all sorts of details about the legs and tail feathers (neither of which were visible in my pic!).

I then followed up explaining that a Wilson's snipe hadn't been seen at my location since last November (and that Wilson's snipe was out of season at my location) and Chat revised its estimate downward to 85% Wilson's snipe.

Again, I followed up and I revealed the precise location of the bird and ChatGPT said something like "oh yeah, 99% short-billed dowitcher"!

I've had similar experiences w/ Gemini (haven't tested Claude).

Again, 90% success rate is pretty good, but the other 10% of the time, the 2 LLMs that I use fail on species ID and often hallucinate features on bird photos.

edits for typos, plus another example from the same "birding outing" the other day.

I uploaded a very clear photo of a sparrow.

* ChatGPT says "song sparrow"

* I explain, "no way. this sparrow has yellow over its eye and the breast is wrong for song sparrow."

* ChatGPT: Oh yeah, savannah sparrow

* I explain, beak is too big for savannah sparrow.

* ChatGPT: Oh yeah, saltmarsh sparrow.

* I expalin, "no orange on the bird's face."

* ChatGPT: oh yeah, seaside sparrow (finally correct!)

busyant··on Canada will match US tariffs 'dollar for dollar' as trade talks break down
I've mentioned that episode as an analogy to current affairs to anyone who will listen.
busyant··on One Oakland police officer made $490k in overtime
> Whoever it is, that's always the case in government. It's not their money and any accountability like this is so rare

The guy who sold me my last car at my Toyota dealership was in his late 50s.

What's weird is that he told me that I would be his 1st sale!

I asked him what he did before and he said he was "in construction" but that it was a young man's game.

Something didn't add up and I googled his name.

Turns out that he was a former state police officer, ensnared in a fake overtime scandal. He served a prison sentence and lost his pension. I think the scandal nailed a few more cops, too.

busyant··on 50k Boat Names
> if you’re rich you don’t need to own a boat, you can spend more per day to rent if you want to use one.

There's a bit by Bill Burr where he says something like "you don't want to be the guy that 'owns the boat' (too much upkeep). You want to be the friend of the guy that owns the boat (you supply a case of beer every time you go out and your friend supplies the boat)."

busyant··on Why Wall Street is ignoring big tech's debt [video]
I can't tell if you're being serious or sarcastic.

In case it's the former, nobody in the corporate world is using Linux desktops.

And let me know when your parents start using the Chinese LLMs on their own.

busyant··on Why Wall Street is ignoring big tech's debt [video]
> the average worker can do most of their tasks with 5% of the api costs using an open source model from China and achieve the same results.

Are you also going to tell me that everyone will be switching to their favorite Linux desktop distribution over Mac & Win because it's "free"?

busyant··on Changes at Google DeepMind: Demis Hassabis from CEO to Chair, Jeff Dean departs
> I'm a researcher in the field and I definitely take AGI seriously

> I just think LLMs are a dead end for AGI.

I have no background in CS, so apologies if this is a naive question, but what makes you take AGI seriously, but also say that LLMs are a dead end?

i.e., is there something else that you think is not a dead end?

busyant··on Netflix employee fired for sharing personal details in retreat trust exercise
I don't have any shocking story, but I also was once made to participate in a day long group bonding exercise.

one activity was for each member of our department to grade the overall "personality" of our department using several personality dimensions (e. g., kindness, competitiveness, etc.)

what I think i learned was that each of us projected our dominant personality traits onto the whole group.

eg, the hyper competitive climber said our department was cutthroat.

the guy who avoided conflict said it was a happy department with few disagreements.

etc.

beyond that insight, I didn't learn much.

busyant··on Show HN: I replaced a $120k bowling center system with $1,600 in ESP32s
The substance of what you wrote is interesting on its own, but I wanted to compliment you on your writing style. It was an enjoyable read.
busyant··on AWS: Inaccurate Estimated Billing Data – $1.7 billion
Reminds me of the decimal point scene in Office Space.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fGHaVn5rGo

busyant··on Show HN: 18 Words
1. I'd prefer to reveal letters ... each press of the hint button reveals the position of one random letter.

2. I don't have a preference.

Very cool and well done.

busyant··on Weird Al Yankovic Pulled Out of AI Ad Deal: 'I Can't Be the Poster Boy for AI'
you'll like this https://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/due-to-a-clerical-error-...
busyant··on Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citizenship
> if you think that it's good to dilute the voice of people whose families have been here for a dozen generations by pretending that people who got here 15 minutes ago have the same values that's fine.

That smacks of entitlement. Yes. I know that the other side of the argument also smacks of entitlement. But I believe I have the 14th amendment on my side.

Also, there are a lot of assumptions baked into your statement. If you think that everyone here who can trace their roots back "a dozen generations" has your ideals, well, I've got $24 worth of trinkets to sell you.

Conversely, if you think that everyone here who is newly immigrated does not share your ideals, well, I have more trinkets.

The Mythology of America that I bought into was that it was a welcoming place where you could re-invent yourself in a way that was rarely possible in the country your were leaving.

And yes. I know it's a mythology--with kernels of truth to it.

But you have your own Mythology--and I find it unpalatable, both to me and my immigrant parents.

busyant··on SpaceX sheds $400B in market value as debut rally hits reverse
Explanation 1: You're lying / delusional about your success rate.

Explanation 2: Your trading "theory" is sound, but your theory requires specific and rare conditions to be met before you trade, so your 95-99% success rate only achieves modest gains.

busyant··on Show HN: I am building a map of people who lived in the Roman Empire
Very cool. I'd like to explore it, but I'm getting a lot of "page unresponsive" and I can't tell if it's a back-end server being swamped, or if it's something else.

My son just graduated with a double major in classics and molecular biology (doing informatics work), so maybe he could help! lol

busyant··on Mathematicians issue warning as AI rapidly gains ground
So ... how many people have you murdered in the name of advancing your goals?
busyant··on Mathematicians issue warning as AI rapidly gains ground
I think plenty of people "listened."

But what was his plan and how would you have proposed implementing it?

busyant··on Ferrari Luce
This is beautiful. Not a modern Ferrari, but still beautiful. La Luce, however, is best viewed *al buio."
busyant··on Ferrari Luce
I'm sure everyone at Ferrari HQ dutifully applauded when this was revealed.

You buy a Ferrari for the sex appeal.

But you nailed it. It's the Ferrari Priuso.

busyant··on Why is almost everyone right-handed? A new study connects it to bipedalism
Interesting!

Handedness is probably not (often) captured in healthcare records, but I'm wondering if epidemiologists could mine insurance claims (or some other data rich resource) to see if there's a correlation with serious outcomes (death, hospitalization, etc.) from venom and handedness.

busyant··on A message from President Kornbluth about funding and the talent pipeline
> Let Mississippi be Mississippi with Texas and Florida, let California find its own way with New York and Washington.

These places aren't homogeneous in their political tastes.

I live in a northeast blue state, but there are rural pockets that are still heavily MAGA. And I'm sure Mississippi has liberal enclaves.

That being said, I don't know what the "solution" to this problem is.

busyant··on Princeton mandates proctoring for in-person exams, upending 133 year precedent
> Because they are still trying to pull one over, to be cleverer, to be the 'good' one at whatever life is in their mind: A long fucking ladder covered in degrees and accolades and tears and jackasses. They live in the derivative.

OP here. I think you're attributing relatively sophisticated motivations to cheating. I've seen it at elite institutions and those that were far less prestigious.

I don't think the motivations for cheating are different in the Ivy League compared to any other institution.

If I can speculate on most motivations (no particular order), they would be:

- Failing would be an embarrassment (to me, my family, etc.) and I probably won't get caught.

- The work for this course is completely irrelevant to my career path. They're just making me jump through hoops. I'll work honestly after I cheat my way through this course.

- I'm pressed for time or other there are other external issues fucking up my life, so I don't have time to study. I could definitely understand the course material if <horrible issue in my life> weren't happening right now, so cheating isn't that big of a deal.

I think most of this is excuse-making, but the human mind is capable of magnificent self-deceptions.

A couple more points (not really addressed to you).

I agree with many other commenters who say that the school admins do not want you to drop problems like this at their doorstep. The prof. usually has to navigate these waters on his/her own.

I've told this story many times over the years and the most common response (also given here) is something like "I'm sure she's put her talents to great use on Wall Street". Gives you a sense of public perception of Wall Street--which I believe is largely accurate.

busyant··on Princeton mandates proctoring for in-person exams, upending 133 year precedent
I have no recollection of the student's name.

~150 students in the class, so they were all a blur.

This was also a few years before the web took hold, so I could not have "Google-stalked" her even if I had been so inclined.

I do remember my fellow TA's name! But that's probably not surprising.

busyant··on Princeton mandates proctoring for in-person exams, upending 133 year precedent
Unfortunately, I don't remember except that it seemed unjust to all the students who didn't cheat.

She certainly wasn't penalized, but I don't remember if she was given credit for her answer to Q2.

iirc, the student stopped attending my recitation after that.

busyant··on Princeton mandates proctoring for in-person exams, upending 133 year precedent
I was a grad student @ Princeton a handful of decades ago.

I was a TA for a few classes and, given the honor code, we did not proctor the exams for undergrads. We just handed them out (left the room) and returned to collect them at the end.

- One of the exams in a course that I TAed had 5 free-response questions.

- There were also 5 TAs in that class, so we un-stapled the exams and each TA graded one question (for consistency).

- We re-assembled the exams and returned them to the students.

- A few days after the exam, one of "my" students (she attended my recitation) came to me with her exam and explained that I had incorrectly graded question 2.

- I told her that I didn't grade question 2, so she had to go take it up with "TA # 2"

- A few hours later, "TA #2" pays me a visit and she (TA#2) is annoyed. She tells me, "Your student is trying to pull a fast one. She answered Q2 incorrectly. She erased her answer and put in the correct answer and she wants it re-graded"

- I briefly defended the student and said something like, "Why would she do that... and how could you even know?"

- "TA#2" responded with "... because I photocopied all of the student responses after I graded them."

- Then I felt like a piece of shit for doubting my fellow TA. And felt even worse being naive enough to not be suspicious.

- "TA#2" and I brought all of this info up with the prof. who was running the course.

- We were told that the situation would be handled by an Honor Committee or something like that. We forwarded the information to the committee, but no one spoke to us and we were not allowed to participate in the deliberations.

- After about a week, all we were told was that the student was able to explain the "discrepancy" between her exam and the photocopy.

To this day, I have no idea what that student could have possibly said to explain her actions.

After that, I started photocopying every damned scrap of paper that I graded.

edits for clarity. The student did not get a zero on the exam, nor was she booted from the course. I don't remember if she was given credit for Question 2, but the TA and I were both expecting her to be tossed, which obviously didn't happen.

← PreviousPage 2 of 22Next →