HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bwfan123

1,311 karma · joined December 10, 2024

submissionscomments
bwfan123··on We tasked Opus 4.6 using agent teams to build a C Compiler
> I can already feel the contracts coming to fix LLM slop

First, the agents will attempt to fix issues on their own. Most easy problems will be fixed or worked-around in this manner. The hard problems will require a deeper causal model of how things work. For these, the agents will give up. But, the code-base has evolved to a point where no-one understands whats going on including the agents and its human handlers. Expect your phone to ring at that point, and prepare to ask for a ransom.

bwfan123··on Surely the crash of the US economy has to be soon
> you might temper your expectations of a rational market

TSLA is like a snowball down a hill. It morphs from EV to autonomous driving to AI to robots to space to tera fab to space datacenters. Rolling in the next big narrative or gov handout as it speeds down the hill.

bwfan123··on Software Pump and Dump
There was also a mini bubble around social media aggregators and RSS feeds culminating in sites like gada.be

I see the dynamic as follows (be warned, cynical take)

1) there are the youth who are seeking approval from the community - look I have arrived - like the person building the steaming pile of browser code recently.

2) there are the veterans of a previous era who want to stay relevant in the new tech and show they still got mojo (gastown etc)

In both cases, the attitude is not one of careful deep engineering, craftsmanship or attention to the art, instead it reflects attention mongering.

bwfan123··on Prism
producing BS can be equated to generating statements without caring for their truth value. Generating them is easy. Refuting them requires one to find a proof or a contradiction which is a lot of work, and is equal to "solving" the statement. As an analogy, refuting BS is like solving satisfiability, whereas generating BS is like generating propositions.
bwfan123··on Case study: Creative math – How AI fakes proofs
I am actually surprised that the LLM came so close. I doubt it had examples in its training set for these numbers. This goes to the heart of "know-how". The LLM should should have said: "I am not sure" but instead gets into rhetoric to justify itself. It actually mimics human behavior for motivated reasoning. At orgs, management is impressed with this overconfident motivated reasoner as it mirrors themselves. To hell with the facts, and the truth, persuation is all that matters.
bwfan123··on GPTZero finds 100 new hallucinations in NeurIPS 2025 accepted papers
> It would be great if those scientists who use AI without disclosing it get fucked for life.

There need to be dis-incentives for sloppy work. There is a tension between quality and quantity in almost every product. Unfortunately academia has become a numbers-game with paper-mills.

bwfan123··on Show HN: I quit coding years ago. AI brought me back
> If LLMs are covering a gap here maybe there's an opportunity for better, local, lower-tech tooling that doesn't require such a huge tech stack (and subscriptions/rent) to solve simple, tractable problems?

I see this with every new technology stack. Way back, we had folks putting out browser "applets" to do the same things that could be done in excel. And then, we had these apps built in the cloud, in mobile, on ios/android, in react, on raspberry pi, on a gpu etc..etc.. ie, Simple apps reinvented with some new tooling. It is almost the equivalent of 'printf("hello world")' when you are learning a new language. This is not to undermine the OPs efforts, but I see it in the spirit of "learning" rather than that of solving a hard problem.

bwfan123··on Show HN: Streaming gigabyte medical images from S3 without downloading them
thanks for sharing !
bwfan123··on Tldraw pauses external contributions due to AI slop
> Understanding (not necessarily reading) always was the real work.

Great comment. Understanding is mis-"understood" by almost everyone. :)

Understanding a thing equates to building a causal model of the thing. And I still do not see AI as having a causal model of my code even though I use it every day. Seen differently, code is a proof of some statement, and verifying the correctness of a proof is what a code-review is.

There is an analogue to Brandolini's bullshit asymmetry principle here. Understanding code is 10 times harder than reading code.

bwfan123··on The next two years of software engineering
imo, The OP has bad ai-assisted takes on almost every single "critical question". This makes me doubt if he has breadth of experience in the craft. For example.

> Narrow specialists risk finding their niche automated or obsolete

Exactly the opposite. Those with expertise will oversee the tool. Those without expertise will take orders from it.

> Universities may struggle to keep up with an industry that changes every few months

Those who know the theory of the craft will oversee the machine. Those who dont will take orders from it. Universities will continue to teach the theory of the discipline.

bwfan123··on Don't fall into the anti-AI hype
I am not sure why the OP is painting it as a "us-vs-them" - pro or anti-AI ? AI is a tool. Use it if it helps.

I would draw an analogy here between building software and building a home.

When building a home we have a user providing the requirements, the architect/structural engineer providing the blueprint to satisfy the reqs, the civil engineer overseeing the construction, and the mason laying the bricks. Some projects may have a project-manager coordinating these activities.

Building software is similar in many aspects to building a structure. If developers think of themselves as a mason they are limiting their perspective. If AI can help lay the bricks use it ! If it can help with the blueprint or the design use it. It is a fantastic tool in the tool belt of the profession. I think of it as a power-tool and want to keep its batteries charged to use it at any time.

bwfan123··on AI is a business model stress test
> This substantially reduces the incentive for the creation of new IP

And as a result of this, the models will start consuming their own output for training. This will create new incentives to promote human generated code.

bwfan123··on Groq investor sounds alarm on data centers
> FOMO encourages increasingly foolish decisions (or at least unsustainable ones)

Markets will punish them for poor investments. We have not seen that yet, but it is coming.

bwfan123··on The future of software development is software developers
> I can confirm that they are completely useless for real programming

Can you elaborate on "real programming" ?

I am assuming you mean the simplest hard problem that is solved. The value of the work is measured in those terms. Easy problems have boilerplate solutions and have been solved numerous times in the past. LLMs excel here.

Hard problems require intricate woven layers of logic and abstraction, and LLMs still struggle since they do not have causal models. The value however is in the solution of these kinds of problems since the easy problems are assumed to be solved already.

bwfan123··on ManusAI Joins Meta
I saw this in a past hype cycle. What happens is that it becomes a "performative" art in an echo-chamber for startups, startup founders, VCs. Performative meaning doing things one thinks others want to see rather than when it makes sense.

Management is quizzing their tech teams on injecting agents into their workflows whatever the f that means. Some of these big companies will acquire startups in the space so they are not left behind on the hype-train. So, they can claim to have agentic talent on their teams.

Those of us who have seen this movie play out know the ending.

bwfan123··on Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI
> They actively exploit the -- natural, evolved -- inability of most people on Earth to distinguish language use from thinking and feeling

Maybe this will force humans to raise their game, and start to exercise discrimination. Maybe education will change to emphasis this more. Ability to discern sense from pleasing rhetoric has always been a problem. Every politician and advertizer takes advantage of this. Reams of philosophy have been written on this problem.

bwfan123··on Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI
> there's plenty of other training data in the world.

Not if most of it is machine generated. The machine would start eating its own shit. The nutrition it gets is from human-generated content.

> I don't understand the ethical framework for this decision at all.

The question is not one of ethics but that of incentives. People producing open source are incentivized in a certain way and it is abhorrent to them when that framework is violated. There needs to be a new license that explicitly forbids use for AI training. That may encourage folks to continue to contribute.

bwfan123··on Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI
> In what universe is another unsolicited email an act of kindness??!?

Where form is more important than function

Where pretense passes for authentic

Where bullshit masquerades as logic

bwfan123··on Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI
Did you read the bullshit AI generated gratitude message ? What would be your response to it ?
bwfan123··on Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI
As I read it, the "fakeness" of it all triggered a ballistic response. And wasting resources in the process. An AI developed feelings and expressed fake gratitude, and the human reading this BS goes ballistic.
bwfan123··on LearnixOS
> greater focus on the fundamentals versus the implementation

I am seeing this too. Folks are suddenly saying - lets implement this in Rust (or insert any other language here) without thinking about what this does to the fundamentals. A bandwagon effect which developers are swept by. And for managers it is a great way to show how innovative your team is. This applies not just to languages but entire development stacks almost like fashions in clothing.

bwfan123··on Get an AI code review in 10 seconds
When your linter or static analyser says something, you know exactly what it means. When AI says something - many a time, it doesnt make sense. And I use AI code review tools every day.
bwfan123··on Get an AI code review in 10 seconds
I think what has happened is that there are a whole lot of younger programmers who have not used tooling like linters and static analyzers. For them, when AI does the same thing it is a revelation.
bwfan123··on How exchanges turn order books into distributed logs
I need to sharpen my BS sensor. At first glance, I struggled to parse the voice in the article. Going back to the article I can now see the obvious gaps. Generally, AI tends to say things that make us go - "what the hell is this" ? for example in the article "The Problem: Ordering Chaos" is a very weird way to phrase it. As a human I struggled to accept it, and I did by stretching the meaning of that phrase to world model where it made sense. ie, our tendency is to give wide leeway to what we read or see and be very "accepting" in that sense. Instead, i think a better option is to reject everything we see or read as the default.
bwfan123··on How exchanges turn order books into distributed logs
Interesting comment, I "felt" the ai too in an undescribable way. What are some obvious tells ?
bwfan123··on Apple has locked my Apple ID, and I have no recourse. A plea for help
My father passed many moons ago, and the family wanted access to his icloud account and they did not have the password. This was a huge struggle. Finally, after weeks, we were able to reset the password, but only because we had access to the email he used. In retrospect, perhaps it is a good thing that Apple restricts access like this for privacy and security. But in this digital age there should be other mechanisms in scenarios like this. What if i wake up from a coma, and forgot all my passwords and have not recorded them physically anywhere ?
bwfan123··on Horses: AI progress is steady. Human equivalence is sudden
> The hollowing out of Silicon Valley is imminent

I think AI tools are great, and I use them daily and know their limits. Your view is commonly held by management or execs who don't have their boots on the ground.

bwfan123··on We gave 5 LLMs $100K to trade stocks for 8 months
LLM is the fad of the day, and these sort of articles provoke the natural get-rich-quick-greed inherent in all of us, especially the young tech-types. As such they are clickbait, and also a barometer of the silliness that is widespread.

I am curious why re-reading incerto sharpens your bullshit sense. I have read a few in that series, but didnt see it as sharpening my bullshit sensor.

bwfan123··on We gave 5 LLMs $100K to trade stocks for 8 months
shhh. We need more of these as counter-parties to improve alpha.
bwfan123··on Microsoft drops AI sales targets in half after salespeople miss their quotas
> but friction is necessary if we want to maneuver and get feedback from the environment

You are positing that we are active learners whose goal is clarity of cognition and friction and cognitive-struggle is part of that. Clarity is attempting to understand the "know-how" of things.

Tech and dare I say the natural laziness inherent in us instead wants us to be zombies being fed the "know-that" as that is deemed sufficient. ie the dystopia portrayed in the matrix movie or the rote student regurgitating memes. But know-that is not the same as know-how, and know-how is evolving requiring a continuously learning agent.

← PreviousPage 8 of 18Next →