HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

c3534l

6,371 karma · joined May 15, 2015

submissionscomments
c3534l··on Absurd Trolley Problems
I selected kill people over have my Amazon packages being late, but then I felt guilty about it and answered seriously in the rest of them.
c3534l··on Absurd Trolley Problems
The fact that its so low is kind of disturbing, and the fact that you're so cynical about it being so high means maybe you should reassess your values.
c3534l··on Why nobody ever wins the car at the mall (2018)
Timeshares are implicated in so many unethical scams and schemes that at this point I think we should just outlaw them entirely.
c3534l··on Mastercard and visa are the de facto regulators of porn
Normally I would disagree with you, but there's only two major credit card companies. People aren't given a choice.
c3534l··on Human-specific gene increases primate neocortex in the fetal marmoset
You're the only person who brought race into this and that says way more about you than anyone else.
c3534l··on DevOps is a failure
I think a lot of good ideas in tech get communicated to people who want a cargo cult and don't understand the underlying good ideas until agile becomes a flavor of waterfall, test driven development becomes development with tests, and devops becomes just another wall between developers and their end product.
c3534l··on Cache made consistent: Meta’s cache invalidation solution
I've heard this sort of thing is almost as hard as naming things.
c3534l··on My students cheated... a lot
I've never understood people's attitudes towards cheating, which is perhaps why its so prevalent. People cheat at sports all the time and people just sort of accept it. When people cheat in school, we just kind of go "well, yeah, kids do that, I guess we'll give you a few warnings first."

If someone is caught cheating how do I know they didn't cheat in previous classes, but got away with it? Do you really want to go to a doctor who, regardless of if he knows his stuff now, is the kind of person who can live with cheating? As I've grown older and seen more and more people get away with not a moment of weakness, but a deep, unfixable character flaw requiring planning and sustained effort to gain an advantage over people foolish enough to be doing things fairly, it makes me wonder why anyone chooses to tolerate this.

Who wants to get a degree from a university that knowingly and willingly passes students who cheat, but just makes them retake the course or in this case do what sounds like essentially extra credit. But rather than prevent people from participating in systems they have demonstrated are not trustworthy enough to participate in, we just give them a stern lecture and extra work, or an asterisk in their hall of fame record, or make them say they're very sorry.

c3534l··on Terraform should have remained stateless
If its not specified to be there, it shouldn't be there.
c3534l··on The age of Scrum is over
Agile, but reinvented, until it becomes full of gurus, coaches, and certifications, at which point we will declare it dead and continue to reinvent the saming manfucturing system we've had since Deming in the early 1950s.
c3534l··on FTC fines Twitter $150M for using 2FA phone numbers for ad targeting
Fines are generally made small enough not to be overturned, so the agency doesn't have to waste money litigating it, while also typically being large enough to change future behavior. They're not really retributive so much a cold calculations meant to get companies to do what they're supposed to do.
c3534l··on The math prodigy whose hack upended DeFi won’t return funds
Yes, but the I believe similar cases have appeared where the courts have found against the objectivity of smart contracts. I think, ultimately, the point of regulating the financial markets is not to protect investors, but to protect the economy. And if a smart contract undermines the security of our financial system, then that smart contract may simply be illegal.
c3534l··on “What if it changes?”
I don't like this authors approach. Always ask the question, but never add complexity because you assume you know the answer. If you have "multiple layers of indirection" that is "unused" because of paranoia that you might have to refactor your code, then you're doing it wrong. Write code such that you never have to be afraid to refactor it. That's not write code that never has to be refactored. In fact, refactor often and liberally. And if things break when you refactor, then that code is bad code. But don't add worthless layers of indirection because you write code that can't be tested, full of side effects, requiring entire components be rewritten from scratch, etc.

The top commenter says good code rarely needs to be changed. I think thats foolish. Good code is constantly changed, because its good enough it can be.

c3534l··on Billing systems are a nightmare for engineers
Tax is written by a bunch of people whose background is overwhelmingly from law, not finance, for reasons that have nothing to do with logic, consistency, financial literacy, understanding, sanity, or common sense. Politicians frequently pass laws without understanding what it will do or what its implications are, because they just didn't think that far ahead. It is quite possibly the worst system you could come up with for writing tax law.

That said, there is a logic to most of it, but not in a way that allows you to come up with general heuristics or universal abstractions.

c3534l··on Common libraries and data structures for C
Yes, writing libraries and tools. The horror.
c3534l··on Tech bubbles are bursting all over the place
profit != revenue
c3534l··on Fastest-ever logic gates could make computers a million times faster
I'm actually more excited that they found a use for very small segments of graphene, which is needed if we're ever going to produce higher-quality, unbroken strands at scale.
c3534l··on Apple, Google and Microsoft Commit to Expanded Support for FIDO Standard
I don't want my password to be something I leave behind on everything I touch, which the police have because I was arrested once, which can be ascertained from high quality photos, and which I can't ever change once stolen.
c3534l··on The $440M software error at Knight Capital (2019)
There seems to be some confusion. I am saying the top is American - at least as I was taught it in school. The bottom is the more typically British variant. But I think the reality is the both America and Britain have variations. To an American ear, bracket to mean parenthesis is not just odd, but wrong. But someone already said they consider bracket to be a catchall term, so obviously this is not universal.

Edit: okay, apparently there is just complete bracket anarchy across America and words have no fixed meaning.

c3534l··on The $440M software error at Knight Capital (2019)
parens: ()

brackets: []

braces:{}

Versus:

brackets: ()

square brackets: []

curly brackets: {}

Still drives me less mad than "inverted commas" though.

c3534l··on Zelensky Compound NDA
I'm not: https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/597018-two-gop-senators-... (however, I was confusing Cruz for Rubio)
c3534l··on Zelensky Compound NDA
No, I brought it up specifically because they were specifically told not to do that and signed the NDA. He was heavily criticized by other members of congress for endangering Zelensky.
c3534l··on Zelensky Compound NDA
IIRC, two American Senators shared photos from their zoom call with Zelensky on Twitter. Cruz being one of them.
c3534l··on Divergent Association Task: Fast creativity test
Except that extensive internal tracking showed that the question was useless. The whole point of why I brought it up is because it sounds smart to the interviewer, but doesn't actually measure anything. Actual, validated psychometric tests are typically quite boring and seem intuitively insufficient, while the creative and fun questions never pass validation.
c3534l··on Divergent Association Task: Fast creativity test
I don't know if those are better. They sound like the same superstitous interviewing techniques that led Google to ask engineers to estimate the number of ping pong balls that would fill up a Boeing 747.
c3534l··on Divergent Association Task: Fast creativity test
I think the idea is, actually, valid. But I don't think the measurement is. I think this plagues all creativity measures: you're asking the subject to be very open in their thinking, but the evaluation method must be narrow and objective.
c3534l··on My experience getting a tech job with no degree or relevant work experience
Pretty much every company I've worked with not just doesn't care about bootcamps, but actively avoids them. They prefer self-taught over scammed-into-crash-course. In particular, they don't trust that any github projects were completed independently.
c3534l··on You can now ask Google to remove your phone number, email or address from search
Sweet. This should finally get rid of that sex story I accidentally posted from my regular email account.
c3534l··on Ask HN: What's the most stable form of digital storage?
I love how the answers in this thread range from highly technical subject matter expertise to build a pyramid and carve your data on the walls.
c3534l··on Errors are constructed, not discovered
It seems like you're conflating blame with bugs.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →