HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

calhoun137

1,201 karma · joined February 8, 2013

I am a builder, not a breaker.
submissionscomments
calhoun137··on The Ugly Truth of Ugly Produce
I strongly disagree. In my opinion, the relationship between VC and rising inequality is indirect at most. The primary factors which contribute to inequality in a given country are related to the number of available jobs, the distribution of wages among various subsets of the working population, the robustness of social safety net programs, and the underlying distribution of political and economic power.

Our startup movement, more so than any other segment of the global economy, embodies the idea of the "American Dream" that if you work hard you can be successful and move up the social ladder. It's not perfect, and clearly it's not a pure meritocracy, but to claim that the VC world is "the most important driving force of rising inequality" is very inaccurate in my judgement.

It is true that silicon valley style tech companies are more and more becoming an important part of the economy, but the types of startups which are part of the tech startup eco system are creating jobs and are disrupting existing industries as part of a healthy capitalist process.

Here are two factors which I consider to have a much more significant influence than VC's on the global trend of rising inequality:

1) It is well understood that middle class families keep on average the majority of their wealth in the form of a house which they own. The housing crisis, which was fueled by wall street excess, wiped out an incredible amount of wealth from poor and middle class families and the bailout and shorting transferred this wealth to the top 0.1%

2) Approximately 3 trillion is collected by the US government every year in taxes, and approximately 1.5 trillion is borrowed by the government, for a total budget of approximately 4.5 trillion. This money is handed out by congress members to powerful banks and corporations from their state as a form of quid pro quo for campaign donations. The budget deficit is then used to justify a never ending cycle of cuts to social safety net programs.

calhoun137··on Absolute Hot
This is an amazing video by vsauce called How Hot Can It Get and which deals with the same concepts. I very highly recommend it for everyone.

https://youtu.be/4fuHzC9aTik

calhoun137··on 1/0 = 0
I very strongly object to this convention, as both a programmer and a mathematician.

A basic theorem is that for any field we must have that a/b = c/d if, and only if, ad = bc. See theorem 2 in this classic text here for a proof[1]

So if 1/0 = 0, then we also have 1/0 = 0/1, which implies 1 x 1 = 0 x 0 which is a contradiction. But then we also have 1/0 = 0/x for any x, hence we also have shown x=0 for any x, which is an infinite number of contradictions. Is this a problem which is addressed in the post that I missed?

By the way, I have spent more time than it's polite to discuss in public studying the topic of dividing by zero, and also what 0/0 means. If you are also interested in this topic, the best youtube video is by Mathologer and I highly recommend it to everyone. See here [2]

[1] https://books.google.com/books?id=3ApEDwAAQBAJ&lpg=PP1&pg=PA...

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oc0M1o8tuPo

calhoun137··on Where Vim Came From
When you are learning programming, its important to be able to isolate the problem you are working on and focus on that. The fact is that vim has a steep learning curve, and no matter how fast you are at typing things, your rate of productivity is still limited by how fast you can make decisions and how fast you can think and solve problems. I strongly believe that mastering hotkeys and tools like vim is the final stage of achieving the highest levels of programming skill. This is because once you have learned so much and trained yourself hard to think and move really fast, only then does your productivity bottleneck become things like using the mouse too much, not knowing certain hotkeys, not using things like regex replace, multi-line edit, and so on. The problem is mastering a single tool requires a tremendous amount of investment of time and energy, and once you are at the point in your development as a programmer where you need to start improving on hotkeys, well you are already deeply invested in whatever tool you are using and making the switch to vim has a major cost associated with it, because now you have to learn everything you already know how to do all over again. Is this cost worth it? Sometimes, depending on how advanced a person is, other times, depending on the situation, it's not. I think this phenomenon explains a lot about why vim is not as popular as perhaps it deserves to be.
calhoun137··on Where Vim Came From
The majority of "vim users" are painful to watch berating other programmers out of a misguided sense of self importance and overblown massive egos all because someone else dares to use the mouse to do something when they could save less than 1 second by using a hotkey instead.

People are most productive when they use the tools they know best. I use vim all the time, but I also like to use the right tool for the job, and sometimes that tool is an IDE and other times that tool is a gasp mouse.

( P.S. Please don't take this comment too seriously or personally, I am mostly kidding and am being extra hyperbolic on purpose because this thread seems like such a wonderful opportunity to rehash the never ending vim vs sublime debate and I wanted to get the sublime side of the argument off on a strong footing ;) )

calhoun137··on What's the Best App for Making Memes?
What's really funny is that all the time I put into learning how to make meme's and animated gif's caused me to accidentally do a lot of professional graphic design work for my company. As a programmer who works in early stage startups, I have found having the skill set to be able to work with tools like GIMP to be invaluable. Sometimes dealing with artists can kinda be a pain and its nice to be able to just make this stuff myself and skip all the back and forth.
calhoun137··on What's the Best App for Making Memes?
I do not disagree with you that there is a huge vacuum in the market for a good meme making app and that this will be extremely profitable for whoever gets it right and is able to execute and build a large user base.

That being said, as someone who has been making memes for 6+ years I can tell you hands down no mobile app will ever compare to the power of photoshop, or GIMP for that matter. Even if it was possible for a mobile app to do everything photoshop can do, the small screen size and touch screen interface is a huge issue that can't be solved without plugging a mouse + keyboard into a tablet, at which point, just use a computer.

There is an interesting phenomenon that the younger generation is so enamored with mobile apps and devices that many of them don't realize how certain use cases/work flows simply are always going to be way better on a desktop or a laptop. I would characterize your comment as saying its possible to profit off of the ignorance of a certain subset of today's 15-25 year old's when it comes to this fact.

I know there are so many brilliant people in this generation who are going to be sick nerds one day. But lots of others only interact with computers via their phones and don't even realize how silly they are being by refusing to make memes on a laptop.

calhoun137··on What's the Best App for Making Memes?
"some memers have found the current suite of mobile applications so lacking that they choose to create their memes on desktop computers instead. “On your phone, you’re never going to be able to do as much as you could as on a computer,” says Noam, who memes under the account @listenintospitandgettingparamoredon.

Ronnie, who memes under the handle @mspainttrash, is part of a group of meme makers that works exclusively in MS Paint."

Finally I thought, a voice of reason! Someone is going to mention GIMP or photoshop. But then they go straight for MS Paint and then totally ignore the idea of using a desktop to make memes and go right back to the "problem" that you need 4 apps to make a shitpost. LOL! Someone tell these kids about GIMP please

calhoun137··on [dead]
This article would be a lot better if instead of rambling on and on about nothing in the most boring way possible, that it didn't make you feel like you are being punished for reading it when you get to the end where it just stops out of nowhere and leaves all the questions it raises such as "what is this article about" completely unaddressed. Why would anyone submit or upvote this trash lol
calhoun137··on Steven Strogatz on chaos theory, game theory, and why math isn’t boring
Proffesor Strogatz wrote a book called Ninlinear Dynamics and Chaos which is the best intro book on non linear diff eq I have ever come across. I highly recomenend it: https://www.amazon.com/Nonlinear-Dynamics-Chaos-Applications...
calhoun137··on Have you had the “AI talk” with your kids?
I assume you are talking about the American service industry and not the Chinese one. In my view, the massive growth in the chinese manufacturing industry is also not a result of technology either, but rather a result of shipping american manufacturing jobs oversees.

Which illustrates my point that people lose jobs because of decisions made by other people.

calhoun137··on Have you had the “AI talk” with your kids?
>> "and rehashing that tired trope about how old jobs that got displaced by new technologies eventually were replaced with new, but different jobs we couldn’t fathom at the time.

That’s not the case this time. This time it’s different."

I guess the point here is that the author cant fathom new job types in the future, so therefore there will be no new job types in the future. Glad we got that one settled!

This argument has been going on literally for hundreds of years. Just because the author cant fathom new job types proves nothing.

People lose jobs because of decisions made by other people. Science will not ever come to an end, and there will always be new job types because of that.

Just imagine when commercial space travel becomes a serious thing. They will look back and say "did you know once a month they used to argue on HN about how in the future there will be no jobs? They were so silly because they didnt know about space travel."

And then someone else will say "yea they were wrong then, but this time its different..."

calhoun137··on Graphing when your Facebook friends are awake
nvd3 is actually really awesome http://nvd3.org/
calhoun137··on A Message to Our Customers
Its intimidating for the same reason that having the kgb show up for a russian companies meeting would be intimidating.
calhoun137··on I no longer understand my PhD dissertation
Programming is a subset of math, namely, the part of math that deals with algorithms. There are many parts of math that are not contained in programming. For example, floating point numbers are finite representations of real numbers, but since floats are finite, without some math theory beyond just algorithms, there is no way to understand them. There are may similar examples.
calhoun137··on Feynman’s Derivation of the Schrödinger Equation
> Well, F = ma was a bad example, I grant you. It's actually a definition of what a force is, nothing more.

Although I would agree that it's fair to say "F=ma is a definition of what a force is", I think of it more as a law of physics than as a definition.

I would also add that Newton's second law is more than merely the statement F=ma.

The original formulation is:

Law II: The alteration of motion is ever proportional to the motive force impress'd; and is made in the direction of the right line in which that force is impress'd. [1]

So in addition to stating what the word force means, the second law is also saying there are these things called forces which move things in a certain direction.

The way I think of F=ma personally, is that it means the laws of physics are associated with differential equations. So for me, the statement F=ma implies a huge number of other things, since without also having made the assumption that the laws of physics can be described in terms of vector calculus, the definition of force is rather useless and uninteresting.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton%27s_laws_of_motion#Newt...

calhoun137··on Feynman’s Derivation of the Schrödinger Equation
It's actually not true to say that Schrodinger's equation, or F=ma, cannot be derived.

This is because in order to derive something, you need to first start from a set of assumptions. You can pick any assumptions you want, that is your privilege, as it is mine. If you want F=ma to be an assumption, you can go on and derive things from that.

But truly, F=ma is not the most general assumption in theoretical physics.

If you look in any decent book on classical mechanics, you will find that F=ma in fact is derived from a much more general principle, the Lagrangian.

That is the same Lagrangian that is the subject of the OP, which is used to derive the Schrodinger equation; and it's not just a coincidence.

calhoun137··on If too many users are wrong, it's probably your fault (2011)
It's not the users fault for being stupid, it's your fault for assuming they are not.
calhoun137··on Google, D-Wave, and the case of the factor-10^8 speedup
I found this remark from the linked pdf[1] very interesting:

"...it has also been shown that for the class of problems used in initial benchmarks,the performance of the devices also correlates well with a classical(meanfield) approximation of quantum annealing [4],which raises questions about whether the devices can outperform classical optimizers."

In other words, if you ran a simulation of this device on a normal computer and gave it the same problem to solve, you will get basically the same efficiency.

[1] http://www.scottaaronson.com/troyer.pdf

calhoun137··on Is it possible to formulate category theory without set theory?
I posted this question over at math stackexchange after the thread about category theory and haskell from yesterday[1].

I found Carl Mummert's answer especially illuminating and definitely recommend reading it. He compares category theory to a strongly typed language, and set theory to a weakly typed one.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10527428

calhoun137··on The category design pattern
Mathematicians used the "naive" concept of a set as "a collection of objects" for thousands of years, and it led to a major crisis in the foundations of mathematics that was only resolved by establishing a rigorous system of axiom's that define what a set is.

So I disagree that a "set is more than a collection", with the qualification that the concept of a "collection" that is not associated with any axioms whatsoever, is meaningless. Why do I say "meaningless"? Because this "naive" concept of a collection leads to a number of logical paradox's that can only be resolved by using a system of axioms to define these collections.

So it's true that you can define sets by various axiom systems that are not the same, but these systems all exist under the umbrella of "set theory".

Using the "naive" concept of a collection is fair enough, since we all "know what you mean", but only as long as your point isn't that category theory is more fundamental than set theory.

calhoun137··on The category design pattern
I have been studying Category theory recently, on the surface, its merely a theory about dots that are connected by arrows.

For some reason, category theorists often claim that category theory is "more fundamental" than set theory, whatever that means. It's especially bizarre since many category theory books begin by saying they will define categories without using sets, and then proceed to say "let A be a collection of dots, and B a collection of arrows" but only God knows what the difference between a collection and a set is, from what I can tell...

calhoun137··on The category design pattern
+1 for "just using the definitions is cargo cult", that seems like a common problem!

I would add "just using a word from math is cargo cult". I just wish someone had told that to the 7 people who decided to use the word "static" for 7 different things ...

calhoun137··on Twitter Faced SEC Questions on Changing User-Engagement Metrics
Twitter can avoid unwanted SEC attention by taking massive risks that will potentially blow up the global economy.
calhoun137··on A collection of debugging stories
"This is the only time in my entire programming life that I've debugged a problem caused by quantum mechanics." [1]

This quote is amazing lol

[1] http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/DaveBaggett/20131031/203788/M...

calhoun137··on Deadly Sins of Graphic-Adventure Design
If this article hadn't picked on space quest I would have liked it a lot more.
calhoun137··on Firefox tracking protection decreases page load time by 44%
I agree with you that it's a valid objection. I disagree however, when you say " any company claiming to care about your privacy should not be using it." That's an easy accusation to throw around, but what is hard to is come up with a better alternative.

What is your suggestion, that they should abandon all analytics, or that they should build their own, or do you not have one? Are you willing to acknowledge that GA solves a real problem and provides valuable information?

In my judgement, it makes a lot of sense that Mozilla would use GA. I want them to use it because I believe in their mission, and I'm sure in the balance of things, it helps them maintain a stronger position as an organization.

calhoun137··on Wolfram Language
Mathematica is very powerful, but it's also very expensive and based on a proprietary code base. For me, this is unacceptable and the only solution in my judgement is to build our own.

I have been working really hard on exactly that, and in the past 3 weeks have made the most amazing progress. I don't want to spill the beans just yet, but this is my second attempt at building a better mathematica, and this time around I am using python, the scipy stack, and sage.

I will be releasing the project quite soon, as free open source software, along with a website that is 100% free for everyone. I am really hopeful that I will be able to find like minded programmers who are excited about working on this project together.

If this sounds interesting to you, please reply in comments below, or else reach out to me @calhoun137 on twitter.

calhoun137··on Ask HN: Are developers in India highly over-rated?
I recently had a contract job where I worked on code written by indian dev's. My main reaction was that they were actually quite capable and knew more than a few tricks, but these particular dev's were also making a large number of amatuer mistakes. There was a lot of copy/pasting of large blocks of code, for example.

My impression was that if they knew more high level theory, and did things in a more organized way, that they could be even more lazy and make even more money.

calhoun137··on Is there something mysterious about mathematics?
Physics is about the way things are, whereas math is about the way things have to be.
← PreviousPage 5 of 10Next →