HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

calhoun137

1,201 karma · joined February 8, 2013

I am a builder, not a breaker.
submissionscomments
calhoun137··on How Young Is TOO Young To Teach Kids To Code?
I was 10, original BASIC, APPLE 2C
calhoun137··on Cowards
Oh the irony! Obviously if Zuckerberg cared about people's privacy he would have run facebook differently.
calhoun137··on Posting to HN is like exposing yourself to the eye of Mordor
Yea i posted a project on here[1] and got completely ignored, i then posted the same project on /r/gamedev and spent all weekend as the top post with a steady steam of thank you so much this is awesome comments. I really would like the validation of the HN community, but that seems super hard to achieve, if not impossible. Doesnt mean im gonna give up, just gonna keep working hard and hope to get a little lucky.

[1]http://calhoun137.github.com/animator

calhoun137··on NSA collecting phone records of millions of Americans daily
Its nice to finally see a glenn greenwald article on the front page for once. I have been reading him every day for years and i would highly recommend his entire body of work to anyone who is not familiar with it.
calhoun137··on Learning from top performers - the importance of making notes
I don't like to take notes on the computer, I like to actually write notes in notebooks, and I have a lot of them! I think the act of writing things down in a notebook is really helpful for me to think things through carefully and clearly, and I just don't get the same feeling typing notes on a computer.

I keep a separate notebook for each project that I am working on, be it for work or pleasure, and I also have a whiteboard for the important TODO items that I don't want to get lost in a notebook page that I don't check everyday.

Before I begin working on a project for the day, I always review at least the most recent pages from the relevant notebook to refresh where I was at when I left off.

Sometimes when I have a good insight that I can't implement right away because I am busy with something else, I will find the right notebook and write it down very quickly in a few words. Then occasionally I come back to it later and get a bit confused about what that note was all about, and in the process of trying to figure out what it means, I remember the whole thought process and come up with a better variation on the original idea that inspired the note in the first place.

calhoun137··on You can't impress developers
I don't mean value in the financial sense, but rather in the sense of helping a person improve as a developer.

As for mixing praise and criticism, that is appropriate for certain situations; for example when dealing with a student with low self confidence. However there is a danger in praise which I outlined in my previous comment, it really doesn't accomplish much besides stroking a person's ego, and that can have unintended negative consequences for their long term development.

calhoun137··on You can't impress developers
There is a huge amount of value in constructive criticism, and really very little value in praise. In order to reach your full potential you must be able to handle criticism of your work. If you simply praise a person you are really not doing them any favors, in fact you might be hurting their development by creating a false sense of superiority that causes them to stop pushing themselves as hard to succeed. However, you really are doing a person a favor when you take the time to read through their work and offer constructive criticism, because then you are helping them to achieve their full potential.

In fact, it's a sign of respect to give constructive criticism because the implied message is: I found your work interesting enough to spend time looking over it and thinking about; and I'm not going to treat you like a child who needs to be coddled, but rather like a peer who is capable of handling criticism.

calhoun137··on I Wasn’t Prepared to Work
I just read like all of this guys blog posts, they are great!
calhoun137··on Interview with a Blackhat (Part 3/3)
I think of "hacking" as breaking things, taking them apart, and learning how they work; and "programming" as creating and building new things. As much as I am in awe of the amazing technical power of elite black hat hackers, there is something really special about creating something new and transporting it from your imagination into the real world.
calhoun137··on Physicists Create Quantum Link Between Photons That Don't Exist at the Same Time
I love how at the end of all these physics articles there is always some guy who is like "O HELL YEA WE CAN USE THIS FOR QUANTUM COMPUTERS!"
calhoun137··on Need a browser with one Tab
Dondrey's Law: The number of tabs a programmer has open is proportional to how stressed out they are.
calhoun137··on Always Be Coding – How to Land an Engineering Job
I've been noticing this recently, it's amazing that such a basic issue is unresolved. Apparently overflow: scroll has been broken on android browsers since 2009[1], but was fixed as of Android 3.0. For me scrolling works fine in the native android browser, including overflow:scroll, but shockingly not in Android chrome.

[1] https://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=6864

calhoun137··on The New York Times Told Me To Take This Down
I clicked the link, but only because ironically on my android tablet i couldnt scroll the page! I think it must be an android chrome overscroll-y issue, because i can scroll it on the native android browser.
calhoun137··on One-Time Pad reinvented to make electronic copying impossible
OT: If two people have to send a signal to each other, they should be named Alice and Bob, this goes back to Einstein's paper on the EPR paradox[1], and is based presumably on the fact that Alice starts with A and Bob starts with B.

Sometimes I read articles where Alice sends a signal to Charlie or something like that, and for me that is a huge red flag that indicates the author may not have payed much attention in school and/or may not have a great grasp on what they are talking about.

Fortunately this article is about Alice and Bob, so I am inclined to take it seriously.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPR_paradox

calhoun137··on The One-Person Product
Or the one that says owning a boat only makes you happy two times: when you buy it and when you sell it.
calhoun137··on Tesla Raises $1B from Stock and Bond Sale
After reading through all the comments in the dilution thread I think I finally understand:

The value of a stock is determined by what people are willing to pay for it on the market, and if a company simply issues more stock, its entirely possible that the price of the stock will go up, go down, or stay the same.

This is of course only true for public companies, and in the case of private companies dilution is a completely different issue.

calhoun137··on U.S. Secretly Obtains Two Months of A.P. Phone Records
What? If you didn't sound so serious I would think your comment is meant to be a parody.

> Very little of this is actually true, at least with regards to what the U.S. does internally.

The majority of the OP's comment is not about domestic US politics, it's about support of dictatorships abroad. I'm guessing you are not very familiar with the history of Latin america, you should read up on that before making comments like this again. By the way, the US backed ex-president of Guatemala was just found guilty of genocide[1], Hillary Clinton said Egypt's dictator Mubarak was a "friend of her family", and the US strongly backs the regime in Saudi Arabia which is one of the most repressive in the entire middle east. When Madeleine Albright was asked if she thought the death of half a million Iraqi children due to the sanctions was too high a price to pay, she said "I think...the price is worth it"[2].

> The U.S. government very rarely ignores the Constitution

Are you aware that it was recently revealed that Henry Kissinger was recorded saying "The illegal we do immediately, the unconstitutional takes a little longer"[3] Or are you familiar with the regime of secret law that surrounds drone assassinations, do you think that just because the president can get his lawyer to write him a permission slip that it makes assassinating US citizens abroad constitutional? What about locking people up in Guantanamo bay without a trial? What about torture? What about the 4th amendment. Do you even know which one that is, or why that is relevant to the article about spying on reporters from AP? What about freedom of the press?

> As for externally--the Constitution puts almost no limits on the American government's ability to intervene in foreign affairs

Have you even read the constitution? It doesn't sound like it. The entire point of the constitution is to constrain the ability of the government to do things. It says that the government is bound by all foreign treaties[4]. It also happens to say that congress is the only body of government that can declare war, even though after Vietnam that clause has pretty much been ignored.

> as far as global hegemons go, the U.S. is the most benevolent such entity in the history of the world

are you serious?

[1] http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/05/13/us-guatemala-riosm...

[2] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RM0uvgHKZe8

[3] http://rt.com/news/wikileaks-assange-release-files-475/

[4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_Six_of_the_United_State...

calhoun137··on Samsung is hurting Android
This article is decent, but it forgets to mention that Samsung has done more to help Android take market share away from Apple than any other company.
calhoun137··on A note to myself
Finishing stuff is nice, it took me awhile but i finally got there. The new problem i have is: now that i finished a project, how do i get people to know about/use it?
calhoun137··on NSA Google Search Tips
For anyone who doesnt know: http://www.exploit-db.com/google-dorks/
calhoun137··on Why I'm Furious with Silicon Valley (2011)
Take a look at this amazing book by Glenn Greenwald, it has an overwhelming amount of evidence, examples, and very well thought out arguments:

http://books.google.com/books?id=Je_fc_WjF9oC&printsec=f...

calhoun137··on WordPress Core is Secure
Wait, isn't WordPress insecure?
calhoun137··on Entrepreneurs are the New Labor
A proper analogy which i have shared with my smart friends for reading articles of a wordy nature, including said article, is best understood by reflecting on the late 19th century philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche, who besides being a prototype of current wordy article authors also articulated an interesting theory of good and evil, and who said that which does not kill us makes us stronger.
calhoun137··on The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas
Here's the problem. If your team takes the time to really try and come up with something that everyone agreed they wanted to eat, then you all end up with a high quality lunch. If you just start with the worst idea and iterate from there you run the risk of getting something that has bugs in it which you don't even realize were there until much later when it's already too late.
calhoun137··on Physicist proposes new way to think about intelligence
For a rational agent, a decision is good or bad based on it's preferences, which are described mathematically as part of the definition of the rational agent. So I don't believe it's tautological.

I do agree with your statement that intelligence is difficult to describe. And for the record I never claimed the rational agent approach will achieve "true machine intelligence". Frankly, I don't even know what "true" machine intelligence is or would be. What I am very interested in however is how to create an AI that is capable of fooling a person into thinking it's intelligent, in other words an AI that can pass the Turing test. For that purpose I find the concept of a rational agent to be very helpful, in that it provides a solid foundation to work from.

I'm also not worried about Godel's theorem at all. The statements that are undecidable are very obscure and basically never come into play in human decision making. I think Godel's result has very little practical application, if it has any at all; I certainly don't think it's relevant for AI. I agree that choosing a logical framework to work in presents many problems, but I don't agree that you have to disprove Godel's theorem to create an AI that can think outside the box.

calhoun137··on Physicist proposes new way to think about intelligence
Just so you know, before I started spending all of my time programming I was a physicist, and statistical physics was my best subject.

Anyway, I kind of object to your definition of intelligence as "the ability to predict the unknown". Of course it comes down to personal preference, but I feel that when it comes to making AI, a better definition is something along the lines of "intelligence is the ability to make good choices when faced with a decision". In other words, I like to come at AI using the definition of rational agent[1].

Machine learning is the subject that involves predicting the unknown, and there is a ton of linear algebra involved. I am not an expert at ML, so it's possible that the second law in some form plays a role, but if so I have not come across that yet in my studies.

Now in as much as the second law applies to AI, I am skeptical, but your comment has convinced me to keep an open mind and look into it more carefully. Entropy is merely the log of the probability distribution, so when we talk about maximizing entropy for decision making, what probability distribution should we use, and should we use different distributions for different situations, and if so how do we decide which one to use?

A much more relevant subject for AI in my opinion is game theory, which is really a theory of decision making. Finding the optimal strategy for navigating a decision tree can be a hard problem, and just because maximizing entropy works to find solutions for some types of decision problems, doesn't mean that it's a magic bullet that will always, or even frequently, work out.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_agent

calhoun137··on Physicist proposes new way to think about intelligence
This sounds like nonsense to me. First of all, what exactly do they mean by "intelligent behavior"? I looked in the paper but I couldn't find where they define what they are trying to model. They do however use the vague expression "remarkably sophisticated behaviors associated with the human ‘‘cognitive niche,’’ including tool use and social cooperation."

Tool use and social cooperation, sounds interesting. Let's see, that seems to be figures 3 and 4 from page 4. Once you get over the idea of modeling an animal with a disc, it seems a little bizarre that figures 3 or 4 have anything to do with intelligent behavior. Figure 3 is about one disc bouncing off another disc so that a third disc goes into a cylinder. I would say that doesn't really capture the essence of how "non-human animals" use tools. Then the social cooperation example is about a big disc attached to a string, that moves differently when 2 smaller discs touch it at the same time, and then under some specific configuration the discs have "social cooperation" to move the big disc. As far as I can tell, whether or not moving the big disc is an intelligent decision or not seems to not matter in this example.

We then get very bold claims, such as "physical agents driven by causal entropic forces might be viewed from a Darwinian perspective as competing to consume future histories."

calhoun137··on No Housing Bubble Trouble (2005)
This reminds me of this you tube video, called "Peter Schiff Was Right": http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2I0QN-FYkpw

It's basically a bunch of people screaming at Peter Schiff that he has no idea what he is talking about, when he was basically predicting everything that happened. Apparently Peter Schiff is pretty smart, I watched a bunch of these videos and listened to his radio show. He is now predicting a massive drop in the dollar due to inflation.

calhoun137··on My Time at Lehman
I actually agree about the group-on example, but i strongly disagree with your broader point. First of all, getting someone to click on an ad or pay for a video game is not even in the same dimension as destroying the pensions of millions of hard working people or crashing the economy only to get bailed out by taxpayers, and so on. Second of all, SV and developers in general actually produce something of value, as opposed to the gambling wall street engages in. There is a difference between making a profit by producing something of value, and ripping people off by hustling and gaming the system. Third of all, there is so much interesting computer science happening all the time in the developer community, so while wall street invents new obscure financial products, "SV" invents things like AWS, google maps, smart phones, and so on.
calhoun137··on Everything I know about design I learned playing Starcraft
There is a difference between EAPM, and effective EAPM, in the sense that if you have a high EAPM but do the wrong thing, you still lose the game. SC2 has a way of training you to actually think and make decisions faster, in addition to typing faster, and this is something that I have found to be valuable for increasing my productivity as a programmer.
← PreviousPage 8 of 10Next →