HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

calibas

4,451 karma · joined December 9, 2015

submissionscomments
calibas··on AI companies cause most of traffic on forums
It seems like they just grabbing every possible bit of data available, I doubt there's any mechanism to flag which edits are corrections when training.
calibas··on Does current AI represent a dead end?
I'm saying I personally want uncensored versions of LLMs, I'm not suggesting the government pass laws that force companies to do this. Your claim that I'm asking for more restrictions on speech is false.
calibas··on I was wrong about the ethics crisis
> the belief in the magical power of the free market always to serve the public good has no theoretical basis

This needs to be repeated more often.

Early on, there was this idea that free market capitalism was inherently amoral, and we had to do things like "vote with your wallet" to enforce some kind of morality on the system. This has been gradually replaced with a pseudo-religious idea that there's some inherent "virtue" to capitalism. You just need to have faith in the system, and everything will magically work itself out.

calibas··on Does current AI represent a dead end?
The data used to train LLMs is almost always sexist and racist, so they put special guidelines on what it's allowed to say to correct for the sexism and racism inherent in the model.

Whether this counts as "suppression" is beside the point, the problem is these guidelines make it really stupid about certain things. For instance, it's not supposed to say anything bad about Christianity. This is a big problem if you want to have a real discussion about sexism. ChatGPT whitewashes Christianity's connection to sexism, saying:

"The New Testament offers various teachings on how to treat women, emphasizing respect, equality, and love within the broader Christian ethic."

That's actually kind of a problem if you're against sexism, and it's just plain wrong when compared to what the Bible actually says about how to treat women. The guidelines make it so the AI often avoids controversial topics altogether, and I'm not convinced this is a good thing. I believe it can actually impede social progress.

calibas··on Does current AI represent a dead end?
If you want an easy solution that makes good financial sense for the companies training AIs, then it's censorship.

Not training the AIs to be racist in the first place would be the optimal solution, though I think the companies would go bankrupt before pruning every bit of systemic racism from the training data.

I don't believe censorship is effective though. The censorship itself is being used by racists as "proof" that the white race is under attack. It's literally being used to perpetuate racism.

calibas··on Does current AI represent a dead end?
censor (verb): to examine in order to suppress or delete anything considered objectionable

This is exactly what's happening, information considered objectionable is being suppressed. The correct word for that is "censorship".

You comment is kind of bending the definition of censorship. It doesn't have to come from a human being, nor does any kind of harm need to be involved. Also, my argument has nothing to do with anthropomorphising an AI, I'm certainly not claiming it has a right to "free speech" or anything ridiculous like that.

I already abhor racism, and I don't need special guidelines on an AI I use to "protect" me from potentially racist output.

“Censorship is telling a man he can't have a steak just because a baby can't chew it.” ― Mark Twain

calibas··on Does current AI represent a dead end?
> It's more like they refuse to provide comfort to racists.

That's still censorship though.

Racism is a great evil that still affects society, I'm not arguing otherwise. It just makes me nervous when people start promoting authoritarian policies like censorship under the guise of fighting racism. Instead of one evil, now you have two.

calibas··on Antimatter production, storage, control, annihilation applications in propulsion
Short answer: it's not happening yet.

> A general conclusion was drawn that antimatter technology and its development for propulsion is still in its theoretical stages.

calibas··on Antimatter production, storage, control, annihilation applications in propulsion
That actually lends credibility as it probably wasn't written by an AI.
calibas··on "This is not a joke, Funko just called my mom"
Or call their mom...
calibas··on Try asking ChatGPT about "David Mayer"
Try using chatgpt.com
calibas··on Why pipes sometimes get "stuck": buffering
Buffers are there for good reason, it's extremely slow (relatively speaking) to print output on a screen compared to just writing it to a buffer. Printing something character-by-character is incredibly inefficient.

This is an old problem, I encounter it often when working with UART, and there's a variety of possible solutions:

Use a special character, like a new line, to signal the end of output (line-based).

Use a length-based approach, such as waiting for 8KB of data.

Use a time-based approach, and print the output every X milliseconds.

Each approach has its own strengths and weaknesses, depends upon the application which one works best. I believe the article is incorrect when mentioning certain programs that don't use buffering, they just don't use an obvious length-based approach.

calibas··on Teen mathematicians tie knots through a mind-blowing fractal
> a tetrahedral version of the Menger sponge

Better known as a Sierpiński tetrahedron, AKA the 3d version of a Sierpiński triangle.

calibas··on The two factions of C++
At the current rate, we'll have full module support for all of the most popular C++ libraries sometime around Apr 7th, 2618.

https://arewemodulesyet.org/

calibas··on Salmon return to lay eggs in historic habitat after Klamath River dam removal
It could power 70k homes at full capacity. Important note, it wasn't at full capacity, and the entire county of Siskiyou is only about 40k people (not homes).

Our power company, Pacific Power, said they didn't need the dam at all, and it would cost more to maintain than it was worth.

calibas··on Salmon return to lay eggs in historic habitat after Klamath River dam removal
A lot of the local opposition to dam removal is because of this guy specifically. Here's his article on why the toxic cyanobacteria that was in the former reservoirs is actually good for the river:

https://www.siskiyou.news/2024/01/24/blue-green-algae-in-cop...

It pretends to be a regular news site, and even "scientific", to the point where it fooled Google and his site was often at the top of search results. He was also aggressively promoting his articles on Facebook.

The guy is confusing green algae with bacteria. He's also ignoring the fact that the kind of blue-green "algae" in question, Microcystis aeruginosa, isn't the nitrogen-fixing kind. He has no clue was he's talking about, but that doesn't stop him, and he's unfortunately a major source of "knowledge" (confusion and misinformation) for the locals here.

calibas··on Fair coins tend to land on the side they started
I think I can explain it:

Other side: 1/2 flip, 1 1/2 flips, 2 1/2 flips...

Same side: 1 flip, 2 flips, 3 flips...

It seems like there's equal chances, but my theory is that the 1/2 flip is the least likely thing to occur. When you take that into account, there's a slightly increased chance that it's going to land on the same side.

calibas··on Faking Shaders III: Tixyland
It's an HTML canvas, but you can give it input similar to a shading language?
calibas··on Three-Quarters of U.S. Adults Are Now Overweight or Obese
> General Mills has toured the country touting anti-diet research it claims proves the harms of “food shaming.” It has showered giveaways on registered dietitians who promote its cereals online with the hashtag #DerailTheShame, and sponsored influencers who promote its sugary snacks. The company has also enlisted a team of lobbyists and pushed back against federal policies that would add health information to food labels.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2024/04/03/diet-cult...

calibas··on Analysis of economic and productivity losses caused by cookie banners in Europe
The company that dominates the browser market also makes billions off of tracking people. That might be part of the problem.
calibas··on Mom jailed for letting 10-year-old walk alone to town
To me at least, a cop arguing that it's not safe to walk around town, is a cop saying they have failed to do their job.

If our towns have actually become so dangerous recently, and that's not what the statistics say, then it seems like there's a whole other discussion we need to have. I don't think the world is more dangerous though, I think the average American has become more isolated and fearful over the past 25 years.

calibas··on Mom jailed for letting 10-year-old walk alone to town
Yes, while childhood suicide, depression and obesity rates have all been increasing. If you look at all the factors, I'm not sure there's a net benefit.

Edit: I decided to look up the CDC statistics to see if there is any net benefit, but total childhood mortality rates have been increasing in the US. Measuring accidental deaths is extremely flawed, if that were a good target then we should keep all children indoors. No bike riding, no swimming, no tree climbing, just keep them inside on a screen all day long and accidental deaths will continue to drop.

calibas··on ASCII Delimited Text – Not CSV or Tab Delimited Text
I think this would catch on much more quickly if text editors treated the Record Separator character as a new line, and there was a special character for the Unit Separator.
calibas··on WebSockets cost us $1M on our AWS bill
Why use Chromium at all? Isn't it just decoding video and sending it over a websocket?
calibas··on USFS Decision to Halt Prescribed Burns in California is History Repeating
Yep, they've always happened. The Summers are very dry and hot, then the thunderstorms come...

There's a number of plants that have actually evolved to take advantage of the fires.

calibas··on New York Times Tech Guild goes on strike
Why would anybody trust a NYT article about internal drama at the NYT? Does HN not understand bias?

Compare the NYT article to other reporting, and you can see the difference. There's a few things the NYT forgot to mention, like the fact that these negotiations have been drawn out for 2 years now. Or this:

"Throughout the bargaining process, Times management has engaged in numerous labor law violations, including implementing return-to-office mandates without bargaining and attempting to intimidate members through interrogations about their strike intentions. The NewsGuild of NY has filed unfair labor practice charges against The Times on these tactics as well as numerous other violations of labor law."

https://nyguild.org/post/new-york-times-tech-guild-walks-off...

The NYT does include a quote blaming everything on the Tech Guild though: “We are disappointed that the Tech Guild leadership is attempting to jeopardize our journalistic mission at this critical time,”

calibas··on Universe would die before monkey with keyboard writes Shakespeare, study finds
Actually, the study doesn't say that it wont happen, but that there's a 6.4 * 10^-7228454 chance of it happening before the Universe ends.

That's an infinitely larger chance than 0!

calibas··on HTML Form Validation is underused
Here's a simple example that doesn't use React:

https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/HTMLObjectE...

calibas··on Up to $41B in World Bank climate finance unaccounted for, Oxfam finds
> Does not the article say that these are "declared allocated" but not yet dispersed?

Not sure where you're seeing that in the article, it doesn't use that language at all. It actually directly contradicts what you're saying in the first sentence:

"Up to $41 billion in World Bank climate finance —nearly 40 percent of all climate funds disbursed by the Bank over the past seven years— is unaccounted for due to poor record-keeping practices"

calibas··on Plastic chemical phthalate causes DNA breakage, chromosome defects, study finds
"The study also showed that C. elegans metabolizes BBP in the same way as mammals, and is impacted at similar BBP levels that occur in humans, suggesting that C. elegans is an effective model for studying the impacts on people."
← PreviousPage 6 of 32Next →