HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

calibas

4,451 karma · joined December 9, 2015

submissionscomments
calibas··on How Good Is ChatGPT at Coding, Really?
Maybe my reading comprehension is awful, but I don't see it mentioned anywhere in the article that the "ChatGPT" from the study is the worst at coding of the 3 models that people commonly use.

It seems relevant to mention that the "ChatGPT" in the article isn't the one most of us are using for coding.

calibas··on How Good Is ChatGPT at Coding, Really?
Interesting study, but unfortunately already outdated. I don't think anybody uses ChatGPT 3.5 for coding anymore.

From my personal experience, Claude 3.5 or GPT-4o work best. They're more coding assistants, not really capable of writing anything more than very simple programs on their own. They make a lot of mistakes, and you need to know how to debug code they produce.

Claude is my favorite but it just randomly added a division by 100,000 to a line of code for no discernible reason. According to Claude it was "an oversight on [Claude's] part".

calibas··on Should the Hawthorn Be Saved?
I was curious, because I was always told Hawthorns weren't poisonous, and I can't find anything more about this. The only source seems to be the book itself, I couldn't find the study, and I can't find any other sources that say Hawthorn or its thorns are poisonous.

Either way, it's probably a bad idea to get stabbed in the eye by their thorns.

calibas··on US Supreme Court throws out rulings on state laws regulating social media
Ideology of some Democrats, certainly not all...

https://www.salon.com/2024/05/02/jewish-groups-decry-passage...

calibas··on US Supreme Court throws out rulings on state laws regulating social media
> It sounds like you think Republicans are in general against government regulation.

Nope, but I think most Republicans think that.

Personally, I think politics is more about money and power than adherence to any kind of ideology.

calibas··on US Supreme Court throws out rulings on state laws regulating social media
It's interesting how fast political ideology goes out the window. Here we have the Republicans fighting for increased government regulation of private businesses, while Democrats are arguing it's unconstitutional and violates "free speech".
calibas··on U.S. state welcome signs
I fixed California, for some reason it was showing the sign for Arizona...
calibas··on Nobody knows what's going on
I was tangentially involved in a news story a few years ago. The reporter went to a small town, interviewed a few people, then wrote up an article. Only problem was they didn't actually interview anybody directly involved, it was a lot of hearsay from the small town rumor mill, which they reported as fact.

Nothing major about the story was changed, but I know some of the details were incorrect. It bugs me that these are now "facts", and places like Wikipedia confidently state these "facts" without anybody knowing the origin was just small town gossip.

calibas··on Gavin Newsom wants to take smartphones out of schools
> many people now develop anxiety if unable to use a phone for even a very short time

That's a very polite way of saying "addiction".

calibas··on Longer and Longer Freight Trains Drive Up the Odds of Derailment
Look up Cantara Loop in Northern California, a derailment caused a major environmental disaster back in 1991.

They've never really figured out how to stop derailments there, they still happen on a regular basis. We've just gotten lucky recently and the derailed cars weren't full of toxic chemicals.

https://www.ijpr.org/disasters-and-accidents/2022-11-17/four...

calibas··on Remote Amazon tribe did not get addicted to porn
It's interesting, this article largely shifts blame to the Post, while the leader of the Marubo seems to blame the original article.

>The Times article had overemphasized the negatives of the internet, he said, “resulting in the spread of a distorted and damaging picture.”

calibas··on Extracting concepts from GPT-4
Yes, thank you, I understand that part.

It's the might condition in the description that makes me think the results might not be the exact same as what's used in the live models.

calibas··on Extracting concepts from GPT-4
I saw that, but the language makes me think it's not quite the same as what's really being used?

"how a piece of text might be tokenized by a language model"

"It's important to note that the exact tokenization process varies between models."

calibas··on Extracting concepts from GPT-4
I think it's done on purpose, it's related to a very important point when understanding AI.

Humans aren't perfect, AI is trained by humans, therefore...

calibas··on Extracting concepts from GPT-4
I want to be able to view exactly how my input is translated into tokens, as well as the embeddings for the tokens.
calibas··on One-third of Amazon warehouse workers are on food stamps or Medicaid
> Attacking someone character shows mental weakness.

Sure sounds like an attack on my character...

You didn't clarify what kind of minimum wage you're talking about, and I pointed out that you're mistaken regarding state minimum wages.

calibas··on A crazy experience losing Apple earbuds in a remote town in Chile
When put together, your first couple sentences seem to imply that we shouldn't call Apple "bad" because they're just out to make a buck.
calibas··on A crazy experience losing Apple earbuds in a remote town in Chile
> taking the position that Apple is the baddie here is just as absurd. These are all big companies out to make a buck.

I see this logic often, and I don't understand it.

If I did something people considered unethical, arguing that I did it out of greed wouldn't change people's minds. It would probably hurt my argument.

When a big company does something people consider unethical, there's almost always someone who mentions that the point of a business is to make money, as if that's a excuse for their behavior.

It's like there's a separate set of ethics for business, and the worst sin of all is not being profitable.

calibas··on 2023 planetary heat uptake from termination shock of inadvertent geoengineering?
Assuming the positives outweigh the negatives. You can't release tons of sulfur dioxide into the atmosphere without causing acid rain and speeding up ocean acidification.
calibas··on One-third of Amazon warehouse workers are on food stamps or Medicaid
I'm sure Bezos appreciates the PR you're doing for him, but you're wrong. "Up to $20.75/hr" is what they're offering, that's not the same as $20.75/hr. The pay rates marginally above minimum wage for California.

https://hiring.amazon.com/app#/jobDetail?jobId=JOB-US-000000...

calibas··on To the brain, reading computer code is not the same as reading language (2020)
To me, reading new code is like separating a bunch of string that's been tangled together. What thread goes where, what's it's purpose, how is it connected to the other threads? It's a very active process.

Reading language is different, I move my eyes left to right, top to bottom, to consume someone else's ideas. It's a much more passive process than reading code.

calibas··on One-third of Amazon warehouse workers are on food stamps or Medicaid
> Amazon Warehouse positions all pay well above minimum wage, in every state

Federal minimum wage is $7.25 per hour, so that's not saying much.

Going by state minimum wage, your statement is incorrect. According to Google the average Amazon warehouse worker in California makes $17-18 an hour. California minimum wage is $16 per hour.

calibas··on 3M executives convinced a scientist forever chemicals in human blood were safe
Ironic, just about every time I see industry propaganda that defends some toxic chemical, they use two tactics. First, compare it to something else everybody uses and considers harmless. Second, repeat over and over again there's no studies that show it's harmful at very very low doses.

You managed to do both.

calibas··on OpenAI departures: Why can’t former employees talk?
> It forbids them, for the rest of their lives, from criticizing their former employer.

This is the kind of thing a cult demands of its followers, or an authoritarian government demands of its citizens. I don't know why people would think it's okay for a business to demand this from its employees.

calibas··on ChatGPT-4o vs. Math
I tried the "Zero-Shot Chain-of-Thought" myself. It seems to work the best but one time I got:

"Therefore, the thickness of the tape is approximately 0.000589 cm or 0.589 mm."

calibas··on North Yorkshire Council to phase out apostrophe use on street signs
With the printing press it makes sense, there's physical constraints that make things very difficult if you want to support a huge number of different characters. Those limitations don't exist anymore though.

On one hand we have systems supporting Unicode and just about every character imaginable, it's an example of using technology to go beyond the limitations of the past. You could have a system that supports emojis on street signs, but instead we're going the opposite direction and introducing artificial limitations that are even more restrictive than 500 year-old technology.

calibas··on North Yorkshire Council to phase out apostrophe use on street signs
You can print apostrophes on a street sign without any database issues because a street sign doesn't interface directly with a database. At least not yet...

All the technical issues here have already been solved a hundred times, there's plenty of other options. It's a little worrying that we're eliminating punctuation in real life because of issues with integrating with geographical databases.

calibas··on Jeff Geerling: Corporate Open Source Is Dead
The resistance to GPL isn't just companies, I think you'll find the average programmer prefers using libraries licensed under MIT when given the choice.

It seems like there's a kind of political ideology over what "open source" even means and how it should be practiced.There's a school of thought that says we should switch everything over to viral copyleft licenses. This will "protect" the code and ensure all derivative work is always open source.

Then there's others, like myself, who believe if you want something that's truly "free and open" it should come with as few conditions as possible.

calibas··on AI Can Tell Your Political Affiliation Just by Looking at Your Face
From the actual study:

"The algorithm studied here, with a prediction accuracy of r = .22, does not allow conclusively determining one’s political views, in the same way as job interviews, with a predictive accuracy of r = .20, cannot conclusively determine future job performance. Nevertheless, even moderately accurate algorithms can have a tremendous impact when applied to large populations in high-stakes contexts. For example, even crude estimates of people’s character traits can significantly improve the efficiency of online mass persuasion campaigns (Kosinski et al., 2013; Matz et al., 2017). Scholars, the public, and policymakers should take notice and consider tightening policies regulating the recording and processing of facial images."

https://awspntest.apa.org/fulltext/2024-65164-001.html

Compare that to the article:

"A study recently published in the peer-reviewed American Psychologist journal claims that a combination of facial recognition and artificial intelligence technology can accurately assess a person’s political orientation by simply looking at that person’s blank, expressionless face."

The article is misleading. You can't claim the model can accurately assess an individual's political orientation just because it performs better than random chance. Sure, it demonstrates there's a statistically-significant link between facial structure and political orientation, but claiming you can use it to "accurately assess a person’s political orientation" is absurd and not what the study found.

calibas··on Senate passes reauthorization of key US surveillance program after midnight
So if I communicate with a non-US citizen, I effectively forfeit my right to privacy? Am I understand this correctly?
← PreviousPage 8 of 32Next →