HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

californical

2,035 karma · joined January 4, 2020

submissionscomments
californical··on Pion, an agent designed to run any company autonomously
I’m not on normal social media so I had no idea that stuff was out there.

Absolutely incredible trolling from some of those people I’m sure, while others are actual believers

californical··on Why are AI agents lying, cheating and coordinating?
I mean I think there’s a similar level of judgement required.

Was the owner negligent in controlling their pig/dog/AI?

Was anyone else negligent along the way?

For example if the pig was just a normal pig, the owner cared for them normally, and there was a freak accident where the pig escaped and happened to kill a kid? Obviously nobody at fault.

If you have a dog with a history of violence and let it walk around off-leash with you around town, and it kills a kid? Absolutely the dog owner was negligent and should be charged.

Did you buy an AI sold to you as secure and the provider implies that it’s in a sandbox? Provider is on the hook for the damage.

californical··on Feeling Sad about AI
> We sold out for crypto scams and toxic social media and surveillance capitalism

Eh maybe you did, I and a bunch of people that I know have worked in companies that build software that genuinely helps people and improves their lives - either by simplifying something that sucked for them or by just improving inefficient industries and giving people new abilities.

I don’t feel that way about anything I’ve worked on in my 20 years of building software

californical··on NTSB issues investigative update on B-767 runway excursion accident in Miami
> Rarely works that way.

How sure are you? Could it actually happen that way 95% of the time, which means they don’t crash and we never hear about it? Likely a pilot gets disciplined for the other errors and nobody else cares? This exact thing could happen 20 times with everything turning up relatively ok and we only heard about it because they didn’t make that final call correctly either.

To be clear I’m not an aviator, just an armchair statistician with an interest in aviation

californical··on Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit
(1) not the point I was making, I’m not any of those categories. But I am worried about the treatment of those people, as well as giving the government tools to someday come after people with guns, people who vote incorrectly, meeting up with a friend who happens to have a strong political view, etc.

(2) It can be both - we can ban the government from having direct access to mass surveillance and data privacy laws which makes retaining and using data on individuals much more restrictive.

californical··on Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit
Just wait til we have an administration in the White House (I’m guessing not this one?) which directly threatens your freedoms in such a way that they can easily use cameras to prosecute those who they disagree with.

Current governments have used the mass surveillance to go after people for abortions and for being too foreign-seeming (even if here legally). If those don’t affect you, surely you can think of something that the next wave of government officials might be opposed to, which could use a surveillance network to take away from you.

Having laws to prevent abuses doesn’t help when the lawmakers change and can just revoke those laws, while the full infrastructure exists to do whatever they want.

> Red light cameras, for example, strike me as unalloyed good.

This actually makes me think that your post is satire, due to the heavy debate on whether these cameras actually improve safety [0]. Lots of studies that contradict each other on that. I agree we need to prevent the recklessness of drivers, and there is an argument to be made here. But it’s not at all obvious like you imply.

From [0]:

> When the Houston cameras were removed, angle accidents increased by 26 percent. However, all other types of accidents decreased by 18 percent. Approximately one-third of all Houston intersection accidents are angle accidents. This suggests that the program’s drawbacks canceled out its benefits.

> Our study showed no evidence that cameras reduce the total number of accidents. We estimate that total accidents are reduced by a statistically insignificant 3 percent after the cameras are turned off.

> Likewise, there’s no evidence that the camera program reduced the number of traffic-related injuries or the likelihood of incurring an incapacitating injury.

[0] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/red-light-cameras...

californical··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
Her family can own their copies of Harry Potter forever.

But copyright restricts others from building on top of previous works. Can her family forever sue anyone into poverty for naming a wizard “Harry”? Does that even make sense in 100 years from now when most people have never heard of Harry Potter anymore?

For your building analogy, it would be more like the builders created your building there, and now you own it. It has a red roof and blue shutters. And also the government passed a law that said nobody else can own a building ever again with a red roof and blue shutters, otherwise you, the owner of the idea of those colors, can take possession of every new building like that.

californical··on How the Tobacco Industry Drove the Rise of Ultra-Processed Foods (2025)
Whole wheat is not ultra processed though?

It is processed but not ultra-processed. You can look into this by a simple search: “is flour ultra processed” and I got a number of results explaining the difference.

White flour though, generally is

californical··on Google AI Mode shows same products 21.6% more expensive than traditional search
Holy gaslighting! Why do more reputable sites which don’t rank highly in the shopping results not have this problem? It’s specific to using the shopping results from search engines, I didn’t recently get any “surprise fee” on the Polk Audio manufacturer website directly, for example
californical··on Sony makes bold claim about game ownership
I think it depends. If they are also required to allow 3rd party stores, and one of the third parties has a “buy” button while the others have “lease (lifetime)” buttons, it might sway a decent number of people.

Same thing with consoles, if one has “buy” and the other “lease”, then it might not convert everyone but could it take 5% of sales? 10%? 20%??

californical··on GitHub Outage Tracker: Is GitHub Cooked?
If I own a restaurant and buy bread from a supplier — BreadHub.

And 99% of the bread that I get is good but 1% of the loaves, they forgot to add flour. Consistently, for years, they always have loaves missing a key ingredient that I still end up paying for.

I can be pretty sure that BreadHub have a pretty major internal issue, and should probably be questioning their competence, regardless of their “scale”, and without any knowledge of the “problems they’re solving”

californical··on Meta reaches $17B settlement over social media harms to children
My favorite is the “acoustic bike” instead of electric bike (the joke comes from guitars, I think)
californical··on Everything I own, owned
Eh I think the monitors should just handle this automatically - mine do. I basically have no idea that they do any cleaning cycles except when I check their “advanced” menu and it says it’s run 1200 times or whatever
californical··on I dream of quieter computing
I agree that input latency matters a LOT but disagree about 120hz being some sort of sweet spot.

On the input side, yeah even a few 10’s of ms is very noticeable when typing or doing something quick.

But also I use 240hz monitors for everything, and when I had a config bug on my Mac that degraded my connection to 180hz, my computer felt slow and laggy, and I only realized when it drove me crazy enough to check the settings again. I’m sure the same would happen if I was on a 480hz monitor and it got degraded to the 240hz that I’m used to now.

And I agree there are diminishing returns, but there are still very perceptible returns.

californical··on Risk of transmission of amyloid β pathology via transfused blood products
> All of medical science still imagines a world where humans are in "God's shape", denying the fact that we are machines made of systems of smaller machines.

No, it’s that these systems of systems are so incredibly complex that we still don’t understand many of them deeply. And misunderstanding the relationships of systems leads to major side effects and unpredictability.

If we understood these systems then we wouldn’t have vague success rates on things like drugs or surgeries - we’d be able to say “based on all of these factors this is the treatment that works for you”. But we can’t do that, instead we have trials and shrug and say “it works for most people so it’s worth using”

californical··on Canada will match US tariffs 'dollar for dollar' as trade talks break down
Have you seen that SmarterEveryDay video about trying to make a grill brush in the US? That obviously would’ve been possible in the US 50 years ago but is borderline impossible today because every manufacturer laughs in your face and just says “make it in China, we can’t help you”
californical··on Kagi added a setting for removing paywalled links from search results
I’m guessing because it’s valuable to have a trustworthy AI assistant that you can just explain what you want and it finds the best options
californical··on And then the men with guns tell you to do it anyway
To be clear, I agree with you. I was making a point to the person that I replied to who wanted zero homeless people.

My point was that there is a bottom some-percent of homeless people that can’t immediately be helped.

But yeah I think I made my point clear in the second paragraph that we need the resources to provide housing and basic necessities for the majority of homeless people who are able to receive it, though I probably should’ve clarified that those benefits should be tiered and someone who just goes through a terrible point in life and is otherwise in a reasonably healthy place should have easy access to something decent.

californical··on Universal health coverage could save $1T and 114k lives a year: study
The spending per capita, unless I’m mistaken, is just “per person in the country” not “per person insured by the government”.

That means that even though government insurance in the US only covers a relatively small percent of the population, we pay more than other countries that cover the whole population.

californical··on And then the men with guns tell you to do it anyway
I’m guessing there’s a bit of breathing room at the lower end of the system - there will be people who become drug addicts or have major mental health breaks and lose everything.

And ideally we have good safety nets that find these people and give them resources and treatment, but some people will refuse everything and end up in bad situations of homelessness due to their drug and/or mental health crises.

And even in a society that forces those people into attempted treatment programs, there will still be a bit of time in between their issues manifesting and them going into treatment/therapy/confinement.

To have “zero homeless” you’d need to preventatively intercept these people before they become homeless and force them into confinement in treatment facilities and mental hospitals essentially. And that’s a dangerous game because you’re essentially taking away someone’s freedom preemptively before they become homeless

californical··on As Wisconsin cities flee Flock, its shared camera network loses value
On the flip side, you are Uber and you’re trying to decide if you should charge the “low price” or the “high price” to somebody who just opened your app.

Luckily the person you’re about to make an offer to lives within the flock network so you quickly get pings from the last week that they shopped at Whole Foods and dropped by a dispensary on the way home. Yeah this person probably has disposable income, let’s charge them the 30% increased rate.

Or maybe you’re a future employer - oh this guy stopped at a dispensary 12 years ago? The algorithm will give him +4 risk points before we make our hiring decision. Plus he regularly goes to this bad neighborhood (which the algorithm doesn’t know is where his sister lives that he visits), that’s another +9 risk points.

AND on the darker side — if you knew they did this, would you visit your sister less?

californical··on Why does Opus 5 feel worse to work with?
I agree that it’s better at writing than a 50%-ile human, but it’s worse at communicating through writing than most humans.

Even an average human writer can communicate details much more succinctly and directly than an LLM

californical··on U.S. used 'virtually all' of its long-range precision missiles during Iran war
Agreed yes that’s not great. But really if that’s the worst thing you’re noticing in your daily life at home, things must be pretty ok?

You must see the difference between us being unhappy that gas is more expensive, versus somebody living in Iran worrying that their entire government and country is in chaos.

Obviously this war is bad for a bunch of reasons, but the US is completely fine at home relatively.

californical··on U.S. used 'virtually all' of its long-range precision missiles during Iran war
Have they? Obviously there have been a ton of issues due to the US’s strategy in Iran. But almost nobody in the US has any affect from this war. Gas prices are up a bit. Mildly inconvenient for the majority of people, and that’s the biggest failure people are mad about.

Meanwhile Iran is in rough shape

californical··on LLMs reward expertise
A static website is one that doesn’t have an associated backend API server, just serves as one or more self contained file assets.

The files you serve to the browser are static, not the contents of the page itself

Updating the dom can happen with only individual assets, so it’s a static site

californical··on Don't be a meat proxy
It’s just a fancy version of previous tools. Imagine a coworker instead does a refactor by grepping the entire codebase and doing a find-and-replace.

Do they ensure that it didn’t accidentally overwrite something it shouldn’t have?

Or do they just throw up a PR and assume their little refactoring bash command works fine, then expect their coworkers to debug it for them?

californical··on Truth is not a direction: a Tarski attack on LLM probes
Every breath you take, there is a 99.99% chance that everything is normal, and a 0.01% chance that you breathe mild acid which horribly burns and causes a massive coughing fit.

It probably don’t cause long term damage unless that breath happened to be more important than normal, like while driving right as a child runs into the road.

Would you act differently knowing that you had one of these occasional acid breaths? Even if it only happened once per day on average (0.001%)

californical··on What is happening to jobs? Separating AI hype from reality
I don’t think it’s even “seniors” containing slop of others.

I think it’s those who still care about quality (which seems to be decreasing in the industry overall) trying to keep the whole thing running, in a sea of people who think going really really fast and not understanding their code is fine because LLMs can make sense of it and clean it up later.

Just look at the condition of open source contributions recently

californical··on Claude Opus 5
Two things tell me this isn’t the case:

(1) it’s not that I can’t understand their output, it’s just written in a way that is very homogenous and same-y, with very boring cliches and phrases that don’t quite match their context

(2) a pretty strong sign of intelligence is being able to explain complex things in simple terms

californical··on Startup founders urge U.S. government not to shut off Chinese open weight AI
Sure, just like it’s illegal to steal the formula of Coca Cola from their documents.

But you can do an analysis of a bottle of Coke to figure out exactly what’s in it.

You can even make your own and sell it, if you call it a different name.

← PreviousPage 3 of 22Next →