HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

camhart

1,638 karma · joined April 8, 2016

submissionscomments
camhart··on South Korea has jailed a man for using AI to create sexual images of children
The source they posted doesn't conclude what they claimed. It starts with "For most people".

See https://fightthenewdrug.org/violence-and-rape-connected-with... (it links to many different studies, sources at the bottom of the article).

camhart··on South Korea has jailed a man for using AI to create sexual images of children
I can't stop a bird from flying over my head, but I can stop it from making a nest there.
camhart··on South Korea has jailed a man for using AI to create sexual images of children
There are ample studies that show that porn use does increase rape. The results are mixed. Declaring that "current evidence" says otherwise is false.

Update:

See studies referenced at https://fightthenewdrug.org/violence-and-rape-connected-with....

The source the parent provided does not claim what the parent claims. The article starts with a caveat stating "for most people".

camhart··on South Korea has jailed a man for using AI to create sexual images of children
You absolutely can and should control your thoughts. It's not futile. It's not societies job to control anyone's thoughts (neither am I arguing that society should try--that sounds like pure evil), however it is each individuals job to do so.
camhart··on South Korea has jailed a man for using AI to create sexual images of children
Its not backwards. It may be circular. They view it because they want to, but viewing it doesn't satisfy the craving long term. It reinforces it.
camhart··on South Korea has jailed a man for using AI to create sexual images of children
How can someone who likes viewing this look at a child on the street and not see them as a sexual object?

The thoughts/fantasies you harbor while viewing images on a screen do not magically turn off when you step outside. It sticks with you and shapes how you view the world.

It encourages the moral decay of our society and puts our kids (and the future of society) at risk.

camhart··on SpaceX projected 20M Starlink users by 2022–it ended up with 1M
Did the dark paint have no effect?
camhart··on YouTube blocks Russell Brand from making money through its platform
X/twitter is going to explode (in user count) if other platforms continue behaving this way.
camhart··on Shrinkflation Tracker
Did they get smaller or just fewer in the pack?
camhart··on iPhone 15 and iPhone 15 Plus
I don't know a single person using an 8+ year old phone. I'd guess 99% of the population makes a phone last 2-4 years.
camhart··on Ask HN: What is your policy regarding smartphones for your children?
The mental health issues our youth are facing have significant roots in smartphones/social media. The longer you can delay it without having your child be ostracized from their peers the better. Each child will likely need a different approach, but I'd encourage heavy involvement and oversight by parents. The bad far outweighs the good, but if monitored you can hopefully mitigate the bad.
camhart··on When your coworker does great work, tell their manager (2020)
Because its confusing. Don't say that you like something when you don't. It's a failure to communicate.
camhart··on For many home-schoolers, parents are no longer doing the teaching
Not feeling comfortable could be question of time. You get comfortable when you go from kindergarten to 12th grade with the same kids. You know them well, because you've been in classes with a lot of them for 6-7 hours / day, 5 days a week, 9 months a year.

As I typed the above paragraph out, it actually makes me question. Is that really growing social skills if they're always surrounded by the same kids? For example, I moved to a different state between 8th grade and the start of high school. That experience helped me to understand what it's like to not have friends, how long it takes to make friends (2-3+ years), and how to interact with a lot of peers you don't know and who don't know you.

It was interesting when I went to college, and I found other students who were nice, but never really interested in being your friend because they went to the same college as many of their high school friends. Or they grew up near the college and had all their high school friends nearby still. I guess this latter point isn't really social skills, but it is something that I learned to be aware of.

camhart··on Ask HN: Anyone Having Issues with AWS?
Nevermind, clock was off due to linux dual boot.
camhart··on Show HN: Get notified when sites update their terms of service
Use ChatGPT to compare the different versions and summarize the changes for you.
camhart··on Show HN: San Francisco Compute – 512 H100s at <$2/hr for research and startups
Optimism is (almost) always required in order to accomplish anything of significance. Those who lose it, aren't living up to their potential.

I'm not encouraging the false belief that everything you do will work out. Instead I'm encouraging the realization that the greatest accomplishments almost always feel like long shots, and require significant amounts of optimism. Fear and pessimism, while helpful in appropriate doses, will limit you greatly in life if you let them rule you too significantly.

When I look back on my life, the greatest accomplishments I've achieved are ones where I was naive yet optimistic going into it. This was a good thing, because I would have been too scared to try had I really known the challenges that lay ahead.

camhart··on The underground economy of Glassdoor reviews
> No one trusts these review companies actually.

Most people do trust them, but shouldn't.

camhart··on Workers with less experience gain the most from generative AI
My experience with Bard/ChatGPT has been that you'll easily shoot your foot off if you don't know what you're doing. Dangerous for workers with less experience.

I see claims that it makes you 7-8x more effective. That hasn't been my experience. Maybe 5-10% improvement at best. Instead of Googling myself, LLMs can sometimes give me the answer more quickly than I could find it.

Once you ask it anything not easily scraped on the internet it hallucinates like crazy and sounds so confident about it. Maybe I'm just horrible at prompting, but I can't help but feel we're still N breakthroughs away from having it really impact dev jobs.

camhart··on Apple joins opposition to encrypted message app scanning
That isn't reality. You give up privacy all the time in exchange for things. And even with e2ee you don't "have" privacy guaranteed.
camhart··on Apple joins opposition to encrypted message app scanning
> CSAM does carry emotional weight.

I never argued it doesn't.

> Your entire argument is that since privacy measures are already loose then its okay to make them looser for "the children".

Where did I make this argument? (hint: I didn't)

camhart··on Apple joins opposition to encrypted message app scanning
> Very nearly nobody is arguing otherwise, though.

How is equating CSAM to (merely) emotional weight not doing that?

camhart··on Apple joins opposition to encrypted message app scanning
If the update is targeted at a single individual, it's almost guaranteed to go undetected.

Yes you can decompile code. But reverse engineering is time intensive (I've done it). And these code bases are huge. It wouldn't be difficult to obfuscate some element of the code so it's difficult to detect. Especially if it's rarely triggered.

> The proposed solution to stopping child porn from being shared on these platforms would at most only do just that: Stop sharing on these specific apps. There are plenty of alternatives including encrypted zips, TOR etc. Breaking e2ee in WhatsApp would not do anything to stop sharing the material.

There is value in introducing barriers, even when imperfect. You must admit that, otherwise the fact that Google/Apple can ship an OS update whenever they want negates the entire argument in favor of e2ee.

Also, just FYI encrypted zips are easily brute forced.

camhart··on Apple joins opposition to encrypted message app scanning
I understand your argument, and I appreciate it. The same could be said of of the "other side" of this argument though. The "government will spy on you!"--is also emotional weight cynically being used to get people to go along with technical solutions that support CSAM.

I'd argue society would generally agree CSAM is unacceptable and we're allowing it right now. Many are quick to adopt the assumption that this law is an intentional and cleverly designed "attack on our rights to e2ee", as fact. If one can't recognize it's at least a poor attempt to balance the right to privacy with protecting kids, then I struggle to see how they're being honest with themselves.

I'm not arguing this law proposes the correct solution that should be adopted. I'm not arguing the surveillance state isn't licking their chops. I'm simply trying to point out that CSAM is a real problem. People really care about it. And it's factually wrong to claim otherwise.

It's also wrong and harmful to attribute motive based on assumptions. While you haven't done this, many others have. Instead of taking part in a constructive debate by arguing specific points, they try to paint a false motive on the opposition. "it's just so they can spy on you!" is roughly equivalent to "you view CSAM and that's why you don't want to protect our kids". These approaches are not how you reach a good solution that balances both sides of the argument. They're just throwing the oppositions legitimate concerns under the bus.

I'd also add, while e2ee is strong, unless you're verifying and compiling all the code you run on your device yourself, Apple/Google/etc still maintains the technical ability to snoop on you regardless of this law. I assume the bar to snoop on someone would most likely be lowered if laws like this are passed. But it's still technically possible (and likely happens).

camhart··on Apple joins opposition to encrypted message app scanning
Children literally are the future society. Making them a priority is more selfless than making today's adults a priority.

What does covid have to do with the 10+ years of data I referenced? And even if the data does skew up during covid, how does that make it less of a problem?

camhart··on Apple joins opposition to encrypted message app scanning
Parents are more selfish? That is the exact opposite of my experience. Parents are generally the most selfless. Its those who choose not to be a parent who prefer their selfish desires.

And yes, csam is on the up and up.

> From March 2009 to February 2022, the number of victims identified in child sexual abuse material (CSAM) rose from 2,172 victims to over 21,413 victims. From 2012 to 2022, the volume of reports to the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children’s CyberTipline concerning child sexual exploitation increased from 415,650 reports to over 32 million reports.

See https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/press/dem/releases/durbin-i....

camhart··on Apple joins opposition to encrypted message app scanning
CSAM is a real problem. Its not merely emotional weight.
camhart··on Eating microwave popcorn increases the level of PFAS in body (2022)
It's not an affiliate link... I just copied the URL my browser gave me.
camhart··on Eating microwave popcorn increases the level of PFAS in body (2022)
I've found I burn the popcorn often with this. Maybe just a lack of experience (we always had an air popper growing up). You can also use small amounts of butter (or I guess oil if you wanted) with the silicone popper or air popper. Having enough oil to cover the base seems like a lot more oil? I could be wrong, just guessing.
camhart··on Eating microwave popcorn increases the level of PFAS in body (2022)
Microwave popcorn (in the bag) is garbage. I found I much prefer using a silicone popper [1], and then adding my own butter/salt to it. Tastes just like when I use an air popper. Since that approach doesn't use the popcorn bag, would it then be free from PFAS?

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Proper-Popper-Microwave-Collapsible-D...

camhart··on My 24 year old HP Jornada can do things an iPhone still can't do
What is the perceived "value" the walled garden is giving you?

I've always owned an android, and not once had to worry about security or malicious apps. Apple seems to have sold everyone on this idea that Android is super insecure. It's not.

← PreviousPage 4 of 15Next →