HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

caminante

2,626 karma · joined March 21, 2014

submissionscomments
caminante··on IBM Spins Off the First Pure-Play Quantum Chip Foundry
This is a pro-IBM piece.

I'm surprised it has zero mention of potential advantages of trapped ion despite being superior on stability windows, accuracy, and operating temps.

I also appreciate the disclosure about AI generated content, but this article gets too repetitive.

caminante··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
> Complaining about 2:1 immigrant to local birth rate has absolutely nothing to do with long-time permanent residents (who are locals)

Wrong again. They're locals and overseas-born immigrants.

caminante··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
Here you are again [0], unable to represent comments in good faith.

Nobody said "non-white" and it isn't even implied because a significant proportion -- 35-40% of Australian Permanent Residents (US green card equivalent) -- come from EU/"White" countries.

The suggestions above are consistent with my request for you to review the HN comment guidelines.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48252227

caminante··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
>I know you're going to...

Well, I'm apparently not in the imagined conversation you're having. Seems insecure to pre-bake an out for a hypothetical.

Never rejected systemic racism exists, but calling everything racist without substance (and accusing people of ignoring system racism without support) erodes meaning.

I suggest reviewing the HN guidelines for comments. If you disagree with them, this forum may not be for you.

caminante··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
That's a strawman.

Even so, you're "having trouble" acknowledging a singular fact that calls a claim into question? Is two facts the magic number? Three? Why is one insufficient?

It'd be more effective to offer an actual reason.

caminante··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
How is a scheme systemically racist when >50% of 13M green card holders are from Latin/South America and Caribbean?

You can't be serious.

caminante··on El Niño is coming. The last time ocean temp. looked like this, millions died
Yeah...I know you want to gripe, but you'll have to be more convincing.
caminante··on El Niño is coming. The last time ocean temp. looked like this, millions died
LOL!

How do you reconcile arguing it isn't "alarmism" and acknowledging the claims are "absurd"?

You're definitely trying to have it both ways on the issue of whether people have been guilty of promoting alarmism.

caminante··on El Niño is coming. The last time ocean temp. looked like this, millions died
You really should revisit the absurd claims Gore was promoting that didn't age well like the north pole melting in 5 years (2014).

IMHO, the toxic chemicals comparison doesn't work.

For climate change, you have alternatives to raise people's quality of life more effectively and saying that you must prioritize fighting climate change over ... better healthcare, sanitation (avoidance of toxic chemicals!*), nutrition, workforce development, etc. is not really an easy sell because the other paths yield better ROI.

*Edit*

caminante··on El Niño is coming. The last time ocean temp. looked like this, millions died
>rich Westerner

Not quite.

These affluent countries torture themselves with terrible energy transition projects that jack up prices for everyone at the cost of more efficient alternatives.

Healthcare, nutrition, education and other programs do vastly more for quality of life improvements for the poor.

caminante··on Growing tribe of jobless techies is stuck in Silicon Valley's new reality
Hiring 2-6% of applicants?

That sounds high, not to be dreary, but given how easy it is to spam and roles having thousands of applicants.

There's about 10M in US tech jobs and the forecast for net job adds is +2% in 2026 so the number on a macro level checks out.

caminante··on A message from President Kornbluth about funding and the talent pipeline
>is not the same as not getting to complete a PhD (rare)

BTW, your perspective is bizarre.

Not sure where you're getting the idea that PhD candidate attrition is rare. Maybe at MIT where only 20% don't finish (within 10 years -- which is generous), but these are already pre-screened superstars. Most other places converge around 50%.

As for salaries, the median salary for CS PhDs outside academia is $180k. That means a lot are lower and probably aren't working at big tech with full comp pushing them above $300k. [0]

[0] https://ncses.nsf.gov/pubs/nsf26312

caminante··on U.S. DOJ demands Apple and Google unmask over 100k users of car-tinkering app
> They cannot void your warranty, in whole or in part.

I understand what you're saying, but your core beef seems really pedantic in context.

Yes, the warranty terms aren't abandoned, but...

..."voided" isn't a defined term, it's not used anywhere in the Magnusson-Moss Warranty Act (from my scan), I sourced an attorney using "voiding" in a more casual sense, and you even acknowledge that in practice, you're screwed if you tune your car, get caught by the dealer/manufacturer, and have issues with relevant components.

caminante··on U.S. DOJ demands Apple and Google unmask over 100k users of car-tinkering app
Damn. You get a complimentary track day, but Toyota said going 114 MPH is abuse. Both cars were just serviced.

Adding insult, one guy had his comprehensive insurance coverage lapse right before!

caminante··on U.S. DOJ demands Apple and Google unmask over 100k users of car-tinkering app
What is your understanding of the Act and its limitations [0]?

Here's a legal view that explains it further [1].

Basically, they can deny warranty service if you make modifications, and they can tie it to a failure. You can add 100s of HP to your engine profile with these things, and why would it be reasonable to expect a manufacturer to warrant related component repairs if they're pushed beyond spec?

Here are relevant quotes, and []'s are mine.

> The Magnuson Moss Warranty Act requires manufacturers to honor their warranties and auto manufacturers only warrant their vehicles against manufacturing defects. Your claim here could be denied because the failure was not due to a defect in a factory component. It was caused by something added to the car[...] That system caused a non-defective part to fail. Your mod did not void the [entire] warranty. It’s just that the failure was not caused by a factory defect.

> Obviously, an aftermarket camshaft or a hopped up ECU won’t void the entire warranty on your car. The master cylinder failed? The blue tooth quit working? Unless there is a logical connection between the mod and the part or system that failed, you should be good to go.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnuson%E2%80%93Moss_Warranty...

[1] https://lehtoslaw.com/will-modifications-void-new-car-warran...

caminante··on U.S. DOJ demands Apple and Google unmask over 100k users of car-tinkering app
If you start tuning, then make sure you turn it off before bringing your car to the dealership.

It'll void any warranty.

caminante··on We are retiring our bug bounty program
Maybe "Hurricane Hacker" who produces "tactical tornadoes" via agents?
caminante··on A message from President Kornbluth about funding and the talent pipeline
>In CS/tech, those who exit academia after PhDs get paid $300K-$500K

Yes, I'd like to see data on what percentile gets this and breaks even for lost wages from their PhD years. IMHO, it's not fair to generalize this outcome. I could be wrong.

caminante··on A message from President Kornbluth about funding and the talent pipeline
Yes, they don't realize it or lie to themselves because ~50% dropout.

Given the attrition, I really question if PhD programs are honest with incoming prospects. Law schools and business schools are similarly "guilty" of pimping outcomes.

ITT: it's people complaining about being overworked and mislead in their PhD programs.

caminante··on A message from President Kornbluth about funding and the talent pipeline
He appears to be tunnel-visioning on academia.

The vast majority (>75%) of Computer Science PhDs leave academia. [0] Becoming a "world expert in a specific topic" is overfitting skills for a sub-niche of a specific career. There certainly aren't enough jobs in academia.

[0] https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/213640/what-rat...

caminante··on Claude for Small Business
This guy's acting in bad faith. Sorry you got swept into this.
caminante··on Claude for Small Business
> I concede that I started the thread with a joke but wow you really are upset.

You went further than "a joke."

You continued making aggressive, non-substantive remarks that were out of line.[0]

#1 > you have no idea about the details.

#2 > i don’t think you have a grasp what’s going on around you.

#3 > What is your deal about contract law? It’s not some mystical thing.

You wasted everyone's time.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

caminante··on Claude for Small Business
> You can get red lines with Anthropic, you can get a DPA with Anthropic.

IMHO,

1. Dismissing attorney client privilege is reckless

2. and the vast majority of users aren't aware of what "customization in the contracts" is needed to enable autonomous agents or if it's already contractually allowed.

This is still a fair question:

> Do you, and those executives, own the risks associated with that practice? Are those risks actually indemnified?

caminante··on US inflation jumps to 3.8% as energy costs surge from Iran war
> I’d say who cares if demand for oil specifically goes down?

"How" it happens is the nuance.

The point above was that people would get priced out (not by choice), lowering (read: destroying) demand. They experience lower quality of life, can't afford fertilizer for crops, lack capital to build reliable renewables, lose jobs, etc.

caminante··on US inflation jumps to 3.8% as energy costs surge from Iran war
I suggest revisiting the definition [0]. IMHO, your understanding is at odds and I suspect you're intending to say people will replace with energy from elsewhere (which still qualifies as demand destruction).

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demand_destruction

caminante··on US inflation jumps to 3.8% as energy costs surge from Iran war
Disagree.

I assume your understanding of "demand destruction" is mixing concepts.

GP said switching to alternative sources isn't demand destruction when it IS technically and relatively.

The parent's point: until you get those renewables online (decade long process now with permitting), prices will go up. You'll have people using less energy (in general) and less O&G -- both are quintessential demand destruction.

For nitrogen fertilizer (ammonia), there's already demand destruction with people cutting back due to price shocks. That's less food and ag.

caminante··on US inflation jumps to 3.8% as energy costs surge from Iran war
It's in direct response to the parent

> I shudder to think just how badly we will be outmatched in a shooting war with China.

caminante··on Valve releases Steam Controller CAD files under Creative Commons license
And they've done legendary doublespeak while looking the other way!
caminante··on Security through obscurity is not bad
Regarding Counterstrike (game) example, there were already a lot of cheaters and a cheater ecosystem that still exists to this day. I suspect Valve could address it if it wanted to, but the gameplay/development cost trade-offs aren't enough.

Valve pivoted to server-side anti-cheat and toleration because someone probably did the math on max(profit) with lootboxes.

caminante··on How an oil refinery works
They're still playing above the law and read anti-corruption regulations as "how to" manuals.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →