HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

caminante

2,626 karma · joined March 21, 2014

submissionscomments
caminante··on In Japan, the robot isn't coming for your job; it's filling the one nobody wants
You mean "METI"? METI is your key driver?

You're really overselling their capabilities.

See the "lost decades" or most recently, the hundreds of billions deployed for the failed hydrogen initiatives.

caminante··on AGI won't automate most jobs–because they're not worth the trouble
Ironic given author brazenly brags about being a top AI assisted author, "writing" 100 articles per month [0] and this article is paywalled.

If you're going to AI, why paywall?

[0]https://www.wsj.com/business/media/an-ai-upheaval-is-coming-...

caminante··on F-15E jet shot down over Iran
I was aware of the IRGC graft.

I tried to check the amounts normalized for % of GDP.

Conservative estimates put them at half of the 2% GDP military spend. However, the IRGC's tentacles are also estimated to siphon off something like +50% of the GDP.[0]

Not all of that money's going to military hardware, but they have a substantial slush fund and use the Iranian resource base as a military piggy bank.

[0]https://fortune.com/2026/03/02/iran-islamic-revolutionary-gu...

caminante··on LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions
I agree that it could come off as gross negligence to not care about what happens with your data.

My point is that LinkedIn already has enough information (We've willingly given them!) to manipulate outcomes and if they're doing something nefarious, then it's already too late.

Whereas Cambridge Analytica involved bad actors (not Facebook) duping customers and re-selling their data. I don't think those elements are necessarily in play here.

caminante··on LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions
You're glossing over the nuance of the Cambridge Analytica scandal or at least I don't see how it's connected here.

Facebook was a party, but not the protagonist.

- a Cambridge researcher (Aleks Kogan) created a personality quiz FB app advertised as academic research

- users had to consent to download the app

- the app nefariously scraped users' friends' data (300k users unlocked 87 million users' data)

- the information was sold to Cambridge Analytica

- who then used the information to profile American voters

LinkedIn already has all of this information from the information you feed it. Scanning for more information provides more refined views, but LinkedIn already has your graph.

caminante··on LinkedIn is illegally searching your computer
I agree.

I'm not convinced by their page explaining "Why it's illegal and potentially criminal" [0]. It's written by security researchers and non-attorneys.

For example, this characterization seems overly broad:

> The Court of Justice of the European Union has ruled, in three separate cases, that data which allows someone to infer or deduce protected characteristics is covered by this prohibition, regardless of whether the company intended to collect sensitive data.

[0] https://browsergate.eu/why-its-illegal/

caminante··on LinkedIn Is Illegally Searching Your Computer
They already have so much telemetry from your phone, IP, etc.

God forbid they make an educated guess based on your actual LinkedIn connections, name, interests, etc.

caminante··on Why the US Navy won't blast the Iranians and 'open' Strait of Hormuz
I didn't take it as exhaustive.

While you're alluding to high-end reapers/etc., the majority of drones in the Ukraine-Russia conflict have foam wings and low cost components.

caminante··on TSA lines are so out of control that travelers are hiring line-sitters
>if it was a jobs program, it would be way better staffed..

You're saying it's not comparable to the size of the New Deal, the biggest jobs program ever in the US.

That doesn't disqualify it from consideration as a jobs program as there are many jobs programs much smaller.

Adding 60k to ~3 million is significant because it's permanent. These are low skilled workers (and security theater as you astutely say) mostly concentrated in large cities.

Whereas the New Deal was temp jobs that disappeared once grants and funding disappeared.

caminante··on Stop microphones from recording your voice
It's not "pearl clutching" when there are enforceable laws like 18 U.S.C. § 1362.[0]

Were you even aware of this?

Can you actually cite a legal opinion about the device or similar applications? Otherwise, I'm assuming you are speculating, too.

[0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1362

caminante··on Stop microphones from recording your voice
You're right about FCC laws, but there are non-FCC laws, too, such as penalties for willful interference with federal/state emergency communications.

I'm wondering if this device would cause issues for a nearby person's emergency communications. Seems potentially really bad.

caminante··on TSA lines are so out of control that travelers are hiring line-sitters
Doesn't work.

If TSA were added, there still wouldn't be any lines at private terminals.

caminante··on TSA lines are so out of control that travelers are hiring line-sitters
By what standard?

Federal civilian workforce (ex Postal Service and Military) is only 3 million.

TSA has 60k employees.

That's a lot of permanent jobs.

caminante··on Stop microphones from recording your voice
This seems like product spam.

The explanation isn't satisfying

>What is Spectre I and how does it work?

Spectre I is a portable audio security device that creates a 2m protection zone around you. It sends out signals that are inaudible to you but can be detected by a microphone. Through customization of the signals to match the human voice, your conversations are "overlayed" when a microphone receives them. It uses local processing to prevent nearby smartphones, smart speakers, and other devices from picking up your voice. Everything happens locally on the device — nothing is sent to the cloud.

It's unclear whether it performs the task or if it's illegal, similar to a phone jammer.

caminante··on LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadly runway crash
They still "apply to your paraphrase" which isn't accurate?

What?

It doesn't work like that unless you're having a different conversation.

caminante··on LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadly runway crash
“Vehicles with large blind spots don’t belong on the runway” is a completely untenable proposal.

I never said this. This is very different to what I said.

This reveals you're having a different conversation.

caminante··on LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadly runway crash
>from the driver's seat the jet would be quite hard to see in this case.

..is what I was responding to.

>We can’t say that emergency vehicles should just stay in on dark and stormy nights.

This conclusion is flawed and doesn't apply to what I said.

If a truck can't see (conditions or not), then they shouldn't be on the same runway as takeoff/landing because...the consequences were severe despite the safeguards you mentioned, e.g. Not driving fast is relative and the "eyes" failed too initially.

caminante··on LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadly runway crash
Visibility was bad (night and mist) too.

But if your truck has blind spots and vis is poor, you shouldn't be driving as fast if at all.

caminante··on Bored of eating your own dogfood? Try smelling your own farts
Not offended. Try to have a 'better' day.
caminante··on Bored of eating your own dogfood? Try smelling your own farts
I blame me ;-). Though, one haywire reply can taint everyone's interpretation!
caminante··on Bored of eating your own dogfood? Try smelling your own farts
The irony isn't lost on me, either.

Googling does result with a Gemini/AI response at the top.

caminante··on Bored of eating your own dogfood? Try smelling your own farts
Are you replying to the intended comment?

The parent said they were getting stonewalled by a colleague over a T/F. Maybe you're assuming I called the parent a liar...?

caminante··on Bored of eating your own dogfood? Try smelling your own farts
What do you propose instead?

edit: Nevermind. You shared your thoughts in a later comment above, dismissing the HN forum as vindictive.

caminante··on Bored of eating your own dogfood? Try smelling your own farts
Liars gonna lie.

> I challenged him on this by Googling the Intune manual to set the default browser.

I've found that LLMs really democratize debate when issues like this arise!

Can't guarantee you'll win, but when someone bets you're not willing to RTFM to call their bluff-- Oh boy!

caminante··on BYD is seeing a flood of new EV buyers
I can't take your comments seriously, though, I don't think you're trying act in bad faith.

> You’re saying the overbuild is “insane”. Do you have an actual cite for this? I’m assuming there’s some percent over capacity you need to build that would allow people to reason about this.

If you have zero intuition about storage overbuild or underbuild to firm up intermittent capacity or why PJM has an undersupply of storage, then on what basis are you calling my comments on storage "sleight of hand"? My assumption, though, and seriously not trying to be mean, but based on your bio and paradoxical comments, you don't really know how to defend your argument or read these primary sources you requested.

> I’m still not seeing an answer here re: the cost of natural gas, it seems like that has a huge impact on all of these assumptions.

Taking one step at a time, you still haven't acknowledged you were incorrect about LCOE comparisons to date. These are provided in the sources that you asked for.

As for the future, you can run sensitivities. My primary sources included price shock sensitivities. You probably overlooked or can't process them as it appears.

caminante··on BYD is seeing a flood of new EV buyers
> You’re arguing that the industry analyses on this subject are wrong because they’re underestimating how much solar + batteries need to be deployed to be as reliable as a gas power plant.

No, the industry knows this. Talk to any investor or developer. See the capacity market blowout in PJM because they don't have enough firm power supply to offset the flood of renewables (sans storage). Or just look at the announcements for natural gas turbine demand by datacenters, which need 24/7 power. The overbuild for renewables and storage is insane to hit the same reliability and safety margins.

> So you’re arguing that initial capex (which everyone acknowledges is higher than natural gas) is somewhat higher than existing analyses think it is

It's not just CAPEX. It's also OPEX. LCOE is a normalized ($/MWh) metric that allows for comparison. See Lazard [0] or NREL's analysis [1] on LCOE costs. Note how expensive solar plus storage becomes on an LCOE basis and realistically, you might need way more than 4h batteries to hit reliability targets.

[0] https://www.lazard.com/media/5tlbhyla/lazards-lcoeplus-june-...

[1] https://atb.nrel.gov/electricity/2024/index

> because both solar and batteries are frequently found to last well beyond their factory-rated lifetimes.

BTW, this is like saying you can still use laptops past their 5 year warranty. Yes, but that's not how depreciation, financing, and service levels work. These assets are getting pushed to their limits and not everyone's buying tier 1 suppliers.

caminante··on BYD is seeing a flood of new EV buyers
> Solar and batteries have been and will continue...

Yes, your statement is still false. Opposite is true.

caminante··on BYD is seeing a flood of new EV buyers
No, solar reliability requires overbuild and storage to compare accurately on LCOE. Hybrid and overbuild = expensive, so not "cheap/er", which you said.

A lot of people have this misconception about solar even with awareness of the duck curve.

caminante··on BYD is seeing a flood of new EV buyers
> Solar and batteries have been and will continue to he the cheapest source of power, and globally, deployment is accelerating.

I think storage is great and solar has a place, but this is not true unless you discard reliability and other features, which should be in the price. Solar plus storage for baseload power matching requires huge overbuilds. Even in the last few years, before the AI hype, installed utility scale renewables costs went up in the US. It's not just the hardware or national politics.

And if you can't get renewables interconnected in a couple years, then the install rate won't lower the carbon of the existing grid mix charging your car.

caminante··on BYD's bet on EVs is paying off as drivers ditch gas amid rising oil prices
> I wasn't talking about BYD in particular,

You quoted the parent's mention of BYD.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →