HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

canadian_voter

842 karma · joined October 25, 2016

submissionscomments
canadian_voter··on Future Economy (2010) [video]
"When you positively leave a house and enter into another house your positive action ceases to be positive action at all because you have abandoned one power structure for another, which you will again have to leave. So this constant repetition, which appears to be a positive action, is really inaction. But if you reject the desire and the search for all inward security, then it is a total negation which is a most positive action. It is this action only which transforms man. If you reject hate and envy, in every form, you are rejecting the whole structure of what man has created in himself and outside himself. It is very simple. One problem is related to every other problem." -- Krishnamurti (from Freedom, Love and Action)

The main problems that STNG deals with are ethical, philosophical and spiritual, not technological or economical.

Just as there is "technobabble" about space-time continuums and positronic brains, there is also a bit of hand waving about the specifics of how the economy functions.

Just as it's silly to worry about whether they're calibrating the plasma manifolds correctly, it is missing the point to think that STNG is going to deliver actionable economic advice.

canadian_voter··on Future Economy (2010) [video]
> What threshold is going to make prime real estate lots around Lake Washington not scarce?

Warp drive? A thousand habitable planets that make Earth look like dusty, irradiated backwater? An vast frontier to explore, filled with endless new challenges and experiences?

canadian_voter··on Future Economy (2010) [video]
Not everyone can get what they want, but certainly everyone gets what they need. Everyone living in mansions? Nope. But is anybody homeless? Nope. It's a trade-off.

Many sought-after things are scarce. Starship commissions are scarce. They require hard work and are assigned based on merit. Not just anyone gets the opportunity to explore the edge of space; it takes dedication and sacrifice.

The show is certainly influence by the philosophy of Stoicism[0].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stoicism

canadian_voter··on Future Economy (2010) [video]
Well, for a start, it's a post-scarcity society that has the capacity to produce 7 billion widgets if necessary. So that gets you around a lot of problems.

You'll notice that the crew quarters in the show are decorated in a minimalist style. The only objects people keep are the ones that are important to them. Tools, games, gifts can be conjured as needed and recycled when you're done with them.

Scarce resources do exist, however, especially on a starship: crew quarters are probably not all of the same size, for example. Some people might have to walk a little further to the turbolift (elevator). These sorts of resource allocation problems are likely solved by either a lottery method or based on need. For example, if the Captain gets bigger quarters, it's not because she's the captain, it's because she might need the space to host visiting delegates, etc.

Although I suppose there are still some material inequalities based on rank. For example, ensigns get a single rank pip, while a captain gets four.

canadian_voter··on U.S. Punishes Russia for Election Hacking
Trump's cavalier response to this is shocking. These are serious allegations. His statement is mind melting on so many levels:

Asked on Wednesday night at his Mar-a-Lago estate in Palm Beach, Fla., about reports of the impending sanctions, Mr. Trump said: “I think we ought to get on with our lives. I think that computers have complicated lives very greatly. The whole age of computer has made it where nobody knows exactly what is going on. We have speed, we have a lot of other things, but I’m not sure we have the kind, the security we need.”

canadian_voter··on People's underestimation of AI
An old man told me that, once upon a time, every steam train would have two stokers aboard. Their job was to fuel the fire with coal; a hard, dirty job. They were replaced by mechanical stokers and their jobs made obsolete. But the union was strong and negotiated that the stokers would ride on each train, just as they had before; but of course now they could relax and not have to work.

I suppose trains to this day must still have pairs of stokers, riding along, benefiting from labour saving technology. But of course it is not so. Eventually the dead weight gets cut.

Sometimes it gets done slowly and with respect for the dignity of the workers. Sometimes they're just tossed out in the cold.

canadian_voter··on People's underestimation of AI
> We just need to be better to each other.

I believe that the fundamental problems of our time are ethical, not technological. If we can figure that part out, the technology should take care of itself.

I would love to live in a post-scarcity utopia where we all run around self-actualizing. I don't think we need to give up AI to get there -- in fact, I think technology will be the key that unlocks the gate.

But we have to have the wisdom to pass through it with style and bring as many people as we can on the way. Otherwise we might find ourselves fighting for our place in line and possibly even annihilate ourselves in the process.

canadian_voter··on People's underestimation of AI
They don't need anyone to buy their wares if they are self reliant and can produce everything they need. We're not talking about making more and faster cell-phones with less labour, we're talking about a small group of people making everything they need without the need for any labour at all.

That might not be a "handful" of people, but it's certainly a smaller number than our current population.

Who needs coal miners if we have all the cheap solar we can use? Who needs farmers if we automate farming? Who needs drivers, maids, schoolteachers, cooks, etc. if we can have the machines do it for us?

Who needs lawyers if our disputes are simply settled by some AI judge? Who needs cops if our streets are patrolled by security robots and we have a Minority Report style crime-prediction system.

In a way, it's paradise -- if you're at the top.

Oh, and I'm pretty sure they suggest democracy as we know it is dead. One person, one vote? Only in an age of massed human warfare. If you can take out a million or a billion people with high-tech biological warfare (and those people aren't producing anything anyway) what good are they and why do they deserve the vote?

Not saying it's right, but the logic of megapolitical violence is cruel and unyielding. It's quite the lens.

canadian_voter··on People's underestimation of AI
It's a great book. Their analysis of violence as the organizing force of society was what stuck with me the most.

They also talk about how the core values people will need are trustworthiness, self-reliance, etc. That's where the title comes from. But it's anything but a self-help book.

> Can society do something to prevent mass concentration of wealth into the 0.00001% of people via the march of technology and innovation, or is this an inevitable outcome?

That's the ultimate question. Very much looking forward to finding out the answer! I'll let you know if I figure it out. ;)

canadian_voter··on People's underestimation of AI
Microwave dinners?
canadian_voter··on People's underestimation of AI
I think the megapolitical perspective on violence in The Sovereign Individual[0] by James Dale Davidson and Lord William Rees-Mogg can be helpful here.

Unions were powerful because they could limit access to labour, which was required for production. Now they are increasingly powerless. Mass manpower was once required to wage war. Now is increasingly less useful in a world of high-tech warfare.

What prevents the powerful from going straight to the source of production and value? I'm not talking about off-shoring manufacturing to China, I'm talking about something more extreme, along the lines of a small cabal of wizards in a tower conjuring spells to extract energy directly from the wind and sun, and materials directly from the ground? The tech is far off, but the direction is clear. Maybe y'all think you're going to be one of those wizards. We'll see.

But what's going to happen to the rest of us? Are we all going to wake up some day as basic-income supported artists, happily chewing on organic granola and self-actualizing (or not) as we please? I think a study of history suggests it's not going to be that easy. Those union rights were hard fought. People died.

What happens when those at the top decide it's not worth keeping 8 billion people around just for kicks, when they can make do with ... 5 billion? 500 million? How many programmers, painters and yoga instructors do we need? On a planet with dwindling resources, tough decisions are going to get made.

So yeah, watch out for those robots. Especially the ones with the lasers on their heads. (That's a joke. But the rest?)

[0] https://www.amazon.com/Sovereign-Individual-Mastering-Transi...

canadian_voter··on Amazon refuses to let police access US murder suspect’s Echo recordings
"Minor crimes" like stalking can lead to major crimes like murder. There are 2 major issues here:

1) The information might be used "off-label" for all sorts of personal and political reasons. There are countless examples of this in history.

2) The standard of evidence must remain high. Circumstantial evidence has been, and continues to be, used to convict innocent people of crimes. Giving the authorities what amounts to a mountain of circumstantial evidence could allow them to build a case out of thin air.

"Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, he must be guilty: he entered the bar two minutes after the victim, and left a minute after they did. He took an Uber along the same route and exited at the same address. 3 minutes later the murder weapon was purchased by a man matching his description a block away." ... and so on.

"If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him." -- Cardinal Richelieu (disputed, but classic)

Imagine what can be done with a lifetime of data from hundreds of sensors?

canadian_voter··on Aaron Swartz’s Theory on How to Save the World
Now we're talking. That's a prescription for action. I will agree with this.

Edit: Although I think there is more we do too. :) (Not defending Aaron's particular actions here.)

canadian_voter··on Aaron Swartz’s Theory on How to Save the World
Okay, so you're advocating for some sort of direct democracy. It sounds lovely, but I'm not sure it's realistic. We sure as hell don't have it, so how do we go about getting it?

We live in a world where there are huge imbalances in power. We can say it ought not be that way, that it should be another way, but any sensible individual interested in making change must confront political reality and take it into consideration when deciding how they can best effect change.

> Anything that exacerbates the problem of one man having more than one voice is not a step in the right direction.

Some people have no voice at all, while others are hugely influential. This isn't about going from some current equality (1:1) to inequality for some group (1:2). This is about going from out state of gross inequality (100:1) to as close to equality (1:1) as we can get.

I think we're mostly on the same page, just coming at it from different positions.

canadian_voter··on Aaron Swartz’s Theory on How to Save the World
"Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains." --Rousseau

(Ties in with my previous point: To ask "Why should anyone have more power than anyone else?" is missing the point: people clearly DO have different amounts of power in the world.)

canadian_voter··on Aaron Swartz’s Theory on How to Save the World
...

I think we're working from a different set of assumptions.

Edit: To ask "Why should anyone have more power than anyone else?" is missing the point: people clearly DO have different amounts of power in the world.

What part in particular of "groups of people supremely competent in certain relevant disciplines — investigators, activists, lawyers, lobbyists, policy experts, political strategists, journalists, and publicists — who could combine their efforts and advocate effectively for any issue, big or small" do you have issue with?

Is it that he would be at the head of this group (thus showing his desire for power)?

Is it that the group would be made up of experts (and thus presumably elitist?)

Is it that people should not form groups and make collective decisions or take collective action?

Is it that people shouldn't seek to make change in the world at all, since it's all up to God anyway?

Or something else entirely? Please clarify. Thanks! :)

canadian_voter··on Aaron Swartz’s Theory on How to Save the World
“Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed, citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.” ― Margaret Mead (disputed, but still catchy)

What would be your alternative strategy for positive change? Is desire for change a desire for power, and thus corrupting? How is an individual supposed to make their voice heard?

canadian_voter··on Ask HN: Can I exclude Trump supporters in my open source license?
How about a more positive message? "The creator of this software believes in equal rights" or "Be excellent to one another".

Picking on "Trump supporters" is a pretty low blow. And in practical terms is probably pointless -- basically just virtue signalling[0].

I know it's hard to know what to do, but if we're going to make a positive change in the world, we're all going to have to do better than this.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtue_signalling

canadian_voter··on World War Three, by Mistake
> Maybe if everyone had all the nuclear weapons they could want, no wars could ever happen again which would be a good thing.

Please see The Weapon by Frederic Brown. [0]

[0] https://writenowisgood.wordpress.com/the-weapon-questions/

canadian_voter··on World War Three, by Mistake
Or how about we set up a Mars colony, and do all of our wars there? Seems somehow appropriate. We can nuke the hell out of Mars and everyone on Earth will be fine.

And what makes people think that in the event of global thermonuclear war that Mars will escape unscathed? Absolute ridiculous nonsense. The solution here is not to run away, it's to confront the problem directly.

I never understood how anyone could think that "Earth is so messed up, with so many problems, it's just easier to colonize Mars." Earth is PERFECT for human beings to live on. Let's make it work.

canadian_voter··on Man gets $75 after being wrongly imprisoned for 31 years
"After considering all of the evidence, the board did not find clear and convincing evidence of innocence and declined to recommend clemency in this matter."

Hey, just because he's not guilty doesn't mean he's innocent.

Isn't it is better that ten innocent persons be jailed than that one criminal escape justice? [0]

Edit: Obviously it's more complicated than this. I don't envy anyone having to make these sorts of calls. There are certainly legal minutiae here that the CNN article doesn't get into.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone's_formulation

canadian_voter··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People
Love the bit at the end: "Quantum computing and consciousness are both weird and therefore equivalent."

Quantum consciousness doesn't sound very different from plain old vitalism.

canadian_voter··on 9M American men in prime working age can’t find jobs. I’m one of them
The references, in order, are to Frank Herbert, Albert Einstein and Johhny Depp. The point is that famous, successful people don't always start out that way. Just trying to give people some hope.

POP: I read that you did telemarketing. How was that?

DEPP: [laughs] I marketed pens—on the phone. But the beauty of the gig was that you had to call these strangers and say, "Hi, how ya doing?" You made up a name, like, "Hey, it's Edward Quartermaine from California. You're eligible to receive this grand­father clock or a trip to Tahiti." You promise them all these things if they buy a gross of pens. It was just awful. But I actually think that was the first experience I had with acting.

Source: http://www.interviewmagazine.com/film/johnny-depp/

canadian_voter··on 9M American men in prime working age can’t find jobs. I’m one of them
We were traveling in Central America and we passed a mansion on a hill: the biggest, nicest house we'd seen in the country. We asked the driver who lived there, thinking it was perhaps the president's mansion.

He said: "That's the house of the Toilet Paper King."

I've cleaned toilets and programmed computers. I've worked the night shift in a hotel and I've sweated over machines in a sweltering factory. I've sold credit cards and advertising.

Five years I opened a bookstore. Just before I had a conversation with someone who knew my tech background, who was shocked that I would consider entering a dead end industry. I must know future was in tech? Kindle, Amazon, the Internet -- weren't bookstores dead?

Five years in and I make more than I ever did programming. YMMV, but the lesson I learned is do what YOU think is best and don't be ashamed to do what you need to do to get by.

Furthermore, while there may be "dead end jobs", don't ever believe you're in a "dead end life". Stuck working as a oyster diver? Write a best-selling book. Stuck in a patent office? Win a Nobel prize. Stuck in telemarketing? Become a famous actor. You're more than where you are right now.

I'm sure this sounds like heresy to some of you, but you don't have to outrun the bear: you only have to find a temporary local maximum, not an enduring global one. Perfection is the enemy of the good.

“We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars.” -- Oscar Wilde

canadian_voter··on Management theory is becoming a compendium of dead ideas
John Ralston Saul does a great job explicating this in his book Voltaire's Bastards[1].

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Voltaires-Bastards-Dictatorship-Reaso...

canadian_voter··on Can Evolution Have a ‘Higher Purpose’?
We're a zoo for a higher intelligence? Joke is on them, reality is a simulation! Turtles.
canadian_voter··on ‘I am utterly disgusted’: Legendary animator Hayao Miyazaki takes AI down a peg
Imagine if you came to Jean Luc Picard and said "Captain, we found a way to replace exploration with the holodeck! And the best part is, none of those boring nebulas or silly aliens -- we can generate endless grotesques unlike anything you've ever seen!" I believe you'd be asked to leave the ship.

Miyazaki is a humanist. Why would he be interested in simulated zombies?

canadian_voter··on In Pennsylvania, Claims of a Rigged Election May Be Impossible to Disprove
For those of you who are unfamiliar with how voting works in other parts of the world, I'd like to describe the voting process in Canada.

Registered voters (which is virtually everyone) receive a card in them mail telling them where to vote. They bring the card, along with proof of address and photo ID to their polling station on election day. Their ID is checked against a list by two poll clerks and the elector is given a ballot. They take the ballot behind a curtain and make a mark with a pencil beside their candidate of choice. They take the ballot to the ballot box, where an observer watches them place it inside.

At the end of the night, the ballot box is opened by the two poll clerks, who are generally (but not necessarily) observed by several "scrutineers": one representative from each party. One of the poll clerks holds each ballot in turn, and announces who they believe the ballot was cast for. If everyone agrees, the ballot is counted. If it is disputed, a discussion takes place with reference to the printed rulebook. If there is still no agreement, it gets escalated.

Once all of the ballots have been counted, the results are reported to the Deputy Returning Officer, who phones them in to Elections Canada. The ballots go back in the box and the box is sealed. It is delivered to Elections Canada and stored in case of a recount. Enough results are generally available nation-wide a little after midnight (polls close at 9 or so) for a winner to be declared and concessions speeches given, although the official results can take a little longer.

The system seems to work. I don't see how electronic voting machines could do it cheaper, more securely or even very much faster.

I understand an American election is more complicated and may require a more complex system, but truly I feel electronic voting machines are a false efficiency here.

Source: Worked a few elections as a poll clerk. More details at http://www.elections.ca

← PreviousPage 4 of 4