HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

candiodari

4,236 karma · joined September 25, 2016

submissionscomments
candiodari··on Ask HN: Is a masters in ML worth it?
Makes you wonder ... how to break in if you have a master's in AI, but from 2007 (before the mild AI winter ~2006-2008) and have been doing systems engineering since.

So how do you get a job in AI without dropping to an intern's wage?

candiodari··on IEEE no longer accepts Lena image containing submissions from 4/1 onward
By their own choice, yes.
candiodari··on Inside the failed attempt to backdoor SSH globally that got caught by chance
Companies and in fact everyone has the choice to NOT use software that comes without warranty. But, of course, the cost difference will be astronomical. Alternatively companies and everyone have the choice to inspect open source software for security problems BEFORE use. Of course, astronomical cost.

This is an attempt to shift costs onto open source developers. Which, aside from being totally unjust, won't work. There's a legal expression "you can't squeeze blood out of a stone". Shifting costs onto people that can't carry those costs doesn't work for the same reason supporting a skyscraper with a toothpick doesn't work. The toothpick breaks, and when the skyscraper lies collapsed on the floor, nobody blames the toothpick. Hell, they might say the toothpick was heroic: trying to save the situation, sacrificing itself, screaming, and when nobody helped, not the government, not the owners, not ... the building collapsed and all the damage was done.

But it's even more stupid than just that. As soon as this gets introduced, and some company makes a security fix. They of course, for GPL or AGPL software, have to release their fixes. This will then make them liable for any other security problems in that same software. After all, they'll be the last ones releasing that software after the government implemented this law.

So how will you even do this, without making software fixes effectively illegal? Achieving the exact opposite of what such a law tries to achieve ... But of course, you can't have this discussion with people just looking to keep "their" free stuff but trying to shift the rest of the costs.

candiodari··on IEEE no longer accepts Lena image containing submissions from 4/1 onward
That choice was made by the inventor of that technology. He actually deserved to make that choice.

Morality police don't.

candiodari··on Rust developers at Google are twice as productive as C++ teams
So we can expect another round of layoffs?
candiodari··on XZ backdoor: "It's RCE, not auth bypass, and gated/unreplayable."
What it does is this: RSA_public_decrypt verifies a signature on the client's (I think) host key by a fixed Ed448 key, and then if it verifies, passes the payload to system().

If you send a request to SSH to associate (agree on a key for private communications), signed by a specific private key, it will send the rest of the request to the "system" call in libc, which will execute it in bash.

So this is quite literally a "shellcode". Except, you know, it's on your system.

candiodari··on Canva has acquired Affinity in an effort to compete with Adobe
Profit in software companies does in fact provide most of those example.

Only the last one needs some clarification. If a business did not do things that benefit others, they wouldn't get paid. So, almost by definition, businesses do. You might argue that a bigger value could be provided in another way, but it definitely does provide value.

candiodari··on Canva has acquired Affinity in an effort to compete with Adobe
It's not a cult if it works ...
candiodari··on Canva has acquired Affinity in an effort to compete with Adobe
Not really. They did so because people pay MUCH more for much less functionality in Canva, and so accepting the offer gives them a payday they couldn't hope to accumulate themselves.
candiodari··on Nix at Scale
Video available anywhere?
candiodari··on Most CO2 emissions were in the last 30 years
Which doesn't matter at all because once CO2 is released, getting it back out is utterly beyond human capabilities. Not 1y out, not 10y out, 100+ years out, maybe impossible.

So we won't be doing that.

Which seems to mean, climate engineering, here we come ... But it's not so easy.

Cooling the planet is easy. Heating it is the hard thing. In an emergency, we could undo 130+ years of global warming in a few hours, with nukes, without advance warning. And given a few months to a few years we could use much more subtle methods too.

Of course, cooling would make REALLY large pieces of land unliveable. And ... in warm climates you have energy available. You can fight the effects of warming locally, even in a single house, which humans have been doing since before history began. Fighting cooling ... only possible if you bring your own energy. Cooling is much worse than warming.

So in the long term the evolution of thought is even more funny. We COULD cool the planet. We'll doubtless figure out a few ways to do it. We have already figured out one or two ways, though they could be more subtle. Maybe even one or two really good ways. Then, we'll research the implications better, and find that given the choice between cooling and warming ...

We'll take the warming over the cooling, given the choice. Even just cooling back to the levels of the beginning of the 20th century would be far worse than 2 or even 5 degree warming. And the limit of what the climate anomaly, also called global warming, probably isn't even 5 degrees warmer than 1850. What burning all fossil fuels (including coal) could induce is not quite 5 degrees. Unthinkable (but historically occurred) levels of volcanic activity can get us close to 8 degrees warming, but humans can't.

If you look it up, by the way, you'll find that solar power, no matter which method is used, is MUCH better at cooling the planet than forests, oceans, steppes, deserts, ... just about any place where you might build solar power.

So we could see the ultimate joke. We may cool the planet WAY too much by accident ... then find we're forced to find ways to artificially heat the planet again!

The problem with the current viewpoint is it's very basis. The view that nature is good for humans, is good for itself. Of course, this is bullshit. Nature doesn't care. Ironically, Gaia is often associated with the view that nature will provide. What did the mythical godess Gaia actually do? She fought to protect her children, the titans, who killed entire countries with their entire population and left desolate, lifeless places behind, against Zeus. Funny, that.

Nature doesn't care and will kill us all. The question is when, but that it will is a complete certainty.

candiodari··on Bunk beds in aircraft cabins: the realistic prospects
I have actually done that. Also laid on 4 seats sideways because they were unoccupied.
candiodari··on UN adopts first global artificial intelligence resolution
A bunch of people who can't stop AI ... and if it requires any kind of commitment or money WON'T actually follow through decide to make several hundred "laws" per year.

And as if that problem isn't serious enough, often the governments these delegates supposedly speak for either don't agree with their own delegates or make their delegates lie, often to the point Iran just did with Nuclear disarmament. They opened the meeting, reiterated their commitment to ... and it made such an impression laughter was heard in the next building over.

The only good thing about the UN is that obstructionism at the UN often leads to inaction of other governments that wanted to do something, which often turns out to be the better course of action.

candiodari··on Florida Just Banned Lab-Grown Meat. I Tried to Find Out Why
If you think this is bad ... then don't look at historically approved medicines. It is easy to kill yourself with aspirin and even easier to do it with paracetamol. By accident I mean.

There is no way in hell these would be approved today, but outlawing them because they are dangerous is not up for discussion. Once approved, always approved. Aspirin's approval, specifically, is centuries old.

candiodari··on How to Start Google
Tesla has a VERY bad reputation on that front, as does SpaceX.
candiodari··on How to Start Google
Well you can calculate that somewhat, right. If you're "top-1%" in skill, enough to get hired at Google (even if you did it for the badge), then did you or did you not start a business?

Google: 180,000 employees. Let's say including ex-employees 250,000

These started 1,200 companies, according to the only source I could find. These collectively apparently made their founders ~20 billion. Let's say (heh) that it's a power law, let's say the top 10 got 1 billion each.

So we're talking the odds for an "average" software engineer to get to 1 billion is about 0.1% * 10/180000 = 0.000005556%, or about 1 in 18 million.

Odds for a current or ex-Google engineer: 1 in 18,000.

candiodari··on Gaza: 23M tonnes of debris 'will take years to clear'
Look, the muslim brotherhood was implicated (yes "unproven") in both the Charlie Hebdo and Bataclan massacres in France. Given that, say whatever you want. If this organisation is wiped off the face of the earth tomorrow, VERY few people, and I'm really hoping that includes 99% French muslims, will shed any tears.
candiodari··on Gaza: 23M tonnes of debris 'will take years to clear'
He mentioned Morsi, and how unfair it is that he was not given control of Egypt. Morsi is muslim brotherhood, and parts of that organisation is Hamas/PIJ/IJ, which is referred to as "Daesh" in Europe/France, there is no real difference between these organisations. Most definitely, Daesh wanted to "unify the muslim world". And sorry but these are obviously religious organisations.

They're also worse than Nazis. If these people come to power, war WILL start. And absolutely guaranteed: it won't stop at Israel. It will be WW3. There will soon be no other choice left for anyone.

So I disagree strongly: how can I get you to understand that this is comparable to complaining how unfair it is that Hitler wasn't given full control of Germany after the election result of July 1932?

candiodari··on European Union AI Act
So there's effectively a blanket exception for the organisations you really don't want to be doing this, ie. Police, the institution itself and government? (incidentally, government is your health insurance company in most of Europe)

I keep coming to the same problem with these regulations. I am much less afraid of Amazon/Google/... figuring out something about me and using it to sell me stuff than I am afraid of the police doing the same, and arresting me or otherwise having a huge negative impact on my life. Knowing the police, they'll probably not even do AI monitoring correctly, and of course, won't be responsible for the damage they cause.

Frankly, that Amazon and Google figure out stuff I might want to buy might actually be a positive. Maybe. Sometimes. If they become better at weeding out scams, that is.

candiodari··on Gaza: 23M tonnes of debris 'will take years to clear'
I don't get it. He makes a slightly obscured reference and you don't get to call him out on wanting to convert a country into an islamist/terrorist state? Just because the GP doesn't name it directly?

I would call out a Frenchman singing the praises of Le Pen as well. I bet people would ALSO say Le Pen is trying to "unify France". She is, kind of. Genetically, so to speak. She's a monster. Not on equal footing with Trump, she is far worse. This is serious. Likewise, Egypt has their fascists, the "muslim brotherhood", and Morsi was at one point their champion.

If he didn't get deposed, we might be fighting WW3 now. Really.

candiodari··on Hypothesis That Universe Has No Dark Matter and Is 27B Years Old
It's just that people just can't deal with existence proofs. In Math people seriously tried for ~180 years to prove that you don't need a single existence proof (which notably means you can't have real numbers, or calculus)

For Dark Matter we have existence proofs. It MUST exist, in some form, we just don't know what it is. It will take another century before we're at 180 years ...

candiodari··on Gaza: 23M tonnes of debris 'will take years to clear'
The "attempts to unify"? You mean Daesh/ISIS? There has been no other attempt to unify so you must mean that. The muslim brotherhood, Morsi, is Hamas/PIJ.

This is what is so depressing about some muslims. Let's face facts here: you see massacres and destruction as a positive, not a negative, as long as they "serve islam", and want to turn the middle east back into the hellhole it was before oil.

And "serve islam", only in a superficial way ... it should be said that of course this sort of attitude is giving EVERY world power reason AND excuse to destroy islam. Russia is trying to destroy islam, in Chechnya and the Caucasus. India is now trying to destroy islam, in Kashmir (and everywhere else they can). China is trying to destroy islam, in Xinjang, and even in parts of Pakistan. Iran is trying to destroy Islam (yes, really, they will massacre entire countries before they allow a caliph). Australia ... Half of Europe now has governments trying to destroy islam, and if Trump gets elected, out of 6 inhabited continents on earth ONLY ONE will not have government policies targeting islam ... well done, fuck man, well done. Obviously, the next decades are going to be VERY painful for the middle east, islam, and even muslims in the west. VERY painful. Surely that can't be hard to see? And all you see is more opportunity for destruction. Fuck man.

I don't understand people like you, I mean, you must realize that even the internet as a whole, never mind a forum like this, is ENTIRELY and heavily against islam, for 100 different reasons. So why are you here if you have even the smallest amount of faith in what you say? You want to live in a supposedly religious hellhole? Go and do that. Plenty of choices available. STOP trying to conquer places.

candiodari··on Gaza: 23M tonnes of debris 'will take years to clear'
The only thing muslims hold against Jews is that they succesfully defend themselves. Kurds are being massacred, no one cares, least of all muslims. Armenians were being subjected to an Azerbeijani genocide, a month before this conflict started. No muslim cares. In Yemen, Sunni and Shi'a are committing genocide on eachother ... for decades now. Aside from an obvious disastrous failure by Saudi Arabia, no-one is doing anything. In Sudan, somewhat black muslims are killing somewhat more black muslims, because of skin color. No one cares.

EACH of the named conflicts has at minimum double the number of victims of the Gaza conflict. Sudan at least 10x more. Yemen, as well, is far worse than the Gaza conflict.

The problem in the middle east ... is not hatred against Jews. Sorry. It isn't.

Given what muslims in the middle east call peace, then I'm sorry to say but peace is worse than war. Much, much worse.

candiodari··on Facebook Messenger and Meta Pay are used to buy child sexual abuse material
There needs to be a balance though. You could say the same about money, after all. It is used in probably every transaction involving CSAM. That doesn't mean the FED (and ECB, and ...) are to blame.

Nor does it mean that the FED needs to start sabotaging money to make it impossible. It there is a very low-impact way to do that, fine. If there is a high impact proposal ... we need to be more careful.

candiodari··on I summarized my understanding of Linux systems
Really? The issue is that those structs don't cross-compile correctly if you aren't very careful in their use. I've personally managed to write an IRC bot that had a select loop that worked fine on i386 but didn't on amd64 until I figured out what was happening to the size of the structure behind it.
candiodari··on AI Beats Multiple Records in Trackmania
More reasons than just that. Overbuild drones while expanding (or even before) and then transfer to have a new base up and fully droned in construction time + 10s. You overbuild because you're going to lose 1-2 drones to any capable attack minimum. You can risk more on the defense when overbuilt. You have bigger chances of being able to expand during a base trade, ...
candiodari··on I summarized my understanding of Linux systems
> There's some ideological benefits, but plan9 creates a mess of implicit text protocols, ugly string handling, syscall storms and memory inefficiencies.

On the other hand, linux ioctl and syscalls have infinite binary structs you need to know (and cannot let the compiler reorder fields in), which then doesn't make cross-platform development any easier.

candiodari··on AI Beats Multiple Records in Trackmania
Yep and then alphastar started winning matches against top players by individually microing ~20 stalkers at the same time. Not something any human, even a world champion, can do.

The fun thing is that alphastar did have influence on the starcraft scene. Overbuilding drones used to be taboo, now everybody does it. And even individually microing stalkers ... now it's quite normal for players to go out with 2-3 stalkers and indeed individually control them. These are good tactically, even when you're not an AI.

candiodari··on Responsibility for Boeing's Poor Performance
Management that focuses on financial metrics only wants employees that don't rock the boat and aren't a risk of calling them out on their decisions.

It is management's job to fix it. Regardless of the actual problem.

candiodari··on Giant 'sand battery' holds a week's heat for a whole town
Water vaporizes, and at that point blows up just about every container you can build around it. As will ice when it cools down. Sand is just sand, very little difference, very unreactive from way under freezing temps to about 1300 degrees.

And you might vent steam, but you should probably take into account that while water < 45 degrees or so is pretty innocent, steam will strip flesh from bone starting at 180 degrees or so, it won't "just" burn you.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →