HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cantastoria

346 karma · joined January 6, 2010

submissionscomments
cantastoria··on IMF Chief Economist apologizes for being wrong on austerity
Fair enough. A policy of stricter enforcement of tax laws sounds like a better plan than stimulus to me. Maybe they should start there instead.
cantastoria··on IMF Chief Economist apologizes for being wrong on austerity
I think the real pseudoscientific idea is that debt-financed stimulus is the cure all for any economic ill. The argument that Greece needs to get further into debt to solve it's debt crisis seems insane to me. At this point how much good could a stimulus really do (even if they could find someone to lend them the money to do it). I know the standard Krugman/Keynsian style argument here but it doesn't seem to make much sense in Greece. As another poster said it seems the only real cure for Greece is going to be inflation, probably and unfortunately similar to what happened in Argentina.
cantastoria··on IMF Chief Economist apologizes for being wrong on austerity
Shut out of international bond markets, Greece had little choice but to begin bringing its public finances into line or face a catastrophic default. Financing wasn’t available to sustain prior spending levels.

I'm confused. If Greece couldn't borrow money to sustain its prior spending levels what choice did they have? How is a Keynesian-style stimulus possible if no one will lend you the money to implement it? It also doesn't make any sense to me why a stimulus plan would have worked. Lending Greece more to perpetuate its already unsustainable expenses doesn't make much sense. It seems the Keynesian argument here is that they need to do stimulus - i.e. borrow and spend - even more then the pre-austerity level just to get the economy back to the previous (and unsustainable) debt levels. It's running to stand still.

cantastoria··on The Woman Charged With Making Windows 8 Succeed
As a program manager in Development Tools and Languages, she was instrumental in several releases of Visual C++ for 32-bit operating systems and led the development of Microsoft's first customizable integrated development environment for Windows.

This impressed most about her resume and makes me hopeful about the future of Windows. Visual Studio is one of the few products were Microsoft was truly innovative and she was a key factor. I just hope Ballmer will stay out of her way.

cantastoria··on The Myth of American Meritocracy
The creator of the word meritocracy created it to parody how people think the world is mostly just. Curious no?

It would be if it were true. The satire you're referring to, used the word as a way to criticize how the British government of the period was selecting people into an elite ruling class based on suspect standards of intelligence and aptitude. The word itself was invented as a shorthand to refer to that process and its justifications. It was not a parody of the idea of meritocracy as it is understood today.

From wikipedia; Meritocracy is the implementation of advancement based upon intellectual talent. Often, advancement is determined by demonstrated achievement in the field where it is implemented.

Aside from that, I'm curious, If you believe that meritocracy is indeed evidence of right-wing sociopathic behavior. What would be the Communist/Liberal/Democratic alternative? Surely you're not advocating a kakistocracy (i.e. rule by the worst).

cantastoria··on Inside the Hostess Bakery
Hacker news?
cantastoria··on Google down in Huntsville AL
same here
cantastoria··on Statistical Analysis of Election Manipulation in Republican Primaries
Hacker News?
cantastoria··on Today is Ada Lovelace Day
Carol Bartz http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carol_Bartz

Even though she blew it at Yahoo she was great for Autodesk.

cantastoria··on Today is Ada Lovelace Day
Susan Kare http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Susan_Kare

Who designed many of the original Mac typefaces, icons and marketing material.

cantastoria··on You keep using that word "meritocracy"
Once again we see members of the social justice community promoting "privilege" as the metric for which all achievements should be judged. Developed an amazing search technology? "Well, they're two straight white males... big deal". Revolutionized the mobile devices industry? "He's a straight white male of course it's easy for him". Created the largest social network on Earth? Pfff...all he had to do was show up.

The fundamental flaw with privilege theory is that there is no way of discerning where someones supposed privilege ends and where their actual achievements and talent begin. Unless you're gong to simple say "anyone could of done that and the only reason you were able to was because you're a white male" or a "dude" or "boy" as this author seems to be fond of calling men (misandrist much?). In other words we're all equally talented, smart, motivated and lucky and the only differentiator is race, class and gender. Which I think most would agree is absurd.

One question I have though is what would be the ideal world for the OP? A system where everyone's race, class, gender and privilege are considered when making hiring decisions and then adjusting applicants qualifications accordingly? Is that really the world we want to live in?

cantastoria··on A different take on sexism in IT
Privilege is essentially a shaming tactic. It's proponents believe that they can create a reverse social hierarchy by convincing those supposedly at the top (straight while males) that every aspect of their lives benefits from a social advantage they don't know they have. Thus straight white males are encouraged to live in a constant state of paranoia and shame essentially for being born. For those who accept this belief system, the only way to achieve harmony with those around you is to actively "give away your privilege" which is to say sabotage and undermine your own potential and achievements so that other, less privileged persons may somehow benefit. How this should be done is typically left unclear. As with most "social justice" belief systems the point is to spread guilt and shame. Ultimately, this belief system just further stigmatizes those that it seeks to help by not only classifying people by race, class and gender but by states of privilege as well.
cantastoria··on Romney tries to Solyndraize Tesla Motors, calling it a 'loser'
Hacker News?
cantastoria··on Racism at a gaming company
I love how someone always hauls out that set of speech codes every time there's any discussion of race or gender in a forum, as if there's a "correct way" to participate in these discussions. You're not our proctor. If you want to let that absurd list of rules dictate how you discuss these issues then go ahead but please don't expect the rest us to follow suit. Hopefully the rest of HN doesn't subscribe to that kind of self-censorship.
cantastoria··on Racism at a gaming company
I love how someone always hauls out this set of speech codes every time there's any discussion of race or gender in a forum as if there's a "correct way" to participate. If you want let a bunch politically correct rules dictate how you discuss these issues then go ahead, but please don't expect the rest us to follow suit. Hopefully, the rest of HN doesn't subscribe to that kind of self-censorship.
cantastoria··on How Stereotype Threat keeps women from working in SW — and how we can fight it
If someone is consciously aware they are not performing at their potential and continue to do so, I find it hard to lay the blame at the feet of stereotype threat. No? It sounds like they're either misjudging their potential or just being lazy.
cantastoria··on How Stereotype Threat keeps women from working in SW — and how we can fight it
Ah I see... From your vocabulary, writing style and misandrist digs I can tell you're a "trained feminist" and I know once that belief system takes hold there's no going back and as such, there's no point in arguing. I'm sorry to have wasted your time. Good luck to you and especially to your colleagues.
cantastoria··on How Stereotype Threat keeps women from working in SW — and how we can fight it
It is impossible to forget, because the environment and people around me reproduce them, mostly entirely unintentionally. Even just the lack of women is a subtle, ever-present reminder that I am doing something weird and kind of awkward.

It's interesting that you're conscious of all this and yet it still effects you. In your case it seems to not be a case of stereotype threat but more a lack of self-confidence (re: "doing something weird and kind of awkward") or a need to fit in. If they started hiring more women developers would that make you feel more confident in your own abilities or have a positive effect on your job performance? If so why?

cantastoria··on How Stereotype Threat keeps women from working in SW — and how we can fight it
I am a damn good programmer. I have these problems.

Do you really start thinking about how bad woman are believed to be at science and math every time you speak to a male colleague or walk into a room full of men? I don't know, I'm asking...

The difference between us is that they aren't asking you to do something that is biologically impossible

Are you suggesting that male programmer behavior has a biological basis?

cantastoria··on How Stereotype Threat keeps women from working in SW — and how we can fight it
That it does, but my argument is that that what the author experienced isn't stereotype threat. The effects of stereotype threat are (supposedly) manifested in a decrease in performance. Feeling excluded or thinking (in this case unjustifiably) that you're not wanted isn't due to stereotype threat. If the author was failing her courses or was under performing at work that would (potentially) be a result of stereotype threat. I see no evidence either occurred, she was getting As in her classes and from what I gather was able to get and keep jobs in the software industry. She's just seems unable to cope with being the only woman in the room .
cantastoria··on How Stereotype Threat keeps women from working in SW — and how we can fight it
When women look at tech companies and math departments, they see few women. This activates the stereotype that women aren’t good at math. The stereotype…

Is there any evidence that this is what actually happens? Are all women carrying around these stereotypes with them? It just seems like a "just so" explanation.

Most of the examples in this article aren't of stereotype threat, they're examples of the authors' insecurity and social anxiety about being in tech. I can understand how a women would feel uncomfortable working in large groups of, what are generally socially inept, geeks but that seems like a different problem. This was the money-quote for me:

I remember one instance in particular when I was feeling particularly isolated at our company. “I feel like an outsider! Like the guys don’t want me here because I’m a woman!” I whined to one of my male colleagues. He looked at me and replied, “Well that’s dumb. Of course they want you here. You’re great to work with.”

So essentially this woman has a self-confidence issue. I see little evidence from this article (and the NPR one) that these problems, to the extent that they exist, are just run-of-the-mill social anxiety and nothing more.

cantastoria··on Health care law stands in U.S.
I think a similar thing would happen nationally. Polls show that when people are asked about the various major provisions of the Affordable Care Act (but are not told that they are being asked about that Act, so that they aren't prejudiced by the ridiculous claims the Tea Party spread about it, such as the "death panel" fantasy) they are overwhelming in favor of everything except the mandate.

But the mandate is what makes everything else possible. This is like saying "we polled peopled about getting more services from the government and they were in favor of it except for the parts about taxes going up". Which, as of this morning, is essentially what's going on as the "mandate" is now going to have to be implemented as a tax penalty. So that polling just shows how clueless people are about how this whole scheme works.

No way would the Republicans be able to get repeal of those through without committing political suicide with the voters. I think the more likely proposal would be to "put it all back the way it was before" instead of a full government takeover. At that point the current situation would be ,rightly, described as being caused by the government (i.e. ObamaCare). I'm not sure how easy a sell a full government take over would be.

cantastoria··on New NSA docs contradict 9/11 claims
this is hacker news?
cantastoria··on Here Are No Women On StackOverflow… Or Are There?
It's not obvious at all unless you're talking about a diversity of programming backgrounds in which case I agree. C++ doesn't work differently when it's used by a black or female programmer. Same goes for programming perspectives in general. I don't design my classes differently because I grew up in the inner-city (nor would I need to tailor an answer for someone who did). I think your taking an argument usually reserved for social environments that are more dependent on interaction and group dynamics (e.g. a classroom) and trying to apply it to a more static engineering one. And while that study did find that increased diversity improved performance on "business measures", it did not find a causal link that specifically pointed to diversity as the reason, although I'm not sure it would have much bearing here anyway. Being creative in a broader business/social context is not the same as solving the type of specific engineering/programming questions generally found on SO. Programming skill is completely divorced from race/gender/class and that's something we should all be happy about.
cantastoria··on Here Are No Women On StackOverflow… Or Are There?
Why? If I'm able to get quality answers what advantage does racial/sex "diversity" in and of itself bring to the table. Should I feel extra good about getting a quality answer from a black female programmer over a white male one? If so why? It would seem to me that using diversity to assess community quality on a programming Q&A site is a poor measure given it has no bearing on programming ability. Unless of course one is purely interested in aesthetics.
cantastoria··on Here Are No Women On StackOverflow… Or Are There?
So there’s good news, there are women on StackOverflow. The visible ones are far below the representative % of women in the industry. So you can safely determine that it’s an unfriendly-to-women place.*

Oy vey...

cantastoria··on NYT: “MEN invented the internet”
But I'm sure that if you try to create an exhaustive list of people involved in creating the Internet, you would wind up with an enormous list, if you are even able to complete it.

What makes you so sure?

First of all I think it's hard to define the Internet: is it just the networking? Do you count the application layer?

From Wikipedia: The Internet is a global system of interconnected computer networks that use the standard Internet protocol suite (often called TCP/IP, although not all applications use TCP) to serve billions of users worldwide. It is a network of networks that consists of millions of private, public, academic, business, and government networks, of local to global scope, that are linked by a broad array of electronic, wireless and optical networking technologies.

But even if you wanted to include the "application layer". Who are the women that contributed to developing it?

The problem is not that women did not contribute to the Internet, the problem is saying that this means that women cannot make productive contributions to technology or the Internet or computers in general.

No it doesn't. It means that women did not contribute to the invention of the Internet. Anything else you read into that is purely your imagination.

cantastoria··on NYT: “MEN invented the internet”
That would suggest that in discussions on the history of technology, it is implied that there is some arbitrary threshold...

But there's nothing arbitrary here, we know who invented the Internet. None of them where women. The argument that women could have contributed but didn't "because they were an oppressed group" is just an absurd couterfactual. Who knows what would have happened? You can say anything you want...

Richard Spikes' contribution of turn signals...

Richard Spikes invented the turn signal. Full stop. Saying he contributed to the invention of the automobile is as absurd as saying that Edison or Tesla contributed to the invention of the turn signal. No one would say that because the turn signal stands on it's own. Using your line of reasoning, Richard Spikes invented the turn signal with contributions from who knows how many women and other minorities.

Or is it merely an acknowledgment of the fact that white men get the credit because they structured the industry to give it to them, by excluding everyone else?

That doesn't mean women should get a historical "participation trophy" just for being somewhere and doing something in computing while the actual inventors where developing the Internet. It's insulting to them and women (and Al Gore...).

cantastoria··on NYT: “MEN invented the internet”
If we are talking about a particular invention we can talk about specific inventors.

But we are talking about a particular invention and it's invention has been well documented (see "Where Wizards Stay Up Late" among I'm sure many others). If there's some alternative history here please point me to it...

part from that, saying that women did not contribute enough to the Internet, is like saying black people did not contribute enough to the invention of cars; it's mostly true, but it could be argued that that's because they were an oppressed group.

So woman *could" have contributed more to the Internet had they not been oppressed? That's a counterfactual argument one and two it doesn't change the fact that women didn't partake.

cantastoria··on NYT: “MEN invented the internet”
Women may have been invisible, but the work we did laid the groundwork for more visible advancements now credited to more famous men.

But what aspects of that work specifically led to the invention of the Internet? If "laying the groundwork" is the criteria then Newton, Tesla and Turing had a hand in inventing the Internet as well (an assertion I think few would make...). The fact that Lovelace and Hopper were women and programmers doesn't mean that "women" deserve credit for every invention that came after them.

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →