HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

carbonguy

840 karma · joined December 26, 2020

In essence, an educated layman. Formally educated in biochemistry, informally educated in I.T. and computing technologies, professionally employed in teaching. Currently devoted to making sense of carbon sequestration to save the world from climate change.
submissionscomments
carbonguy··on Return to Office Is a Mistake
Couldn't agree with you more, and honestly I think you're softballing it here:

> I think it’s pretty lazy to crank out a vibes based article describing specific grievances and generalizing to an entire population.

In that the article doesn't even describe _specific_ grievances, really; we get three quotes in this order:

- A Paul Graham tweet where he says "multiple founders" have changed their minds; the _personal_ opinion he expresses is that "he doubts things will go all the way back to the way they were before Covid, but it looks like they will go most of the way back." Nothing specific mentioned about why the founders changed their minds.

- A truly stripped-of-context quote from Keith Rabois that gets closest to saying something specific i.e. 'that younger workers “learn by osmosis,” which requires in-person interaction' (false as presented, and if this is a genuine reflection of his opinion then he doesn't actually understand training) and 'supervisors discover hidden talent by watching [younger employees]' (true enough, but presented as a problem with remote work when it's actually not)

- Absolute banger from Sam Altman: “I think definitely one of the tech industry’s worst mistakes in a long time was that everybody could go full remote forever, and startups didn’t need to be together in person and, you know, there was going to be no loss of creativity ... I would say that the experiment on that is over.” - the implied grievance here is that "remote work makes startups less creative" which is, to its' credit, an actual position for which one can make a coherent argument. He may even have gone to the trouble of doing this at some point, for all I know. The rest is pure sophistry, though - "one of the tech industry's worst mistakes ... was that everybody could go full remote forever" is just not an accurate reflection of what actually happened, and if he's exaggerating for effect, then I'd be interested to know what effect he was going for; he's also really softballing the reason why remote work happened in the first place: it wasn't an "experiment," it was a forced response to a world crisis with existential implications!

There's significant overgeneralizing happening here too, as you suggested; at best, you can say that these guys are referring to what's true of _startups specifically_, where they're at least domain experts, but even if their arguments ARE true of startups (and I am deeply skeptical that this is the case) you can't assume that they'll be true of OTHER organizational types.

carbonguy··on Optimizing For Feelings - On seeking meaning beyond metrics
Genuinely of two minds about this piece - on the one hand, the cynical hand, it feels (to me) like one of the second-tier pitches you see in Mad Men that's meant to contrast with a top-tier Don Draper pitch...

... but on the other hand, the optimistic hand, it's compelling to consider what "optimizing for feeling in software" could mean, beyond just an impressive-sounding mission statement for The Browser Company.

... of course, back to the cynical hand for a moment, it's hard to read something like this:

> You see — if software is to have soul, it must feel more like the world around it. Which is the biggest clue of all that feeling is what’s missing from today’s software.

and just take it for granted. Really? The thing that software should have is soul, and that means it should feel like the world around it(?) and that's a clue(??) that feeling is missing?

... but back to the optimistic hand for a second, who cares how the piece is written if it's making you think about how to make software, writ large, radically better? Or even just making you think, as it made me think, that software, writ large, CAN be radically better than it is? Because the piece is right! OKR culture feels crappy! Down with KPIs!

And back and forth I could go. I upvoted this piece because I think it could spark some interesting discussion here - anybody else of two (or three, or...) minds about this?

carbonguy··on Rule for Beneficial Ownership Reporting (2022)
Looking over the "fact sheet" linked in the announcement[1], this appears to be the key requirement:

> When filing [Beneficial Ownership Information] reports with FinCEN, the rule requires a reporting company to identify itself and report four pieces of information about each of its beneficial owners: name, birthdate, address, and a unique identifying number and issuing jurisdiction from an acceptable identification document (and the image of such document).

While I could wish this information would be public in the same way as eg. SEC form 4 filings, this rule really does feel (to me, a rank layman) like a big step forward for corporate transparency... to government, at least. Still pretty exciting!

Any corporate legal eagles out there who have an actual informed perspective to share on this new rule and its possible effects?

[1]: https://www.fincen.gov/beneficial-ownership-information-repo...

carbonguy··on Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic levitation of LK-99
Almost certainly: improving the ease/consistency of producing this stuff.
carbonguy··on Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic levitation of LK-99
IANA physicist, so grain of salt etc. but yes, I agree with your assessment - even if not as impressive as we're all hoping, at the least we have a very promising new vein of superconductor research to mine (as it were).

In other words: even the downside here is great, and the upside is...

carbonguy··on The Problem of Excess Genius (1997)
Having read the essay, I'll take a crack at a causal hypothesis: "geniuses" in the sense that the author seems to be using the term[1] cluster in periods and settings where:

1) their societies were "recently" exposed to existential threats (eg. Persian invasion for Athens, Spanish Armada for England, etc.), that were 2) mastered (Battle of Marathon, defeat of the Armada) 3) but left underlying problems unresolved

So, there would be incredibly motivation for these societies to try and address these problems, and perhaps some additional measure of confidence that problems could be mastered. And, in periods of existential crisis, normal patterns start to break down and new modes of expression and organization, new perspectives, etc. can start to manifest.

It's also interesting that the essay calls out that

> all three’s florescences were ended by right-wing revolutions (the Rule of the 400, Savonarola, and Cromwell).

as these responses are often prompted by some perception of chaos/lack of 'order' in a society - a breaking down of accustomed patterns.

So, in the spirit of the goal as stated by the essay:

> We want explanations that make sense, and which can be corroborated by specific historical research.

I would say: look for genius where there is also social turmoil and crisis - where there was a belief within a society that it may not be able to survive the problems that faced it, or where it experienced such rapid change that within a generation or two the previous assumptions about how the society worked and what was and wasn't acceptable/normal came into question - and you might find geniuses there.

And it would probably be a good idea to have a concrete, sensible definition of genius that we all agree on.

carbonguy··on What we talk about when we talk about system design
Extremely high-quality work here - I spend (what I think is) a significant amount of time trying to understand systems, in general and in detail, and this feels on first reading like something I'll be referring to repeatedly in future.

Already it suggests a surprising idea, which may or may not be fleshed out elsewhere, that a good way to understand an existing system is to try and solve the same problem without reference to how the existing system works:

> You will often expend more cycles understanding the existing design than you would solving the problem from first principles. ...

> Even good solutions can bias your thinking towards a particular part of the design space. ... A great time to look at other systems is after the Design phase, to see if you can map those solutions to your space. Even better, you can often reverse-engineer the details of solutions simply by understanding where they fit in your design space.

If it doesn't already exist somewhere else, we can call it Balakrishnan's Law - the best way to understand a problem is to solve it!

carbonguy··on Dietrich Bonhoeffer on stupidity (1943)
After reading this, I'm also reminded of (among other things) one of the points that Paul Graham made in "Lies We Tell Kids"[1]:

> You can't distinguish your group by doing things that are rational, and believing things that are true. If you want to set yourself apart from other people, you have to do things that are arbitrary, and believe things that are false.

"Stupidity" seems so strongly associated with a motivation to identify with a particular group, in almost exactly the sense that I understand the old Sinclair quote about what a man will and won't understand when his salary is involved, that I wonder now if "stupidity" as a phenomenon is JUST social signalling to demonstrate group association. Or does it has aspects beyond social conformity?

[1]: http://www.paulgraham.com/lies.html

carbonguy··on Ask HN: Technology/creative books and games for my daughter (7 years)
Perhaps a bit late to the thread here, but I have to put in my $0.02 for "The Way Things Work" (and its sequels):

https://www.alibris.com/Way-Things-Work-David-Macaulay/book/...

For the unfamiliar - the book is an illustrated guide to how different kinds of mechanisms and designed systems work starting from simple machines, levers, wheel and axle, etc. through to nuclear fission and moving on through computers in the sequels.

David Macaulay's writing and illustrations are top-notch. Honestly, all of his books are great, but this is the one that I actually owned when I was younger so I read it all the time - hard to put into words the impact it had on me at around that same age.

carbonguy··on AI is making it easier to create more noise, when all I want is good search
> Are you not interested in ensuring that the answer or solution is based on the most authoritative information that exists, the source material on which all regurgitations are based?

Not OP, but I'll answer: No, I am almost never interested in finding the most authoritative source for anything, because the effort vs. reward of those searches is not favorable and the cost of being incorrect on any given point is pretty dang low.

EDIT: However, with respect to the idea of using ChatGPT for answering general knowledge questions - there's enough demonstrations of it providing fabricated information that I've adopted the low-cost heuristic of not trusting ChatGPT for anything and preferring to seek information elsewhere. I guess this means I seek moderately-authoritative sources (say, Wikipedia) as a general rule.

carbonguy··on Early-life stress can disrupt maturation of brain’s reward circuits
> I don’t like the phrase “normal reward behaviors” in this article... Maybe these responses are adaptive and provide a fitness advantage under historically normal conditions even if they appear maladaptive in the current environment.

Agreed - the cant of this article could just as easily be "environmental factors during formative years influence behavior at maturity" without representing a particular set of responses as "normal" or "abnormal". I'm surprised they didn't use adaptive/maladaptive, like you do; it seems more appropriate.

carbonguy··on High-speed rail board completes environmental clearance in northern California
I gotta say, it's hard to know how much of a hurdle has been cleared here when this project seems to be absolutely nothing but hurdles to clear. Normally I would guess that getting this report approved would be a big deal in that construction could finally really get going, but then I read this:

> The Board’s certification of the San Francisco to San Jose Final EIR/EIS and approval of its project section will move the project section closer to being “shovel ready” when funding for final design, pre-construction and construction becomes available.

"Closer" to being "shovel ready" when "funding for final design... becomes available" is not a series of words that gives me confidence that meaningful progress has been made. However, I grant that I am no expert in the art of parsing press releases about big infrastructure projects.

Anybody out there with meaningful understanding of what this announcement might mean in practical terms?

carbonguy··on Attempts to power planes with hydrogen
While land and resource availability are definitely reasonable concerns in any discussion about, say, shifting humanity's primary energy source to direct solar (lots of panels means lots of factories to build them and lots of land to put them on) as opposed to indirect solar (oil and coal) I'm struggling to understand why you think "thermodynamics" means that usable energy will become scarcer on a timeline that is meaningful to human civilization. Happy to listen if you care to explain, but no worries if not.
carbonguy··on Attempts to power planes with hydrogen
> Kerosene makes aviation viable because it has a high energy return on investment and is readily available because it is produced by fractional distillation that would occur regardless.

Kerosene (and liquid petroleum-derived fuel generally) works well as an aviation fuel because it is relatively stable and energy-dense in both volumetric and mass terms. That it often has a high EROI means it can be dollar-cheap as well, which doesn't hurt, but it's still used even when the EROI is terrible (eg. military aviation - delivering fuel to a war zone costs a lot of energy) because the other advantages are still overwhelming relative to the energy cost.

> Hydrogen and e-fuels involve substantial energy losses even in ideal circumstances

Absolutely, though this is true of every industrial activity.

> and require dedicated supply chains that would not otherwise exist, which adds additional energetic costs.

While this is certainly true for hydrogen, e-fuels (which I take to mean synthetic electrochemically-produced hydrocarbon fuels, though perhaps you mean something different) can be produced and distributed using the much of the same infrastructure that exists today - for example, if you're making Sabatier methane, there's no reason you need to build new pipelines and tanks for it, though I'll grant that you do need new production facilities.

Of course, the rub is that the energy to drive it all has to come from non-carbon-producing (in operation) sources - solar, wind, hydro, or nuclear - and there's no denying that building out that infrastructure is going to be a massive project.

> In a world where available energy is going to become scarcer, I don't think using these fuels is going to make sense.

Available fossil energy is indeed going to decrease, but what makes you think that's true for renewables too?

As I was writing this comment, I took a small detour to do a bit of rough figuring here:

- Assume $77/MWh (Q1 2021) for utility-scale solar+storage [1]

- Assume 75 cents/L (today) for wholesale gasoline [2]

- Assume 105 L of gasoline contains 1 MWh (roughly) [3]

Then: $77 of solar energy can, if 100% efficiency were possible, produce 105 L of gasoline having a wholesale value of $78.75 at today's prices.

Obviously, 100% energy efficiency (or anything close to it) is impossible. But if solar energy instead cost $30/MWh, it suggests that an industrial process with an overall efficiency of 38% in energy terms (i.e. 2.625 MWh is needed to make 1 MWh of fuel) would be able to produce gasoline that matches the current market wholesale price.

Unfortunately I wasn't able to find anything quickly that describes industrial process efficiency in quantitative terms, so I don't know if 38% overall efficiency is reasonable to expect; personally, I think that probably would be considered high efficiency, so solar would need to get even cheaper (which it will) and/or gasoline will need to get more expensive (which it will) to improve the economics.

[1] https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy22osti/81325.pdf

[2] https://markets.businessinsider.com/commodities/rbob-gasolin...; price quoted in gallons and converted

[3] https://hextobinary.com/unit/energy/from/gasoline/to/megawat...

EDITED because I can never remember to double-space when I want newlines

carbonguy··on Attempts to power planes with hydrogen
Presumably that it costs more energy to produce hydrogen than you get back when you use it as a fuel, which is strictly true for all fuels; however, with fossil fuels, the energy cost of production has mostly been "paid" already.
carbonguy··on A biochemist’s view of life’s origin reframes cancer and aging
The hypothesis described in this article sounds remarkably similar to one advanced by Günter Wächtershäuser back in 1988 [1], the key concepts being that a) "metabolism" preceded and eventually gave rise to life and b) arose in and among iron-sulfur mineral beds near oceanic volcanic vents.

Looking forward to reading Lane's work and seeing how it compares. I'm particularly interested in hypotheses and theories about abiogenesis and I remember being struck by the elegance of the Wächtershäuser paper when I first read it, even if it was over my head at times. Hoping for a similar feeling here!

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC373159/

carbonguy··on Cheap, green hydrogen would be a breakthrough in clean energy
> the only advantage would be temporal storage.

This is not an insignificant advantage, to be fair. However, I agree that using electrolytic hydrogen as a Fischer-Tropsch or Sabatier feedstock is the way to go.

carbonguy··on The silent majority of experts (2012)
> I will be[t] $1000 immediately that kid will do well without knowing a single other thing about that family or situation.

I'd take the other side of that bet; in my experience, a parent who still feels the need to take on their adult child's domestic labor likely hasn't prepared them well for independence in other respects, such as managing their own education well enough to get good grades in university classes.

carbonguy··on Amazon builds property empire, quietly buying land across the US
Historically, because it hindered the ability of independent movie productions to get access to audiences: https://constitutioncenter.org/blog/the-day-the-supreme-cour...
carbonguy··on Tell HN: I used the same computer since 2007 (with minor upgrades)
Almost certainly referring to this technique:

https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Temporarily+Repair+a+Lost+Cause...

carbonguy··on Tell HN: I used the same computer since 2007 (with minor upgrades)
I can't recall the last time I threw away a computer. Either I've repurposed or fixed my devices over the years, as you have. A few examples:

- When my partner replaced their desktop, I rebuilt the old one into a NAS. I had to get new hard drives and a SATA port card to make that one work.

- Current main computer is a desktop that I helped my friend build, which I bought back from him in 2013 or 2014 after he upgraded. I've had to replace the power supply and the graphics card; currently it has an RX 580 from 2017.

- Picked up most of my networking gear from my previous job as an IT consultant, including an HP JE008A switch and an old Sonicwall TZ210.

I've also got the IT pack-rat shelf full of equipment that I "might use someday" - a stack of Chromebooks, network switches, graphics cards, various bits and pieces.

The last piece of kit I actually spent real money on was an refurbished Dell R720, which I'm currently using as my VM server. I've added more RAM and drive space to it as I've needed.

carbonguy··on Ask HN: Is it true that any community that grows big enough, gets ruined?
> Is it true that any community that grows big enough, gets ruined?

Well, you know what they say - nothing lasts forever. But, glibness aside:

I think the answer is yes, ultimately. But I don't think that it is bigness per se that dooms a community. This depends on how you define community, of course - is "all of Facebook" a community? Does everybody have to know each other for it to be a community? In my opinion, no; what defines a community is what it unites around - what it believes to be worth defending, specifically.

So the real killers are whatever influences force the community to sacrifice exclusionary principles - the places where the members of the community will draw a line and fight for a side, so to speak. A growth imperative is such an influence, since less exclusion = bigger TAM, hypothetically, and as other commenters have pointed out, people change the communities they join.

Interestingly, I don't think monetization as such kills a community; after all, there are plenty of communities that rally around monetization in itself as something valuable and worth defending, and many others might tolerate it as one of the exclusionary principles that keeps out the trolls.

carbonguy··on White noise improves learning by modulating activity in midbrain regions (2014)
Not so much a fan of white noise either, but I like brown noise so much I wrote my own generator: https://justbrownnoise.com
carbonguy··on Simutrans – Transport Simulator
You may be interested in Railroads Online: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1696810/RAILROADS_Online/

It leans less to the "model railroad" side of things and more towards the "Railroad Tycoon" economic simulator, but it does seem to have solid multiplayer support.

carbonguy··on Emergence of Life in an Inflationary Universe (2020)
I'm not the parent commenter, but I studied biochemistry and find abiogenesis to be a particularly fascinating topic, so I'll take a crack at answering your questions:

> How far down does this apply? E.g., do amino acids come basically for free in the same way?

Broadly, I think it is fair to say that many molecules that we associate with biological processes (e.g. amino acids, nucleotides, simple alcohols, etc.) do come "for free" in the sense that there are known pathways for these molecules to be produced in the absence of living organisms. The Miller-Urey experiment is probably the most well-known proof of concept of this idea, though it's debated how well the experimental conditions correspond with "the real world."

> ... [W]hat's the bootstrapping process like, and how random is it?

If I understand you correctly, here you're asking "what does it take to get from prebiotic organic molecules to living organisms?" And that is a fascinating question that has, to my mind, several possible answers, though ultimately I think the answer is "we don't know."

One very suggestive paper I read describes the bootstrapping process as a "surface metabolism" [1] that succeeds through several epochs before eventually producing free-floating lipid-membrane-enclosed micelles containing complex organic molecules and a rudimentary metabolism - i.e. protocells.

However, the IIRC paper falls short of explaining how these protocells can then start to independently reproduce. One hypothesis I recall from David Deamer is that hydration/dehydration cycles in shallow pools promote complex organization of simpler protomolecules into structures we typically associate with living organisms [2]; in other words, given the protobiomolecules mentioned above, certain environmental conditions encourage [proto]cell formation.

So, to answer your question (I think), there are many good candidates for the "bootstrapping process" and while there is randomness involved, it turns out that certain environmental conditions that were present on the early Earth (as well as currently!) tended to promote complex molecular formation.

> How many steps do you have to take from self replication to functional cells?

Not many; I would say that if you have something that looks like a cell and reproduces itself, it's a "functional cell." Personally, I think from that point we are at an, if not the, "origin of life," and understand in broad strokes "what happens next" - ever-more-refined single-celled organisms, multi-cell aggregates becoming "true" multi-celled organisms, and so on.

Let me know if you're curious about any other aspect of this topic and I'll try to provide more info!

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/labs/pmc/articles/PMC373159/

[2] https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/ast.2019.2045

carbonguy··on Ant mill
> The human body and the ant colony are units of reproduction; an individual ant, like an individual cell, cannot reproduce. Only the colony or the human can do that.

I honestly don't know if you're trying to be rhetorical here or what, but individual cells DO reproduce and individual humans do not.

carbonguy··on The economic consequences of major tax cuts for the rich
From the abstract:

> We find tax cuts for the rich lead to higher income inequality in both the short- and medium-term. In contrast, such reforms do not have any significant effect on economic growth or unemployment. Our results therefore provide strong evidence against the influential political–economic idea that tax cuts for the rich ‘trickle down’ to boost the wider economy.

I'd be interested in hearing from those who consider this a surprising result. To me it seems entirely expected, but with online echo-chambers being what they are I have no doubt my lack of surprise could just mean I'm in an informational cul-de-sac.

carbonguy··on Japan’s anti-aging vaccine looks promising in mice
Reading the abstract for the paper (thanks to skybrian for providing the link) it seems that the phrase "anti-aging vaccine" is a gross exaggeration in this context rather than the science itself being flawed.

Broadly, the abstract seems to be describing a particular cell-surface marker found to be associated with senescence ("seno-antigen") which can be targeted by a therapy ("genetic ablation") which accelerates removal of cells with that marker. Doing so improves the lifespan of mice so treated.

Thus, as the abstract concludes, "...vaccination targeting seno-antigens could be a potential strategy for new senolytic therapies."

carbonguy··on Bird populations declining fast across North America
> I didn't say that waiting for western countries to decline to 5% of their populations was solution.

I suppose not, though what you say later in this comment is remarkably close:

> Most of the highest consuming countries have naturally declining populations, so one thing would be to leave those alone rather than institute growth policies.

Moving on:

> What's really odd is that you think an observation is verboten if it does not come with any solutions!

Well, all right, you kinda got me there - I do, in fact, believe that observing a problem without suggesting solutions is not particularly helpful in most cases. "Verboten" is too strong a word, though - one should be as free to make pointless remarks as productive ones in a public forum such as this.

And, for what it's worth, I didn't intend my question as a "gotcha" - I appreciate that you actually answered it. Broadly, I agree with you: taking advantage of demographic transition through eg. better education seems like a good tactic, as does avoiding policies that tend to boost consumption.

Unfortunately, since anti-growth policies are antithetical to our current economic order (again, broadly speaking) I'm stuck on what combination of influences would actually synergize to make these changes possible and/or more rapid. Fortunately, I suspect at least one important transition is happening now, in the minds of the people of the world (the wealthy nations particularly) deciding they do not need as much as they are used to having access to.

To be as transparent as possible about why I care about this matter, the perspective on the destruction of the biosphere that I've internalized is that it has gone so far that mass human casualties are likely in my lifetime, and moreover that this will be how I personally die - either directly via environmental effects (heatstroke? fire? flood? famine?) or from the social breakdowns that will multiply as the foundation of our society crumbles away. I consider this outcome existentially bad and want to avoid it, to say the least.

Given this, I very urgently desire solutions that DON'T take 500 years to work, because if those are all we can come up with, then we might as well not bother: this civilization of ours is doomed sooner rather than later.

carbonguy··on Bird populations declining fast across North America
The point is probably that, if you believe the biosphere is in crisis NOW, then waiting hundreds of years for human populations to decline is not a solution.

There's an odd disconnect in the comments you've been making where you identify this problem of overpopulation, but seem extremely reticent to describe what you think should be done about this problem you've identified. Maybe I've missed it, and I plan to continue reading the thread to see if that's the case, but if I haven't, let me ask you directly: what, if anything, should be done about human overpopulation?

And if your answer is "nothing, I'm just pointing out it exists" then... well, thanks for contributing, I guess?

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →