HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

carbonguy

840 karma · joined December 26, 2020

In essence, an educated layman. Formally educated in biochemistry, informally educated in I.T. and computing technologies, professionally employed in teaching. Currently devoted to making sense of carbon sequestration to save the world from climate change.
submissionscomments
carbonguy··on Bird populations declining fast across North America
> _My_ world view deems no person "excess".

So we don't have "too many" people? The world is not OVERpopulated? Because excess means "too many" or "more than needed," so if you're saying there's no excess, then you're saying there's not too many people.

I definitely agree with you, by the way: the world does not have an excess of humans!

carbonguy··on Bird populations declining fast across North America
I suspect part of the reason people have a strong response to your suggestion is that it's patently impractical, and thus easy to pick apart.

To offer one small critique: you suggest that we first need "people to migrate from Earth into orbit," THEN "take full intentional control of the planet's climate" - surely if we have the ability to fully control Earth's climate, we don't need everyone in orbit?

And, since we have to develop the technologies necessary to implement your plan anyway, wouldn't it be easier to just figure out how to remediate the biosphere directly, instead of figuring out how to get everyone into orbit, THEN figure out full planetary climate control, THEN artificially-accelerated natural productivity restoration?

carbonguy··on Facts don’t change our minds (2018)
> Generally I think I change my mind if new (reliable and significant) facts come in.

I think most people feel this way - but it's the very notions of "reliability" and "significance," and how personal they are, that filter out an awful lot of possible mind-changing facts.

carbonguy··on “Coding is basically just ifs and for loops.”
Well, it's more complicated than that - you see, occasionally the electrons are not shared, but given up entirely.
carbonguy··on Steam Is Down
https://downdetector.com/status/steam/ reports a dramatic spike in reports as of roughly 4:45 PM PST.
carbonguy··on Gin, television, and social surplus, or, “looking for the mouse” (2008)
I've been fascinated by the ideas of this piece ever since I first read it, particularly by the idea that leisure time is something that many - or most - people actually have a hard time dealing with and integrating into their lives.

I wonder now what other "Wikipedia"-type projects have arisen since 2008 to serve as similar public goods. GitHub? Maybe YouTube, if you squint hard enough?

carbonguy··on Clerk: Local-First Notebooks for Clojure
Yeah, here's one I put together a few years back: http://pontingdynamics.org/tri
carbonguy··on Clerk: Local-First Notebooks for Clojure
I've been a Clojure hobbyist for many years, and these are a few of the things I've done repeatedly:

- Scrape webpages with http-kit and Specter

- Visualizations with Quil

- Serve static pages with Ring, Compojure, and Hiccup

(un)Fortunately, I don't write Clojure professionally, so I can get away with liking it for aesthetic reasons as much as anything. It definitely does feel like swimming against the current sometimes, though - one runs into bus factor issues a lot in the Clojure ecosystem. But hell, I love it all the same :)

Personally, I am really excited for Clerk - this looks like a really useful tool and I'm looking forward to trying it out!

carbonguy··on Facebook Renames to Meta
I doubt it's THAT high a multiple - in 2020 they earned just over $32 per user [1] and an Oculus Quest 2 retails for $299; one assumes the manufacturing cost is lower, meaning the multiple is likely 9x or less.

Of course, the essence of your point is true: Facebook doesn't make as much per year per user on average as a headset costs.

[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/234056/facebooks-average...

carbonguy··on Facebook Renames to Meta
> They couldn't get the manufacturing for it, either.

A very good point. I think the financing would be less of an issue, honestly; $200 billion a lot of cash up front, but spread out over five or ten years it's well within their FCF if they wanted to allocate it that way.

EDIT: As another comment pointed out, FB might also be able to convince advertisers to subsidize some (or all) of the costs of "free" headsets for the masses, if they wanted to try this scheme.

carbonguy··on Facebook Renames to Meta
This is an extremely interesting idea - I wonder if they'll start some kind of "invitation beta" for this fraction of users you describe.
carbonguy··on Facebook Renames to Meta
You are correct, that is the sense that I meant it. I'll edit my comment to clarify.
carbonguy··on Facebook Renames to Meta
> If there is going to be a metaverse, I'm not sure I want Facebook to own it. It's like a bad sci-fi pulp story.

I'm confident I don't want them to own it - or for it to be owned by a single party of any kind, for that matter.

> Given their investment and research, I wonder if they should open it all up (even if contradictory to short-term gains in ad revenue) so it has a chance to grow?

I mean, that would be nice for users, but:

a) I don't think Facebook is constitutionally* able to give up ad revenue gains: what they do is maximize ad revenue, basically

b) I strongly suspect they have other means at their disposal to maximize growth. After all, every FB-IG-WA user is a Meta user now, right? How much would it cost to just send every one of them an Oculus headset for free?

And if that sounds insane, consider that this announcement is basically saying "we're betting our entire brand on this particular future" - I suspect they'll do everything in their power to make that bet succeed (or appear to succeed).

* in the sense of "this is the fundamental basis and goal of the company," not in a U.S.-founding-document sense

carbonguy··on A lesser known mechanism for alcohol tolerance
> fwiw "fifth" usually means 750ml (seven-FIFTHty)

A "fifth" is also about a fifth of a gallon.

carbonguy··on Laziness does not exist (2018)
> What you quoted was directly followed by an example of laziness from the article.

Well, it was DIRECTLY followed by an assertion of intellectual laziness in the premise of the article, as your quote so helpfully shows. Perhaps if you were a bit less lazy you might have caught that?

> It is not about how I feel but the meanings of words.

Ah! An interesting assertion, considering that what you have repeatedly described as "an example of laziness" from the article could easily be described in another way, as my other reply to you hints at. For example, we could say it was "stubbornness" [1] or "passivity" [2] or even "dysfunction" [3] with as much justification as you use "laziness." So on what basis do you choose the one, and not another?

[1] "the quality of being determined to do what you want and refusing to do anything else" https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/stubb...

[2]: "the quality of being passive, where "passive" is defined as "not acting to influence or change a situation" https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/passi...

[3]: "a problem or fault in a part of the body or a machine" https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/dysfu...

carbonguy··on Laziness does not exist (2018)
> When a person takes a course twice without ever managing to turn in homework, the situation of the student is not completely to blame, since the student didn't take the time to do something - the work, withdrawing in time, discussing options with the professor, something.

And yet, any number of other words might legitimately describe the student's behavior - hesitant, confused, indifferent, passive, distracted etc. etc.

So, is "lazy" the correct term to use? And if so, why? All that we know about this particular student is that they took a class twice without turning in any assignments! Perhaps they simply enjoyed how the professor lectured and weren't actually interested in getting a degree - though I'll grant that that's a less likely possibility, given the context of the discussion.

carbonguy··on Laziness does not exist (2018)
Your original comment starts with:

> The author directly stated seeing repeated procrastination in many situations, yet stated that laziness does not exist.

This phrasing, with its use of "yet" to contrast procrastination and laziness, strongly implies that from your perspective procrastination IS laziness.

So, while you didn't literally say "procrastination is identical with laziness" maybe you can see how you might have given that impression?

For what it's worth, I agree with you that the title "Laziness Does Not Exist" is not literally true; "laziness" is a real term that people use to describe behavior, and it "exists" in that sense, at least. Do you feel there is some deeper relevance to the term, though? For example, do you think it's more accurate to say that "laziness" is an inherent character trait that explains behavior, rather than merely describing it?

carbonguy··on MIT-designed project achieves major advance toward fusion energy
> Once you have a fusion reactor running, could you use the fusion reactor itself to breed tritium?

I'll have to find the citation, but IIRC the answer is "theoretically, yes" - the concept is that molten lithium could be used in a tokamak to absorb neutrons and produce tritium at the same time.

EDIT: Here are two citations I was able to find quickly - it looks like one of the ITER experiments will be to validate the concept [1] and that this could also be the way that heat is removed from the reactor. [2]

[1] iter.org/mach/TritiumBreeding

[2] https://www.euro-fusion.org/faq/top-twenty-faq/what-is-a-lit...

carbonguy··on Why Doesn't Software Show Up in Productivity?
> I think the main hurdle is the transformation of a fluffy real world problem into something of an algorithm.

I came to a very similar conclusion after I had been teaching programming in high school for a few years: the difficulty of "programming" is in learning to think algorithmically, and no amount of "No Code" tooling gets you around that problem. The article alludes to this with the "PBJ sandwich problem" - people are used to specifying processes based on a collective (and often unconscious) cultural understanding, which computers obviously do not share!

carbonguy··on Let’s Talk Collapse
And the death toll of capitalism far exceeds that of communism, so by this metric capitalism must be more dangerous still - right?
carbonguy··on Entrepreneurs don’t have a special gene for risk, they come from rich families
> We are creating a culture of excuses for anybody who fails at chasing their dreams or doesn’t even have the motivation to do so; the equivalent of getting a “trophy for trying”, but tailored to adults.

You seem to be implying that it's a moral failing of some kind to NOT be an entrepreneur - am I reading you right? As though failing at a risky undertaking - or not bothering in the first place - is something that needs to be excused?

carbonguy··on Entrepreneurs don’t have a special gene for risk, they come from rich families
> There's a +billion entrepreneurial hustlers in the world doing whatever it takes to feed their families

If your definition of "entrepreneur" is "people doing what it takes to stay alive" then literally everyone is an entrepreneur and the term has lost any particular meaning.

I would take entrepreneur to mean "an individual who undertakes an unusually risky venture in order to have access to exceptional personal gains" and from that perspective it seems almost axiomatic that people who start with more capital have less downside risk, which in turn makes it easier to be an entrepreneur, so more of them will do it and with more success than the relatively less-resourced. What part of that do you disagree with, if any?

> Stop letting idiots build imaginary barriers to your life outcome. Just go find a way and do it.

Just buy enough tickets and you're guaranteed to win the lottery! How hard could it be?

carbonguy··on Unprecedented Heat Wave in Pacific Northwest Driven by Climate Change
What part of the evidence in this article do you consider "anecdotal?"
carbonguy··on Engineers can disrupt climate change
> But people are hoping Engineers find magic bullets so that our leaders don't have to take drastic action.

And engineers are hoping that politicians will just adopt their ideas without further work on the part of the engineers. Who's being more unreasonable in this situation, do you think?

This whole thread is riven with the attitude, sometimes more explicit and sometimes less, that in effect the engineering work to stop climate change is pointless: we have the tools, but that implacable demon Political Viability has condemned, and will always condemn our good works to eternal obscurity - as though the responsibility of the engineer ends when the tool is designed!

Which, to be fair, might be the case: the role of the engineer is to express the forms of nature and human craft in ever-more-useful ways. But as humans in a human culture, faced with the grim realities of climate change, can we really say that our responsibility ends with tool-making? Or do we have the additional responsibility to work to see those tools actually used for the common good?

carbonguy··on Ask HN: Words of encouragement for someone lost in life?
First, thank you for sharing how you're feeling - in a lot of ways, this is one of the hardest steps to take, because it acknowledges a reality that one might prefer not to acknowledge, and I respect the hell out of you for being willing to take this step.

Second, the first and best piece of advice I can give is: find and talk to a therapist (assuming you haven't already). It was probably the best decision I made when I was in a similar place to the one you've described, and the perspective shift I internalized as a result of those sessions has continued to benefit me in the subsequent years, in good times and bad.

Third, I wholeheartedly echo what many other commenters have said RE: Tinder and social media more generally - they're not going to help you get through this and in fact are probably making things worse, as you've already observed. These sites won't do anything more than reflect back to you what you're already feeling, for good or ill.

Beyond that, into some "squishier" observations and suggestions -

- The problems you describe are ones that I've only come to appreciate the significance of as I've aged; they would have sounded superfluous or insignificant to me as a teenager, maybe, but I know better now. You're right to take your feelings seriously!

- Rather a shot in the dark here, but: is there something you've wanted out of your own life, or some part of who you feel you might be, that you've ignored or suppressed or compartmentalized away because you think it's "not who you are" or something like that?

- You are absolutely right to feel that you are not alone in dealing with these issues!

- There is no "normal," and there's nothing and nobody that you are "supposed to be." This is not to say that our culture and society has not presented you with images of a particular set of ideals for literally your entire life, to the point where just figuring out what to start questioning is a years-long project - but it's true all the same.

- This, too, shall pass.

carbonguy··on TDD from the Factorio Team
For anyone like me trying to find the comment that kovarex made, apparently it was removed by the moderator of the r/factorio subreddit.

EDIT to add link to mod comment: https://www.reddit.com/r/factorio/comments/o2ly6f/friday_fac...

carbonguy··on TDD from the Factorio Team
For what it's worth, and to try and balance the scales here, I'm of the opinion that:

1) you were 100% in the right to point out that Uncle Bob is a problematic figure

2) promoting his work while ignoring 1) is, in fact, a political act as you pointed out

3) you expressed these views very tactfully and clearly (to my eye as a native English speaker - I wouldn't have known it was a second language for you had you not mentioned it)

4) based on this thread and the post you made on Reddit, there was no call whatsoever for you to "shove it up your ass" or be called toxic or anything of the sort

From where I sit, you were in the right and you remain in the right.

carbonguy··on When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell
> as they aren't full-on manipulations of reality, I view them as a useful entry point into a subject.

But then, this is exactly the critique the article advances: in this book Gladwell presents a narrative that gives readers (to put it charitably) an incomplete understanding of the nature of American air doctrine in WWII. Omission of facts IS manipulation of reality, and what Gladwell has created seems to be more akin to a third- or fourth-order representation of reality where a heavily biased selection of (to be fair, mostly true) facts is then glossed and presented in a form where one "can read it in the bathtub with a cold beer" and have a good time. Nothing inherently wrong with that, but it's pretty remarkable to assume that such a work gives you any meaningful grasp of a subject in addition to being entertainment.

carbonguy··on ALiEn – a GPU-accelerated artificial life simulation program
Continuing the thread of other individuals who've done interesting work in this area, I've always been a huge fan of Jeffrey Ventrella's "Gene Pool": http://www.swimbots.com/genepool/

His fractal art is quite compelling as well: http://www.ventrella.com/

carbonguy··on Developers can't fix bad management (2020)
> this can mean that the lead developer becomes a manager in responsibility but not in resources.

I think you've nailed it here - what's been described is a manager under another title, and one who will be hampered in that role in the exact ways you describe.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →