HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

carbonguy

840 karma · joined December 26, 2020

In essence, an educated layman. Formally educated in biochemistry, informally educated in I.T. and computing technologies, professionally employed in teaching. Currently devoted to making sense of carbon sequestration to save the world from climate change.
submissionscomments
carbonguy··on The End of Retirement (2014)
> No, I'm asking for a citation that the average American doesn't want a better life for all. Which was the claim I'm objecting to.

Frankly, it's unlikely there is such a citation, but that doesn't mean OP is wrong - just consider whether there's some class of people you feel negatively about (billionaires? homeless? immigrants? republicans? democrats? criminals? violent criminals? etc) and then ask yourself the question "do I want THEIR lives to be better?"

And if your answer is yes, then ask yourself "am I willing to sacrifice any of my own wealth or comfort to make that happen?"

And if your answer is yes again, then ask yourself "do I think the average American would say yes to the first two questions?"

For example, I can say with all honesty that I don't feel the lives of American billionaires need to be "better" in the abstract - they're doing fine, and they'll continue to be fine regardless of what I think or do. In fact, I want their lives to be worse - insofar as I believe they should contribute more of their wealth to the common cause, and I agree with the argument that less wealth is "worse" than more wealth in most ways.

So, while if there was a poll that had asked a representative slice of the American populace "do you want a better life for all?" sure, most people might say yes. But with a more specific question, for example "do you support the death penalty for a person convicted of murder?" fifty-five percent say "yes, the death penalty is acceptable" - which is apparently the LOWEST level in fifty years! So clearly there is at least one class of people (murderers) for whom it is the majority viewpoint that their lives should not only be worse, but ended entirely. No doubt others could be found.

[1] https://news.gallup.com/poll/312929/record-low-say-death-pen...

carbonguy··on The digital natives are not who you think they are
> I've met a few of the vintage computing nerds in my travels, and am constantly impressed by the depth of their knowledge.

Sure, I've met a few greybeards too, and I'm happy to agree that they have tremendous depth of knowledge about computing that most of us millennials (myself included) lack. But keep in mind that they have a depth of knowledge about computing that most of their generational peers lack as well!

Additionally, your statement that "we don't understand the technology in the same way the older generation had to" is just as true if you reverse it: the older generation doesn't understand the technology in the same way WE have to. For my part, I find it pretty difficult to look at the obvious technical aptitude of somebody like, say, Alyssa Rosenzweig or Mike Stewart - and then conclude that the younger generation doesn't "understand the technology."

Perhaps the problem here is that we're trying to compare multiple unknowns. What counts as "impressive depth of knowledge" for a generation? Is there anything objective one could use to say "actually yes, this generation really does know less than that one?" Because to me it sounds like the argument being made is "the fact that they don't understand what we went through is proof they know less than us" - not that they know differently but that they know less - and I don't buy that argument.

carbonguy··on The digital natives are not who you think they are
> When it comes down to the meat and potatoes, they do not know jack shit.

Don't forget to tell the kids to get off your lawn after you're done shaking your fist at that cloud.

I find it pretty difficult to believe that, in the age of universal instant access to technology information at every level of abstraction, "kids these days" are somehow less knowledgeable about computers than they were in the author's glory days of, presumably, the early-to-mid 80's - "I grew up with the 286, 386, 486 and all the other x86’es."

If I had to, I'd bet that just as many (or just as few, depending on your perspective) "kids" get their hands dirty (as it were) with the guts of computing as ever have - and having written this out, my assertion sounds absurdly conservative. How is it possible that more kids don't know more?

carbonguy··on The Opportunists
> ... I wouldn't call this unanticipated adoption. The work was explicitly commissioned, purchased in advance.

Fair enough - certainly in his own time he was known to the Church thus his commissions were not "unanticipated," as you point out.

Perhaps in this case the term could apply more to the legend and myth that has grown up around Michelangelo as an exemplar of the "Renaissance man" - why do we know about him more than, say, Domenico Ghirlandaio?

carbonguy··on The Opportunists
> ... academic anthropology has a history of making wildly universal claims that turn out to only apply to the WEIRD demographics that they have studied.

A very fair point indeed. It would certainly be unusual to have the opposite be true here.

carbonguy··on The Opportunists
If the thesis of this book is, as the article summarizes:

> ... artistic success owes little to vision and purpose, more to self-promotion, but most to unanticipated adoption by bigger systems with other aims, principally oriented toward money, political advantage, or commercial churn. [emphasis mine]

then the question I have is - was it ever NOT this way? Perhaps these dynamics are more legible in post-war America, but I certainly don't think they're uniquely American.

Granting that I am no student of art history, the little I do know makes me think this argument is much more broadly applicable than the author suggests - to give one example, consider the relationship between Michelangelo and the Catholic Church.

carbonguy··on U.S. adds just 266,000 jobs in April, far below expectations
Your original comment:

> .. as soon as the very generous unemployment came out she had dozens of people quitting. A lot of people prefer unemployment to menial jobs.

This comment:

> ...after last March they furloughed (laid off? not sure) a lot of people that they subsequently couldn't get to come back

Did it not occur to you that your statements are entirely contradictory? What actually happened here? Did people quit to get that sweet, sweet government lucre or were they "furloughed" ("no, we're not firing you, we're just not going to pay you or give you work for an indefinite period") and then decide that, gee, maybe they didn't want to come back to work for a company that kicked them to the curb the second things got tough?

carbonguy··on Efficiency Is the Enemy
> It can also be done by the employees by slacking off on surplus.

Can't argue with that, given that we're having this conversation while I, at least, am on the clock. However, I suspect my bosses have a much greater capacity to benefit from cannibalizing the company than I do.

carbonguy··on Efficiency Is the Enemy
I think you're on to something important here - the word "efficiency" is used to describe optimization in two different mental regimes: one, "how to meet a given quality of work with the minimum of friction/wastage" vs two, "how to perform the maximal work within a fixed resource allocation."

They sound similar, which is probably why we use the word "efficiency" to describe improvements in both regimes, but the fundamental constraint is different: in the first case, it's the standard of work that must be achieved; in the second, it's the resources allocated to the work. I'd summarize the first "do enough with enough" and the second as "do more with less."

What you describe sounds like "doing enough with enough:" given the work to be done, how can we remove resource-draining obstacles, idle loops, etc. and identify "what the work really should be?" - is that a fair assessment or am I off the mark?

carbonguy··on Efficiency Is the Enemy
> Who exactly is the target audience of this article?

If I had to guess, it would probably be most useful for those companies that have not yet reached the stage where they can serve as the venue for the executive-musical-chairs stage of management you describe.

My assumption is that when the company is small enough, that which "makes me look the best" and that which "is in the long term interests of the company" are probably mostly aligned due to the higher visibility of those early executives and managers. Not that this stops the ladder-climbers, of course - it's just more obvious when they personally contribute to wrecking a company if the company is small, which presumably the personal-brand-conscious executive would try to avoid.

> Eating up all available slack is one of the more mundane ways to cannibalize the company for your own benefit.

Otherwise known as "maximizing shareholder value."

carbonguy··on Efficiency Is the Enemy
One of the quotes suggests that DeMarco (the author of the book under discussion in this post) himself views 'slack' somewhat negatively:

> “Slack represents operational capacity sacrificed in the interests of long-term health.” [emphasis mine]

Quibble it might be, but nevertheless: surely if the goal is to appreciate the value of 'slack,' it would be better to describe it as an investment in long-term health, rather than a sacrifice for it?

To be fair, I suspect he was trying to implicitly refer to "opportunity cost" - every investment implies a "sacrifice" of the alternatives. But it seems to lead the blog post author into a similar dissonant frame of thinking:

> Slack consists of excess resources... Slack is vital...

Here I quibble with the use of "excess." Excess compared to what? Presumably, excess compared to the resources one might assume were necessary to guarantee a healthy operation - but as the author then notes, these resources are not "excess" at all, but indeed "vital!" In other words, they are fundamental to the continued existence of the operation. Why imply anything else?

carbonguy··on The Unix Magic Poster
- The wizard hat says "su," naturally

- The "shell process" (visual pun! I love it) is "outputting to null"

- The hat ribbon has the initials "dmr," "kt," and "bwk" - presumably Dennis M. Ritchie, Ken Thompson, and Brian W. Kernighan

Any others?

carbonguy··on How many x86 instructions are there? (2016)
The assembly bug bit me again a few months back, but instead of writing it I had a grand time hand-disassembling some ARMv4T binaries - scratched something of the same itch as solving a sudoku.
carbonguy··on How many x86 instructions are there? (2016)
For me the article was well worth it; where else but in ISA discussions can you find gems like the following?

> Does a non-instruction that is non-defined and unofficially guaranteed to non-execute exactly as if it had never been in the instruction set to begin with count as an x86 instruction? For that matter, does UD2 itself, the defined undefined instruction, count as an instruction?

carbonguy··on Coding Machines (2009)
I have been looking for this exact short story since I first encountered it via a now long-forgotten HN comment - thank you, djoldman, for bringing it back to my attention! I'll make sure to bookmark it this time :)
carbonguy··on Could index funds be “worse than Marxism”?
Who would have guessed - an article that seems to consist mainly of quotes from hedge fund managers reaches the conclusion that passive investment is bad not just for them personally but for the entire economy!

I wonder if it's occurred to them that they could perhaps use their knowledge and resources to provide better investment options rather than spending their time being shocked and appalled that investors prefer to pay less and earn more.

carbonguy··on Min wage would be $44 / hour if it had grown at same rate as Wall Street bonuses
The article you link fails to mention that McDonald's also spent about 8.5 billion on stock buybacks and dividends in 2018, which would have been enough to give every one of their 210,000 employees an extra 40,000 dollars that year on top of what they already made that year. Not quite $44 an hour, but a hell of a lot better than minimum wage - and the company wouldn't need to spend a single extra cent or raise any prices in order to do it.

From the 2018 annual report: https://corporate.mcdonalds.com/content/dam/gwscorp/nfl/inve...

carbonguy··on Min wage would be $44 / hour if it had grown at same rate as Wall Street bonuses
While it's true that very few people earn exactly the federal minimum wage, which is what your source is discussing, it's probably worth mentioning that "Currently, 29 states and D.C. have minimum wages above the federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour." [1] Saying that "very few people earn minimum wage" while referring to federal minimum wage statistics is not particularly informative - and even the statistics you cite are somewhat misleading, as they refer to people earning the federal minimum wage or less, although it's implied that those earning less are mostly tipped workers.

It turns out to be somewhat difficult to find statistics for which fraction of workers earn their state's minimum wage or less; focusing just on California [2], it seems that at least 4%, or ~630,000, CA workers were earning at or below the CA minimum wage in 2017. In other words, the 1.3 million figure given as "the number of minimum wage workers" is almost certainly off by a large factor, once you take into account different minimum wages.

[1] https://www.ncsl.org/research/labor-and-employment/state-min...

[2] https://www.labormarketinfo.edd.ca.gov/data/oes-employment-a...; the 630k figure comes from looking at the industries in the "State of California" summary sheet that have a "25th percentile" wage of 10.50 or less, then taking 25% of the workers in those industries to get a lower-bound estimate.

carbonguy··on Programming is hard
Interesting that the author didn't really discuss WHY programming is hard; I agree that it is, but if their concern is that beginners are being misled into thinking it's easy then I would have expected they'd spend some time exploring what programming is really like rather than commenting on tangential social issues.

My own experience as a programming teacher leads me to believe that one of the main difficulties for the new programmer is the level of precision with which they must be able to articulate a concept in code in order to have it work. For example, it was much more common for a given student to grasp, say, a conditional statement and when to use it than it was for them to understand that changing the capitalization of a variable meant they weren't referring to what they wanted.

carbonguy··on Amazon illegally fired activist workers, Labor Board finds
> Not increasing its power is not undermining it.

This might be true if you were describing a situation with three parties: a company, a union, and you - affiliated with neither. But as almost all unionization takes place after people have already entered an employee/employer relationship, the neutrality has been lost; you are, by default, on the side of the employer if you are not a part of the union, and having employees not in a union does weaken the bargaining position of the union since it's relative representation that matters.

> Stop changing definitions to suit your political goals.

Don't forget to call the kettle black, while you're at it.

carbonguy··on Amazon illegally fired activist workers, Labor Board finds
> JFC talk about a "you're with us or against us" mentality... your rhetoric has pushed me further towards unions being bad.

It's a remarkably odd choice to refer to OP's comment as "rhetoric" in this case given that the remark "it's not physically possible to be neutral on this issue" is a literal statement of truth.

Generally, neutrality implicitly supports the status quo; it's a choice like any other, whether you acknowledge it as such or not, and as OP pointed out it is literally true that if you have the option to be part of a union and you aren't, the bargaining power of that union is less than it otherwise would be.

I suppose you'd have to clarify what you meant with respect to your own decisions - have you ever even had the option to join a union? Because if not, then I could see how you might be able to see yourself as "neutral" as it's not an issue that has directly affected you. But if you did have a choice then presumably you made a choice one way or the other, in which case "neutrality" isn't something you can actually claim.

carbonguy··on Amazon illegally fired activist workers, Labor Board finds
> You don’t imagine that “unions are good because of X, Y, and Z facts” is a more compelling argument to anyone anywhere in the middle spectrum than “if you don’t like unions, you’re a selfish asshole” or “if you’re not with us, you’re against us” and that difference in compelling nature would influence someone’s support of unions?

I'm not the OP, but to answer your question: frankly, no - in general it seems to often be the case that the factual merit of an argument is not really important in influencing opinion.

That the argument you mention ("if you don't like unions, you're a selfish asshole") has any influence at all is proof enough of this; note that it makes no direct statement about the merit of unions themselves, and yet is presented as an example of an influential argument about the value of unions - and rightfully so, based on your reaction and the reactions of other people in this thread.

Furthermore, I think it's fairly naive to think that "we developed [our opinions regarding unions] over time by deciding on the arguments advanced," as though it were always a conscious process or that a broadly fair view of unions was widely disseminated with which to make an informed decision. After all, why would it be?

carbonguy··on The zombie economy and digital arm-breakers
> I think the author doesn't appreciate that the debt is being repaid... #1 we are doing gargantuan "stimulus" transfers of money... #2... IF any issuer of debt, like a bank, gets in trouble, like in 2008 or March 2020, they are bailed out.

Changing who's holding the hot potato is not the same as repayment of debt. In both of your examples, it's the government who's assuming the debt from corporate debtholders who have (presumably) milked it for return already in the way the article describes. But, as you point out:

> ...govt debt still needs to be repaid. But that can happen via #1 ["The US will become a net exporter (and to some degree, it always was) of inflation."], or via taxation.

Taxation is a no-go - even if the political will could be mustered in the US to increase taxes, who are you as the government going to tax? The companies who were so indebted you had to bail them out, or the private individuals who've already been put through the wringer by the companies?

So we have to export the debt in some way - but it stays debt, and it has to be paid.

> Its just that the time horizon for repayment is so long, and hard to observe, that it may lead to the conclusion that the debt is not being repaid.

I suspect that if it takes long enough then it doesn't really matter whether the debt is "repaid" in some technical sense because the negative outcomes associated with default will have already taken place.

carbonguy··on Let there be more biographies of failures
Are you making the argument that "people who think it's a good idea to start restaurants" are representative of "grown-ups?"

I think you're right insofar as you point out that opening a restaurant is a fraught enterprise, but I don't really think that refutes the comment you're responding to - the overwhelming majority of adults don't open restaurants, even though there are always plenty of dreamers who think it's a good idea.

carbonguy··on Clearing price for supplying power to Texas grid –$31.65
This article is referring to the effect of a class of compounds called "aerosols," which does not include CO2. Aerosols do prevent some fraction of solar energy from reaching Earth's surface, but this is separate from the effect of increased CO2 concentrations.
carbonguy··on What World War I Can Teach Us about Misjudging Tech and Social Change (2020)
From my understanding of the period, one might describe WWI as "anticipated, but not comprehended;" one of the catalysts for the war was a general understanding on the European continent that France and Germany were going to re-litigate the Franco-Prussian war at some point, as well as an understanding in Germany that time was not on their side due to the demographic changes in France - higher relative population growth - and economic changes in the Russian Empire allowing for more rapid and effective military deployment.

However, the types of wars in which the Great Powers of the time were involved - and from which their military planners derived their assumptions about war with modern weaponry - were mainly colonial conflicts against relatively under-armed opponents, eg. the Boer war, which the Great Powers typically "won." The outcome of the Russo-Japanese war (1904-05) was shocking enough to change the calculus for planning the European war, as Russia was now seen as a less able ally for France... and on and on such analysis could go!

With respect to this article, I would take the lesson of the early 20th century and WWI and ask:

Is there any major geopolitical development that is generally assumed to be inevitable, and how might modern technology upset the assumptions of the powers-that-be in their planned response to that event?

carbonguy··on Launch HN: Noya (YC W21) – Direct air capture of CO2 using cooling towers
I'm no engineer; that said, I think you're being slightly unfair to the Carbon Engineering folks, as paper [3] that OP linked states that CE's design reflects "reflects roughly 100 person-years of development." That doesn't strike me as outrageous in this context (30 people working for ~40 months?), although I'll grant I don't have a ton of perspective on industrial process development.

That said, OP's idea does have merit. avernon, I think you hit the nail on the head with your comment downthread regarding the main concern being avoiding disruption to existing plant processes where this kind of tech might be installed - I would be worried specifically about how radically raising the pH of cooling process water would affect mineral deposition, for example, but then that in turn would surely depend on how a given plant had set up its cooling system to begin with.

Nevertheless, it seems very likely that this idea could in itself knock about $4/t off of the cost of CO2 relative to the CE estimate ($212M saved for their air contactor design amortized over 30Mt of CO2 captured during a CE plant lifetime) which in the best case is around 5% of the cost of the CO2 capture.

carbonguy··on We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college
> It's a cliche but if we spent 10% of of what we spend on Nukes or drug enforcement on this it would be a game changer.

> > I think people that say things like this overestimate how much we spend on things like this and underestimate social spending.

These caught my attention because they both made claims for which the quantitative basis can somewhat easily be established, partly because the parent was making a relatively specific claim as these things go.

Here's what I was able to find with ~20min of searching for federal spending in these three categories:

Foster care: $22 billion (2017) [1]

Drug control: $25 billion (2015) [2]

Nuclear arms: $35 billion (2019) [3]

I was surprised that these three areas received roughly equivalent amounts of money - support for your statement that people tend to underestimate social spending.

As to the parent comment: while it does seem likely that taking 10% of the budget from nuclear arms or drug enforcement would indeed make a qualitative difference to foster service provision, my hunch is that the 10-20% increase that implies wouldn't be a "game changer" as the parent asserted even if the claims in [1] that the program needs to be entirely reconfigured are warranted.

EDIT: The parent comment also asserts that a better-funded foster care system would be "cheaper than prison" - another question which could probably be answered with some quantitative basis. Anyone else want to take a shot at it?

[1] https://abcnews.go.com/Primetime/FosterCare/story?id=2017991...

[2] https://drugpolicy.org/sites/default/files/DPA_Fact_sheet_Dr...

[3] https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/14/us/nuclear-weapons-spending-t...

carbonguy··on Why Combustion Is Exothermic
> Breaking oxygen bonds produces no energy and in fact requires energy

And this, in turn, is a specific example of a general principle: breaking any chemical bond always requires energy, while forming any bond always releases energy.

carbonguy··on Bill and Melinda Gates: America’s Top Farmland Owner
> But is that maintenance lower than the existing maintenance burden?

While I haven't looked up the data yet, it seems plausible to assume that maintenance on photovoltaic electric generation is not only lower but significantly lower than thermal generation.

For example, having no moving parts in the generation process must be a large maintenance savings, though of course there must be unique costs associated with photovoltaics - cleaning, perhaps?

> Even then, this is still a wildly conservative estimate in terms of price.

I just did some quick calculations to check this statement and found it basically true - I estimate the cost of 100% PV solar generation at around $180tn 2019 USD for 30 years of capacity.

For reference, I used these figures:

173,340 TWh energy consumption in 2019 [1] * $35/MWh for utility-scale PV solar[2] * 1,000,000 MWh/TWh = $6.1t yearly energy cost for 100% PV energy production, or $182t over a 30-year lifetime.

This, of course, does not take into account the increase of energy consumption over that period which would raise costs, nor the economies of scale of this level of PV deployment which would surely lower costs, but as a BotE calculation it sounds about right and corresponds with your earlier estimate of $210tn for the same investment. Note also that the $35/MWh figure includes all operating expenses and amortized capital costs i.e. it takes all costs into account already.

However, as you imply with your first question regarding maintenance burden, the correct comparison is not "how much would it cost" but rather "how much would it cost relative to projected costs of energy" - and again per [2], utility PV solar is already cheaper than new utility thermal power generation. There is of course plenty of nuance when it comes to energy consumption - you point out, for example, that aviation will be a difficult sector to "electrify," a true enough statement in and of itself. However, it's pointed out in [3] that jet fuel represents 12% of transportation energy consumption and that transportation overall represents 25% of global energy consumption, implying that aviation only represents about 3% of global energy consumption.

Based on this, I speculate that aviation fuels can be produced in a 100% solar PV energy regime without increasing - and likely lowering - energy production costs above the current regime.

[1] https://ourworldindata.org/energy-production-consumption [2] https://www.lazard.com/perspective/lcoe2019 [3] https://www.maritime-executive.com/article/transport-uses-25...

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →