Or, in other words: how can you genuinely further the cause, rather than simply seem to?
840 karma · joined December 26, 2020
Or, in other words: how can you genuinely further the cause, rather than simply seem to?
Nevertheless I think you're making a solid point: information overload can be pretty harmful. I think that's what Thompson is getting at with his comment "the solution to misinformation is improving our ability to tell the difference" but honestly that's not a solution so much as it is a goal - granting that it's desirable for people to have this filtering capacity, how can it be learned?
I suppose the point could be interpreted to mean "investigate the assumptions of the status quo and find out which ones are no longer valid" - but then, that's not what Thompson wrote.
As to points one and three - I don't buy that "free speech is good" is no longer the default and I don't see much in this essay that shows otherwise. The example given (Youtube censoring perspectives that contradict the WHO, despite the WHO itself having disseminated falsehoods) leads directly to the questions: should Youtube not have been allowed to make that decision? And if not, how should they have been prevented?
As to the third point - revisiting the example just discussed, surely the WHO's communications (of which Thompson seems critical) could be seen as an example of an organization hewing to the very default he asserts as valuable? Move fast with your communications, value early release over perfect certainty, etc.
I would be very interested to see statistics on this, because I suspect the answer is "almost nobody" - as I assume your question was meant to imply.
> ... [How] many non-academic taxpayers are trying to read articles that don't have institutional access through their employer or local public library?
Count me in this population, although to be honest it literally never occurred to me to check if the local public library had journal access.
> Where the fuck is the actual case study about the structure of the system, constraints, influences, incentives? How does it evolve and how does the contract change and evolve that system?
These are the questions that some organizers who have written books about organizing are also trying to answer.
Assuming that you make no effort to influence any of the hypothetical 100,000 people voting on the contract in any way.
> The contract will reflect your coworkers aggregate preferences, which will in general be completely orthogonal to your own preferences.
This is a fairly surprising assertion for me - I can't recall a time I've personally found this to be the case professionally. May I ask how you encountered this in your own professional experience?
For context: the paper describes an air-to-fuels system requires carbon dioxide as a carbon source as well as some source of hydrogen gas. Given these two feedstocks there are then two main routes to fuel production: reduction of carbon dioxide to methanol or ethanol, which can then be "upgraded" to heavier fuels, or reduction of carbon dioxide to carbon monoxide, which is used along with the hydrogen to feed a Fischer-Tropsch reaction producing a variety of fuels directly. My understanding is that in either case production costs are dominated by the cost of acquiring the feedstocks, which are in turn mainly driven by the cost of energy.
What the article describes is a technique that modifies the Fischer-Tropsch step of the process that uses it, which would perhaps bring costs down somewhat for that step. Additionally, and more importantly, carbon monoxide is not needed as a separate feedstock as CO2 is apparently directly reduced by this new catalyst - this is where significant cost savings could potentially realized.
I'm no expert in any of this but for what it's worth I did go through a process of estimating what "air-to-fuels" fuel might cost to produce and came up with a cost of about $1300 per metric ton. If the technique described in the paper were applied to the process I investigated, the $1300/mt price could potentially decrease to around $1000/mt. For comparison, Brent crude oil is currently about $380/mt and aviation fuel is about $430/mt.
[EDIT] Forgot to include a link to my analysis: https://bit.ly/34JTCFm
1) The conversion will always be energy-negative due to the laws of thermodynamics, as a sibling comment mentioned. This is true even of existing fossil fuels, though we tend not to think of it that way.
2) The process of converting CO2 to hydrocarbon fuels leads to a decrease in atmospheric carbon. Burning these fuels or fossil fuels (what I assume you mean by "the existing process") produces an increase in atmospheric carbon.
This means it's possible to create a net-positive, net-neutral, or net-negative outcome with respect to atmospheric CO2 concentration depending on how you balance these two processes.
As you point out, "zero emission" doesn't mean the same thing as "no net CO2 release"; rather, it more often means "zero emissions of CO2 at the point of energy usage," with CO2 emissions usually occurring elsewhere. That said, with a system of hydrocarbon fuel production from air-captured CO2 it is genuinely possible to have "zero emission" mean "zero net emission of CO2 over the entire energy transport process."
EDIT: The key enabling technology is, of course, carbon-free renewable energy, of which solar is likely to represent the lions' share as time passes.
However, you are right in the sense that taking advantage of our current hydrocarbon distribution infrastructure would save capital costs versus switching to, e.g., an all-hydrogen or all-electric energy infrastructure. The trick is to get those hydrocarbons from non-fossil sources, which is a solved problem from a technical perspective but very much still unsolved from an economic perspective.