HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

carlisle_

1,089 karma · joined September 14, 2012

I'm currently an SRE with a history of operationally focused engineering roles.
submissionscomments
carlisle_··on Successfully Merging the Work of 1000 Developers
This paper might be of interest to you on this very subject:

https://eng.uber.com/research/keeping-master-green-at-scale/

carlisle_··on Tom Delonge’s UFO Research Center Is Making Politicians Demand Answers
>I haven't; what was in the movie?

Pretty much exactly what you're describing haha (with obviously a fair bit of artistic license).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4onAJ-3FAM

carlisle_··on Greta Thunberg has done her science homework
That's quite possibly the most overreaching analogy I've seen. Your entire argument is disingenuous and is meant to provoke an emotional response. It's also just wrong.
carlisle_··on Greta Thunberg has done her science homework
Did you seriously just try to equivocate climate change and child pornography?
carlisle_··on Greta Thunberg has done her science homework
Having not heard the speech, this was news to me, and extremely alarming:

> They do, however, include negative emission techniques on a huge planetary scale that is yet to be invented, and that many scientists fear will never be ready in time and will anyway be impossible to deliver at the scale assumed.”

Imagine somebody said "a meteor is going to hit the Earth in 11 years and end life as we know it unless we made massive changes to our way of life and invented new technologies to thwart it." I fully believe we as a species could collectively band together to stop it.

What's so horrible about climate change is it's not that the world ends in 11 years. It's that in 11 years we likely are doomed to watch our own extinction. On top of that, we're not even beginning to deal with the problem in a way that gives hope for the future. I can't think of a more existential crisis inducing reality.

carlisle_··on SpaceX Gets FCC Approval to Sell Wireless High-Speed Home Internet from Space
Who else besides the FCC needs to approve SpaceX launching over 4,000 satellites into space? That seems like a fairly significant number of satellites, but admittedly I am a layman in this area.
carlisle_··on U.S. Nuclear Power Plants Weren’t Built for Climate Change
That's pretty neat, what makes the newer reactors able to use old waste as fuel?
carlisle_··on Jack Ma defends the 'blessing' of a 12-hour working day
Pretty easy to justify long working hours when the payoff is $40 billion.
carlisle_··on US Government Tracking Journalists and Immigration Advocates
>Government tracks people breaking the law. Backhanded activism at its finest, this article is.

Is this the fox news talking point? This exact sentiment is slathered all over those hateful vile Facebook comments at the bottom of the article.

carlisle_··on You Don’t Need All That Complex/Expensive/Distracting Infrastructure
>Your users to don’t care how your code gets onto your server.

I don't like arguments like this. This is true for any number of tasks that a layman wouldn't care to understand. You still will do them anyway, regardless of whether or not your user cares. It doesn't take a lot of experience to see the correlation between poor engineering practices and poor user experience.

Now, I don't think the author was using this argument to pitch poor engineering, but there are good reasons for setting up resilient and consistent build deploys, as he addresses. I think the only real takeaway is "dont over-engineer your infrastructure" which is just an extension of generally "don't over-engineer."

Every time infrastructure gets talked about on HN the conversation gets so sidetracked. The real problem is that people don't think about infrastructure in the context of a holistic view of a project. The hours you spend setting up your project with resilient and consistent CI builds are many times more valuable down the road.

I think people need to not be so afraid of spending time on infrastructure. People already err on the side of spending less than more time on infrastructure. I don't think it's wrong at all that the author spent hours building an automatic build process for his project, especially because now that he's set it up he can refer to it in the future. Maybe with his newfound knowledge and experience on the problem means that he can leverage it with little effort in the future. None of this is a bad thing especially if you think about your engineering career on a macro scale instead of week to week.

carlisle_··on Lyft Files S-1
Google wasn't really a cloud provider for like 15 years and hosted their own infrastructure that entire time.
carlisle_··on Lyft Files S-1
Uber hosts its own infrastructure, so does Google, so does Facebook. All three of those companies have no problems remaining focused on their business models without turning into a "datacenter company."

I strongly dislike the notion that on-prem hosting is somehow a bad thing, or too cumbersome, or otherwise totally solved by cloud providers. AWS specifically is hugely convenient in a number of ways, but it doesn't come close to the cost savings from running your own infrastructure. You need a pretty large amount of capital and engineering talent, but it really is worth it even in the short term (~3-5 years).

I think people would be shocked at what the money comes out to be if they saw costs from companies doing their own physical infrastructure. AWS makes you pay through the nose, seeing the difference would change a lot of minds I'm sure.

carlisle_··on Anthony Levandowski: Pronto AI
Lol and he touts his safety record like the shit he was directly working on didn’t kill somebody a few months after he left. This whole blog reads like somebody still in denial.
carlisle_··on Kubernetes for personal projects? No thanks
>The complexity overhead of k8s is non-trivial, and switching from Heroku to something like k8s doesn't involve undoing much work, since setting up Heroku is trivial.

This sounds like exactly what I'm advocating. I wasn't saying that you need to build specifically with Kubernetes in mind, but some people aren't even thinking about what it means to deploy to Heroku. Maybe you do some small amount of reading and research to know "switching from heroku to kubernetes is a viable migration path.' What I strongly dislike is this mentality:

> taking more time away from actually building your side project

None of what I've mentioned is time taken away or lost. Time spent doesn't just pause when you are ready to deploy or productionize. SWEs need to think more holistically about their software's lifecycle.

carlisle_··on Kubernetes for personal projects? No thanks
> taking more time away from actually building your side project and putting it into building infrastructure around your side project.

I generally dislike this way of thinking. Infrastructure is a core component of whatever it is you're building, not an afterthought. Maybe you can defer things until a little bit later, but if you can build with infrastructure in mind you'll be saving yourself so many headaches down the road.

You don't need to build with the entire future of your project's infrastructure in mind, but deploying your project shouldn't be "ok now what?" when you're ready, like it was a big surprise.

carlisle_··on “It’s Easier To Ask Forgiveness Than To Get Permission”
None of these are a license to forge ahead anyway. All of these problems have their own solution that should be addressed, and most definitely not by just doing what you want anyway.
carlisle_··on FCC plan would give Internet providers power to choose the sites customers see
https://science.howstuffworks.com/life/inside-the-mind/human...
carlisle_··on Investing in ICOs May Be Even Riskier Than You Realize
I feel like people hear the word 'cryptocurrency' and ignore all of the well established risks of currency speculation as an investment strategy.
carlisle_··on Show HN: Airborn – Private Google Docs Alternative
Yeah, exactly. I agree with the "so secure" suggestion by the other commenter. You can tweak it to your liking but you don't want to give the impression you're anything less than complete with your approach to security.
carlisle_··on Show HN: Airborn – Private Google Docs Alternative
I feel like "Even if we get hacked" as a marketing message might send the wrong signals.
carlisle_··on I have no side code projects to show you
If you want people to show up with code why aren't you asking them to take home something and show you their solution in the interview, working through it step by step?
carlisle_··on US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert
Some would argue a threat worsened by provocative and unilateral actions, but we'll see who writes the history books.
carlisle_··on Why we switched from Python to Go
> Python, Node and Ruby all have better systems for package management

Maybe they have better tools for managing package dependencies but Go doesn't have to deal with interpreter dependencies, which can be a major headache. Go also doesn't have the problem of conflicting system level packages.

Honestly no matter how good your deployment practices are, if you have to manage an application's deployment long term you're going to have dependency problems of some kind. I'd rather deal with those problems at compile time than hit an edge case during deploy or in prod.

carlisle_··on 2017 California school test scores: Why are they flatlining?
This is the kind of comment that truly derails education. It's reactionary and doesn't have a real objective.
carlisle_··on Amber Rudd accuses tech giants of 'sneering' at politicians
I think it's a bit arrogant to assume that tech companies (especially those based out of other countries) are deliberately trying to undermine governments rather than empower people.
carlisle_··on New antibody attacks 99% of HIV strains
I believe that's actually somewhat how AIDs treatments have worked. I'm not sure if all are like that but it's pretty much the exact logic.
carlisle_··on Ray Dillinger: If I'd Known What We Were Starting
>That's why I added "despite consequences". Ok, now they're in jail and they still refuse. Now what?

This already happens without block chains.

carlisle_··on Ray Dillinger: If I'd Known What We Were Starting
> And what if they refuse [despite consequences]?

I feel like this is a problem that is pretty commonly exercised in our legal system and incarceration is usually a strong last resort motivator.

carlisle_··on Someone Made a Fake Equifax Site. Then Equifax Linked to It
The creator of the site was on here today posting about it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15295146

Weird seeing a repost on the website where a lot of the story unfolded on the same day.

carlisle_··on Improbably Frequent Lottery Winners
Ever hear of Occam's Razor? We have two broad options, a small set of people who are psychic, have kept it secret for the entire history of humanity, and use it to win the lottery but in almost no other context that we know of or have recognized.

The other option is that these frequent winners are surrogates for others who can or would not hand in their lottery ticket on their own.

What follows the razor?

← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →