HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

carnagii

251 karma · joined March 14, 2019

submissionscomments
carnagii··on Julian Assange Indictment (2018)
> Manning, who had access to the computers in connection with her duties as an intelligence analyst

they are gendering her correctly. at least we have a progressive politically correct Stasi.

carnagii··on The Twilight of Combustion Comes for Germany's Empire of Engines
The whole point of a brand is that people make buying decisions based on irrational ephemera as opposed to utility. Once you establish a luxury brand then charging ridiculous prices for the same utility only reinforces brand perception because consumers have no ability or desire to judge things based on utility and so they equate paying more with a better product, or at least with personal prestige.

BMW will do just fine.

carnagii··on Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Reviews Audio
> utterances are anonymized

if only we had some technology that could identify a speaker based on their voice. oh, wait a second. but, lol, no, they aren't anonymized ... "recordings sent to the Alexa auditors don’t provide a user’s full name and address but are associated with an account number, as well as the user’s first name and the device’s serial number"

carnagii··on House of Representatives Passes Net Neutrality Protections
Correct, but suppose one company has hundreds of edge's to their private network very close to the last mile and they run 10-20% of all internet traffic going across that last mile. If you are Google or Amazon and push a lot of low priority streaming bandwidth, a neutral last mile dedicates a lot of capacity to you, so when you prioritize high value data on your own network that priority ends up applying to the last mile as well.

The only way a new company without a massive nationwide network could compete with Google or Amazon is if they could pay a carrier for prioritized service. If you prevent the carriers from offering prioritized service then you are reducing competition because Google and Amazon can and do offer this.

Google and Amazon are far more dangerous monopolists than the traditional telcos. They are already vertically integrated hardware/software/media/everything companies. If some innovative startup builds a killer product that requires their network to function then they will either buy it, or create their own competitive product and kill it.

AT&T, Verizon, and Comcast are relatively small companies now and they are in direct competition with Google and Amazon on many fronts, including this one. The Google version of net-neutrality is nothing more than an attempt to stifle what little competition they have left.

carnagii··on House of Representatives Passes Net Neutrality Protections
This net neutrality is far from it when Google, Amazon, etc have their own private networks to which net neutrality rules don't apply. If carriers are prevented from offering differentiated services, which are required for next Gen products like self driving cars, video games in the cloud, Tele presence, and even just reliable video conferencing, then the only companies that will be able to offer these services will be the ones with existing multi billion private networks. Or you have to run your business on aws or gce and pay them 10X and they get all the profit. The only way a true competitor could get started is if they can buy the network service they need from an independent carrier. The fcc is right on this and Google is full of bs.
carnagii··on New paper quantifies how quickly Southern planters recovered from the civil war
Class is not about money. This was an iron law up until a couple hundred years ago but the American attempt to create a classless society obscures it. The earlier belief that class was about "blood" was crude and probably mostly inaccurate (although genetic affinity does confer some benefits to a group) but the real mechanism for class transference is more likely the unconscious education that children receive from interacting with their parents and their peer group.

European history is full of destitute monarchs and nobility. The key to understanding the elite is that they are usually not wealthy - they are deeply in debt most of the time and that is what makes them seem so successful.

To understand this simply: suppose you have lots of money. naturally people will try to take it from you and may even kill you to steal it. On the other hand suppose you have lots of debts. Your creditors must keep you alive in order to recover their money and will steer business your way because they have a stake in whatever you earn.

So, counterintutitve as it may seem, having (the right) debts will make it easier to succeed then having lots of money.

carnagii··on New paper quantifies how quickly Southern planters recovered from the civil war
Chattel slavery was horrible and immoral which tends to make people forget that it was also incredibly stupid and inefficient. Wage slavery where people have the illusion of freedom but are still coerced by the threat of starvation and homelessness is a far more efficient form of exploiting labor. Once the slavers were forced to modernize their operations became much more profitable.
carnagii··on Show HN: Ethical Resources – 300 ethical alternatives to mainstream stuff
Blank page with ad-block plus.
carnagii··on Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees Have Value
Harsh but true. Requiring advanced math classes as a gatekeeper for comp Sci is also massively exclusionary and totally pointless because the vast majority of programming jobs require no math at all.
carnagii··on Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees Have Value
I think it is true that it takes a lot of practice to develop implementation skill but that is largely optional in cs. You can graduate from cs programs with no implementation skills and only the ability to talk about programming.
carnagii··on Facebook to ban white nationalist content
that is the default answer but there comes a point when you have to reconsider it in light of the facts of a particular situation.

Take email for instance: first class mail is protected by the 5th amendment, and a warrant is required to open and read first class mail. Move communications to a private digital platform and the presumption of privacy is completely flipped into a presumption that all your emails will be read and stored for future reading. When all communications go online that leads to a very significant change in how the law applies to private communications and that is exploited by the government just as much as it is exploited by the corporations. After many years of there being a free-for-all where law enforcement and intelligence claimed they could view anything online without a warrant there was finally some push back by courts to reassert the rule of law, but email still has substantially less privacy than first class mail.

Speech on public forums is a similar case. The 1st amendment applies to the town square but if a corporation creates a digital town square then it gets the right of censorship. Then the government applies pressure on the corporation to censor on their behalf and the government begins to exercise a power it did not previously have. That was not a problem when online platforms were small and inconsequential, but when they grow to billions of users globally, then the power to censor speech on those platforms becomes quite influential on the exercise of real world power.

Corporations do not have police powers but they are subjects of governments that do, so once they get power they can always be made tools of the people that hold power over them.

carnagii··on F-35: What The Pilots Say
> to penetrate sophisticated enemy air defenses and find and disable threats—requires what the fifth-generation jet offers: stealth and a stunning array of passive and active sensors

> U.S. forces first took these capabilities into combat last September, when Marine F-35Bs struck the Taliban in Afghanistan

against disorganized rebel forces less well armed than the average suburban American, with no air force and no surface to air missiles. and the U.S. still can't win that war.

carnagii··on Meet Q, a Genderless Voice
it is an interesting idea. technology of course has no gender, and any synthesized speech can only express an arbitrary simulation of gender, so making this explicit reveals the underlying reality that all technological simulations of gender are by definition constructed. a piece of art that demonstrates the construction of gender probably will not catch on well as a product though.
carnagii··on Facebook to ban white nationalist content
why not just have their policy be the first amendment and they abide by the same rules as the country that created them? Why should corporations take on censorship powers that are prohibited for the government? Why should a private for-profit corporation controlled by one man have more power than a transparent institution controlled by democracy?
carnagii··on Why We Love QUIC and HTTP/3
It is not necessarily bad. Moving complex stuff to user space can be good sometimes. There are things this would break like splice but also allows much tighter integration with applications because you can get and set state without system calls. As you layer on more complex app level adaptations to connection failures having it in user space means the client has the same capabilities irregardless of platform which is important so that both client and server can make mutual complimentary adaptations to the same conditions. This stuff is not really needed for web, it is mostly video conferencing type stuff that gets the biggest benefit. Googs new game service for instance.
carnagii··on A Story About Piracy
there is far more money being made off of all of the forms of art you mention than ever before in history. there are more books being published, more photos taken, etc, etc.

it was never easy to make money off of writing before. it still isn't. given than many more people are doing it the proportion of failures to successes is higher and the earnings are more widely dispersed.

people don't usually make money off of software directly but usually by using software to enable some sort of process that they can charge for.

software engineers make money the same way ghost writers, or script writers, or other real writing professionals make money. they get a spec and they implement it. the difference between professionals and artists is that professionals get paid up front.

carnagii··on A Story About Piracy
in a post physical scarcity world ideas are the only things with any value.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2