HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

carpdiem

561 karma · joined September 15, 2009

submissionscomments
carpdiem··on Ask HN: Favorite purchases of last two years?
Ankles can be tricky. Most "barefoot" style shoes have essentially zero ankle support. What ends up happening for most people is that if you ease into them, and use them regularly, you end up building up substantially more muscle in your foot and lower leg which ends up being the "thing that gives you ankle stability".

If you've got really serious ankle problems / past injuries / etc, that might not be a plausible approach for you. But if it's just a case of your ankle being a little unstable every so often, it might be worth trying the barefoot shoe approach, and treat it like building up new muscles in any other context: start slow and easy and try to be consistent about it.

carpdiem··on IKEA buys 11,000 acres of U.S. forest to keep it from being developed
Forests are not perpetual carbon sinks, as trees eventually die and then decompose, releasing their carbon back into the atmosphere.

At best, a young and growing forest can be a temporary carbon sink, until it reaches maturity (and steady state).

Alternatively, a forest might support continual carbon sinking if and only if the recently dead and/or mature trees were somehow harvested and treated/stored in such a way that their carbon would not decompose and re-enter the rest of the biosphere.

carpdiem··on Back pain is a problem which is badly treated
No discussion of back pain is complete without mention of Stuart McGill (see, for example, his book "Back Mechanic" - https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01FKSGJYC/ ).

He's a professor emeritus @ UWaterloo, and spent years studying the biomechanics of the back. As a consequence, he's developed exercise techniques (e.g., the "Big 3" - curl up / side plank / bird dog), and a host of diagnostic and treatment techniques for rehabilitating back injury, especially in athletes.

I personally had a dynamic disk bulge that would leave me in bed, unable to move for a couple days at a time, and it was successfully and completely treated by his methods, leaving me completely pain free and in better shape than ever four years later (and I'm an extremely active person, spending ~10 hrs / week on various athletics).

carpdiem··on Tracking collars reveal just how extreme a wild cheetah’s movements can be
This is very likely. There's also the chance they're taking advantage of some portion of the ground effect ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground_effect_(aerodynamics) ), thereby allowing themselves to increase their speed even further.
carpdiem··on Mark Zuckerberg Calls for a Universal Basic Income
Generally, UBI schemes advocate some sort of drop-off in payout as people earn money outside of the program (but structured in such a way as to ensure no sticking points of greater than 100% effective marginal tax).

So in net you're not actually giving that $1k/month out to everyone, only the people who don't otherwise make anything. Then someone who makes $1k/month from other sources might pay $500/month in tax, thus reducing their effective, net UBI payment. (note, I made up these numbers completely off the top of my head)

Someone who makes much more than that would also pay much more taxes.

So in the end, UBI needs to be accompanied with some sort of tax reform, and isn't just about sending out checks to everyone (including Warren Buffet) on top of the existing system.

carpdiem··on Top Books on Amazon Based on Links in Hacker News Comments
I notice that this list looks like it has a very long tail.

Can we get the top 100 books as well? (since many of those would have very similar mention numbers as the end of the top-30)

carpdiem··on Why nuclear energy is our best option at the moment
I think you've misunderstood the point. Terawatt-hours is ambiguous, without specifying a time period.

In particular, Terawatt-hours can be converted to Joules. To say that humanity's energy usage is X Joules is meaningless without specifying the time period that that energy is used over. For example, it means very different things to say that humanity uses 5 TWh per day than to say that humanity uses 5 TWh per year (versus 5 TWh since the dawn of recorded history!).

carpdiem··on The Economist's US college rankings
Interestingly, having gone to Caltech, I suspect that its extreme focus on STEM research actually hurt it here. Mostly because that focus results in a very large portion of undergrads going on to grad school (much larger % than any other university), and grad students don't earn very much.
carpdiem··on Slow and Steady is Bullshit
Agreed! I think it's super important to avoid getting burned out, but I really wanted to highlight the importance of getting to new rungs, though, before you stop for so long that you slip back down.

Where do you personally find the optimums of productivity? For me it's all about having enough projects going that when I get tired of one, I can switch to another and feel fresh about it.

carpdiem··on New RFS – Breakthrough Technologies
I feel like this is not a good comparison. Boeing took fifty years to go from the company that built that plane, to the company that helped build the Saturn V. I'm all for long time horizons, but I don't think that most startup founders envision spending fifty years on a company in order to finally, at the end of that, get to do what they wanted to do in the first place.
carpdiem··on [dead]
I think he's counting in Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia as distinct, largely self-governing regions.
carpdiem··on Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn Hard)
I don't know about MIT and Stanford, but I went to Caltech, and while there are first-year courses with names like 'Calculus', they are categorically nothing like the first-year courses at UCs or CSUs.

To put things into perspective, there is zero AP credit offered at Caltech. The only way to skip classes is to pass Caltech's own placement exams. I took the first placement exam (after finishing the entire AP math curriculum, as well as the entire math curriculum at the local community college—through linear algebra, diff eqns, and multivariable calc), got a 96% on Caltech's placement exam, and was recommended to take an extra, remedial mathematics course in addition to the regular freshman load to help bring me up to speed.

carpdiem··on Could You Modify It ‘To Stop Students From Becoming This Advanced?’
As someone who learned to read at a very early age, this is horrifying to me.
carpdiem··on Show HN: Kickstarter project for snap-together, desktop trebuchets
Well, it's a combination of two things:

1) We wanted to keep the price / trebuchet low, so our margin after materials is slim.

and

2) The laser cutter that we need to produce these is expensive.

But such is life!

carpdiem··on Why Caltech Is in a Class by Itself
Yes, but you have to consider very carefully what "poor grades" means here. Coming from a Caltech admissions offices, "poor grades" is anything less than about a 3.8 (unweighted), or anything less than straight As in math and science.

Anything less is beyond poor compared to Caltech's admissions standards.

carpdiem··on Why Caltech Is in a Class by Itself
I went to Caltech recently, and I feel I should weigh in on this.

The author of the article spends an unfortunate amount of time talking about SAT and AP scores, as if that's all that Tech cares about. Having served on an institute committee to decide the direction of the Admissions office, I can assure you that this simply isn't true. Caltech's sky-high SAT and AP scores aren't an end in and of themselves, they're simply a side-effect. Caltech looks, more than anything else, for a demonstrated passion for math and science. Near-perfect SAT and AP scores are just a check box on the way to demonstrating a true passion and ability for math and science.

And that's really key, because a perfect GPA, SAT & AP scores, and great teacher recommendations isn't enough to get in. There has to be something more. Usually that 'something more' is independent work in a research lab, science competition, personal projects, or somesuch, and so the incoming class at Caltech is never just people who know how to get good grades and do nothing else, but a crowd of voracious achievers, many of whom have spent their lives figuring out how to push themselves harder and faster towards their passions than allotted for by whatever system they were raised in. To characterize them otherwise is a mistake.

carpdiem··on Using the Cython Compiler to write fast Python code
I spent some time building numerical simulations as the theorist on an R&D team in Los Angeles, and Cython was a lifesaver. Iirc, I got ~150x performance increase (note, 150x, not 150%) out of it. That gave me all the great high-level bits of python (and ease of writing code!) with the speed of C.
carpdiem··on How to Solve Hard Problem Sets Without Staying Up All Night
You should also work while standing up.

There's a reason why academics prefer whiteboards and chalkboards to pen and paper. It's because they feel genuinely more productive and creative while working on them. I personally think that it comes down to improved blood flow, and it's one of the key tricks that my friends and I used to earn physics degrees from Caltech. We'd go camp out in empty lecture halls late at night, filling chalkboard after chalkboard with scrawl, and only sit down to copy finished problems in their final form.

carpdiem··on BU scientists discover group of genes that code for 100+ year lifespans
I'm pretty sure this is how we end up in a Gattaca future. This is the first story I've seen that really has the chance to make genetic screening followed by IVF worthwhile.
carpdiem··on What Does HN Recommend for Presentation Slide Creation
If it's simple, then just about anything (including Google Docs) will do fine for you.

But if you have a complex presentation, or you're a stickler for detail, I recommend creating each of your slides in Inkscape or Adobe Illustrator, and stitching them together with something else. It's the only way to get the design just right.

carpdiem··on "Men Who Do Nothing But Think."
That's a great advertisement. It's too bad that groups like Westinghouse's R&D division and Bell Labs aren't around anymore. Are there any real corporate research groups doing basic research anymore?
carpdiem··on The End of Men
I actually spent a bit yesterday writing a short response piece to this. Here's an excerpt:

"The problem with "The End of Men" is that it isn't an isolated problem, putting males today and males tomorrow out of jobs. Instead, it's part of a larger pattern. That pattern is the replacement of human labor with automation."

Check out the whole thing here: http://www.intellectualpornography.com/2010/06/one-oclock-da...

carpdiem··on I am a junior angel in Silicon Valley. AMA
What's the most unexpected thing you've learned along the way?
carpdiem··on Ask HN: Would you go to Iraq for a year and be paid $200k?
In the wise words of Marilyn Monroe, "Ever notice that 'what the hell' is always the right decision?"
carpdiem··on Middle school evacuated because of a science project
I, on the other hand, went to a public highschool in a well-to-do Los Angeles suburb. The year before I graduated, a senior girl was expelled from school two days before her graduation because she brought a swiss army knife on the senior trip.
carpdiem··on Ask HN: The Primers on different subjects
With regards to physics in particular (my specialty), I think it's important to understand what part of physics you want to learn, and in what depth.

If you want a good, basic introduction to mechanics and E&M, I would point you towards Serway. The problem is that Serway is a very basic book, and not really written like physicists think.

A step up from Serway is The Mechanical Universe.

The best intro physics book on E&M for physicists is Purcell.

The Feynman Lectures are great, but you have to be willing to devote serious time and effort to studying them. Especially if you're new to physics, and thinking like a physicist.

If you want another step up past the Feynman lectures, and you're willing to devote a serious amount of time to it, the Landau and Lifshitz series is incredible, though very advanced. If you can make it through all of those, you're among a rare group indeed.

carpdiem··on Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory to Quantum Mechanics
I think this post title is misleading.

Roger Penrose is not merely saying that quantum mechanics is wrong. Instead it would be more fair to say that he views quantum mechanics as an incomplete theory, and one that should be continually challenged.

It's like Newtonian mechanics. Newtonian mechanics is correct, within its domain (for velocities much less than the speed of light). No one argues with the predictions of Newtonian mechanics within their domain. Einstein's achievement with special relativity, then, wasn't showing that Newtonian mechanics was wrong; instead, he just showed the world the true extent of its domain, and developed a theory (special relativity) that generalized Newtonian mechanics to a larger domain (velocities less than the speed of light). It's terribly unfair to Newtonian mechanics to call it 'wrong' in the same way that the statement 2+2=5 is 'wrong'.

Similarly, the fantastic experimental success of quantum mechanics ensures that it would be unfair to call quantum mechanics 'wrong'. Incomplete? Certainly. Worthy of being challenged? Absolutely. Is it taken as gospel by too many physicists? Probably. But is quantum mechanics wrong? No, decades of successful experiments, and practically the entire modern electronics industry, would disagree with that sentiment. The problem is that we just don't know where the domain of quantum mechanics ends, nor the more general theory that will take its place.

carpdiem··on The future of schooling may lie with video games
Computer games can also improve your eyesight:

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn16857-shootemup-video-...

carpdiem··on The future of schooling may lie with video games
The effect of computer games on education is probably also tied to when the person is exposed to the particular games.

As a kid, my best friends and I spent ages playing every manner of strategy game out there, from Red Alert to Alpha Centauri. In retrospect, we've come to the conclusion that those games taught us invaluable lessons about what it takes to analyze new situations for optimum strategies, and how to balance competing demands of time, resources, attention, and effort in the pursuit of several related goals at once.

Of course, this doesn't apply so well for studying quantum mechanics, but for learning project management, it's amazing.

carpdiem··on Equity investing in superstar individuals (not their companies, them)
I think indentured servitude is the wrong way to look at this. The key difference is that the investors don't dictate that you need to achieve a certain level of returns, or that you pursue a certain line of work. Instead you're still free to do whatever you want.

Since these contracts don't impinge on personal freedom, they should be legal. And I dare say that any number of highly motivated and intelligent people would jump at an opportunity like this (myself included), especially with the buy-out clause.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →